Can a CharlieHebdo-type attack happen in the US?

The moral equivalence some people are attempting is pretty revolting.

Exactly. When people feel they must choose the lesser of two evils to support to fit a "blame" framework, one wonders how they could possibly function in society. If we could only teach them to reject both evils, what a boon to morality that would be.
 
I think this is probably where we disagree the most. The significance. In my view, it's overblown by extremists on both sides.

Probably not to the people who've been killed around the world for insulting Mohammedinism.
 
It's not?

Are we still talking about the OP?

I'll bite. Who are the sovereigns involved again? Or is it more like a gang war of some sort, with the radical Muslims fighting for some tenement building against the anti-muslims?

Or maybe it's more like the war on poverty?

No, it's not a war. It's one group of idiots provoking another group of idiots and some further idiots trying to make hay out of it all. It's as much a war as throwing a dozen cats in a bag and seeing which get out alive.
 
Exactly. When people feel they must choose the lesser of two evils to support to fit a "blame" framework, one wonders how they could possibly function in society. If we could only teach them to reject both evils, what a boon to morality that would be.

It isn't evil to draw cartoons of Mohammed.

And you cannot teach the Islamists anything, at least not by the methods you would prefer, so the idea that you can get both sides to just settle down is a delusion, you're only putting pressure on one side, the side you call the "lesser evil", though it doesn't deserve that insult.
 
Loss of diversity, for a start.

If whites mix into the pot we lose red hair, blonde hair, green and blue eyes, freckles, etc.

I happen to think many of these traits are beautiful but their uniqueness and rarity globally are enough to justify their preservation.

Nope, that is complete nonsense based on a profound lack of understanding of genetics.

What happens is we still have the extreme ends of the human phenotype spectrum, we just fill in a lot more of the gradations between them.
 
Are we still talking about the OP?

I'll bite. Who are the sovereigns involved again?

This definition of "war" is artificially constrained, for no useful purpose. But even by this measure, ISIS is involved. And much as you might like to think they are not sovereign, they are sovereign in every meaningful sense. And they are at war with, well, everyone.
 
It isn't evil to draw cartoons of Mohammed.

And you cannot teach the Islamists anything, at least not by the methods you would prefer, so the idea that you can get both sides to just settle down is a delusion, you're only putting pressure on one side, the side you call the "lesser evil", though it doesn't deserve that insult.

Just to be plain then, you support inciting religious fundamentalists to violence by drawing cartoons of Mohammed? To what purpose?
 
They are not arbitrary race lines. Northern Europeans have nearly 3% Neanderthal genes. Though propably due to fears of being called racist, I don't hear which traits are attributable to that. Bigger brains is a possibility. Anyhow, there are races, they are discernable.

As I recall, the "ginger gene" appears to have crossed over from Neanderthals.

And it's not just Neanderthal genes, there is also Denisovan, and possibly a third unnamed branch, genetic crossover as well.
 
Probably not to the people who've been killed around the world for insulting Mohammedinism.

Oh, don't knock it. Apparently, those dead people were heroes and martyrs for some larger, morally important cause. Without those deaths, it's unlikely we would see the freedom to lambaste Mohammed such an important and prevalent activity.

They died so we could post what we post. So I could post this: Mohammed was a pig and a child molester.

Thank you heroes!
 
Just to be plain then, you support inciting religious fundamentalists to violence by drawing cartoons of Mohammed? To what purpose?

If drawing cartoons incites violence the issue is with the aggressor, not the illustrator.
 
Oh, don't knock it. Apparently, those dead people were heroes and martyrs for some larger, morally important cause. Without those deaths, it's unlikely we would see the freedom to lambaste Mohammed such an important and prevalent activity.

They died so we could post what we post. So I could post this: Mohammed was a pig and a child molester.

Thank you heroes!

So there are no legitimate criticisms of Islam to be made?
 
But I don't care for Christianity either. Are you suggesting I start attacking Baptists?
Atheism in and of itself is an attack on Christianity; by declaring that G-D does not exist, and that nearly all of the foundational principles are false.

Simply by existing, atheists are offensive to fundamentalist Christians.

The big difference between them and the fundamentalist Muslims, is that Christians almost never kill anyone for blasphemy anymore. Can't say the same for Muslims.

Personally, I fully support events like this, regardless of the fact that the people staging it were jackasses. Doing otherwise is to acceded to the unreasonable and irrational. It is saying that the most violent and vicious among us gets to decide how we are allowed to live and express ourselves. By all accounts, Galileo was one of the biggest jackasses of his day; but he was right. Saying what we want to say, drawing whatever pictures we want to draw, regardless of who it might offend, is a right we possess simply by dint of being human. Either all of us have the same rights, or none of us have any.

Offending the persistently irrational is not something we should shy away from; unless we're happy living under oppressive theocracies.
 
For those arguing the freedom of speech angle: the mujahedin think drawing the Prophet is worthy of death.
Do you trust their judgment about what else deserves death? When, and it is a when, some terrorist nut decides your family gathering is somehow insulting to the Prophet, will you be equivocating then? These attacks are only going to continue.
 
Which source are you using for your statistics?

I'm wondering about that too. I can guess who's in the lead but I think European-American(the other one, not the other group of European-Americans in the lead) still have a significant lead over Asian-Americans and African-Americans.
 
It's framing it as win/lose I disagree with. I feel no loss whatsoever because I don't spend my time drawing pictures of Mohammed.
Yet you still say and do things which offend a great number of people.

It's the sort of war you get on the playground between children:

"He bullied me, so I hit him."
"Free speech! I have the right to bully someone without interference!"
Sorry, but your distortion of the case is far too blatant to ignore.

The more accurate analogy would be more like this:

"He called me names, and drew a bad picture of me, so I hit him."

"I have the right to call someone names and draw pictures of them, as long as I don't do anything to actually hurt them."

Are you able to see the difference there?
 
They are not arbitrary race lines. Northern Europeans have nearly 3% Neanderthal genes. Though propably due to fears of being called racist, I don't hear which traits are attributable to that. Bigger brains is a possibility. Anyhow, there are races, they are discernable.
'
And currently, in California, us Honkies is a minority. Not even the largest one any more. It is time for us to expect all the rights perk and privileges of of minority status. I eagerly await our Brown Overlords to set aside a "Little Reich" neighborhood. Some place where our gangs can spray paint "Viva Los Blancos" on the walls, then riot and burn it all down. And let the Browns set up rebuilding programs.

I am so tired of being hassled by the hombre.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom