Can ID be disproven?

Meadmaker said:
It's tempting to say that a is correct, and leave it at that. Dembski rejects evolution as the source of the flagellum. This isn't exactly news. Also, a and b are not mutually exclusive.
Yet you're saying that Behe accepts evolution? Which means he rejects all the Dembski stuff?

But that isn't the point of his argument anyway. He is using that probability as an indicator of complexity. This isn't some sort of bizarre, weird ID thing. As a second semester physics student, I had homework problems that required me to calculate entropy, a measure of complexity, for hands of cards. He's doing the same thing here, although he doesn't use the term, "entropy". His "specified complexity" is suspiciously close to the statistical definition of entropy.
That probability is an indicator of the complexity of a flagellum falling together by chance, period. It tells us nothing of the probability of the flagellum evolving or coming about by any other means. And even that calculation is wrong, because it commits the AND-multiplication error twice.

He is pointing out that living systems are very, very, complex. Then, he asks how complex systems come into existence. He looks around at other complex systems, and asks where they came from. In every case where we know the origin of a complex system, that complex system came about from design. He then claims it is reasonable to infer that design played a role in those complex systems, as well.
So the weather came about by design?

In other words, his calculations shouldn't be taken as "Evolution says the flagellum fell together from a bunch of random stuff, but that is highly improbable. Therefore Evolution is wrong." Rather, it should be taken as "Evolution can't explain how the flagellum came together. If it were to fall together randomly, it would be highly improbable. We know of other systems that also would be highly improbable to fall together randomly. In all of those systems where the origin can be determined, design was a factor. Therefore, we think design was a factor here, as well."
What you say doesn't follow. Are you sure he wants to have that shoved in his mouth?

It isn't a proof that design happened, and he doesn't claim it is. However, it doesn't strike me as some sort of off the wall, wacky, concept, nor does it misrepresent anything about evolution.
That's because it doesn't address evolution at all.

~~ Paul
 
Meadmaker said:
All right, Paul. Have it your way. He believes in the common descent of all organisms from single celled organisms.

What do you think he ought to be called?
A magical evolutionist.

~~ Paul
 
He is pointing out that living systems are very, very, complex. Then, he asks how complex systems come into existence. He looks around at other complex systems, and asks where they came from. In every case where we know the origin of a complex system, that complex system came about from design. He then claims it is reasonable to infer that design played a role in those complex systems, as well.

Well, the logic problems here are abundant. And there is no evidence to support it.

First, the definition of what constitutes a "living system" is extremely broad and open to debate (e.g. very simple viruses or AI). And the range of complexity in "living systems" is far broader and more signifigant the difference between a computer virus and biological virus.

Second, "he looked around at complex systems" - if only living systems are "very, very complex", what exactly is comparing it to? Man-made machines? That's not a valid comparison. How is a pulsar or black hole not a "very, very complex system? Or for that matter, weather? Or a hurricane as small subset.

Does this mean weather has to be designed as well? There is no logical connection between complexity and design. Did any ID every take chaos theory?

Again, design is a human only activity until proven otherwise.
 
Shhhh, Paul, you're spoiling it! Tricky is bucking to have a Book Of Darwin inserted just after Genesis. Dang, boy, you're gonna mess him up. That, and his beatification bid.


St. Tricky. Just rolls off the tongue, don't it?
Beatification? Does this involve a beating?
 
Dammit! You beat me to it. A pox on fast typists...
No problem. You can field the obvious question "Is weather 'alive'?".


Paul, not to shortchange you, but I'd say all of us are striving for "clarity of definition, and understanding"; most just don't accept your statements as automatically falling in that category. :)
 
No problem. You can field the obvious question "Is weather 'alive'?".
Easy answer. No.
  1. Organized structures that are composed of heterogenous chemicals - in units of "cells"
  2. Metabolism: chemical and energy transformations
  3. Maintain internal conditions separated from an outside environment: homeostasis
  4. Growth: conversion of materials from the environment into components of organism
  5. Reaction to select stimuli, physiologically and/or behaviorally
  6. Reproduction: making copies of individuals via the mechanism of genetic transfer: sections of DNA molecules that contain instructions for organization & metabolism
  7. Evolution: change in characteristics of individuals, resulting from mutation & natural selection - these result in adaptations
adapted from The Characteristics of Life
-- Oklahoma State University, Department of Zoology
1. Maybe, depends on what you call a "cell"
2. Yes
3. Probably not. Certainly no "membranes"
4. Yes. Water, heat etc.
5. No. Except in bad movies
6. No. (see #5)
7. No. Nein. Non. Nyet.

So weather is complex, yet it is not alive. Now, back to the question. Is it designed?
 
Lost track of the discussion already? An ID Journal, sir, exists, sir, at least one, sir. If you would be so kind, sir, as to find the ID research article examples I requested pages and pages ago. SHOW ME THE ID RESEARCH THAT SUGGESTS ID IS REALLY SCIENTIFIC. SHOW ME THE ARTICLES DEMONSTRATING ANTI-ID NULL HYPOTHESES THAT COULD NOT BE REFUTED.

Is this clear enough, sir?

Milord,
Are you simply asking for a reference in an ID journal, in which they talk about how to falsify ID?

It's not a journal, but this one does it quite nicely. Well, it's sort of a journal. If there's a journal out there, I don't know about it. I'm unimproved, I suppose.

http://www.arn.org/docs/dembski/wd_isidtestable.htm

We had been over that so many different times that it didn't occur to me that you could have meant that.

I hope you are enjoying laughing at me as much as I enjoy laughing at you.
 
So weather is complex, yet it is not alive. Now, back to the question. Is it designed?

Clearly designed by French Toast futures investors which periodically create threatening weather to cause vast amounts of Americans to rush out and purchase bread, milk and eggs....

Weather (and chaos systems theory in generally) is a nice mouthful for IDers to munch on. If you don't "see complexity" in weather, I'm not sure you would see complexity in anything.

Yet, I think chaos theory is a much better explanation (with some nice evidence already here to back it up) for weather and other complex systems.

Anyone know of work on chaos, origins of life and/or evolutionary theory?
 
A magical evolutionist.

~~ Paul

I'll try "miraculous evolutionist". Will that do?

But then we have a problem, because usually people point out that evolution is about changes over time, and miraculous evolution could easily be confused with the nonmiraculous theory. Therefore, when discussing evolution that rejects the possibility of miraculous interference, I will call it "godidntdoit".
 
Second, "he looked around at complex systems" - if only living systems are "very, very complex", what exactly is comparing it to?

In the unlikely event you are interested in learning, he is using definitions from information theory.
 
In the unlikely event you are interested in learning, he is using definitions from information theory.

Perhaps you have not been reading my posts. I am in the midst of large ID/Evolution project and am reading everything I can get my hands on (admittedly, I have much more to read). My question is not where he got his definitions & terms from, but the examples of complexity = design.
 
Easy answer. No.
So we agree. Therefore, why does anyone care, here, if it's designed or not?

(although of course it is designed at least in the anthropic principle sense...)
 
Last edited:
Yet you're saying that Behe accepts evolution? Which means he rejects all the Dembski stuff?
[/QUOTE}

Only miraculous evolution. Dembski's stuff is compatible with miraculous evolution.

That probability is an indicator of the complexity of a flagellum falling together by chance, period. It tells us nothing of the probability of the flagellum evolving or coming about by any other means.

Nor does it pretend otherwise. He's quite explicit about that, at least in the writings I have seen.


So the weather came about by design?

You're onto something. Run with it. But be careful.

What you say doesn't follow. Are you sure he wants to have that shoved in his mouth?

I can't shove the words in his mouth, but I think that's what he said.

That's because it doesn't address evolution at all.

I couldn't find my keys this morning.

Stupid keys.
 
So we agree. Therefore, why does anyone care, here, if it's designed or not?
It is posited by ID proponants that life is designed because it is complex. Weather is also complex, but I do not hear ID proponants putting forth the theory of intelligent raining. It seems that many people care so much whether or not life is designed that they want to "fix" science to say that it is so. Perhaps you can see why scientists might not care for that solution.
 
So would I. That's what makes me wonder if the defenders of science here who keep dragging it up to beat on it have a clue.
You mean if you do not agree with a concept you should never mention it?

So for example when scientists had doubts about the validity of the concept of phlogiston they should have just kept this to themselves and never had the temerity to disagree with a phlogiston supporter?

I have already pointed out that the major religious grouping in the world have insisted for the past several centuries that the supernatural is indeed a real thing.

According to you someone who disagrees with this has no right to put this view into words.

Except of course that you beat up on the concept earlier in this thread.

So you are apparently free to do what you criticise others for.

Odd that.
 
It is posited by ID proponants that life is designed because it is complex. Weather is also complex, but I do not hear ID proponants putting forth the theory of intelligent raining.

But Dembski gave something related to that as precisely the falsifiability criterion for ID. If you can show that weather is just as complex as life, then ID is falsified, by Dembski's own admission.

Go for it, dudes.
 
But Dembski gave something related to that as precisely the falsifiability criterion for ID. If you can show that weather is just as complex as life, then ID is falsified, by Dembski's own admission.

Go for it, dudes.
Is there a source for this - is it his book? What measure of complexity is he talking about? After all in his papers he confuses the terms "information" and "complexity" and gives a definition that no info theory text book would accept for either.

Under some definitions the weather and life might have equal complexity.

Of course if they were both caused by the intelligent designer then they would have equal complexity since one must include the complexity of the source in the total.

So maybe according to Dembski the existence of an intelligent designer is the falsifiability criteria for an intelligent designer.

That would be consistent anyway, an intelligent designer would have more complexity and therefore improbability than the bacterial flagellum and so if you reject one as existing without a designer then you should reject the other.
 
So we agree. Therefore, why does anyone care, here, if it's designed or not?

(although of course it is designed at least in the anthropic principle sense...)
Complexity is the main argument of ID, not aliveness. They don't propose that the bacterial flagellum was designed because it is alive but because it is complex.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom