You and your allies in this thread have made some interesting analogies. In one, the predictable Muslim response to a religious taboo is a force of nature like the wind or the sea or gravity that cannot be changed.
What is the predictable response to calling a group of blacks a bunch of *******? Does that make blacks unreasonable? Unthinking? Knee-jerk reactionists? What is the predictable response of an ACLU member to nativity scenes? Everyone has something they find offensive. Muslims are no different.
In another analogy, Muslims are like sick people who have no control over their actions and cannot change their behavior.
Not at all. The vast majority of Muslims are peaceful. Some Muslims are mentally sick people. Some members of any group are mentally unstable, because a certain percentage of the population is unstable. Was the Unabomber Muslim? Was Timothy McVeigh? David Koresh? Jim Jones?
So, just as it's stupid to try to fly by jumping off a building, or inconsiderate to eat peanuts around somebody with a nut allergy, it's both stupid and inconsiderate to let devout Muslims see you display a picture of Muhammad.
Yes, it is, like telling racist jokes. In both cases, you have the right to do so. Just because you have the right to act stupid and inconsiderate doesn't mean you SHOULD do stupid and inconsiderate things.
The problem with these analogies is that the Muslims who get offended by the breach of one of Islam's taboos, and even the ones who are prepared to use violence to punish it, are neither immutable forces of nature nor sick people, but generally normal and rational human beings.
Yes, rational people get offended over stuff. We've already established that. With blacks, it's the N-word. With atheists, it's the mention of god in the public square (or on money). With Muslims, it's depictions of Mohammed. Muslims, no matter how much you want to pigeonhole them, are as human as you are I. I get offended when women are whistled at. That pushes my button for some reasons. For a lot of Muslims, it's Mohammed cartoons.
I doubt very much that the two jihadists who were killed in Garland, TX were crazy in any meaningful sense of the word. They weren't born with a murderous aversion to Muhammad cartoons. They had to be taught that, along with the rest of the Islamist ideology that motivated them. Not only can what is taught be untaught, but their aversion to Muhammad cartoons is likely insincere and mostly pretextual.
I have no idea how sincere they were about Mohammed cartoons. I do have doubts about their mental stability. They may not be insane in the legal sense of the word, but do you think mentally stable people go around killing people over cartoons? These two guys (had they lived) would have joined a long list of people who were declared legally sane, but had obvious mental hangups. Jeffrey Dahmer liked to eat people. He was declared sane. So was Ed Kemper.
It's so unnatural to be offended by a drawing of somebody that nobody alive has ever seen a picture of that I can only think that the taboo and its enforcement is part of a deliberate strategy to earn respect and win some measure of control over another group.
Why is it unnatural? I wasn't alive to see Martin Luther King Jr, yet I would be deeply offended by a cartoon that showed him being ********** in the ass by a Clansman. Nobody is alive who has ever seen Susan B. Anthony. Does that somehow preclude someone from being offended of a cartoon showing her being raped?
This leads me to the key difference between drawing cartoons of Muhammad and drawing cartoons making fun of blacks being lynched. The latter is offensive to all reasonable human beings, and discouragement of such activity happens naturally as a result of social pressure. The former is only offensive to Muslims, and even then, probably only to some of them, and furthermore probably only as a pretext.
No it's not. I (not a Muslim) find the cartoons very offensive. I hate publicity stunts devised to provoke a violent response, whose only purpose is to ridicule and demean a minority group.
It can only be imposed on non-Muslims through the threat of violence.
What bigoted nonsense. The only recourse for offended Muslims is violence? Seriously?
Of course another difference is that the NY Times would have no problem publishing a racist or antisemitic cartoon if it was necessary to understanding a story. There are many such examples. But the NY Times has so far refused to publish cartoons of Muhammad, regardless of how relevant they are.
And a lot of media outlets will substitute "the n-word" for ******. What's your point?
Edited by Agatha:
removed several breaches of rule 10. Do not attempt to bypass the autocensor by swearing; type the word out in full and allow the autocensor to work.
Last edited by a moderator: