Can a CharlieHebdo-type attack happen in the US?

The fact remains that those who can debate instead of kill should survive to reproduce and those who cannot don't deserve the privilege.

There may be some truth in that, but I'm not sure how it's relevant to my post.
 
Was the "call to arms" a rhetorical device, saying "there is a real threat to freedom of speech, we need to defend it" or a call to take up arms and shoot people?

This should make it easy for you to get your head round the concept of rhetoric... when president Obama called on some groups to "punish their enemies", was he talking about voting a specific way in an election or about taking GOP candidates down to a dungeon and giving them a good spanking?

Jeez, you could look up her words....

From her website:

As I said, the war is here. The war for free speech is a shooting war. Will the US fight or surrender?

http://pamelageller.com/2015/05/all...-muhammad-s-a-w-art-exhibition-in-texas.html/ (scroll down; her comment at the end of the captures of the bad dood)

From her interview afterwards with Fox:

This is war.... and war is here.

I don't have/do Twitter, but the first one, or a variation thereof was originally reported as a Twitter. They may be quoting from her website, or her website may produce tweets (someone with better knowledge of this stuff can correct any misapprehensions there).

But I'd be curious to see you interpret "The war for free speech is a shooting war" to be anything but a call to arms.
 
But I'd be curious to see you interpret "The war for free speech is a shooting war" to be anything but a call to arms.

A statement of the obvious perhaps? (Given that her free speech group had just been shot at)
 
By whom? Based on what evidence? Please include citations for your references.

Got any cites for this one?

I think he was refering to this article...:(

However,

That article was soon debunked by this one...:D

But then again, it is not surprising that "Tank" here would celebrate any derogatory item towards an organization that stands against the kind of racism, bigoty, xenophobia, and just plain "hatred of the 'other'" that he or she spews out on a regualar basis...:eek:
 
How is the right to critique religion involved?

Did you mean some fictitious right to critique religion without consequences?
There are two specific consequences, for which the right is not fictitious. The first is the right to criticize religion without the consequence of the government silencing your criticism.

The second is the right to criticize religion without the consequence of losing your government's duty to protect you from violence, or losing your own right to defend yourself against violence.

The group sponsoring this is a hate group, plain and simple. One hate group fighting another hate group - arrest the survivors.
The two groups are neither morally nor practically equivalent. The first is engaging in speech. The second is engaging in deadly violence. Equating the two is a morally depraved argument, doubly so if that false equivalence is then used to excuse the government from protecting its citizens in the first group or to justify the violence in the second group.
 
Yeah!

You know who I blame for all the heretics getting burnt in medaeval Europe? The heretics!

Everyone from sir Thomas moore, galileo, on down should have just shut the hell up.

Those are terrible examples of medieval heretics who were burnt for their beliefs, since neither was medieval (both lived in the Renaissance) and neither was burnt (More was beheaded; Galileo died of natural causes).
 
A statement of the obvious perhaps? (Given that her free speech group had just been shot at)

Gee, no condescending comment about me wrapping my head around a difficult concept?

(Try not doing that in the future. It comes back to bite you in the ass.)

She said it's a shooting war and asked what we were going to do about it. That is a far cry from the dubious claims about Palin posting bullseyes or Obama using locker room halftime rhetoric. (And I no more supported the attacks on Palin's web spots/ads than I did the twist of Obama's words.)

So.... do you agree or disagree that she just went from A to B in your arbitrary categorization. Or does she have to jump up and down and froth at the mouth and shout "Getcher Guns! Gotta kill 'em!" until people get the, er,... subtlety of her message.
 
I'm no longer surprised at the number of posters who place more blame on the victims of Islamic terrorism than the terrorists themselves. I don't care if cartoons offend Muslims. Too goddamn bad - they need to grow up and take it like adults.

Since I don't want to turn the "Things You Shouldn't Have to Tell People" thread in a political bent, I'll say it here - if you say "I believe in free speech, but..." then you don't believe in free speech.

This happened maybe 3-minutes away from one of my best friends' houses.
 
I'm no longer surprised at the number of posters who place more blame on the victims of Islamic terrorism than the terrorists themselves. I don't care if cartoons offend Muslims. Too goddamn bad - they need to grow up and take it like adults.

Since I don't want to turn the "Things You Shouldn't Have to Tell People" thread in a political bent, I'll say it here - if you say "I believe in free speech, but..." then you don't believe in free speech.

This happened maybe 3-minutes away from one of my best friends' houses.

And I'm no longer surprised by the number of posters who think that false dichotomies are appropriate when there's no evidence that anyone is applying them.

Meh? I'm not victim blaming. Geller wasn't a victim, nor was Wilder. They are just hateful individuals. Are they more hateful than the complete ********** who got themselves killed and who would have cheerfully killed anonymous individuals? No. But it doesn't change the fact that Geller and Wilder are hateful bigoted miscreants.

I wasn't happy when Reagan was shot, yet I had sincerely dislike his positions and actions. I didn't cheer when bigot extraordinaire George Wallace was shot, nor even when Nazi ********** George Lincoln Rockwell was killed by one of his own. It is possible to have a realistic view of the characters in a scenario without deifying the murderers and wannabe murderers. I pulled for both Reagan and Wallace to recover.

We had this same discussion in the Baltimore threads. Everything does not break down to an either/or position.
 
Since I don't want to turn the "Things You Shouldn't Have to Tell People" thread in a political bent, I'll say it here - if you say "I believe in free speech, but..." then you don't believe in free speech.

Quite pithy, that.

Plainly silly claim, but very well expressed. See, it really does matter what comes after the "but". The sentence, "I believe in free speech, but I don't think it's a good thing to purposely antagonize others," contains no contradiction at all. The sentence, "I believe in free speech, but the law shouldn't protect blatantly offensive speech," arguably does contain a contradiction, at least given traditional views about what the right entails.

So, kudos for clever expression, but not so much the thought conveyed.
 
This is very important that these insults keep coming. Forget about who is doing the insulting, this is a great service. When Muslims can take an insult and not want to kill in retaliation.... that's when you stop the insulting.

I've been thinking about this truly, monumentally silly suggestion, and how one might explain the strategy to a perfectly reasonable muslim who takes offense to it.

"Listen, nothing against you or anything, but we're going to put out some messages you find truly appalling. These messages will target the sensibilities of Muslim faithful -- you know, caricatures of Mohammed humping a dog, that sort of thing.

"I'm sure you'll be a little sensitive about our message, but, see, the thing is, some of your lot have been violently reacting when they see imagery they find offensive. Our idea is to flood the culture with so many appalling, sacreligious, insulting messages that we will break the spirit of the Muslim people, so they won't fight back at what they perceive as abuse.

"And then, of course, we'll stop abusing Muslims. Cold turkey.

"But until then, it might get a little rough. Still, nothing personal, right?"

Is that the kind of speech you'd be prepared to make?
 
Beating these people(http://www.thesisters.org/) with axe handles would be bad and the people holding the axe handles would be wrong but they did sort of have it coming for, y'know, provoking people. Is that right? Or is there people we can safely provoke and others we can't or at least shouldn't?
 
Of course, this isn't the first time a group branded by the $PLC as a "hate group" has been targeted for violence...
Family Research Council (FRC) officials released video of federal investigators questioning convicted domestic terrorist Floyd Lee Corkins II, who explained that he attacked the group’s headquarters because the Southern Poverty Law Center (SPLC) identified them as a “hate group” due to their traditional marriage views.

“Southern Poverty Law lists anti-gay groups,” Corkins tells interrogators in the video, which FRC obtained from the FBI. “I found them online, did a little research, went to the website, stuff like that.”

The Washington Examiner’s Paul Bedard reported that Corkins, who pleaded guilty to terrorism charges, said in court that he hoped to “kill as many as possible and smear the Chick-Fil-A sandwiches in victims’ faces, and kill the guard.” As Bedard explained, “the shooting occurred after an executive with Chick-Fil-A announced his support for traditional marriage, angering same-sex marriage proponents.”
http://www.washingtonexaminer.com/fbi-video-domestic-terrorist-says-he-targeted-conservative-group-for-being-anti-gay/article/2528072

The $PLC sure does seem to inspire people to act out violently. Maybe they should include themselves on their list.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom