P.J. Denyer
Penultimate Amazing
I think that what marplots is saying is that if we accept violence and threats of violence to enforce one of the taboos, it does not encourage the threateners to enforce any of their other taboos by the same method.
Maybe so, although Marplots words were "This is partly because I don't think taboos are manufactured in a directed, one-off fashion, but arise organically" so I have no reason to assume he wasn't referring to the creation of the taboos themselves.
Either way though, to suggest that the success of a policy in achieving a desired objective does not encourage those pursuing it to continue and expand to related aims seems strange to say the least. Indeed it seems to fly in the face of human nature. Slippery Slope isn't a fallacy if there is valid reasoning behind it and I can see no particular reason why it shouldn't be considered likely (rather than certain) that demands for other behaviors in wider society to be modified to avoid causing offense, particularly since non-disparaging depictions of Mohamed are not taboo in all branches of Islam whereas other religious prohibitions such as dogs, pork and other non-halal food, alcohol, or critical speech about Mohamed are wider or universal and of more concern to the majority of muslims.
In addition of course the success of one religious group in silencing critics could encourage others, Christian groups for example tried to prevent 'Life of Brian' and 'Jerry Springer the Opera' and failed, there's no reason to believe this censorious instinct has gone away and no valid way I can see to defend Python or Springer but condemn Geller's exhibition without opening ones self up to legitimate accusations of cowardice or hypocrisy.
The right to draw cartoons of a single religious and historical figure is a pretty painless one for most of us to give up however if this trend does expand, either within Islam or to other religions it will start to rub up against the rights of more people outside of those groups and move from deliberate acts of defiance like Geller's to more everyday activities.