Can a CharlieHebdo-type attack happen in the US?

"If there is no check on the freedom of your speech, then let your hearts be open to the freedom of our actions."
 
And we should consider not kissing venomous snakes too.
It's amazing to me that some might advocate stirring up trouble in the service of what? Some higher ideal? The thinking seems to be that if we just keep insulting zealots they'll stop being upset by it.

What's the point?

Muslims are venomous snakes?

It's called free speech.
 
You don't have to ban anything. You also don't have to be surprised when incitement incites. And, if the consequences can be inferred, then there's a negligence element in play.

If I know a dog is likely to bite me and I taunt the dog, then where's my complaint when I get bit? I am left to complain that dogs bite. Well, duh.

Now Muslims are dogs.
 
And smaller groups of racists can have delusions of grandeur, when in the grand scheme of things they're no more significant than gnat striking your windshied.

Yet you are advocating swerving to avoid the gnats.
 
Jeez, you could look up her words....

From her website:



http://pamelageller.com/2015/05/all...-muhammad-s-a-w-art-exhibition-in-texas.html/ (scroll down; her comment at the end of the captures of the bad dood)

From her interview afterwards with Fox:



I don't have/do Twitter, but the first one, or a variation thereof was originally reported as a Twitter. They may be quoting from her website, or her website may produce tweets (someone with better knowledge of this stuff can correct any misapprehensions there).

But I'd be curious to see you interpret "The war for free speech is a shooting war" to be anything but a call to arms.

When the other side is shooting at you maybe a call to arms is the proper response.
 
There are two specific consequences, for which the right is not fictitious. The first is the right to criticize religion without the consequence of the government silencing your criticism.

The second is the right to criticize religion without the consequence of losing your government's duty to protect you from violence, or losing your own right to defend yourself against violence.


The two groups are neither morally nor practically equivalent. The first is engaging in speech. The second is engaging in deadly violence. Equating the two is a morally depraved argument, doubly so if that false equivalence is then used to excuse the government from protecting its citizens in the first group or to justify the violence in the second group.

+1
 
You're not under the impression that we need the SPLC to tell us that the American Freedom Defense Initiative are comprised of racist thugs are you?

If the SPLC never existed, the AFDI would still be viewed as a hate group.

If we call them names we can deny them free speech?
 
I've been thinking about this truly, monumentally silly suggestion, and how one might explain the strategy to a perfectly reasonable muslim who takes offense to it.

"Listen, nothing against you or anything, but we're going to put out some messages you find truly appalling. These messages will target the sensibilities of Muslim faithful -- you know, caricatures of Mohammed humping a dog, that sort of thing.

"I'm sure you'll be a little sensitive about our message, but, see, the thing is, some of your lot have been violently reacting when they see imagery they find offensive. Our idea is to flood the culture with so many appalling, sacreligious, insulting messages that we will break the spirit of the Muslim people, so they won't fight back at what they perceive as abuse.

"And then, of course, we'll stop abusing Muslims. Cold turkey.

"But until then, it might get a little rough. Still, nothing personal, right?"

Is that the kind of speech you'd be prepared to make?

Why not. what is there about Islam that makes it special so we should not insult their beliefs?

You are aware that your very existence as a non Muslim is insulting?
 
Why not. what is there about Islam that makes it special so we should not insult their beliefs?

You are aware that your very existence as a non Muslim is insulting?

To a minority of Muslims, it's important to make that distinction.
 
Yes.

It would seem.

Riight, so we can expect to see you at the next "take back the night" rally", shouting "just stay in at night! You're just asking for trouble if ladies go out at night!"


Jeez. The amount of people on this thread who can't differentiate jerks from murderers or seem to regard muslim as incapable of exercising sufficient self control to refrain from homicide is shocking.
 
Here's distinct groups:

A) hate filled folks who say that people who beleive "x" are bad

B) hate filled folks who say that people who beleive "x" should be killed

C) hate filled folks who try and kill people who beleive "x"

Pam geller et al appear to be in bucket (a). That is a world away from buckets (b) or (c). If you think that they are neighbors then you do in fact need an urgent check-up on your moral compass.
Wilders' comment that he wants fewer Moroccans in the Netherlands - and similar earlier comments - clearly places him not just in your bucket (a), but somewhere in between buckets (a) and (b). He has not stated (yet) his intended solution, but I can only think of two, one of which would place him in (b).
 
Earlier in the day there was some speculation that the whole incident had to do with the AP exams being held at the center today. That speculation was mainly mine and only conveyed to my kids who were off to take their AP exams at another location. I thought diligence was warranted. My kids disagreed. They really just wanted me to shut up while they put together a decent lunch to take with them.
 
Riight, so we can expect to see you at the next "take back the night" rally", shouting "just stay in at night! You're just asking for trouble if ladies go out at night!"


Jeez. The amount of people on this thread who can't differentiate jerks from murderers or seem to regard muslim as incapable of exercising sufficient self control to refrain from homicide is shocking.

I don't see where my opinion has any bearing.
The question was simply:
Or is there people we can safely provoke and others we can't or at least shouldn't?

I answered "yes" to the "can't" part. There seems to be a disconnect here, as it's pretty clear there are groups we can't "safely" provoke and some that we can.

Nowhere in my answer did my own personal views appear.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom