Paul C. Anagnostopoulos
Nap, interrupted.
- Joined
- Aug 3, 2001
- Messages
- 19,141
Yet you're saying that Behe accepts evolution? Which means he rejects all the Dembski stuff?Meadmaker said:It's tempting to say that a is correct, and leave it at that. Dembski rejects evolution as the source of the flagellum. This isn't exactly news. Also, a and b are not mutually exclusive.
That probability is an indicator of the complexity of a flagellum falling together by chance, period. It tells us nothing of the probability of the flagellum evolving or coming about by any other means. And even that calculation is wrong, because it commits the AND-multiplication error twice.But that isn't the point of his argument anyway. He is using that probability as an indicator of complexity. This isn't some sort of bizarre, weird ID thing. As a second semester physics student, I had homework problems that required me to calculate entropy, a measure of complexity, for hands of cards. He's doing the same thing here, although he doesn't use the term, "entropy". His "specified complexity" is suspiciously close to the statistical definition of entropy.
So the weather came about by design?He is pointing out that living systems are very, very, complex. Then, he asks how complex systems come into existence. He looks around at other complex systems, and asks where they came from. In every case where we know the origin of a complex system, that complex system came about from design. He then claims it is reasonable to infer that design played a role in those complex systems, as well.
What you say doesn't follow. Are you sure he wants to have that shoved in his mouth?In other words, his calculations shouldn't be taken as "Evolution says the flagellum fell together from a bunch of random stuff, but that is highly improbable. Therefore Evolution is wrong." Rather, it should be taken as "Evolution can't explain how the flagellum came together. If it were to fall together randomly, it would be highly improbable. We know of other systems that also would be highly improbable to fall together randomly. In all of those systems where the origin can be determined, design was a factor. Therefore, we think design was a factor here, as well."
That's because it doesn't address evolution at all.It isn't a proof that design happened, and he doesn't claim it is. However, it doesn't strike me as some sort of off the wall, wacky, concept, nor does it misrepresent anything about evolution.
~~ Paul