Can a CharlieHebdo-type attack happen in the US?

You and your allies in this thread have made some interesting analogies. In one, the predictable Muslim response to a religious taboo is a force of nature like the wind or the sea or gravity that cannot be changed.

What is the predictable response to calling a group of blacks a bunch of *******? Does that make blacks unreasonable? Unthinking? Knee-jerk reactionists? What is the predictable response of an ACLU member to nativity scenes? Everyone has something they find offensive. Muslims are no different.

In another analogy, Muslims are like sick people who have no control over their actions and cannot change their behavior.

Not at all. The vast majority of Muslims are peaceful. Some Muslims are mentally sick people. Some members of any group are mentally unstable, because a certain percentage of the population is unstable. Was the Unabomber Muslim? Was Timothy McVeigh? David Koresh? Jim Jones?

So, just as it's stupid to try to fly by jumping off a building, or inconsiderate to eat peanuts around somebody with a nut allergy, it's both stupid and inconsiderate to let devout Muslims see you display a picture of Muhammad.

Yes, it is, like telling racist jokes. In both cases, you have the right to do so. Just because you have the right to act stupid and inconsiderate doesn't mean you SHOULD do stupid and inconsiderate things.

The problem with these analogies is that the Muslims who get offended by the breach of one of Islam's taboos, and even the ones who are prepared to use violence to punish it, are neither immutable forces of nature nor sick people, but generally normal and rational human beings.

Yes, rational people get offended over stuff. We've already established that. With blacks, it's the N-word. With atheists, it's the mention of god in the public square (or on money). With Muslims, it's depictions of Mohammed. Muslims, no matter how much you want to pigeonhole them, are as human as you are I. I get offended when women are whistled at. That pushes my button for some reasons. For a lot of Muslims, it's Mohammed cartoons.

I doubt very much that the two jihadists who were killed in Garland, TX were crazy in any meaningful sense of the word. They weren't born with a murderous aversion to Muhammad cartoons. They had to be taught that, along with the rest of the Islamist ideology that motivated them. Not only can what is taught be untaught, but their aversion to Muhammad cartoons is likely insincere and mostly pretextual.

I have no idea how sincere they were about Mohammed cartoons. I do have doubts about their mental stability. They may not be insane in the legal sense of the word, but do you think mentally stable people go around killing people over cartoons? These two guys (had they lived) would have joined a long list of people who were declared legally sane, but had obvious mental hangups. Jeffrey Dahmer liked to eat people. He was declared sane. So was Ed Kemper.

It's so unnatural to be offended by a drawing of somebody that nobody alive has ever seen a picture of that I can only think that the taboo and its enforcement is part of a deliberate strategy to earn respect and win some measure of control over another group.

Why is it unnatural? I wasn't alive to see Martin Luther King Jr, yet I would be deeply offended by a cartoon that showed him being ********** in the ass by a Clansman. Nobody is alive who has ever seen Susan B. Anthony. Does that somehow preclude someone from being offended of a cartoon showing her being raped?

This leads me to the key difference between drawing cartoons of Muhammad and drawing cartoons making fun of blacks being lynched. The latter is offensive to all reasonable human beings, and discouragement of such activity happens naturally as a result of social pressure. The former is only offensive to Muslims, and even then, probably only to some of them, and furthermore probably only as a pretext.

No it's not. I (not a Muslim) find the cartoons very offensive. I hate publicity stunts devised to provoke a violent response, whose only purpose is to ridicule and demean a minority group.

It can only be imposed on non-Muslims through the threat of violence.

What bigoted nonsense. The only recourse for offended Muslims is violence? Seriously?

Of course another difference is that the NY Times would have no problem publishing a racist or antisemitic cartoon if it was necessary to understanding a story. There are many such examples. But the NY Times has so far refused to publish cartoons of Muhammad, regardless of how relevant they are.

And a lot of media outlets will substitute "the n-word" for ******. What's your point?

Edited by Agatha: 
removed several breaches of rule 10. Do not attempt to bypass the autocensor by swearing; type the word out in full and allow the autocensor to work.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
(much snipped)
The problem with these analogies is that the Muslims who get offended by the breach of one of Islam's taboos, and even the ones who are prepared to use violence to punish it, are neither immutable forces of nature nor sick people, but generally normal and rational human beings. I doubt very much that the two jihadists who were killed in Garland, TX were crazy in any meaningful sense of the word.

I have been avoiding that aspect to focus on others, thinking it "a bridge to far" to humanize the terrorists. It seemed pointless when criticizing Geller gets the label "apologist."

They weren't born with a murderous aversion to Muhammad cartoons. They had to be taught that, along with the rest of the Islamist ideology that motivated them. Not only can what is taught be untaught, but their aversion to Muhammad cartoons is likely insincere and mostly pretextual. It's so unnatural to be offended by a drawing of somebody that nobody alive has ever seen a picture of that I can only think that the taboo and its enforcement is part of a deliberate strategy to earn respect and win some measure of control over another group.

The part I highlighted struck me as strange in the context of this event. How is provoking someone and killing them teaching? It's a pretty tough class when the first exam gets you killed outright. Hard to teach dead people.
 
I saw nothing suggesting that the 'schizophrenic neighbor' posited by Fudbucker in his hypothetical scenario was Muslim.

Quite the contrary, the scenario seemed to be set up specifically to remove the religious issue from the equation.
Why do you feel compelled to make crap up in order to appear to be commenting on something? If you can't manage to base your responses on things which were actually said maybe the best thing to do would be to not respond, as opposed to lying.

It would definitely be more honest.

Then you admit that your and his scenario has nothing to do with the topic.
 
If I had a liking for.cats, and someone offered me a black cat, yes.
I will not modify my legal behavior SIMPLY TO ACCOMODATE irrational individuals and/or beliefs.

"Irrational"....? It's a mental health condition. He did say "schizophrenic", not "eccentric". What other illnesses or conditions will you not concede to? Legally, you are entitled to walk straight down the sidewalk. Are you going to smack into the guy with the red-tipped white cane?

So just because you "like" cats, you'd flaunt one on your veranda or in your window to a neighbor with a mental health condition, knowing that it might cause serious anguish to that person? This is when "your freedom of speech ends just before my nose". You are actively causing pain to "make a statement"? Let's see... what other group being discussed holds that view?
 
The only reason that drawing Muhammad is dangerous is because Muslims have decided to impose their religious dogma on the world yet instead of criticizing Islam some posters here criticize the person who defy this imposition.

Can't they criticise both ? I think everybody agrees that the blame for the attack goes to the ******** who commited it. Some people are saying that holding the event while knowing that such an attack was likely was irresponsible, and thus partly to blame. I'm not sure I agree with those posters but let's at least argue their point, not some strawman version of it.
 
What is the predictable response to calling a group of blacks a bunch of *******? Does that make blacks unreasonable? Unthinking? Knee-jerk reactionists? What is the predictable response of an ACLU member to nativity scenes? Everyone has something they find offensive. Muslims are no different.

You missed my point which isn't that the response can't be predicted but that the response is not some immutable fact of nature which can't be changed through conditioning and reason.

<snip>

Yes, it is, like telling racist jokes. In both cases, you have the right to do so. Just because you have the right to act stupid and inconsiderate doesn't mean you SHOULD do stupid and inconsiderate things.

There is a time and a place for everything. In some situations telling racist jokes is perfectly fine. In some situations taking off your clothes and prancing around naked is fine. In some situations, eating your entree with your salad fork is fine. And in some situations, these things are stupid and inconsiderate. The problem with the drawing or displaying of Muhammad cartoons is that, for some Muslims, it is considered a blanket taboo with no exceptions. Otherwise the NY Times would have no problem publishing Muhammad cartoons, the vast majority of which, in the case of the Jyllands-Posten controversy, would be considered interesting and inoffensive by reasonable people.

Yes, rational people get offended over stuff. We've already established that. With blacks, it's the N-word. With atheists, it's the mention of god in the public square (or on money). With Muslims, it's depictions of Mohammed. Muslims, no matter how much you want to pigeonhole them, are as human as you are I. I get offended when women are whistled at. That pushes my button for some reasons. For a lot of Muslims, it's Mohammed cartoons.

I agree that Muslims are as human as you and I, even the extremist ones. Which is why I think they can be weaned from their more ridiculous and unreasonable religious taboos, or at least from their expectations that such taboos can and should be imposed on non-Muslims.

I have no idea how sincere they were about Mohammed cartoons. I do have doubts about their mental stability. They may not be insane in the legal sense of the word, but do you think mentally stable people go around killing people over cartoons? These two guys (had they lived) would have joined a long list of people who were declared legally sane, but had obvious mental hangups. Jeffrey Dahmer liked to eat people. He was declared sane. So was Ed Kemper.

No, I'm not just talking about sanity, but about normality. Dahmer may have been sane in the sense that he was logical and not delusional, but he was a psychopath. He was not normal. I suspect these guys were normal. They had just been indoctrinated in an ideology which motivated them to act as if they were soldiers in a war. So yes I do think mentally stable people go around killing people over cartoons. They also cut off the heads of apostates. There is a strategy behind this, and it works particularly well against cowards who conflate surrender with being considerate and respectful.

Why is it unnatural? I wasn't alive to see Martin Luther King Jr, yet I would be deeply offended by a cartoon that showed him being ********** in the ass by a Clansman. Nobody is alive who has ever seen Susan B. Anthony. Does that somehow preclude someone from being offended of a cartoon showing her being raped?

These are strawmen. Even reverent and respectful drawings of Muhammad will get the same response from the extremists. It is the very act of violating their taboo on the depiction of Muhammad that they they take issue with, not the way in which he is depicted. An offensive drawing of Muhammad would be offensive to most reasonable people, although even then there are situations where they can be appropriate. An inoffensive drawing should be inoffensive to reasonable people, of course, once again in reasonable contexts. Posting one on a mosque is reasonably perceived as an offensive provocation.

No it's not. I (not a Muslim) find the cartoons very offensive. I hate publicity stunts devised to provoke a violent response, whose only purpose is to ridicule and demean a minority group.

No, that was not the purpose of the "stunt" as has been discussed in this thread many times. The purpose was to push back against a particular encroachment on our right to free speech.

What bigoted nonsense. The only recourse for offended Muslims is violence? Seriously?

Bigoted? What are you talking about? If it wasn't for the threat of violence, this wouldn't even be an issue. Muslims could still have their taboo, and yet the NY Times would publish a picture of Muhammad from time to time, just as it has published racist and antisemitic cartoons from time to time. And perhaps South Park wouldn't have had to put Muhammad in a bear suit.

And a lot of media outlets will substitute "the n-word" for ******. What's your point?

That's a stupid taboo too, but at least it's not happening because of threats of violence. Some editors have decided to make that substitution for their own reasons of political correctness. It doesn't really detract from the story, since we all know what word to substitute. I still think it's dumb though.
 
<snip>

The part I highlighted struck me as strange in the context of this event. How is provoking someone and killing them teaching? It's a pretty tough class when the first exam gets you killed outright. Hard to teach dead people.

Pour encourager les autres.
 
There are millions of Muslims peacefully living in America. Maybe you can tell me what worldview they're trying to impose on me, because I don't feel imposed on. Are they infiltrating local school boards? Chambers of commerce? Congress? Is one hiding in the closet, waiting for me to draw a Mohammed cartoon?


Useless hyperbole. The millions of peaceful Muslims are not a problem, and no one should care about insulting them any more than they care about insulting the millions of peaceful Christians or Mormons that live in this country. I've noticed no one on this board cares about insulting the latter, so why all the special pleading for the former?

And is not drawing cartoons advancing this..worldview somehow (we both know you're talking about the Sharia Law boogeyman)?


You might be, I'm not; and couldn't care less about the Shari'a boogeyman. I have explicitly said many times what I'm talking about, go back and re-read the thread.


How does that go, if we don't draw the cartoons the jihadists have won? Something like that?


If we refrain from doing so because we fear a violent reprisal, then yes. That's patently obvious, since it is the entire reason for the violence of the fanatics. Have you not been paying attention to history?

The principle at work here is, if you deliberately provoke unstable people, you create a situation where innocent people can get hurt. That's generally not a desirable state of affairs.


Congratulations, you have just managed to completely invalidate the entire history of civil rights in the USA; and indeed, much of the world. They should have patiently waited for someone to hand them their freedom on a platter, instead of provoking the unstable and irrational who were denying it to them; because of all the innocents that got hurt during the protests and demonstrations. If those black people hadn't provoked the bigots by mouthing off to them, or sitting in the wrong part of the bus, innocents wouldn't have gotten hurt.

Nobody's claiming you shouldn't have the right to draw offensive cartoons. You should and obviously do have that right. You also have the right to go goosestepping past the local synagogue in a Nazi uniform. For the Nazi wannabe (and the Mohammed cartoonist), the question isn't whether you have the right to, rather is it a good idea.


Speaking your mind, as long as you are not advocating violence and fraud, is always a good idea.

The arguments for why it was a good idea to A) piss off Muslims and


This had nothing to do with pissing off Muslims, it was about pissing off fanatics. Go back and re-read the thread.


B) create a situation where some unhinged lunatic might feel compelled to strap on a suicide vest haven't been very good. They have, in fact, been very lame.


Sheer nonsense. One cannot "create a situation where some unhinged lunatic might feel compelled" to do anything. The fact that they are unhinged lunatics, or in this case religious fanatics, is sufficient to do so regardless of any other condition. The very existence of those who disagree with them is sufficient provocation. That's what being a fanatic means.

It's all been a version of we have the right to draw offensive cartoons, therefore... we MUST draw offensive cartoons! Cause if we don't draw cartoons, something happens and... Sharia Law!


Blah, blah, blah, straw man dismissal that has nothing to do with the topic; read the thread.

If the issue is asserting our freedom of speech rights, then let's really assert them. Offending an unpopular minority that has no influence is easy and relatively risk free. If Geller really wants to see how strong those rights are, why doesn't she hold a contest to see who can draw the best caricature of blacks getting lynched? Then we could see how strong freedom of speech really is- is it stronger than, say, career suicide?


More nonsense. How would promoting violence against an oppressed minority forward the cause of freedom?
 
I saw nothing suggesting that the 'schizophrenic neighbor' posited by Fudbucker in his hypothetical scenario was Muslim.

Quite the contrary, the scenario seemed to be set up specifically to remove the religious issue from the equation.


Why? Given that this thread is about religious fanaticism; I don't really see what possible relevance that could have had. I could create a scenario involving annoying a local kennel club organization; with just as much relevance.

Why do you feel compelled to make crap up in order to appear to be commenting on something?


Once could easily ask the same of you and Fudbucker, since weird hypotheticals about schizophrenics have nothing to do with the subject of the thread.

It would definitely be more honest.


What would be more honest is trying to stick to the subject of the thread, religious fanaticism in general, and fundamentalist Muslim fanatics in particular; instead of trying to sidetrack the thread with ridiculous and irrelevant hypotheticals.
 
Last edited:
Why? Given that this thread is about religious fanaticism; I don't really see what possible relevance that could have had. I could create a scenario involving annoying a local kennel club organization; with just as much relevance.




Once could easily ask the same of you and Fudbucker, since weird hypotheticals about schizophrenics have nothing to do with the subject of the thread.




What would be more honest is trying to stick to the subject of the thread, religious fanaticism in general, and fundamentalist Muslim fanatics in particular; instead of trying to sidetrack the thread with ridiculous and irrelevant hypotheticals.


Actually, and not surprisingly, you're wrong. It was an analogous situation to doing something that would upset a neighbor. Don't we recall someone saying that it was one's duty to barbecue pork on the patio if the neighbor voiced religious objections. Since numerous members here think that all believers in any religion are fanatics or borderline psychotics, drawing a parallel to doing something that would push a schizophrenic over the line, is actually not bad.... not bad at all.

And as to staying within the thread topic? First of all, analogies and hypotheticals, properly explained, can be fitting to the discussion.

I notice in the below that you're not really sticking to the topic of the thread but all over the map, apparently getting ready to nominate Pamela for the Nobel Peace Prize.

Holding GLBT Pride parades willfully creates a situation that is dangerous to participants; especially in places like Eastern Europe and Africa.

Running an abortion clinic willfully creates a situation that is dangerous to employees and patients.

Holding civil rights marches in the '50s and '60s willfully created a situation that was dangerous to participants and bystanders. Similarly, anti-apartheid demonstrations in South Africa willfully created an even more dangerous situation.

The KKK and Neo-Nazi organizations holding public rallies and marches willfully creates a situation that is dangerous to participants and bystanders.

A whole lot of what humans do in protest to what they see as injustice or oppression or other social ills, rightly or wrongly, willfully creates situations that are potentially dangerous to themselves or bystanders. If that wasn't the case, then there wouldn't be a need for the protests to begin with.

The thing is, it doesn't matter why they hold these protests or rallies, it doesn't matter what their cause is, or how right or wrong they are perceived to be. All that matters is whether they are equally free to exercise their right to express themselves and their views, without explicitly causing or inciting violence or fraud. Any culture that truly cares about equal rights has to support freedom of expression for even the most loathsome, despised, and intolerant; otherwise there is no true freedom of expression, only the privilege of being allowed to agree with the dominant majority worldview.

But perhaps this is too nuanced a concept for you.

You could've just as easily included, "Keeping a black cat when your next door neighbor is a schizophrenic and is deathly afraid of them willfully, etc...." Seems your derailing analogies are cool, 'cuz they're you're derailing analogies. Others? Not so much. Or is this, perhaps, too nuanced a concept for you?
 
You could've just as easily included, "Keeping a black cat when your next door neighbor is a schizophrenic and is deathly afraid of them willfully, etc...." Seems your derailing analogies are cool, 'cuz they're you're derailing analogies. Others? Not so much. Or is this, perhaps, too nuanced a concept for you?

Another dodge. Will no one address the fact the you, marplots etc, apparently view the civil rights marches, freedom riders, rosa parks etc as being wrong?
 
Another dodge. Will no one address the fact the you, marplots etc, apparently view the civil rights marches, freedom riders, rosa parks etc as being wrong?

Wrong how? If I have to support a position someone picks out for me, I need a few more details.
 
Another dodge. Will no one address the fact the you, marplots etc, apparently view the civil rights marches, freedom riders, rosa parks etc as being wrong?

C'mon, I'm sure they're for fighting for civil rights as long as you don't offend anyone.
 
Since numerous members here think that all believers in any religion are fanatics or borderline psychotics,


Which is completely irrelevant. What they believe doesn't change what is. Especially when what they believe is completely and totally wrong. No different than believing any other pseudo-scientific woo.

Not all believers are fanatics, and not all fanatics are psychotics. Rarely, in fact. The vast majority of believers are simple ordinary people who happen to have been raised to believe something, or have not developed the critical thinking skills to allow them to critically evaluate their beliefs, or who have deliberately chosen to believe something regardless of how their rational mind evaluates it.

drawing a parallel to doing something that would push a schizophrenic over the line, is actually not bad.... not bad at all.


Of course it's bad. Schizophrenia is a degenerative neurological disorder that destroys the victim's ability to filter and organize their mental processes; and therefore progressively destroys their ability to make informed, rational decisions. To claim that this is analogous to religion is absurd at best. The egregious problems with should be blatantly obvious, and not needed to be spelled out.

The analogy is denigratory, since it denies agency to the religious; thus absolving them of all responsibility for their actions. It relegates them to the level of children at best, and animals at worst. By that measure, any condemnation of their beliefs is invalid and unjust; because they are incapable of understanding or modifying their beliefs. It puts the entire onus for the actions of fanatics on the victims of their actions; regardless of the circumstances. It goes so far beyond simply blaming the victim that rational criticism is no longer even above the horizon. It's the grossest sort of soft bigotry.

I seriously doubt anyone with a modicum of rationality would believe that to be the case. So as an analogy it fails miserably. The overwhelming majority of religious people are capable of being rational, and of making rational, informed decisions. Even the most fanatical are capable of doing so, but simply choose not to. Fanaticism itself is often a way to cope with self-doubt and feelings of failure or marginalization; and can affect the atheist just as much as the religious.

And as to staying within the thread topic? First of all, analogies and hypotheticals, properly explained, can be fitting to the discussion.


Can be, this one is not.

I notice in the below that you're not really sticking to the topic of the thread but all over the map, apparently getting ready to nominate Pamela for the Nobel Peace Prize.


This is unworthy of you.

Or is this, perhaps, too nuanced a concept for you?


Clearly it is for you, given your unwillingness to discuss this without resorting to gross distortions and irrelevant insults.
 
Last edited:
Another dodge. Will no one address the fact the you, marplots etc, apparently view the civil rights marches, freedom riders, rosa parks etc as being wrong?

Why would we say that? To lie to make you feel better? To give credence to your straw man arguments?

I was on those marches. I was at lunch counter sit-ins. We registered black voters in Louisiana in the early 60s. Ever had a parent run out of town by the White Citizens' Council? I have.

Don't befoul history with your cheap rhetoric, please.
 
Why would we say that? To lie to make you feel better? To give credence to your straw man arguments?

I was on those marches. I was at lunch counter sit-ins. We registered black voters in Louisiana in the early 60s. Ever had a parent run out of town by the White Citizens' Council? I have.

Don't befoul history with your cheap rhetoric, please.

So, you have disavowed your earlier morality. How sad.
 
So, you have disavowed your earlier morality. How sad.

No, no, no. You're not getting it. The right to sit on a bus without physical harm is vastly different and more important than the right to criticize a religion without physical harm.

Or something.

Honestly, I can't make heads or tails of what they're trying to argue.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom