Can a CharlieHebdo-type attack happen in the US?

Huh. Given the amount of effort you've put into making and defending your arguments in this thread, I was going to order a much larger teapot. However, based on this latest development, I think we can safely contain your tempest in one of these.

Wow, that's a mighty big finger. Can you imagine the nose that goes with it?
 
Well, I can't answer for quadraginta, but I can for me. I think the consequences should be "Meh." Anything else just elevates her status and visibility. I don't think her ideas are "cause-worthy."

Those who do can donate at www.pamelageller.com

Putting aside Pamela Geller and her alleged causes, did the incident surprise you in any way, or did you always think that a Muhammad cartoon contest in the United States would likely be attacked by gunmen?
 
If you believe that citizens in North Korea have no choice about free speech, and that this is what sets them apart from citizens in America, then we will never agree on the central questions being discussed in this thread.

I'm not sure I follow. Would you not agree that coercion is a reduction of the ability to choose ? You seem to do so later in your post.

In any case, my only point there was that choosing not to act does not constitute failure to exercise your freedom to act, in my view. In fact, your freedom to act should by definition include the ability to choose to not act.

Not only that, but I will remain convinced that your reasons for condemning Geller's choice in this thread, and assigning to her some responsibility for the attack against her, are unfounded in rational thought.

I think you have me confused with someone else. I have not condemned her for anything, nor have I assigned her any responsibility for the attack. That would be Marplots.
 
Putting aside Pamela Geller and her alleged causes, did the incident surprise you in any way, or did you always think that a Muhammad cartoon contest in the United States would likely be attacked by gunmen?

Given the sort of religiously-motivated violence in the US -- not just Muslims, but others as well, abortion-clinic bombings for example -- I can't say that I'm completely surprised that this would happen; but I am surprised that such an otherwise insignificant event would be targeted like this. Typically, terrorists tend to go for much higher-visibility targets and incidents. Though given the increases in security, and the frequency with which high-profile terrorist actions are being foiled, we might be seeing a shift to softer targets. Only time will tell.
 
Given the sort of religiously-motivated violence in the US -- not just Muslims, but others as well, abortion-clinic bombings for example -- I can't say that I'm completely surprised that this would happen; but I am surprised that such an otherwise insignificant event would be targeted like this. Typically, terrorists tend to go for much higher-visibility targets and incidents. Though given the increases in security, and the frequency with which high-profile terrorist actions are being foiled, we might be seeing a shift to softer targets. Only time will tell.

I guess I'd say that I was surprised, but not shocked. If it had happened in Europe, I wouldn't have been surprised at all.
 
Putting aside Pamela Geller and her alleged causes, did the incident surprise you in any way, or did you always think that a Muhammad cartoon contest in the United States would likely be attacked by gunmen?

I hadn't considered it beforehand, but I would have bet on "no attack." It is very likely that I underestimate the dangers of Muslim extremism in the US. And I'm not sure what level of violence would shift my views - I think it would depend on the proven existence of an organized network, as contrasted with the "lone crazy" scenario.

I say that because I am familiar with incidents of Americans exploding into violence that didn't involve any larger ideal - other than what might exist in an individual's head. In this, I could be fundamentally wrong and Geller right. Or the situation could lay in the middle somewhere. I will not pretend to be an expert in this area.

In a sense, my objections in this thread have not been about Geller at all, but about how the incident is being spun - at times an exercise in free speech designed to accomplish some lofty goal, and at times as an innocent victim of Muslim terrorists. That's what bothers me, the imputing grander goals, and even nobility, where none (in my view) exist.

Because images of Mohammed mean nothing to me, it strikes me as agenda-driven, manufactured controversy for both parties. Akin to the kayfabe of wrestling fame. Not entirely so, because I don't think Geller is actually friendly with Muslims, but in the sense of one disputant both creating and requiring the outrage of the other to justify their own existence.

This, to me, is of a different character than the Boston Marathon attack or 9/11, where innocents are killed without provocation.

What has Geller accomplished, other than raising her cred with others of her ilk? Am I now free to draw Mohammed without fear? If so, that and $3 will get me a nice Starbuck's coffee.
 
I hadn't considered it beforehand, but I would have bet on "no attack." It is very likely that I underestimate the dangers of Muslim extremism in the US. And I'm not sure what level of violence would shift my views - I think it would depend on the proven existence of an organized network, as contrasted with the "lone crazy" scenario.

I say that because I am familiar with incidents of Americans exploding into violence that didn't involve any larger ideal - other than what might exist in an individual's head. In this, I could be fundamentally wrong and Geller right. Or the situation could lay in the middle somewhere. I will not pretend to be an expert in this area.

In a sense, my objections in this thread have not been about Geller at all, but about how the incident is being spun - at times an exercise in free speech designed to accomplish some lofty goal, and at times as an innocent victim of Muslim terrorists. That's what bothers me, the imputing grander goals, and even nobility, where none (in my view) exist.

Because images of Mohammed mean nothing to me, it strikes me as agenda-driven, manufactured controversy for both parties. Akin to the kayfabe of wrestling fame. Not entirely so, because I don't think Geller is actually friendly with Muslims, but in the sense of one disputant both creating and requiring the outrage of the other to justify their own existence.

This, to me, is of a different character than the Boston Marathon attack or 9/11, where innocents are killed without provocation.

What has Geller accomplished, other than raising her cred with others of her ilk? Am I now free to draw Mohammed without fear? If so, that and $3 will get me a nice Starbuck's coffee.

No, thank's Islam.
 
People here are proposing that individuals like Geller should muzzle themselves in response to threats of violence from people who absolutely do want her to be muzzled--with lethal force, if possible.

I think both positions are effectively the same: Both positions hold that violence and threats of violence are appropriate means to silence speech and muzzle dissenters.
ETA: I also think it's kind of weaselly to stick on "no one here has actually said". The argument is clear, regardless of the exact wording used: Pamela Geller did not give some posters here the response they desired, to the threat of violence against her for her speech--the desired response being that she be complicit in her own muzzling by jihadi thugs.

Whooo-eee! Y'all be having yourselves some serious acrobatic training over on the social conservative wing this week, huh? We've got people here ignoring Geller's actual words and saying that Geller "hasn't actually said" X or Y so you can't really cal her a bigot or islamophobe or hateful *****. And that's acceptable. So acceptable, that we've even witnessed a recent convert to Gellerism. But when I ask for that same consideration for posters on this forum, you deem that weaselly? You insist on your right to read between the lines and make **** up? Which amendment in the Bill of Rights is that one?

In case you haven't noticed, chicken-poop liberals have no qualms about stating their piece. If I wished to say "Pamela Geller Should Not Be Allowed to Speak Because She Holds Politically Incorrect Opinions", I could've said so. And I didn't even say that Geller should muzzle herself, but that she should "think about" it. Y'all remember "thinking". It used to be a word unto itself before we co-opted it into half of Critical Thinking (hallowed be its name).

And being so darned adept at reading between the lines... how come you didn't figure out what I was really saying? Nope. Not gonna tell you. Hint: I don't think Geller's reading this forum, nor taking advice from Marplots, Quadraginta and Foolmewunz.
 
I hadn't considered it beforehand, but I would have bet on "no attack." It is very likely that I underestimate the dangers of Muslim extremism in the US. And I'm not sure what level of violence would shift my views - I think it would depend on the proven existence of an organized network, as contrasted with the "lone crazy" scenario.

I say that because I am familiar with incidents of Americans exploding into violence that didn't involve any larger ideal - other than what might exist in an individual's head. In this, I could be fundamentally wrong and Geller right. Or the situation could lay in the middle somewhere. I will not pretend to be an expert in this area.

In a sense, my objections in this thread have not been about Geller at all, but about how the incident is being spun - at times an exercise in free speech designed to accomplish some lofty goal, and at times as an innocent victim of Muslim terrorists. That's what bothers me, the imputing grander goals, and even nobility, where none (in my view) exist.

I think this is the nub of the divide. The attack is, ironically, a political victory for Geller's agenda, and people who disagree with her agenda will downplay its significance, or try to invert its effect, and people who sympathize with her agenda will oppose that effort. The same thing happens with other political issues. I suspect that when an abortion clinic is bombed, the pro-choice people are secretly rejoicing, and the pro-life people are despairing, but in public the pro-choice people exaggerate the chilling effect of the bombing, and the pro-life people frame it as an aberration. And when a crazed gunman shoots up a movie theater, the anti-gun people want to exaggerate its significance, and the pro-gun people want to downplay it.

Geller's agenda is predicated on the idea that Islamic extremism is a real threat to our way of life in the US. If she's right, then she has done a great and heroic thing by highlighting the problem, and by helping to expose the extremists' facilitators, appeasers and apologists. If she's wrong, then she has done harm by wasting everybody's time and by stoking Islamophobia (as it is properly defined - to wit, an irrational fear of Islam).

Because images of Mohammed mean nothing to me, it strikes me as agenda-driven, manufactured controversy for both parties. Akin to the kayfabe of wrestling fame. Not entirely so, because I don't think Geller is actually friendly with Muslims, but in the sense of one disputant both creating and requiring the outrage of the other to justify their own existence.

This, to me, is of a different character than the Boston Marathon attack or 9/11, where innocents are killed without provocation.

What has Geller accomplished, other than raising her cred with others of her ilk? Am I now free to draw Mohammed without fear? If so, that and $3 will get me a nice Starbuck's coffee.

Well, first of all, there are some people who would like to draw Muhammad from time to time, or see it published in a newspaper and resent the fact that it has become a taboo. Perhaps more importantly, however, if you yield to a taboo on drawings of Muhammad, you're going to invite yet another taboo being thrust upon you. I gave a couple of examples earlier in the thread - walking dogs and BBQ'ing pork outdoors. I don't think these are frivolous examples, but I could come up with dozens more if you don't like them.
 
<snip>

I would be very careful about using this as a basis for opposing protests such as Gellar's, since there is still a huge debate over the "clear and present danger" qualification; and typically it must have a more imminent nature and clear incitement to action. In this case, there was no clear incitement; and the expression of the dangers she believed was posed by the drawings was in no way false, as has been amply demonstrated by reactions to similar illustrations in the recent past.


I have no need to be careful since I have not and will not oppose Geller's "protests", or any like them.

There seems to be an inability around here for some people to engage in honest discussion. I have made it quite clear, even in the post from which you just quoted me (A statement which you for some reason saw fit to excise from your quote of my post.), that I do not believe speech should be suppressed.

Do you believe that the right to free speech is unencumbered by any consequences of that speech?
 
Last edited:
Maybe, except for the fact that quadraginta didn't actually answer the question. What would he like the consequences to be for Pamela Geller? Would he like her to be prosecuted? To be sued (and by whom)? To be prevented from doing this again? To be denounced and slandered with vile rhetoric (it's been done, by the way)?


You mean "the question" which wasn't asked by the post I was responding to?

There was nothing referencing what I would "like" to be done about or to Geller. My post clearly referred to hgc's inability to understand. An inability which you apparently share.

Or, possibly, you are just ginning up arguments against things which were never said.

That sort of dishonesty does seem to be popular among some circles.
 
You mean "the question" which wasn't asked by the post I was responding to?

The question was posed implicitly but it was still a question. What did you mean by "take responsibility?"

There was nothing referencing what I would "like" to be done about or to Geller. My post clearly referred to hgc's inability to understand. An inability which you apparently share.

Perhaps it's your inability to communicate clearly.

Or, possibly, you are just ginning up arguments against things which were never said.

That sort of dishonesty does seem to be popular among some circles.

I'm genuinely trying to find out what you mean by "take responsibility." I'm giving you some credit for having an interesting idea, but perhaps you're having difficulty articulating it.

Marplots sort of cleared up his position I think. Do you feel the same way? It's not so much that you want Geller to take responsibility in some way but that you want her to lose political support from this little stunt rather than gain from it. Right?
 
I have no need to be careful since I have not and will not oppose Geller's "protests", or any like them.

There seems to be an inability around here for some people to engage in honest discussion. I have made it quite clear, even in the post from which you just quoted me (A statement which you for some reason saw fit to excise from your quote of my post.), that I do not believe speech should be suppressed.

Do you believe that the right to free speech is unencumbered by any consequences of that speech?
If the consequences themselves are illegal acts performed by the offended, then yes, your speech should be free from consequences.
 
The question was posed implicitly but it was still a question.


"Implicitly". I see. That's your way of saying you're making crap up again.

What did you mean by "take responsibility?"


To recognize that speech can have consequences.

Perhaps it's your inability to communicate clearly.


Perhaps it is your willful refusal to understand. (Or possibly to admit to that, but I'll give you the benefit of the doubt.)

I'm genuinely trying to find out what you mean by "take responsibility." I'm giving you some credit for having an interesting idea, but perhaps you're having difficulty articulating it.


See above. It isn't difficult at all. Admitting to understanding might be harder when someone is intent on adding meaning ("implcit" or otherwise) which was neither present nor intended.

Marplots sort of cleared up his position I think. Do you feel the same way? It's not so much that you want Geller to take responsibility in some way but that you want her to lose political support from this little stunt rather than gain from it. Right?


As far as her stunts are concerned I don't "want" her to do anything aside from recognizing that her free speech can have consequences. She's more than welcome to say any damn-fool thing she wants to. The more she opens her mouth the more feces dribbles out of it. She alienates any rational, intelligent, informed adult a little bit more with each comment she utters.

I wouldn't want stop that. Sewage needs fresh air and sunlight to become anything useful. Hers needs a LOT.


I have no investment in Marsplots' position, whatever it may be. Any concerns you might have about that you need to discuss with him.
 
(much snipped)
Well, first of all, there are some people who would like to draw Muhammad from time to time, or see it published in a newspaper and resent the fact that it has become a taboo. Perhaps more importantly, however, if you yield to a taboo on drawings of Muhammad, you're going to invite yet another taboo being thrust upon you. I gave a couple of examples earlier in the thread - walking dogs and BBQ'ing pork outdoors. I don't think these are frivolous examples, but I could come up with dozens more if you don't like them.

I think I understand your point, but I disagree with the slippery slope aspect. This is partly because I don't think taboos are manufactured in a directed, one-off fashion, but arise organically.

For example, it is both taboo and illegal for me to draw/publish images of sex with underage children. I would not expect to be attacked in the same way, but would certainly expect public outrage and legal consequences. As far as I know, this taboo and restriction has not led to even more restrictions, making me think that the slope isn't really all that slippery and we can evaluate each instance as it arises.
 
To go on: the question that is at issue is whether blame/responsibility for the consequences attaches to the exhibitors in this particular instance. The answer is NO.
The ehibitor knew that offense would likely be taken, and that some individuals COULD be moved to illegal and violent action. So she took precautioms,.as any reasonable person would.
Speech is never free of consequences. Thise consequences SHOULD not include violent illegal acts.
It is the responsibility of our government to insure that those consequences do not violate the civil rights of the speaker.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom