Can ID be disproven?

You mean if you do not agree with a concept you should never mention it?
No,that isn't what I mean.

So for example when scientists had doubts about the validity of the concept of phlogiston they should have just kept this to themselves and never had the temerity to disagree with a phlogiston supporter?
Nope. My point is that supernatural has no more meaning, or merit, than phlogiston. What I object to is the implication that IDers necessarily believe either.

So you are apparently free to do what you criticise others for.
Apparently you are wrong.

Odd that. ;)


Complexity is the main argument of ID, not aliveness.
For some IDers you may be correct, but not for me, nor for others imo. At the moment Behe/Dembski are indefensible; do you suggest that means ID is just going away?
 
Meadmaker said:
I'll try "miraculous evolutionist". Will that do?
Sure thing.

But then we have a problem, because usually people point out that evolution is about changes over time, and miraculous evolution could easily be confused with the nonmiraculous theory. Therefore, when discussing evolution that rejects the possibility of miraculous interference, I will call it "godidntdoit".
No matter how many times you say this, I'm going to ask you why you don't give equal time to all possible explanations for anything, because, after all, maybe we can't tell one of them isn't happening, too.

Science does not give equal time to miracles, because science wants to discover how something actually works. When the day comes that a scientific miracle is demonstrated fairly rigorously, then science will have to consider a different epistemological basis.

~~ Paul
 
Meadmaker said:
Nor does it pretend otherwise. He's [Dembski] quite explicit about that, at least in the writings I have seen.
Aaaaaarrrrgh! You're impossible. Then why did you say:
But that isn't the point of his argument anyway. He is using that probability as an indicator of complexity. This isn't some sort of bizarre, weird ID thing. As a second semester physics student, I had homework problems that required me to calculate entropy, a measure of complexity, for hands of cards. He's doing the same thing here, although he doesn't use the term, "entropy". His "specified complexity" is suspiciously close to the statistical definition of entropy.
if you agree that his calculations tell us nothing about the probability of the flagellum evolving or coming about by any other means? His argument gives no indication about complexity in general.

I can't shove the words in his mouth, but I think that's what he said.
No, it isn't. He admits you have to do the probability calculations for all possible naturalistic origins of the flagellum. He just doesn't do them, for obvious reasons.

But Dembski gave something related to that as precisely the falsifiability criterion for ID. If you can show that weather is just as complex as life, then ID is falsified, by Dembski's own admission.
Why? Maybe the weather is designed. After all, it's a hidden miracle. Who can tell?

~~ Paul
 
Last edited:
But Dembski gave something related to that as precisely the falsifiability criterion for ID. If you can show that weather is just as complex as life, then ID is falsified, by Dembski's own admission.

Go for it, dudes.
Gosh, that would kind of depend on how you define complexity. Weather is very much global in scope, unlike petty little organisms which don't much affect things outside their habitats. (When was the last time you were attacked by a killer wombat?) Weather is, in the short term, much less predictable than life, which pretty much doesn't make major changes in terms of decades or even centuries. Weather has changed a whole lot in the long term too since the days when there was little free oxygen.

It might depend a lot on how you define "complex", but I think you can make a very good case that weather is more complex than life. But it is, in the end, a moot point. It's comparing apples and wombats. And it's also moot because if you ask an ID proponant, they will tell you that weather is designed too. It's just that weather is not the hot topic that the origin of life is. If you believe in ID, then you most likely believe that everything is designed. Because if you believe in ID, then you are more than likely a believer in a specific designer. That is, after all, the reason that ID is being pushed by local school boards.
 
Name one abiogenesis theory that isn't falsifiable.

Name one abiogenesis theory.

I'm not saying you can't do it, but I find it interesting that you haven't felt much need to discuss the matter.

(For what it's worth, I did order "Spark of Life." Looks interesting.
 
Is there a source for this - is it his book? What measure of complexity is he talking about? After all in his papers he confuses the terms "information" and "complexity" and gives a definition that no info theory text book would accept for either.

My info theory text books would accept them, and the two concepts are so closely related that it would be hard not to confuse them.

I will confess that, in this case, my coursework was not advanced enough to give an accurate defintion off the top of my head, nor was my subsequent reading. However, the complexity of a system is closely related to the number of bits necessary to describe the system. More information required = more complex.

It gets a little bit confusing, though, when randomness is introduced. A random system is very difficult to describe exactly, so it would appear to have lots of information. However, one random system is just like another random system, as far as the information in them is concerned. That's why a randomly selected five card hand doesn't have much information, even though any given randomly selected hand is four times less likely than "royal flush". As long as the criterion is "five random cards" then the number of bits is indeed small, but if the criterion is "3H, 5D, 5S, KC, QD", then more bits are required than "10x Jx Qx Kx Ax".

That's why it really doesn't matter how cells were formed in order to describe their complexity. Their complexity is closely related to the probability of them coming together at random. Just like decks of cards, if I want to know the complexity of a poker hand, I don't need to know how it was dealt.

Please, I ask that no one jump all over me with "You idiot Meadmaker. Go back to making mead! You obviously don't know information theory." I already am aware of that. I am working under the assumption that some of you actually might not be aware of the concepts of information theory, and might like to know more. If that is the case, you just got 30 seconds of almost accurate information. If you are intrigued, you are on your own from here. But, if you can't resist pointing out the deficiencies in my explanations, please at least provide something correct. A link, if nothing else.
 
Not happy with any of 'em, huh? :)

Not able to name one, huh? You are the one claiming that they are unfalsifiable. I simply asked you to name one. Any one. My personal preference has no importance in this discussion. If you are unable to back up your bold assertion, then kindly be quiet. Some of us are trying to have a discussion.
 
Name one abiogenesis theory.

RNA catalyst of DNA molecules. Your turn.

I'm not saying you can't do it, but I find it interesting that you haven't felt much need to discuss the matter.

Because it is unimportant. I put forward that any respectible scientific hypothesis about abiogenesis would be falsifiable, otherwise it would not be scientific. I then asked Hamme (who made the claim) to name one that wasn't. He's yet to do so. It is unimportant because we are discussing evolution versus ID. As evolution does not deal with the origin of life, it is a bold Straw Man to argue that it does.
 
I've noticed that this thread has gone arse sideways. I'll attempt to bring it back on track.

Question: "Can ID be disproved?"
Answer: No.

What is your problem with this, Meadmaker?
 
ID makes no testable assertions and is disingenuous religious trash devoid of content.

ID can not disproven.

ID's proponents are dishonest and are proponents of the evil belief: "The end justifies the means."

ID sucks.
 
I've noticed that this thread has gone arse sideways. I'll attempt to bring it back on track.

Question: "Can ID be disproved?"
Answer: No.

What is your problem with this, Meadmaker?

Perhaps I was unclear in my title, because the question can be taken two ways. One way is "Is ID falsifiable?" The answer to that is yes. The second way, which is what I meant is, "Can ID be falsified today, with our current limitations on the knowledge of evolution?" The answer to that appears to be "no".
 
Meadmaker
One way is "Is ID falsifiable?" The answer to that is yes.
How did you come to that conclusion when ID proponents themselves have put nothing forward to be tested?
If you go with Behe’s definition of ID, it’s already been falsified.

Ossai
 
RNA catalyst of DNA molecules.
No, you don't have RNA. And I'd be interested to know why you think any abiogenesis theory can ever be deemed falsifiable.

It is unimportant because we are discussing evolution versus ID. As evolution does not deal with the origin of life, it is a bold Straw Man to argue that it does.
ID does -- or at least can -- deal with the origin of life. You are correct that The Theory does not. That's one major disclaimer IDers want stressed as The Theory is discussed with students.

I've noticed that this thread has gone arse sideways. I'll attempt to bring it back on track.
You failed miserably.
 
Milord,
Are you simply asking for a reference in an ID journal, in which they talk about how to falsify ID?

It's not a journal, but this one does it quite nicely. Well, it's sort of a journal. If there's a journal out there, I don't know about it. I'm unimproved, I suppose.

http://www.arn.org/docs/dembski/wd_isidtestable.htm

We had been over that so many different times that it didn't occur to me that you could have meant that.

I hope you are enjoying laughing at me as much as I enjoy laughing at you.
A journal, sir. A peer-reviewed ID journal. What part of peer-reviewed journal don't you understand? A research paper in a journal. What part of "research paper" don't you understand? One that puts forth an anti-ID null hypothesis that concludes said null hypothesis can't be refuted.

Please explain which part of this question, now days and pages old, you don't understand. Then please explain what business you have making pronouncements about the quality of ID "science."

This is basic, sir. Quite basic. This is the test of a "science", sir. A very basic test of a "science." ID either meets this test or it is, ipso facto, bullsh**.

Now, sir, will you at long last, have the decency to address this question?
 
Then why, sir, do you deign to portray ID as a science when you either don't understand one of the basic requirements to make such a claim or know that such evidence can't be found, or both? Why do you come to this forum to lie to us? How "christian" is that, sir, to lie, blatantly and deliberately? To bear false witness, sir? Are you not ashamed of your duplicitous self? If not, why not?
 
Meadmaker

How did you come to that conclusion when ID proponents themselves have put nothing forward to be tested?
If you go with Behe’s definition of ID, it’s already been falsified.

Ossai

I'm going to pick on Ossai a little bit here, but it could apply to all of you who bring up the "ID is not falsifiable" argument.

Yesterday, we coined a term, "Miraculous evolution" to describe Michael Behe's belief that evolution happened, but it could not have happened without the miraculous intervention of God. More accurately, it says that natural laws as we know them are inadequate to explain the origin and subsequent development of life.

We also coined a term, "godidntdoit", but that term is surprisingly difficult to type. So, I will coin a new term to describe the theory that evolution happened, and that natural laws are adequate to explain the origin and subsequent development of life. I will call this "Natural Evolution". It is what we normally think of as the theory of evolution, but we are adding the explicit qualification that divine intervention was not required. (Note: It may have happened anyway, but it wasn't required. Natural evolution, what everyone here except maybe Hammegk believes, does not require divine intervention, and says that if it happened, it left no visible trace.)

So, is natural evolution falsifiable? I think it is. And how would it be falsified? By demonstrating its null hypothesis. And what is its null hypothesis? One of them is Miraculaous Evolution. (Another is that all of our data is wrong, and YEC is the real answer. I, for one, don't have any interest in defending that one, as I think it is both falsifiable and falsified.)

If Natural Evolution, our theory, is falsifiable, then Miraculous Evolution, Behe's theory, is falsifiable. They are opposites. They are falsifiable. Falsify one, and you have demonstrated the other. Finally, Miraculous Evolution is just another term for one form of ID. (The other major form would be creationism.) Therefore, unless you are willing to assert that Natural Evolution is not falsifiable, then you must acknowledge that ID is also falsifiable.
 
Then why, sir, do you deign to portray ID as a science when you either don't understand one of the basic requirements to make such a claim or know that such evidence can't be found, or both? Why do you come to this forum to lie to us? How "christian" is that, sir, to lie, blatantly and deliberately? To bear false witness, sir? Are you not ashamed of your duplicitous self? If not, why not?

I'm an atheist. I read on a Christian forum that all atheists were immoral, so I decided to try it out.

P.S. I'm not really a McCarthyite, but please, don't blow my cover. I have almost infiltrated them.

ETA: I have to add something. Obviously, everything after the first sentence is B.S. It's just making fun of Bill. I hope that it isn't actually making fun of him. I hope he can't possibly be taking himself that seriously, in which case all I'm really doing is playing along. However, just to avoid some confusion, I want to say that the first sentence is not B.S. I really am an atheist.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom