Can a CharlieHebdo-type attack happen in the US?

And we should consider not kissing venomous snakes too.

It's amazing to me that some might advocate stirring up trouble in the service of what? Some higher ideal? The thinking seems to be that if we just keep insulting zealots they'll stop being upset by it.

What's the point?

One point is to prevent the heckler's veto from winning. If you believe in free speech, that's no small thing.

Another point is to follow Sun Tzu's advice: "If your opponent is temperamental, seek to irritate him." These two terrorists got annoyed. And now they're dead. And that's a good thing.

Will the Islamists ever stop being upset by Mohammed cartoons? Maybe not, but I don't care. Will they stop trying to use violence to suppress Mohammed cartoons? They will if it doesn't work to stop such cartoons and only hurts their cause.
 
One point is to prevent the heckler's veto from winning. If you believe in free speech, that's no small thing.

Another point is to follow Sun Tzu's advice: "If your opponent is temperamental, seek to irritate him." These two terrorists got annoyed. And now they're dead. And that's a good thing.

Will the Islamists ever stop being upset by Mohammed cartoons? Maybe not, but I don't care. Will they stop trying to use violence to suppress Mohammed cartoons? They will if it doesn't work to stop such cartoons and only hurts their cause.

I disagree in the sense that no amount of tactical failure will stop the repeat of the attacks.
 
Why not. what is there about Islam that makes it special so we should not insult their beliefs?

I didn't say there was anything special about Islam in this respect. I can't think of any sort of group for which this strategy (deeply offend them until their radical elements recognize their place) is a good idea.

You are aware that your very existence as a non Muslim is insulting?

No. Got any references that this is a widely held Islamic belief?
 
One point is to prevent the heckler's veto from winning. If you believe in free speech, that's no small thing.

It's framing it as win/lose I disagree with. I feel no loss whatsoever because I don't spend my time drawing pictures of Mohammed.

Another point is to follow Sun Tzu's advice: "If your opponent is temperamental, seek to irritate him." These two terrorists got annoyed. And now they're dead. And that's a good thing.

Sun Tzu would be the go-to inspiration if this were some kind of war. But it's only a war between the nutty participants on either side in this case. It's not a war I'm involved in or support in any way. It's the sort of war you get on the playground between children:

"He bullied me, so I hit him."
"Free speech! I have the right to bully someone without interference!"

Will the Islamists ever stop being upset by Mohammed cartoons? Maybe not, but I don't care. Will they stop trying to use violence to suppress Mohammed cartoons? They will if it doesn't work to stop such cartoons and only hurts their cause.

You don't care about what they care about and probably they don't care about what you care about. Maybe they will use the same logic: continue to attack when Mohammed cartoons aren't suppressed, hoping eventually you'll understand that drawing them hurts your cause.

Two children on the playground...
 
Just to mention it, no one was stopped from drawing their cartoon. Free speech was not harmed in this instance. The results are published on the organization's website for all to see and admire.

The whole "free speech" thing is a dodge. No one's rights were abridged. The event was held as planned, where planned, and I assume accomplished all they set out to do.
 
Just to mention it, no one was stopped from drawing their cartoon. Free speech was not harmed in this instance. The results are published on the organization's website for all to see and admire.

The whole "free speech" thing is a dodge. No one's rights were abridged. The event was held as planned, where planned, and I assume accomplished all they set out to do.

Getting savages to act out?
 
Just to mention it, no one was stopped from drawing their cartoon. Free speech was not harmed in this instance. The results are published on the organization's website for all to see and admire.

The whole "free speech" thing is a dodge. No one's rights were abridged. The event was held as planned, where planned, and I assume accomplished all they set out to do.

Oh sure, it's not as if anyone would be intimidated into thinking twice about using their right to free speech.
 
It's framing it as win/lose I disagree with. I feel no loss whatsoever because I don't spend my time drawing pictures of Mohammed.



Sun Tzu would be the go-to inspiration if this were some kind of war. But it's only a war between the nutty participants on either side in this case. It's not a war I'm involved in or support in any way. It's the sort of war you get on the playground between children:

"He bullied me, so I hit him."
"Free speech! I have the right to bully someone without interference!"



You don't care about what they care about and probably they don't care about what you care about. Maybe they will use the same logic: continue to attack when Mohammed cartoons aren't suppressed, hoping eventually you'll understand that drawing them hurts your cause.

Two children on the playground...

You equate speech with violence? Calling people named is equal to murder?
 
From the Cornell University Law School:
"Fighting Words

"Words which would likely make the person whom they are addressed commit an act of violence. Fighting words are a category of speech that is unprotected by the First Amendment. Chaplinsky v New Hampshire, 315 U.S. 568 (1942)."

From Wiki:
"Fighting words are written or spoken words, generally expressed to incite hatred or violence from their target. Specific definitions, freedoms, and limitations of fighting words vary by jurisdiction. It is also used in a general sense of words that when uttered tend to create (deliberately or not) a verbal or physical confrontation by their mere usage."
 
Oh sure, it's not as if anyone would be intimidated into thinking twice about using their right to free speech.

At least twice. Not because you are intimidated, but because you are a mature adult, embedded in a civilization and society where your actions can have foreseeable consequences.

I believe you are free to take as much cash as you can assemble and leave it out on your front lawn. I also believe you would be foolish to do so and silly if you then complained about theft. Why? Because theft, while wrong, is a foreseeable consequence of your actions, even though those actions are freely available to you.

Just because something is permitted, it doesn't mean that thing isn't stupid. But of course, we should grant them their right to be stupid, no?
 
Sun Tzu would be the go-to inspiration if this were some kind of war. But it's only a war between the nutty participants on either side in this case. It's not a war I'm involved in or support in any way.

This is where you are fundamentally wrong. The Islamists very much see it as a war. Your refusal to see it as a war doesn't mean that it isn't one, it only means that you refuse to fight. But when one side refuses to fight, that doesn't mean the war gets called of, it just means that side loses.

You have the luxury of not fighting because others will fight for you, and that's OK. We don't all need to actually fight, it's enough that some of us do. But we all should recognize that fighting is exactly what is going on.

"He bullied me, so I hit him."
"Free speech! I have the right to bully someone without interference!"

Making cartoons about a long-dead historical figure is not bullying. And your attempt to create moral equivalence between expression (much of which is remarkably benign, if you actually look at it) and actual violence is quite distasteful.

You don't care about what they care about and probably they don't care about what you care about. Maybe they will use the same logic: continue to attack when Mohammed cartoons aren't suppressed, hoping eventually you'll understand that drawing them hurts your cause.

So the question becomes: who will win? And who should win?

You seem indifferent to the answer to the second question. I am not, nor would you be if the Islamists actually do win.

Two children on the playground...

No, marplots. A fundamental clash of cultures, with the future of civilization on the line. The parties are not equivalent, the outcome of victory for the parties will not be equivalent, and you will not be able to escape the consequences.
 
If your higher cognitive functions can't overrule your lizard brain reaction to commit mass murder over an insult, then...you might be a savage.
 
From the Cornell University Law School:
"Fighting Words

"Words which would likely make the person whom they are addressed commit an act of violence. Fighting words are a category of speech that is unprotected by the First Amendment. Chaplinsky v New Hampshire, 315 U.S. 568 (1942)."

Not applicable here. The exhibit was not addressed to the terrorists who attacked it. Plus, from the decision, "It has been well observed that such utterances are no essential part of any exposition of ideas". But there is very much an exposition of ideas at the heart of these Mohammed cartoons. It is those very ideas which are offensive to the Islamists.
 
No, marplots. A fundamental clash of cultures, with the future of civilization on the line. The parties are not equivalent, the outcome of victory for the parties will not be equivalent, and you will not be able to escape the consequences.

I think this is probably where we disagree the most. The significance. In my view, it's overblown by extremists on both sides.

Added to the mix are those who feel there's a free speech issue and an erosion of their liberties. Strange bedfellows.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom