Can a CharlieHebdo-type attack happen in the US?

From Wiki:
"Fighting words are written or spoken words, generally expressed to incite hatred or violence from their target. Specific definitions, freedoms, and limitations of fighting words vary by jurisdiction. It is also used in a general sense of words that when uttered tend to create (deliberately or not) a verbal or physical confrontation by their mere usage."

Not seeing where the "fighting words" are here; and no one so far has posted anything from the event demonstrating a call to violence prior to the attack.

Sorry, but you're creating false equivalencies again.
 

Specifically, to make it clear that violence in the name of religion will not be tolerated, and eliminate all those who cannot express themselves through non-violent means as they become a threat, or reduce them to a state where they are unwilling to act on their violent urges.

You know, pretty much the same thing that happened with politicized Christianity several centuries ago.
 
Oh, don't knock it. Apparently, those dead people were heroes and martyrs for some larger, morally important cause. Without those deaths, it's unlikely we would see the freedom to lambaste Mohammed such an important and prevalent activity.

They died so we could post what we post. So I could post this: Mohammed was a pig and a child molester.

And you don't see a problem with people trying to kill you for saying that?

Do you hold everyone to this same low standard, or just Muslims?

Do you insist that doctors and clinics who provide abortions should share the blame for "inciting" fundamentalist Christians to attack them? Should they shut down and stop providing abortions so innocent bystanders will no longer get killed in clinic bombings?

What about Scientologists? Given what we know about their propensity for harassment and character assassination; maybe society would be better off if we'd all just shut up and stop ridiculing their lunatic beliefs.
 
In the category "I never knew ..." I found this Wikipedia citation interesting:

While Sunni Muslims have always explicitly prohibited the depiction of Muhammad on film,[52] contemporary Shi'a scholars [in Iran] have taken a more relaxed attitude, stating that it is permissible to depict Muhammad, even in television or movies, if done with respect.[53]

The origins of the taboo against depicting Muhammad are vague. Islamists are often not very well-informed about where their taboos come from. I use the term "Islamist" as distinct from "Muslim," although it would be fair to call Iran an "Islamist" state, so it's easy to see that generalities also contain contradictions.

I'm one of those who think these incidents support the truism "Haters gonna hate" more than they support the actions and principles of most of the world's Muslims.

Imagine a contest to show how Mary can be both God's mother and the begetter of God's son. Imagine it showed images of Jesus f------ Mary. See the problem? Someone determined to cause offense causes offense. It doesn't make violence right, but it might add perspective. "C'mon, Mom, let's get it on!" says an amorous Jesus. I don't know if that would incite anyone to violence, but if the point is to spout offensive speech in order to preserve the right to offensive speech, I'd say yes, there is a chance this would incite violence among some populations of "Christians," and that such violence would reveal the true colors of some people who call themselves Christians.

I agree that "fighting words" exist, and that if avoidable, such "fighting words" could, arguably, be excluded from the doctrine of "free speech."

It's the "arguably" part, IMO, that defines "civilization." A civilized system doesn't grant offended parties license to fire upon an otherwise peaceable assembly. If offended Muslims start shooting, civil authorities are justified in slaying such offended Muslims. Whether any of this has much to do with the central tenets of Islam is, IMO, a completely different question.
 
Last edited:
"C'mon, Mom, let's get it on!" says an amorous Jesus. I don't know if that would incite anyone to violence...

I don't know about violence either, but I haven't heard such horrible dialog in a porn film before, and frankly, I'm disgusted.
 
I don't know about violence either, but I haven't heard such horrible dialog in a porn film before, and frankly, I'm disgusted.

I know the dialog is too cheesy for porn but a more realistic erotic dialog is not an option on this forum.

ETA: Oh yeah, Mom, that's it ... etc. Can't make myself write it.
 
Last edited:
I don't necessarily see this as a free speech issue; at present, there isn't legislation in the U.S. discouraging or prohibiting depictions of Muhammed, so it's simply not an issue with government interference.

That said, I find the notion that one has legitimate reason to fear for their life if they draw a picture of Islam's prophet to be arguably more disturbing than government infringement on free speech. From what I've read, Geller and Wilders
seem like pretty vile individuals with little interest in the actual defense of free speech, but the existence of far-right, xenophobic partisans doesn't do anything to curb the exchange of ideas. The fact that one can reasonably expect to die for criticizing an aspect of Islam seems a rather serious affront to the exchange of ideas.

I guess what I'm getting at is that it doesn't have to be about "free speech" to be about infringements on expression and discourse.
 
The attack on american soil happened mere hours ago. We see already the response from "moderate" "mainstream" "democratic" Muslims. Every response from mainstream Muslim community leaders,here in Europe that I've found so far is the usual bile.
First comes the statements that strongly condemn the attack,then subtly(or not)comes the justifications and more loudly the victim blaming. Attacks on freedom of expression" the violence is deplorable but they must have known this could happen" type rubbish. They drew PICTURES of a nutty cult leader who has been rotting for 1400 years. Drawing pictures leading to violence, see that's the insanity of Islam.
All religions are dangerous but currently Islam is well,well in the lead. People need to stop enabling these nutters by pretending that belief in things like flying horses has any validity-it does not.
I really don't care if I'm called islamophobic,these cretins are dangerous. Some years ago there was a attack on Glasgow airport. Do you know how many Muslim protests were held against the terrorism-zero,nil,not one. The so called assimilated, moderates instead put a few top clerics or other community leaders on t.v,radio etc who in one breath condemned the attack then blamed it on everything from is real through the Iraq war and even the British police. That shows how assimilated the moderates really are. If you believe that everyone who isn't a Muslim is going to burn for eternity then there is no way you can integrate with first world democratic principles. The same goes for Hinduism, Buddhism,Christianity, Shintoism,wiccanism and every other religion.
Right now though,the biggest danger is islam-here is something to keep you awake at night,in Pakistan a load of nutters are standing around,nuclear codes in one hand,Koran in the other. Facing them is another load of nut jobs,they too have nuclear weapons-and a belief that they will get another shot at life through the bullcrap that is reincarnation.
 

Yes,I've got a load of books on the rise of Islam and the Baghdad caliphate. They did not seem to have much of a problem with this. Some of the caliphate artwork is beautiful to behold. So is the literature of the period following the rule of what are called"the rightly guided caliphs". Of course the Baghdad caliphate produced one of the wonders of medieval writing-1001 Arabian nights. I have read transitions of many of the stories numerous times,always enjoyable.
Much of the modern hate of drawings of nutty mo comebs from wahhabinism which took control of places like Saudi following the first world war. When fisels men entered mecca they soon destroyed many period Islamic tombs as "places of idolatry". This erasure of Islamic past continues to this day.

Like your avatar,I'm a huge anime and manga fan.
 
Last edited:
And you don't see a problem with people trying to kill you for saying that?

Do you hold everyone to this same low standard, or just Muslims?

Do you insist that doctors and clinics who provide abortions should share the blame for "inciting" fundamentalist Christians to attack them? Should they shut down and stop providing abortions so innocent bystanders will no longer get killed in clinic bombings?

What about Scientologists? Given what we know about their propensity for harassment and character assassination; maybe society would be better off if we'd all just shut up and stop ridiculing their lunatic beliefs.
And what about The Sisters of Perpetual Indulgence?

The have made an art form out of giving offense to Christianity. Will you condemn them to the same degree as you would condemn those who go out of their way to offend Islam?
 
Facing them is another load of nut jobs,they too have nuclear weapons-and a belief that they will get another shot at life through the bullcrap that is reincarnation.

I see, and how many times has India been an agressor re: Pakistan? I am not a big fan of saber rattling, nor of the current Hindu rightwing party in power. However, the difference between the two countries is that India is still a secular democracy and I have enough confidence that the nuclear option will not be whipped our because someone looked at us wrong.

India isn't perfect, and there is a whole lot that is wrong, but one thing that we have is a constitution that declares us to be a "Secular Socialist Democratic Republic"' and a majority want it to remain so. And apart from a brief attempt at Martial Law in the early 1970s, all governments, for better or worse, have been democratically elected.

Let me see, who was it that wanted military intervention in India to aid Pakistan in 1971? Ooh, he also won a Nobel Prize...for Peace no less. If anything, US has always remained partial to Pakistan.
 
As for the topic at hand...it seems like a bunch of guys poking at a dangerous mad pit bull with a stick. My biggest problem with fundamentalism is that it seems to be contagious. One group resorts to reactionary fundamentalism and opposing groups try to one up to counter and capture the flag.
I am seeing it in my country.
 
And you don't see a problem with people trying to kill you for saying that?

Do you hold everyone to this same low standard, or just Muslims?

Do you insist that doctors and clinics who provide abortions should share the blame for "inciting" fundamentalist Christians to attack them? Should they shut down and stop providing abortions so innocent bystanders will no longer get killed in clinic bombings?

What about Scientologists? Given what we know about their propensity for harassment and character assassination; maybe society would be better off if we'd all just shut up and stop ridiculing their lunatic beliefs.

Yep.

Also maybe gays should stop being so gay cause that offends muslims too.

Imagine a homosexual couple holding hands in front of a mosque, ohh the horror!!! They really shouldn't do that, some religious fanatic might get upset and resort to violence.
 
Imagine a homosexual couple holding hands in front of a mosque, ohh the horror!!! They really shouldn't do that, some religious fanatic might get upset and resort to violence.

But this wasn't what it was, was it?

I am not in any way defending religiotards who believe that their paradoxical god, who is all powerful, needs brainless dolts to ensure his safety and also ensure that his feelings are not hurt.

However, this stunt seems to ha e been designed to provoke a reaction and probably placed quite a few innocents at risk.
 
You can't do something designed to illicit a specific response from a group and then whine when they do it. That's childish.

Does this also apply to slutty sluts who dress slutty and then drink too much and do too much drugs at frat parties with drunk, drugged up, horny frat boys and get gang-raped? She was obviously asking for it. If she whines, its childish.
 
Last edited:
Does this also apply to slutty sluts who dress slutty and then drink too much and do too much drugs at frat parties with drunk, drugged up, horny frat boys and get gang-raped? She was obviously asking for it.

False equivalence. And nobody is defending the religiotards.

The issue here is that the whole exercise was desogned to provoke an pd in so doing the organiser(s) may have been putting the lives of innocents at risk.
 
Last edited:
I need to save some of the brilliant arguments in this thread for the next discussion on people erecting intentionally offensive Nativity scenes during Christmas.

You can't do something designed to illicit a specific response from a group and then whine when they do it. That's childish.

So we can make caricatures of Jesus and the pope but not of muhammed? Because we think there will be violence?

The justification for the curtailment of ideas, satire, free expression... All in the name of being grown up (except it's not, it's cowardly and, by burying ones head in the sand and avoiding the bigger picture, rather childish).
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom