Can a CharlieHebdo-type attack happen in the US?

As I recall earlier in the thread, someone here was willing to give up baby back ribs on the grill if their neighbors seemed likely to threaten violence...

If you had a schizophrenic neighbor who told you that black cats are evil and trying to possess him...You would feel compelled to get a black cat? To protect your right of pet ownership?

We modify our behavior in the face of possible conflict all the time. Maybe I think this fat guy in front of me at the store looks totally disgusting, and I feel compelled to make a point to everyone in line that fat people are the scourge of society. I have a right to say that. Should I? Are my freedom of speech rights in jeopardy if I don't?
 
Suppose this was a planned KKK rally in a black neighborhood that sets off a mentally unstable black guy, who plants a bomb where the rally's supposed to be. Except the bomb goes off early and 30 innocent people are killed.

In the above hypothetical, are you claiming that the white supremacists who organized the rally are completely blameless?
Yes, in exactly the same way I hold the people responsible for Taxi Driver completely blameless of the mentally unstable guy who shot President Reagan.
 
If you had a schizophrenic neighbor who told you that black cats are evil and trying to possess him...You would feel compelled to get a black cat? To protect your right of pet ownership?

We modify our behavior in the face of possible conflict all the time. Maybe I think this fat guy in front of me at the store looks totally disgusting, and I feel compelled to make a point to everyone in line that fat people are the scourge of society. I have a right to say that. Should I? Are my freedom of speech rights in jeopardy if I don't?
If I had a liking for.cats, and someone offered me a black cat, yes.
I will not modify my legal behavior SIMPLY TO ACCOMODATE irrational individuals and/or beliefs.
 
Yes, in exactly the same way I hold the people responsible for Taxi Driver completely blameless of the mentally unstable guy who shot President Reagan.

The creator of Taxi Driver had no expectation that creating a movie would lead to a violent chain of events. That's not the case with a clan rally, or Geller's cartoon event. Extra security was hired. Obviously, the organizers felt there was a potential for violence.

So in both cases (a KKK rally, a Mohammed cartoon contest), events are undertaken where the organizers know they're creating a situation where there's a real chance innocent people could get hurt. Is there any moral culpability on their part for creating such a situation? If I know my schizophrenic neighbor has paranoid fantasies about being abducted by aliens, should I talk about how much I miss my home planet and my plans for eventual conquest of the Earth when I see him at the store? Hey, I have every right to, right? It's my free speech.
 
If I had a liking for.cats, and someone offered me a black cat, yes.
I will not modify my legal behavior SIMPLY TO ACCOMODATE irrational individuals and/or beliefs.

A noble principle that is totally divorced from reality. Some examples include: taking your kids to the local park during a riot, bravely staying in your lane when a drunk driver is about to hit you head-on, calmly completing your bank transaction during an armed robbery, not hitting the ground when two gang members start shooting at each other... after all, you have legal right to stand on the sidewalk, right? Why should you duck just because bullets are whizzing by you?
 
A noble principle that is totally divorced from reality. Some examples include: taking your kids to the local park during a riot, bravely staying in your lane when a drunk driver is about to hit you head-on, calmly completing your bank transaction during an armed robbery, not hitting the ground when two gang members start shooting at each other... after all, you have legal right to stand on the sidewalk, right? Why should you duck just because bullets are whizzing by you?
That was the stupidest response I have ever seen.
I state I will not.modify my behavior SIMPLY BECAUSE, and you throw in a **** pot full of extenuating circumstances.
That's a really ********** up argument...
 
That was the stupidest response I have ever seen.
I state I will not.modify my behavior SIMPLY BECAUSE, and you throw in a **** pot full of extenuating circumstances.
That's a really ********** up argument...

You mean I gave you examples of where you would modify your behavior when other people are acting irrationally?

Oh, here's one: you notice your neighbor's four pit bulls just got out of his yard, and you have this nice steak dinner you're just dying to eat on the front porch...
 
A noble principle that is totally divorced from reality. Some examples include: taking your kids to the local park during a riot, bravely staying in your lane when a drunk driver is about to hit you head-on, calmly completing your bank transaction during an armed robbery, not hitting the ground when two gang members start shooting at each other... after all, you have legal right to stand on the sidewalk, right? Why should you duck just because bullets are whizzing by you?

...Publicly insulting the Taliban in Pakistan...seeking an abortion in the midwest... wearing a miniskirt after dark... being black and sitting down at a whites-only lunch counter during the civil-rights movement...driving while female in SA... deciding not to be Muslim anymore in a fundamentalist country... holding hands with someone of the same sex in Uganda...

When will these whiny troublemakers learn?
 
A noble principle that is totally divorced from reality. Some examples include: taking your kids to the local park during a riot, bravely staying in your lane when a drunk driver is about to hit you head-on, calmly completing your bank transaction during an armed robbery, not hitting the ground when two gang members start shooting at each other... after all, you have legal right to stand on the sidewalk, right? Why should you duck just because bullets are whizzing by you?

...Publicly insulting the Taliban in Pakistan...seeking an abortion in the midwest... wearing a miniskirt after dark... being black and sitting down at a whites-only lunch counter during the civil-rights movement...driving while female in SA... deciding not to be Muslim anymore in a fundamentalist country... holding hands with someone of the same sex in Uganda...

When will these whiny troublemakers learn?

The difference between the two lists seems to be whether I think doing the act is worth the risk. Plainly, lots of people saw the stuff on the second list and decided it wasn't worth the risk. Nor would I recommend someone in, say, Uganda display their same-sex preference simply because I want them to make a point on my behalf.

This is no different than deciding if someone is acting heroically or foolishly when they endanger their life. The intent makes all the difference. If I run into a burning building to save someone, I'm a hero. If I run into a burning building to show I don't fear fire, I'm an idiot.

We are left with the same question as always - was Geller acting heroically or foolishly, and what was the intended purpose of the event?

I do not see heroism in taunting Muslims. Others see heroism/courage here.

I still think the free speech connection is bogus, because she could have held her contest online without the risks.
 
You mean I gave you examples of where you would modify your behavior when other people are acting irrationally?

Oh, here's one: you notice your neighbor's four pit bulls just got out of his yard, and you have this nice steak dinner you're just dying to eat on the front porch...
I suggest you look up the difference between "acting" and "believing".
 
This is where y'all keep going off the rails. You can't wrap your mind around the idea that consequences don't have to be "specified". They don't have to be inevitable, they don't have to be punitive.


Except that your'e either grossly misstating your point, or you're engaging in pointless truisms; and it's not clear which.

As others have noted: Of course speech has consequences. That is the entire point of expression. To say that "speech has consequences" is to say that "water is wet". Yes, of course it does, otherwise it wouldn't be speech, it would just be random noise. To say that one should "understand that speech has consequences" is to say that one should "understand that walking will move you from one position to another", or that one should "understand that contacting water will cause one to get wet". What would be the point of the activity otherwise?

You really do need to clarify the point you are trying and possibly failing to make. Really, it is not even remotely clear here what you are trying to say besides these blatant truisms. Do you have a point beyond that?
 
A noble principle that is totally divorced from reality. Some examples include: taking your kids to the local park during a riot, bravely staying in your lane when a drunk driver is about to hit you head-on, calmly completing your bank transaction during an armed robbery, not hitting the ground when two gang members start shooting at each other... after all, you have legal right to stand on the sidewalk, right? Why should you duck just because bullets are whizzing by you?


The false equivalencies fly fast and hard on this one.

Tell me, what beliefs do those bullets have that standing up to them is opposing? What is the worldview that the drunk driver is trying to deliberately impose through his actions.

Really, this much straw is a serious fire hazard.
 
The false equivalencies fly fast and hard on this one.

Tell me, what beliefs do those bullets have that standing up to them is opposing? What is the worldview that the drunk driver is trying to deliberately impose through his actions.

Really, this much straw is a serious fire hazard.

The only reason that drawing Muhammad is dangerous is because Muslims have decided to impose their religious dogma on the world yet instead of criticizing Islam some posters here criticize the person who defy this imposition.
 
If you had a schizophrenic neighbor who told you that black cats are evil and trying to possess him...You would feel compelled to get a black cat? To protect your right of pet ownership?

<snip>


If I had a liking for.cats, and someone offered me a black cat, yes.
I will not modify my legal behavior SIMPLY TO ACCOMODATE irrational individuals and/or beliefs.


Unsurprisingly, you responded with an answer to a question which wasn't asked.

This is the question you were asked (At least as I read it.)

Would you make a point of going out and getting a black cat specifically for the purpose of demonstrating to your schizophrenic neighbor that you had the right to own one whether he liked the idea or not?
 
The false equivalencies fly fast and hard on this one.

Tell me, what beliefs do those bullets have that standing up to them is opposing? What is the worldview that the drunk driver is trying to deliberately impose through his actions.

Really, this much straw is a serious fire hazard.

There are millions of Muslims peacefully living in America. Maybe you can tell me what worldview they're trying to impose on me, because I don't feel imposed on. Are they infiltrating local school boards? Chambers of commerce? Congress? Is one hiding in the closet, waiting for me to draw a Mohammed cartoon?

And is not drawing cartoons advancing this..worldview somehow (we both know you're talking about the Sharia Law boogeyman)? How does that go, if we don't draw the cartoons the jihadists have won? Something like that?

The principle at work here is, if you deliberately provoke unstable people, you create a situation where innocent people can get hurt. That's generally not a desirable state of affairs. Nobody's claiming you shouldn't have the right to draw offensive cartoons. You should and obviously do have that right. You also have the right to go goosestepping past the local synagogue in a Nazi uniform. For the Nazi wannabe (and the Mohammed cartoonist), the question isn't whether you have the right to, rather is it a good idea.

The arguments for why it was a good idea to A) piss off Muslims and B) create a situation where some unhinged lunatic might feel compelled to strap on a suicide vest haven't been very good. They have, in fact, been very lame. It's all been a version of we have the right to draw offensive cartoons, therefore... we MUST draw offensive cartoons! Cause if we don't draw cartoons, something happens and... Sharia Law!

If the issue is asserting our freedom of speech rights, then let's really assert them. Offending an unpopular minority that has no influence is easy and relatively risk free. If Geller really wants to see how strong those rights are, why doesn't she hold a contest to see who can draw the best caricature of blacks getting lynched? Then we could see how strong freedom of speech really is- is it stronger than, say, career suicide?
 
Unsurprisingly, you responded with an answer to a question which wasn't asked.

This is the question you were asked (At least as I read it.)

Would you make a point of going out and getting a black cat specifically for the purpose of demonstrating to your schizophrenic neighbor that you had the right to own one whether he liked the idea or not?

That was indeed the question I asked.
 
Unsurprisingly, you responded with an answer to a question which wasn't asked.

This is the question you were asked (At least as I read it.)

Would you make a point of going out and getting a black cat specifically for the purpose of demonstrating to your schizophrenic neighbor that you had the right to own one whether he liked the idea or not?

There are millions of Muslims peacefully living in America. Maybe you can tell me what worldview they're trying to impose on me, because I don't feel imposed on. Are they infiltrating local school boards? Chambers of commerce? Congress? Is one hiding in the closet, waiting for me to draw a Mohammed cartoon?

And is not drawing cartoons advancing this..worldview somehow (we both know you're talking about the Sharia Law boogeyman)? How does that go, if we don't draw the cartoons the jihadists have won? Something like that?

The principle at work here is, if you deliberately provoke unstable people, you create a situation where innocent people can get hurt. That's generally not a desirable state of affairs. Nobody's claiming you shouldn't have the right to draw offensive cartoons. You should and obviously do have that right. You also have the right to go goosestepping past the local synagogue in a Nazi uniform. For the Nazi wannabe (and the Mohammed cartoonist), the question isn't whether you have the right to, rather is it a good idea.

The arguments for why it was a good idea to A) piss off Muslims and B) create a situation where some unhinged lunatic might feel compelled to strap on a suicide vest haven't been very good. They have, in fact, been very lame. It's all been a version of we have the right to draw offensive cartoons, therefore... we MUST draw offensive cartoons! Cause if we don't draw cartoons, something happens and... Sharia Law!

If the issue is asserting our freedom of speech rights, then let's really assert them. Offending an unpopular minority that has no influence is easy and relatively risk free. If Geller really wants to see how strong those rights are, why doesn't she hold a contest to see who can draw the best caricature of blacks getting lynched? Then we could see how strong freedom of speech really is- is it stronger than, say, career suicide?

Muslims are schizophrenic and unstable?

Risk free!? Guess those two dead guys were just going to critique the drawings.
 
There are millions of Muslims peacefully living in America. Maybe you can tell me what worldview they're trying to impose on me, because I don't feel imposed on. Are they infiltrating local school boards? Chambers of commerce? Congress? Is one hiding in the closet, waiting for me to draw a Mohammed cartoon?

And is not drawing cartoons advancing this..worldview somehow (we both know you're talking about the Sharia Law boogeyman)? How does that go, if we don't draw the cartoons the jihadists have won? Something like that?

The principle at work here is, if you deliberately provoke unstable people, you create a situation where innocent people can get hurt. That's generally not a desirable state of affairs. Nobody's claiming you shouldn't have the right to draw offensive cartoons. You should and obviously do have that right. You also have the right to go goosestepping past the local synagogue in a Nazi uniform. For the Nazi wannabe (and the Mohammed cartoonist), the question isn't whether you have the right to, rather is it a good idea.

The arguments for why it was a good idea to A) piss off Muslims and B) create a situation where some unhinged lunatic might feel compelled to strap on a suicide vest haven't been very good. They have, in fact, been very lame. It's all been a version of we have the right to draw offensive cartoons, therefore... we MUST draw offensive cartoons! Cause if we don't draw cartoons, something happens and... Sharia Law!

If the issue is asserting our freedom of speech rights, then let's really assert them. Offending an unpopular minority that has no influence is easy and relatively risk free. If Geller really wants to see how strong those rights are, why doesn't she hold a contest to see who can draw the best caricature of blacks getting lynched? Then we could see how strong freedom of speech really is- is it stronger than, say, career suicide?

You and your allies in this thread have made some interesting analogies. In one, the predictable Muslim response to a religious taboo is a force of nature like the wind or the sea or gravity that cannot be changed. In another analogy, Muslims are like sick people who have no control over their actions and cannot change their behavior. So, just as it's stupid to try to fly by jumping off a building, or inconsiderate to eat peanuts around somebody with a nut allergy, it's both stupid and inconsiderate to let devout Muslims see you display a picture of Muhammad.

The problem with these analogies is that the Muslims who get offended by the breach of one of Islam's taboos, and even the ones who are prepared to use violence to punish it, are neither immutable forces of nature nor sick people, but generally normal and rational human beings. I doubt very much that the two jihadists who were killed in Garland, TX were crazy in any meaningful sense of the word. They weren't born with a murderous aversion to Muhammad cartoons. They had to be taught that, along with the rest of the Islamist ideology that motivated them. Not only can what is taught be untaught, but their aversion to Muhammad cartoons is likely insincere and mostly pretextual. It's so unnatural to be offended by a drawing of somebody that nobody alive has ever seen a picture of that I can only think that the taboo and its enforcement is part of a deliberate strategy to earn respect and win some measure of control over another group.

This leads me to the key difference between drawing cartoons of Muhammad and drawing cartoons making fun of blacks being lynched. The latter is offensive to all reasonable human beings, and discouragement of such activity happens naturally as a result of social pressure. The former is only offensive to Muslims, and even then, probably only to some of them, and furthermore probably only as a pretext. It can only be imposed on non-Muslims through the threat of violence.

Of course another difference is that the NY Times would have no problem publishing a racist or antisemitic cartoon if it was necessary to understanding a story. There are many such examples. But the NY Times has so far refused to publish cartoons of Muhammad, regardless of how relevant they are.
 
Last edited:
Muslims are schizophrenic and unstable?

<snip>


I saw nothing suggesting that the 'schizophrenic neighbor' posited by Fudbucker in his hypothetical scenario was Muslim.

Quite the contrary, the scenario seemed to be set up specifically to remove the religious issue from the equation.


Why do you feel compelled to make crap up in order to appear to be commenting on something? If you can't manage to base your responses on things which were actually said maybe the best thing to do would be to not respond, as opposed to lying.

It would definitely be more honest.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom