Can a CharlieHebdo-type attack happen in the US?

I think that what marplots is saying is that if we accept violence and threats of violence to enforce one of the taboos, it does not encourage the threateners to enforce any of their other taboos by the same method.

Maybe so, although Marplots words were "This is partly because I don't think taboos are manufactured in a directed, one-off fashion, but arise organically" so I have no reason to assume he wasn't referring to the creation of the taboos themselves.

Either way though, to suggest that the success of a policy in achieving a desired objective does not encourage those pursuing it to continue and expand to related aims seems strange to say the least. Indeed it seems to fly in the face of human nature. Slippery Slope isn't a fallacy if there is valid reasoning behind it and I can see no particular reason why it shouldn't be considered likely (rather than certain) that demands for other behaviors in wider society to be modified to avoid causing offense, particularly since non-disparaging depictions of Mohamed are not taboo in all branches of Islam whereas other religious prohibitions such as dogs, pork and other non-halal food, alcohol, or critical speech about Mohamed are wider or universal and of more concern to the majority of muslims.

In addition of course the success of one religious group in silencing critics could encourage others, Christian groups for example tried to prevent 'Life of Brian' and 'Jerry Springer the Opera' and failed, there's no reason to believe this censorious instinct has gone away and no valid way I can see to defend Python or Springer but condemn Geller's exhibition without opening ones self up to legitimate accusations of cowardice or hypocrisy.

The right to draw cartoons of a single religious and historical figure is a pretty painless one for most of us to give up however if this trend does expand, either within Islam or to other religions it will start to rub up against the rights of more people outside of those groups and move from deliberate acts of defiance like Geller's to more everyday activities.
 
I'm not blaming her for anything. I am pointing out that she knew in advance that she was willfully creating a situation which was dangerous to herself and others.

Holding GLBT Pride parades willfully creates a situation that is dangerous to participants; especially in places like Eastern Europe and Africa.

Running an abortion clinic willfully creates a situation that is dangerous to employees and patients.

Holding civil rights marches in the '50s and '60s willfully created a situation that was dangerous to participants and bystanders. Similarly, anti-apartheid demonstrations in South Africa willfully created an even more dangerous situation.

The KKK and Neo-Nazi organizations holding public rallies and marches willfully creates a situation that is dangerous to participants and bystanders.

A whole lot of what humans do in protest to what they see as injustice or oppression or other social ills, rightly or wrongly, willfully creates situations that are potentially dangerous to themselves or bystanders. If that wasn't the case, then there wouldn't be a need for the protests to begin with.

The thing is, it doesn't matter why they hold these protests or rallies, it doesn't matter what their cause is, or how right or wrong they are perceived to be. All that matters is whether they are equally free to exercise their right to express themselves and their views, without explicitly causing or inciting violence or fraud. Any culture that truly cares about equal rights has to support freedom of expression for even the most loathsome, despised, and intolerant; otherwise there is no true freedom of expression, only the privilege of being allowed to agree with the dominant majority worldview.

But perhaps this is too nuanced a concept for you.
 
Last edited:
Either way though, to suggest that the success of a policy in achieving a desired objective does not encourage those pursuing it to continue and expand to related aims seems strange to say the least. Indeed it seems to fly in the face of human nature. Slippery Slope isn't a fallacy if there is valid reasoning behind it and I can see no particular reason why it shouldn't be considered likely (rather than certain) that demands for other behaviors in wider society to be modified to avoid causing offense, particularly since non-disparaging depictions of Mohamed are not taboo in all branches of Islam whereas other religious prohibitions such as dogs, pork and other non-halal food, alcohol, or critical speech about Mohamed are wider or universal and of more concern to the majority of muslims.

And, in fact, that is exactly what has happened in many places.

Where I live, a very large percentage of taxi drivers are Somali Muslims. Taxis are licensed, and have to comply with a number of regulations in order to operate within city limits; including non-discrimination regulations. When a substantial number of them began refusing to abide by certain regulations (I forget specifically which, this was some time ago). The city tried to enforce the regulations, the drivers invoked exemption based on religious taboos, and the city capitulated. It was a fairly minor issue, and barely made the news.

Some time after that, Somali taxi drivers began refusing to pick up passengers who carried alcoholic beverages, or were visibly under the influence. Some even going so far as to eject passengers from their vehicles if they discovered the presence of alcohol en route to the passenger's destination. When challenged by the city, they again claimed religious exemption. There was a protracted battle, in which the precedent was invoked. In this case, and for strictly pragmatic reasons, the city pushed back and refused to allow the exemption.

Some drivers also began trying to refuse service to openly GLBT passengers, again invoking precedent; which also failed.

The fact that these attempts to enforce religious taboos failed isn't relevant. The fact that they were even attempted at all, and were based on the precedent of already having been granted religious exemptions.

We see that in a lot of other realms as well. Fundamentalist Christian groups in the US are continually pushing for more and greater privileges and exemptions; the most recently being "religious freedom" legislation that is designed to allow them to discriminate against GLBTs; and which has been implemented in many places.

An even better example of this tendency is Fundamentalist Christian groups who managed to get legislative exemption for pharmacists exempting them from providing the "day after" contraception/abortion pill, because of their religious beliefs. That wasn't enough for them, so they then pushed for exemption from providing any kind of female contraception. Then that was expanded beyond pharmacists; and employers were then exempted from having to include contraception as part of their health insurance package. Along with this has been other attempts to restrict access to abortion, restrict even more insurance funding for female-specific healthcare, and so on. All in the name of "religious freedom".

"Slippery Slope" is only a fallacy when the initial conditions are unrelated to the outcome, or when there is no clear logical chain or historical precedent for going from the initial condition to the consequence. In the case of religious exemptions or enforcement of religious taboos, history has repeatedly proven that religious groups can and will push for more and greater concessions to their beliefs. That's the very nature of fundamentalism in any form.
 
And, in fact, that is exactly what has happened in many places.

Where I live, a very large percentage of taxi drivers are Somali Muslims. Taxis are licensed, and have to comply with a number of regulations in order to operate within city limits; including non-discrimination regulations. When a substantial number of them began refusing to abide by certain regulations (I forget specifically which, this was some time ago). The city tried to enforce the regulations, the drivers invoked exemption based on religious taboos, and the city capitulated. It was a fairly minor issue, and barely made the news.

Some time after that, Somali taxi drivers began refusing to pick up passengers who carried alcoholic beverages, or were visibly under the influence. Some even going so far as to eject passengers from their vehicles if they discovered the presence of alcohol en route to the passenger's destination. When challenged by the city, they again claimed religious exemption. There was a protracted battle, in which the precedent was invoked. In this case, and for strictly pragmatic reasons, the city pushed back and refused to allow the exemption.

Some drivers also began trying to refuse service to openly GLBT passengers, again invoking precedent; which also failed.

I think this is a good illustration why the slippery-slope arguments fail. We are perfectly capable of figuring out when "enough is enough."

The fact that these attempts to enforce religious taboos failed isn't relevant. The fact that they were even attempted at all, and were based on the precedent of already having been granted religious exemptions.

We see that in a lot of other realms as well. Fundamentalist Christian groups in the US are continually pushing for more and greater privileges and exemptions; the most recently being "religious freedom" legislation that is designed to allow them to discriminate against GLBTs; and which has been implemented in many places.

The problem is that the overall trend is in the opposite direction - more acceptance of LGBT rights, not less.

An even better example of this tendency is Fundamentalist Christian groups who managed to get legislative exemption for pharmacists exempting them from providing the "day after" contraception/abortion pill, because of their religious beliefs. That wasn't enough for them, so they then pushed for exemption from providing any kind of female contraception. Then that was expanded beyond pharmacists; and employers were then exempted from having to include contraception as part of their health insurance package. Along with this has been other attempts to restrict access to abortion, restrict even more insurance funding for female-specific healthcare, and so on. All in the name of "religious freedom".

The fact that both sides of an issue may push their agenda is not a demonstration of slippery-slope, it's just the opposite: two poles coming to some compromise. It very much isn't all-or-nothing for either side. It isn't logical to claim victories for the side you oppose as demonstrating anything other than another side to the issue.

Why? Because the Christians do the same thing, claiming there's a "slippery slope" leading to licentiousness and permissiveness. One can hardly claim that progress toward the end state I desire must be viewed differently than resistance to that trend. There is very much a symmetry here.

"Slippery Slope" is only a fallacy when the initial conditions are unrelated to the outcome, or when there is no clear logical chain or historical precedent for going from the initial condition to the consequence. In the case of religious exemptions or enforcement of religious taboos, history has repeatedly proven that religious groups can and will push for more and greater concessions to their beliefs. That's the very nature of fundamentalism in any form.

What makes it a slippery slope is not the "pushing," but the imputation that there are natural and unstoppable consequences leading down-slope, without proving or demonstrating the chain of reasoning showing such "pushing" will succeed.

We only need to examine countries with a high percentage of Muslims to see this isn't generally the case, where we can find examples of going up-slope as well as down. The mixture of secular-leaning and fundamentalist-leaning countries shows us it isn't a slippery slope, but a staircase, with lots of stable stopping points.
 
Last edited:
Holding GLBT Pride parades willfully creates a situation that is dangerous to participants; especially in places like Eastern Europe and Africa.

Running an abortion clinic willfully creates a situation that is dangerous to employees and patients.

Holding civil rights marches in the '50s and '60s willfully created a situation that was dangerous to participants and bystanders. Similarly, anti-apartheid demonstrations in South Africa willfully created an even more dangerous situation.

The KKK and Neo-Nazi organizations holding public rallies and marches willfully creates a situation that is dangerous to participants and bystanders.

A whole lot of what humans do in protest to what they see as injustice or oppression or other social ills, rightly or wrongly, willfully creates situations that are potentially dangerous to themselves or bystanders. If that wasn't the case, then there wouldn't be a need for the protests to begin with.

The thing is, it doesn't matter why they hold these protests or rallies, it doesn't matter what their cause is, or how right or wrong they are perceived to be. All that matters is whether they are equally free to exercise their right to express themselves and their views, without explicitly causing or inciting violence or fraud. Any culture that truly cares about equal rights has to support freedom of expression for even the most loathsome, despised, and intolerant; otherwise there is no true freedom of expression, only the privilege of being allowed to agree with the dominant majority worldview.

But perhaps this is too nuanced a concept for you.
Too many people don't get this, sadly. Thanks for saying that.
 
Holding GLBT Pride parades willfully creates a situation that is dangerous to participants; especially in places like Eastern Europe and Africa.

Running an abortion clinic willfully creates a situation that is dangerous to employees and patients.

Holding civil rights marches in the '50s and '60s willfully created a situation that was dangerous to participants and bystanders. Similarly, anti-apartheid demonstrations in South Africa willfully created an even more dangerous situation.

The KKK and Neo-Nazi organizations holding public rallies and marches willfully creates a situation that is dangerous to participants and bystanders.

A whole lot of what humans do in protest to what they see as injustice or oppression or other social ills, rightly or wrongly, willfully creates situations that are potentially dangerous to themselves or bystanders. If that wasn't the case, then there wouldn't be a need for the protests to begin with.

The thing is, it doesn't matter why they hold these protests or rallies, it doesn't matter what their cause is, or how right or wrong they are perceived to be. All that matters is whether they are equally free to exercise their right to express themselves and their views, without explicitly causing or inciting violence or fraud. Any culture that truly cares about equal rights has to support freedom of expression for even the most loathsome, despised, and intolerant; otherwise there is no true freedom of expression, only the privilege of being allowed to agree with the dominant majority worldview.

But perhaps this is too nuanced a concept for you.

I'll just second that this is a great post.
 
I think this is a good illustration why the slippery-slope arguments fail. We are perfectly capable of figuring out when "enough is enough."

Except that everything you posted is utterly and completely irrelevant to the point I was making; which is that the claims of "slippery-slope fallacy" are demonstrably wrong. Fanatics invariably, throughout history, continue to push for more and more concessions to their fanaticism, they never sit happily by if society concedes one or two.

Saying they will do so in this case is not a "slippery slope fallacy" however much appeasers and apologists and ostriches want to paint it as such.

Refusing to draw pictures of Mohammad will not make fanatical Islamists happy enough to leave us alone on every other issue; it will simply prove to them that violence gets them what they want, and they will use more and more violence to gain more and more concessions if we continue to accede to their demands. That is not a "slippery slope fallacy", that is clear and demonstrable historical fact.
 
Except that everything you posted is utterly and completely irrelevant to the point I was making; which is that the claims of "slippery-slope fallacy" are demonstrably wrong. Fanatics invariably, throughout history, continue to push for more and more concessions to their fanaticism, they never sit happily by if society concedes one or two.

Saying they will do so in this case is not a "slippery slope fallacy" however much appeasers and apologists and ostriches want to paint it as such.

Refusing to draw pictures of Mohammad will not make fanatical Islamists happy enough to leave us alone on every other issue; it will simply prove to them that violence gets them what they want, and they will use more and more violence to gain more and more concessions if we continue to accede to their demands. That is not a "slippery slope fallacy", that is clear and demonstrable historical fact.
Maybe our amigo marplots needs to learn about the "thin end of the wedge" theory.
 
Except that everything you posted is utterly and completely irrelevant to the point I was making; which is that the claims of "slippery-slope fallacy" are demonstrably wrong. Fanatics invariably, throughout history, continue to push for more and more concessions to their fanaticism, they never sit happily by if society concedes one or two.

Saying they will do so in this case is not a "slippery slope fallacy" however much appeasers and apologists and ostriches want to paint it as such.

Refusing to draw pictures of Mohammad will not make fanatical Islamists happy enough to leave us alone on every other issue; it will simply prove to them that violence gets them what they want, and they will use more and more violence to gain more and more concessions if we continue to accede to their demands. That is not a "slippery slope fallacy", that is clear and demonstrable historical fact.

Maybe our amigo marplots needs to learn about the "thin end of the wedge" theory.

Or more appropriate the nose of the camel in the tent.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Camel's_nose

"Thou doth protest too much."

IF the premise is that capitulation by not drawing Mohammed will lead to capitulation in other things Islamic, then it very much is a slippery-slope argument. It fails for the reasons I posted previously.

If the premise is that capitulation will not stop zealots from acting like zealots - because they will just find something else to martyr themselves over, then I agree, it isn't slippery slope, but then again, doesn't really matter much in this conversation, unless someone claimed that capitulation over cartoons would produce peace.

So it depends on whose actions we are talking about, the "capitulators" or the extremists.
 
"Thou doth protest too much."

IF the premise is that capitulation by not drawing Mohammed will lead to capitulation in other things Islamic, then it very much is a slippery-slope argument. It fails for the reasons I posted previously.

If the premise is that capitulation will not stop zealots from acting like zealots - because they will just find something else to martyr themselves over, then I agree, it isn't slippery slope, but then again, doesn't really matter much in this conversation, unless someone claimed that capitulation over cartoons would produce peace.

So it depends on whose actions we are talking about, the "capitulators" or the extremists.
As I recall earlier in the thread, someone here was willing to give up baby back ribs on the grill if their neighbors seemed likely to threaten violence...
 
I think this is a good illustration why the slippery-slope arguments fail. We are perfectly capable of figuring out when "enough is enough."

That's reassuring. However, I suspect those god-fearing, paramilitary folks will be the ones telling you when "enough is enough", depending on how high they decide to raise the risks.
 
Last edited:
I think this is a good illustration why the slippery-slope arguments fail. We are perfectly capable of figuring out when "enough is enough."


That's reassuring. However, I suspect those god-fearing, paramilitary folks will be the ones telling you when "enough is enough", depending on how high they decide to raise the risks.


And not everyone would agree on when "enough is enough" anyway. Geller, for example, has decided that what we have seen so far is enough. She has drawn a line in the sand, and it bears a striking resemblance to Muhammad.
 
If the premise is that capitulation will not stop zealots from acting like zealots - because they will just find something else to martyr themselves over, then I agree, it isn't slippery slope, but then again, doesn't really matter much in this conversation, unless someone claimed that capitulation over cartoons would produce peace.

Like your claiming earlier that giving in and not drawing Mohammad is what a "civilized" society would do, and that doing so would not in any way encourage further violent demands?

You and others have been pooh-poohing all along the idea that capitulating to this issue due to the threat of violence was in any way indicative that the fanatics would find that a reason to continue to use violence; deriding such assertions as "slippery slope". History is against you on that. When faced with that fact, you seem to forget your earlier statements.
 
Like your claiming earlier that giving in and not drawing Mohammad is what a "civilized" society would do, and that doing so would not in any way encourage further violent demands?

That's correct, it wouldn't "encourage" further violent demands. You are mixing up two different agendas here.

One the one hand, we have the terrorists looking to make some statement by killing themselves and others. On the other, we have someone who wants to provoke terrorists.

If Geller doesn't hold the event, terrorists don't go away, they are still a threat. But this doesn't compel Geller to hold the event, no more than it compels me to burn a stack of Korans. Neither does the threat of terrorism mean no one is able to draw Mohammed or burn Korans.

All it means is that if I do the things that piss terrorists off, I am at risk for getting attacked by terrorists. The fact that terrorists exist doesn't change whether I act or don't act. What changes is whether or not I attract their attention.

You and others have been pooh-poohing all along the idea that capitulating to this issue due to the threat of violence was in any way indicative that the fanatics would find that a reason to continue to use violence; deriding such assertions as "slippery slope". History is against you on that. When faced with that fact, you seem to forget your earlier statements.

Here's where we disagree. You seem to think that violence only continues when it works - when the terrorists get what they want. But violence is their stock-in-trade. They'll use it no matter what you do. You aren't stopping violence by resisting it, and plainly we can see this in Israel and throughout the middle east, where various extremist sects are currently being resisted and violence continues.

You've repeated the claim that "History is against you on that" and I don't, for the life of me, know what you mean. Can you give an example of what you think history is showing us?

Finally, and I don't know how often I need to repeat this, it is not capitulation to not do something you ordinarily wouldn't do just because you know it bothers someone else.

Otherwise, everyone posting here who didn't draw/publish a cartoon of Mohammed would be guilty of capitulation, of surrendering to Islamic terrorists. Was that the meaning you had in mind?
 
Holding GLBT Pride parades willfully creates a situation that is dangerous to participants; especially in places like Eastern Europe and Africa.

Running an abortion clinic willfully creates a situation that is dangerous to employees and patients.

Holding civil rights marches in the '50s and '60s willfully created a situation that was dangerous to participants and bystanders. Similarly, anti-apartheid demonstrations in South Africa willfully created an even more dangerous situation.

The KKK and Neo-Nazi organizations holding public rallies and marches willfully creates a situation that is dangerous to participants and bystanders.

<snip>


I have consistently said that I stand firmly and unequivocally in support of the rights of people to engage in all such activities.

You seem to need to ignore that in your attempts to make arguments against positions I haven't taken.

Try honest discussion instead.

But perhaps this is too nuanced a concept for you.


There is nothing even remotely nuanced about anything you have written here.

Straw men are not nuanced. Neither is dishonest discourse.
 
I don't think you are trying very hard. Our right to free speech does not exonerate us from any and every fault for the consequences of that speech.
The SCOTUS was verey clear in that regard when they decided Schenck (of 'fire in a crowded theater" fame.

In that case the speech was leaflets, and the incitement was to resist the draft.

Some have said that this is somehow different because it was inciting an illegal act (and some have said that that is tantamount to inciting violence anyway) but the "fire in a crowded theater" parallel makes it clear that the legality of the act was not part of the consideration.

I wholeheartedly defend Geller's right to say whatever she damned well pleases in this country, in public or in private or anywhere in between.

I do not, however, agree that she is innocent of any and all fault regarding the consequences of that speech, most especially when she not only knew full well that such consequences were possible, but was indeed uttering said speech specifically as a demonstration of her condemnation of such consequences elsewhere. It was clearly intended as provocation, and in this case it worked.

I don't concede her the right to pick and choose what social privileges she decides to indulge in while simultaneously willfully disregarding the responsibilities attached to those rights.

If passing out leaflets is an abuse of free speech responsibilities (and the SCOTUS has made it clear that it is) then setting out to create ( or more properly repeat) a blatant provocation of a known and active group of religious psychotics certainly must as well.

Save me the inevitable straw man. This is in no way a sanction or excuse of any sort for the religious psychotics and their reactions. Their actions stand alone and are unquestioningly egregious and unforgivable.

These two positions are not at all incompatible. The fault of one does not ameliorate or offset the fault of the other.

Both parties are reprehensible. Hiding behind false equivalence ('Well, shooting at people is more reprehensible than trying to provoke them into doing it, or even to create a situation where they might be inspired to.') is a willful evasion.

The reprehensibility of one does not add to or diminish the reprehensibility of the other. They are separate acts whose relationship is irrelevant to the quality of the acts themselves.

Each is to be taken on its own, Conflating them is sophistry.

I have no need to be careful since I have not and will not oppose Geller's "protests", or any like them.

There seems to be an inability around here for some people to engage in honest discussion. I have made it quite clear, even in the post from which you just quoted me (A statement which you for some reason saw fit to excise from your quote of my post.), that I do not believe speech should be suppressed.

Do you believe that the right to free speech is unencumbered by any consequences of that speech?

I have consistently said that I stand firmly and unequivocally in support of the rights of people to engage in all such activities.

You seem to need to ignore that in your attempts to make arguments against positions I haven't taken.

Try honest discussion instead.








There is nothing even remotely nuanced about anything you have written here.

Straw men are not nuanced. Neither is dishonest discourse.

"I stand firmly and unequivocally in support of the rights of people to engage in all such activities"


As long as they are prepared to accept some unspecified "consequences".

This is probably more nuance than you can stand.
 
"I stand firmly and unequivocally in support of the rights of people to engage in all such activities"


As long as they are prepared to accept some unspecified "consequences".

Sounds reasonable, if undesirable, to me. You might not want people to punch you in the face because you told them that their mother is ugly, and it certainly isn't legal but it tends to happen, leading most people to think that doing that is not a good idea, despite being their right.
 
hgc said:
The outcome of this event is two dead Jihadists and a wounded security guard - and, I suppose, a bunch of cartoons on her website. These results had antecedents, some of which were proximate causes, some less so.

I have been arguing that when she undertook to hold the event, she could have (and I think likely did) foresee a risk of attack. She did it anyhow. Because of this, she bears some responsibility for the outcome. I've even said that the outcome was a win/win for both sides - she gets to point out how violent Muslims are and a couple of Jihadists get their desire for martyrdom.

In none of this are her free speech rights attacked or abridged. The major criticism is in her willingness to manipulate affairs to gain a end I think is morally impoverished - the death of two and the risk of death for many more. If there is a right I do not think she has, it is the right to risk the lives of others in service to her cause.


And still I don't know what you mean by "take responsibility," other than that she should forego exercising her right to free expression because of the possible threat of violent reaction.

Suppose this was a planned KKK rally in a black neighborhood that sets off a mentally unstable black guy, who plants a bomb where the rally's supposed to be. Except the bomb goes off early and 30 innocent people are killed.

In the above hypothetical, are you claiming that the white supremacists who organized the rally are completely blameless?
 
"I stand firmly and unequivocally in support of the rights of people to engage in all such activities"


As long as they are prepared to accept some unspecified "consequences".


This is where y'all keep going off the rails. You can't wrap your mind around the idea that consequences don't have to be "specified". They don't have to be inevitable, they don't have to be punitive.

They don't have to be anything.

They can, however be anticipated.

Geller obviously believed that a violent response to her "speech" was to be anticipated.

Take that as you want to. Do with it what you will. I am not making any claims or assertions, or expressing any opinions about 'should be done'.

That's all other peoples' insistence on trying to fabricate an argument I am not even making.

This is probably more nuance than you can stand.


It is unquestionably more than you can comprehend. Maybe even more than you can discern.

Don't feel bad about it. You aren't the only one in this group with that problem. There are more than a few people in this thread who seem unable to respond to any position they haven't fabricated themselves out of pure nothing.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom