Can a CharlieHebdo-type attack happen in the US?

To recognize that speech can have consequences.


"Recognize" is something that happens in the mind. "Take responsibility," to me at least, means some kind of action. How, in terms of action, should Geller take responsibility?
 
"Implicitly". I see. That's your way of saying you're making crap up again.

LOL. No, you infer too much.

To recognize that speech can have consequences.

Well, I admit that I was wrong. You didn't actually have an interesting idea that you just had a difficult time articulating. Geller obviously recognizes that speech has consequences. Do you think she spent $50,000 on security just because she likes hanging around virile men with guns? She could have spent a lot less and gotten a lot more if that was her main motivation.
 
I think I understand your point, but I disagree with the slippery slope aspect. This is partly because I don't think taboos are manufactured in a directed, one-off fashion, but arise organically.

For example, it is both taboo and illegal for me to draw/publish images of sex with underage children. I would not expect to be attacked in the same way, but would certainly expect public outrage and legal consequences. As far as I know, this taboo and restriction has not led to even more restrictions, making me think that the slope isn't really all that slippery and we can evaluate each instance as it arises.

The reason I think a slippery slope applies here is that the proscription on drawings of Muhammad is just one blasphemy rule among many that Islam (or at least the Wahabi flavor of it that motivates many of the attacks we've seen recently) seeks to impose on not just its adherents, but on non-Muslims as well. When you think about it, taking offense at somebody drawing a picture, and not just an offensive picture, is pretty extreme, at least by Western standards. And then to resort to violence to stop it is ultra-extreme. I really don't think the people using force to impose Sharia law on others are really the kind that will stay appeased for very long.
 
To recognize that speech can have consequences.

Not sure why you keep insisting on dragging up this irrelevant canard. Gellar hired security for the event; pretty clear that she recognized that there would be consequences, and that some of those consequences could be negative enough to warrant security. I think an actual attempted murder was probably not considered; and given the circumstances, I don't think that was necessarily an unwarranted oversight. But she clearly prepared for some type of violent response. So I'm not sure what "recognize that speech can have consequences" means, since this has been addressed multiple times in this thread already.
 
Last edited:
Hell. The entire idea behind speech is to have consequences. IIRC, consequences are results, and may be good, bad, or indifferent.
No consequences =wasted speech.
 
I think I understand your point, but I disagree with the slippery slope aspect. This is partly because I don't think taboos are manufactured in a directed, one-off fashion, but arise organically.

For example, it is both taboo and illegal for me to draw/publish images of sex with underage children. I would not expect to be attacked in the same way, but would certainly expect public outrage and legal consequences. As far as I know, this taboo and restriction has not led to even more restrictions, making me think that the slope isn't really all that slippery and we can evaluate each instance as it arises.

The taboos already exist, the concern is about them being more widely enforced.
 
PG didn't just hire the security on her own, the owners of the venue required it as part of the rental agreement. Which leads one to wonder how much security was required for the "Stand With the Prophet in Honor and Respect" conference held in the same location in January this year(ten days following the Charlie Hebdo Massacre). Keynote speaker? Imam Siraj Wahhaj, named an unindicted co-conspirator in the 1993 World Trade Center bombing.

She didn't pull Garland, TX out of a hat.
 
Last edited:
LOL. No, you infer too much.



Well, I admit that I was wrong. You didn't actually have an interesting idea that you just had a difficult time articulating. Geller obviously recognizes that speech has consequences. Do you think she spent $50,000 on security just because she likes hanging around virile men with guns? She could have spent a lot less and gotten a lot more if that was her main motivation.

Not sure why you keep insisting on dragging up this irrelevant canard. Gellar hired security for the event; pretty clear that she recognized that there would be consequences, and that some of those consequences could be negative enough to warrant security. I think an actual attempted murder was probably not considered; and given the circumstances, I don't think that was necessarily an unwarranted oversight. But she clearly prepared for some type of violent response. So I'm not sure what "recognize that speech can have consequences" means, since this has been addressed multiple times in this thread already.


She "clearly recognized". She "clearly prepared".

According to sunmaster she spent the equivalent of a comfortable yearly income for an average middle class family to protect the people who went there that day.

Has she pointed out publicly that she had always expected the odds of violence in response to her "speech" were so high that that was needful? Has she explained that she continued in spite of that conviction because 'freedom'?

Or has she claimed that her 'protest' was in no way intended as a provocation?
 
She "clearly recognized". She "clearly prepared".

According to sunmaster she spent the equivalent of a comfortable yearly income for an average middle class family to protect the people who went there that day.

Has she pointed out publicly that she had always expected the odds of violence in response to her "speech" were so high that that was needful? Has she explained that she continued in spite of that conviction because 'freedom'?

Or has she claimed that her 'protest' was in no way intended as a provocation?

'freedom' ?

Why do you put it in scare quotes?

You are blaming her for taking reasonable precautions?
 
'freedom' ?

Why do you put it in scare quotes?


Not scare quotes. Those are irony quotes, because Geller has made it very clear that freedom is one of the last things she advocates (unless it's her own freedom to spew bigotry and hate.)

You are blaming her for taking reasonable precautions?


I'm not blaming her for anything. I am pointing out that she knew in advance that she was willfully creating a situation which was dangerous to herself and others.

You can call that "blaming" if you want, but since I am not disputing her fundamental right to do what she did I don't see how "blame" attaches.

It is this sort of insistence on distorting what people actually say which has made the discussion here so dishonest.

Perhaps I am being ungenerous. Perhaps this is too nuanced a concept for you.

If so I apologize, but I don't think I can make it any simpler or more clear.
 
Not scare quotes. Those are irony quotes, because Geller has made it very clear that freedom is one of the last things she advocates (unless it's her own freedom to spew bigotry and hate.)




I'm not blaming her for anything. I am pointing out that she knew in advance that she was willfully creating a situation which was dangerous to herself and others.

You can call that "blaming" if you want, but since I am not disputing her fundamental right to do what she did I don't see how "blame" attaches.

It is this sort of insistence on distorting what people actually say which has made the discussion here so dishonest.

Perhaps I am being ungenerous. Perhaps this is too nuanced a concept for you.

If so I apologize, but I don't think I can make it any simpler or more clear.

You have made it quite clear that you hate her and therefore anything she does is to be condemned.

Perhaps this is too nuanced a concept for you.
 
You have made it quite clear that you hate her and therefore anything she does is to be condemned.

Perhaps this is too nuanced a concept for you.


Hate is an emotion I very rarely indulge in, and tend to reserve for people I am a lot closer to personally than I am to Geller. She is not important enough to me to invest that sort of time and interest.

The closed I might come is "despise" because she devotes so much energy and wealth into lying to people for the purposes of scaring them and creating needless discord and social division.

"Deplore" would probably be more accurate still.

If her actions were not so harmful I doubt my feelings about her would rise much above "pity". That's certainly what I feel for her followers and defenders.
 
This thread has been a great example of just how far some people on the left will go to apologize for the bad behavior of some Muslims, and try, instead, to lay the blame of this incident at the feet of right-wingers.

If one day in the near future some Muslim goons with automatic weapons show up at the Real Time studios to shoot the place up while Richard Dawkins is speaking against Islam, I'm certain the same people will be back here blaming Bill Maher and Richard Dawkins for provoking them with bigoted hate speech. After all, Bill Maher has admitted that they have to have extra special security because they're afraid of Islamists attacking the studio.

Nauseating.
 
This thread has been a great example of just how far some people on the left will go to apologize for the bad behavior of some Muslims, and try, instead, to lay the blame of this incident at the feet of right-wingers.

If one day in the near future some Muslim goons with automatic weapons show up at the Real Time studios to shoot the place up while Richard Dawkins is speaking against Islam, I'm certain the same people will be back here blaming Bill Maher and Richard Dawkins for provoking them with bigoted hate speech. After all, Bill Maher has admitted that they have to have extra special security because they're afraid of Islamists attacking the studio.

Nauseating.

This thread has been a great example of how some people on the right will try to frame the argument in black and white through application of Straw Man Building 101.

Sort of like the above post.

What part of the various statements saying "I do not support violence as a method of protest" are you having trouble with? We're here to help. Or do you just want to add to the straw? We're having a marshmallow roast on Sunday, and we accept all contributions, gladly.
 
And, of course, Breitbart's ancillary prize (to the 10,000 that Geller was to award the "winning" cartoon) for "most popular".

I suppose it's too much to hope that they could've at least winged Geller and Wilder before getting killed? I don't wish death on anyone, but at least a little flesh wound? That's what they want, isn't it? Her tweet after the event.... no mention of the valiant cops or relief that the attendees weren't harmed... just a call to arms! She's only a slight step above the intended shooters.

You stay classy, Foolmewunz.
 
She "clearly recognized". She "clearly prepared".

According to sunmaster she spent the equivalent of a comfortable yearly income for an average middle class family to protect the people who went there that day.

Has she pointed out publicly that she had always expected the odds of violence in response to her "speech" were so high that that was needful? Has she explained that she continued in spite of that conviction because 'freedom'?

Or has she claimed that her 'protest' was in no way intended as a provocation?

Do you agree then that she recognized that speech can have consequences?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom