Can a CharlieHebdo-type attack happen in the US?

The principle at work here is, if you deliberately provoke unstable people, you create a situation where innocent people can get hurt. That's generally not a desirable state of affairs.
Generally not, but the general case doesn't help your argument much here. Applying the principle generally, we find that the Freedom Riders were partly to blame for how Bull Connors responded to them. We also find that Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn was partly to blame for the Soviet Union's decision to imprison him in the gulags for the crime of political dissent. And so on.

Appealing to the general principle to condemn Geller also leads to the condemnation of many other acts of protest that are customarily viewed as virtuous and laudable--acts of protest where we customarily condemn only those who opposed the act. Therefore I think any condemnation of Geller will require a detailed, nuanced analysis of the specific case, with special attention paid to the ways in which it is similar to other cases, and the ways in which it is different.

I think a comprehensive review of the similarities and differences between the Freedom Riders' act of protest and Pamela Geller's act of protest would go a long way towards illuminating the rational, internally-consistent argument in favor of condemning Pamela Geller. But it's not my argument, so what do I know?
 
No, no, no. You're not getting it. The right to sit on a bus without physical harm is vastly different and more important than the right to criticize a religion without physical harm.

Or something.

Honestly, I can't make heads or tails of what they're trying to argue.

I call it the 'Sour Grapes Gambit', "yeah I could draw Mohammed if I felt like it, but it's too trivial".
 
So, you have disavowed your earlier morality. How sad.

You'll have to quote whatever it is you're referring to as I have no idea what you're on about. (I realize you guys are enjoying this straw man immensely, and wouldn't want to detract from it, but you do realize it's pure bull pellets, right?)
 
So far no one has been able to explain that "something".

The "brights" figure the Musselman will be kept busy going after the Jews, Christians, pagans, the out loud and proud and the grrl-power gals and will pass them over. Anybody ever seen Cabaret? "Do you still think you can control them?"
 
The "brights" figure the Musselman will be kept busy going after the Jews, Christians, pagans, the out loud and proud and the grrl-power gals and will pass them over. Anybody ever seen Cabaret? "Do you still think you can control them?"

I don't think they're that machiavellian. I think they are just trying to justify not standing up for civil rights because they don't like the person getting intimidated. Their viewpoint is based on emotion, which is why their attempts to justify it rationally are so vague and feeble.
 
The "brights" figure the Musselman will be kept busy going after the Jews, Christians, pagans, the out loud and proud and the grrl-power gals and will pass them over. Anybody ever seen Cabaret? "Do you still think you can control them?"

One of the scariest scenes ever.

Alligator appeasers hope to get eaten last.
 
If you're not already familiar with other significant acts of protest and social change in recent history, then you're probably not in the best position to judge the merits of this one.

I'm no expert, just generally aware of the history. Where I'm at a loss is how the poster came to the conclusion that I think the civil rights protests were wrong. Considering I don't even think Geller was "wrong."

I think she's culpable, negligent, disingenuous, and shares responsibility for the consequences of her actions. But not wrong. I think, from her perspective, things turned out quite well. (Although I'd love to think she's since had second thoughts about it.)

Then again, without the moral value-judgements, it wouldn't be much of a thread, would it?
 
As far as the immediate consequences of protests while struggling for civil rights, of course the protestors bear some responsibility.

But it's a good example of the black/white think being demonstrated. Posters would like to say obtaining civil rights flowed from the often-violent interactions with government authorities and give credit to the civil rights movement for causing broad, positive social change. We give them credit for the consequences we like. However, they also don't want to taint the movement with the immediate consequences of their actions. So, their actions are responsible for the good stuff, but not the bad. How convenient.

The same flawed thinking can be used to argue the opposite: the entrenched white power base should get credit for capitulating to the demands of a disruptive minority and allowing civil rights legislation to proceed.

It's hard to take a binary framing seriously when used in an argument when it yields both answers equally well. One suspects the method - placing blame/responsibility on one party - is a poor one. Which it is.
 
Last edited:
I have to say it again: Freedom of Speech is not expandable or negotiable..particualry for those who you might find despicable.
If we have reached the stage where the rights of only those whose opinions are inoffensive are to be protected,then it's over folks;We are not longer a free society.
 
I have to say it again: Freedom of Speech is not expandable or negotiable..particualry for those who you might find despicable.
If we have reached the stage where the rights of only those whose opinions are inoffensive are to be protected,then it's over folks;We are not longer a free society.

For the chronically thick-headed, I will repeat.... Gee, it's a shame that NO ONE is making that argument.

The despicable Geller has every right to say anything she wants on the subject closest to her heart (dread Islamic incursion) or subjects not even near her heart. She has every right to say everything she wants. So do you.

And when Big Brother comes stomping in to shut her up, you can call me and I'll be there.

Phred Phelps has a right to say whatever he wants. If the state government in Florida or Oklahoma or New Jersey sends in troops to silence him, I'm going to be standing over on the side of the road with the Phelps guys. (I'll bathe afterwards... a lot.)

This is not a first amendment issue. Geller is not fighting "the man". She is fighting "a people". She is an Islamophobe. There are no moderate Muslims in GellerWorld. Their religion is the problem. She's free to believe it. She's free to speak it. We're not going to reach her, so we're not trying to convince the miserable bigot of anything. We're trying to have a discussion with normal folks (some will show up, eventually) about whether or not you make concessions to the feelings, beliefs, concerns of others in the enjoyment of your liberty.

She ain't doing this for free speech. She's doing it because she can and because she hates. Elevating her to comparisons with MLK, Rosa Parks, Gandhi, et al... is absurd. She's the Illinois Nazis. They have their rights. I'll support those rights, even if it's the right to hate. That does not mean, however, that I'm going to do a Sunmaster and suddenly say, "Hey, ya know... she's got some good points...."
 
Generally not, but the general case doesn't help your argument much here. Applying the principle generally, we find that the Freedom Riders were partly to blame for how Bull Connors responded to them. We also find that Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn was partly to blame for the Soviet Union's decision to imprison him in the gulags for the crime of political dissent. And so on.

Appealing to the general principle to condemn Geller also leads to the condemnation of many other acts of protest that are customarily viewed as virtuous and laudable--acts of protest where we customarily condemn only those who opposed the act. Therefore I think any condemnation of Geller will require a detailed, nuanced analysis of the specific case, with special attention paid to the ways in which it is similar to other cases, and the ways in which it is different.

I think a comprehensive review of the similarities and differences between the Freedom Riders' act of protest and Pamela Geller's act of protest would go a long way towards illuminating the rational, internally-consistent argument in favor of condemning Pamela Geller. But it's not my argument, so what do I know?

Which is just to say, I'm going to create situation that has the real possibility of turning violent? Should I do so? Do the ends justify the means?

In the case of equality for blacks, the end (equal civil rights), justified the potential for innocents to get killed in the struggle (e.g., church bombings). In the case of Geller's cartoon event, I'm not seeing any good that came about that can justify putting innocent people at risk.
 
Which is just to say, I'm going to create situation that has the real possibility of turning violent? Should I do so? Do the ends justify the means?

In the case of equality for blacks, the end (equal civil rights), justified the potential for innocents to get killed in the struggle (e.g., church bombings). In the case of Geller's cartoon event, I'm not seeing any good that came about that can justify putting innocent people at risk.

You are allowing the violent to determine the universe of discourse.
 
One of the scariest scenes ever.

It's what always comes to my mind whenever someone bleats about being on the "right side(or wrong side) of history". That young man singing "Tomorrow belongs, tomorrow belongs, tomorrow belongs to me!" He seems so confident.
 
For the chronically thick-headed, I will repeat.... Gee, it's a shame that NO ONE is making that argument.

The despicable Geller has every right to say anything she wants on the subject closest to her heart (dread Islamic incursion) or subjects not even near her heart. She has every right to say everything she wants. So do you.

And when Big Brother comes stomping in to shut her up, you can call me and I'll be there.

Phred Phelps has a right to say whatever he wants. If the state government in Florida or Oklahoma or New Jersey sends in troops to silence him, I'm going to be standing over on the side of the road with the Phelps guys. (I'll bathe afterwards... a lot.)

This is not a first amendment issue. Geller is not fighting "the man". She is fighting "a people". She is an Islamophobe. There are no moderate Muslims in GellerWorld. Their religion is the problem. She's free to believe it. She's free to speak it. We're not going to reach her, so we're not trying to convince the miserable bigot of anything. We're trying to have a discussion with normal folks (some will show up, eventually) about whether or not you make concessions to the feelings, beliefs, concerns of others in the enjoyment of your liberty.

She ain't doing this for free speech. She's doing it because she can and because she hates. Elevating her to comparisons with MLK, Rosa Parks, Gandhi, et al... is absurd. She's the Illinois Nazis. They have their rights. I'll support those rights, even if it's the right to hate. That does not mean, however, that I'm going to do a Sunmaster and suddenly say, "Hey, ya know... she's got some good points...."

No ****. There's the strawman at the heart of this all. Free Speech and the 1st Amendment aren't the same thing. Nice of you to fight against the government goons but if a private party wants to silence criticism with violence and threats of violence? Well...
 
Which is just to say, I'm going to create situation that has the real possibility of turning violent? Should I do so? Do the ends justify the means?

In the case of equality for blacks, the end (equal civil rights), justified the potential for innocents to get killed in the struggle (e.g., church bombings). In the case of Geller's cartoon event, I'm not seeing any good that came about that can justify putting innocent people at risk.

And here we go, someone comes right out and says it:


"I support freedom of speech and assembly for those I agree with. Those I disagree with should shut the hell up."
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom