Meadmaker - don't blame the dictionary, at least not too much.
The second word in definition 3 is missing - is should be "imaginary".
Stupid dictionary.
Well, folks, I have good news. I've gotten about all I can out of this thread. Some comments.
I love this quote:
Nonetheless, there are several points intimately related to Dembski's work that bear emphasizing. First, biologists in particular and scientists in general are horribly confused defenders of their field. When responding to attacks from non-scientists, rather than attempt the rigor that the geometry of induction and similar bodies of statistics provide, they fall back on Popperian incantations, trying to browbeat their opponents into acceding to the homily that if one follows certain magic rituals---the vaunted "scientific method"---then one is rewarded with The Truth. No mathematically precise derivation of these rituals from first principles is provided. The "scientific method" is treated as a first-category topic, opening it up to all kinds of attack. In particular, in defending neo-Darwinism, no admission is allowed that different scientific disciplines simply cannot reach the same level of certainty in their conclusions due to intrinsic differences in the accessibility of the domains they study.
It's from here:
http://www.talkreason.org/articles/jello.cfm
One of those Popperian incantations is the necessity of falsifiability. If anyone is interested in ID and falsifiability, I suggest using that as a google search term on the site
www.discovery.org. If it's easier, just go to the site, select search and one of the options will be search using google. There will be several hits, including from Behe and Dembski, describing, using purely materialistic means, how to falsify ID.
On the subject of information and complexity theory. It's hard. It's especially hard to apply it to the real world. Treating things as discrete combinatorial objects is, in fact, one way to treat the subject, which is why I had homework in physics class related to poker hands, but there are other, mathematically equivalent, ways, to treat the subject, and those ways are sometimes better suited to different problem domains. If you get a basic understanding of the subject, you can find Dembski's error in its application. Yes, he did make a "whopper" in applying it.
Speaking of complexity theory and falsifiability, I have been looking at Schneiders' paper, which I mistakenly attributed to Paul. I said that if their claims are correct, they would refute Dembski. I meant his arguments related to specified complexity. I have concluded that his arguments are in fact correct, and that Dembski did indeed make a "whopper". Dembski attacked Schneider's paper, and said that Schneider must have "smuggled in" some complex specified information, and Dembski is right, but here is where he made his "whopper". The way Schneider smuggled in the information seems to me exactly how nature "smuggles in" information. The complexity inherent in selection function, whether Schneider's in his paper, or the nonuniform random selection action of nature can, be transferred to the organism. If you are interested, look up Dembski's "Law of Conservation of Information". The error Dembski makes is confusing information in the sense of information theory with information in the colloquial sense.
So is ID falsified? Well, one of their arguments certainly is, and Schneider's program drives at another. Is it enough to falsify ID? Do that googling if you are interested, and you'll see what it takes to totally falsify it. Schneider points the way to how to falsify it.
On the other hand, read Schneider's paper to see a hideous example of how to write a convincing paper. It's so full of anger that it's hard to actually see the point.
I also think that if you presented Schneider's paper and Dembski's to a class of fourteen year olds, with the appropriate explanations to get over the difficult mathematics, they would come away with a better understanding of evolution and ID, and those who were interested would be able to sort out the BS for themselves. For those of you confused, that means I think fewer of them would believe ID when they graduated high school and became voters.
Let me tell you a few things about myself. I have an MS in Electrical Engineering, with more advance coursework. I'm an atheist. I read science books for fun. I've read two books by Dawkins, three by Sagan, and "The River that Flows Uphill." (I think William Calvin was the author.) One of the reasons I'm winding down is because "Spark of Life" arrived, and I want to read it. I believe, hook line and sinker, in evolution. If test scores are to be believed, I could walk into a Mensa meeting and complain about the low standards for admission. In short, I am the guy who you think ought to be the crusader for your side, because I'm intelligent, educated, non-religious, and knowledgable about science.
You folks just spent a lot of time trying to convince me I was an idiot who didn't understand science or evolution. At the end of it, I am much, much, more sympathetic to the other side, because I have more personal experience with people who insist that science is the reserved exclusively to the non-religious, and I have seen how ugly that can be. Michael Behe, in his testimony at Dover, described one of the plaintiffs' expert witnesses as "almost histrionic" in describing the effects of that silly little statement that the trial was about. I agree with Behe, and some of you ought to consider whether the "almost" is appropriate for you.
There are some of you I've enjoyed all the time, and some of you that I've enjoyed some of the time, and it is probably true that I like less than half of you half as well as you deserve.
I said I was winding down, but I have a pet peeve. When I am a participant in a thread, I can't stand it when someone repeatedly ignores what I think is just a completely incredible point that I make, or when someone won't answer a question. So I won't do that to you. If you are curious about how someone like me would respond to an argument that you bring up, go ahead. Bring it up again. There are some that have been asked and answered repeatedly, so if I think you are just interested in browbeating me with Popperian incantations, I might ignore you, but it's worth a try.
Enjoy.
(Edited for style)