Can a CharlieHebdo-type attack happen in the US?

Poor comma placement, maybe? Try this...
Many peoples are more disadvantaged than say Palestinians, have their own religion they hold dear and yet they DONT wage a worldwide terror campaign.

ETA - Maybe better expressed as
Many peoples, more disadvantaged than say Palestinians, have their own religion they hold dear and yet they DONT wage a worldwide terror campaign.

The "own religion they hold dear" refers to "Many people" not to "Palestinians".
 
Last edited:
Poor comma placement, maybe? Try this...

ETA - Maybe better expressed as

The "own religion they hold dear" refers to "Many people" not to "Palestinians".


Beats me. That post is loaded with non-standard grammar, spelling, diction, etc, so I can't tease it apart. May be a Scientologist.
 
It's called "protest", and it's a time-honoured tradition; with recorded public protests occurring as far back as ancient Sumer and Egypt.

Dismissing such people as "obstreperous children" is condescending and elitist, and common to the rhetoric of oppressors throughout
history. "They're just ignorant savages, incapable of acting civilized like we do; so we must rule them for their own good, and discipline them the same as any rebellious child." Sound familiar?

I think the reason this (and similar) parallels doesn't work for me is because I don't see the clear power relationship. Who is Geller protesting against? Islam generally? But then who has the power in Islam to alter things?

A second reason it fails for me is because I don't see Geller as representing a group of oppressed people. Rather, I see her as an outlier and radical herself. Allowing her the status of offended protestor would (for me) put her in the camp with the terrorist, who would argue that they are the oppressed minority rebelling against the status quo - so I reject the idea for both parties.
 
Last edited:
You do know what "Jim Crow" laws were, right? And "Separate but Equal"? What were those if they were not prohibiting people from doing things, based solely on the colour of their skins?

Your condescending dismissal is pure ignorance. A simplification, yes; but that is exactly what the Civil Rights movement was, boiled down to its essential core: People protesting and exercising their rights to do things that other people did, but which were forbidden to them specifically on account of their racial heritage. To eat at the same restaurants, to go to the same schools, to walk down the same sidewalk, to enjoy the same legal protections, to just as freely speak their minds, to live their lives the same as anyone else; all without fear of legal or violent private reprisals. Everything else is just details. That has been exactly the same anywhere and everywhere throughout history where people have fought for their rights and freedoms.

That's a fair summary. I do not think it matches this situation however. What, for example, is Geller forbidden to do that other people are doing but which she cannot because of her racial/ethnic/whatever heritage?
 
The very obvious difference is the presence of choice.

Seriously, I'm amazed that I have to point this out, but then that would assume that people are discussing in good faith, here.

I would say that in every case, the choice is the same, and only the consequences are different. Political prisoners are a clear example of people who have made a choice in the face of grave consequences. But the existence of those consequences did not remove their ability to choose.

So, arguing in good faith, it seems to me that you are making a distinction that I do not see. The distinction you are making seems to be based on reasoning that I believe is unsound.

If you believe that citizens in North Korea have no choice about free speech, and that this is what sets them apart from citizens in America, then we will never agree on the central questions being discussed in this thread. Not only that, but I will remain convinced that your reasons for condemning Geller's choice in this thread, and assigning to her some responsibility for the attack against her, are unfounded in rational thought.

I am, however, open to good-faith arguments that beyond a certain threshold, the enormity of consequences effectively removes choice, and that therefore we should judge the choices people make, both to speak and to impose consequences, differently on either side of that threshold.

I am hopeful that this seems reasonable to you, and you will respond by defining with examples and reasoning where you believe the threshold to be, between the government of North Korea and murderous jihadis who take offense at anti-Islamist protests. I think that having a clear understanding of where you place this threshold, and why, is an important precursor to determining if we can agree on the amount of condemnation we should heap on Pamela Geller.
 
Last edited:
No one here has actually said they want her to be muzzled. I see people proposing that individuals like Geller be asked to think about muzzling themselves.
People here are proposing that individuals like Geller should muzzle themselves in response to threats of violence from people who absolutely do want her to be muzzled--with lethal force, if possible.

I think both positions are effectively the same: Both positions hold that violence and threats of violence are appropriate means to silence speech and muzzle dissenters.

ETA: I also think it's kind of weaselly to stick on "no one here has actually said". The argument is clear, regardless of the exact wording used: Pamela Geller did not give some posters here the response they desired, to the threat of violence against her for her speech--the desired response being that she be complicit in her own muzzling by jihadi thugs.
 
Last edited:
Sunmaster,

I think that the idea that her freedom of speech is being abridged is a bit of a stretch. As pointed out, she's flapping her jaws on every damned TV station in the country. She has a blog that is available to anyone who wishes to read it.
She elected to get into the field of Muhammad Cartooning for a reason. Even partisans must realize that it was because this was the one that would get the greatest reaction. And.... no one stopped her, not anyone that is actually subject to the US Constitution. And she is free (and was free moments afterwards) to Tweet and Blog and get her face on CNN and Fox and ABC... which she did.

No one here has actually said they want her to be muzzled. I see people proposing that individuals like Geller be asked to think about muzzling themselves. But since neither Marplots nor Librul Lights Weekly actually has any authority over Geller, this is just discussion of philosophy of politics.

Its exactly the conversation the two dead Muslim animals should have engaged in instead of attempting to commit mass murder.
 
I think the reason this (and similar) parallels doesn't work for me is because I don't see the clear power relationship. Who is Geller protesting against? Islam generally? But then who has the power in Islam to alter things?


Fanatical Islamists seeking to enforce their religious taboos on others. This has already been covered repeatedly, go back and read the thread.

A second reason it fails for me is because I don't see Geller as representing a group of oppressed people. Rather, I see her as an outlier and radical herself.


Very convenient for you, but rather irrelevant to the reality of the incident; which, if you haven't been paying attention to world affairs, is just one in a fairly long sequence of similar incidents worldwide. Look up the murder of Theo Van Gogh, the persecution of Ayan Hirsi Ali, the Charlie Hebdo murders, the Jyllands-Posten controversy and subsequent riots, and so on. Some of these can equally be termed "radical" or "outliers"; but that doesn't matter, and your insistence that it does is troubling. Freedoms are freedoms for everyone, not for only a few people who we approve of. Otherwise they are not true freedoms, they are privileges granted to the elite. The right of radicals to speak their minds is exactly the same right as the right of average persons to speak their minds.

Allowing her the status of offended protestor would (for me) put her in the camp with the terrorist, who would argue that they are the oppressed minority rebelling against the status quo - so I reject the idea for both parties.


A people don't need to be oppressed to see their rights restricted. And protests are not always against government agencies; they are and have always been against anyone who has the power to harm them or restrict their rights. In fact, religious authorities have been the target of protests at least as much as any other group. Especially since, for much of history, political and religious power were inseparable. Much like modern Islamists want them to be. In modern times, large corporations are just as often the targets of protests, especially with regard to real or perceived environmental and economic harm.

And we are, by now, fully aware that you consider protesting against violence to be equivalent to inciting violence.
 
Last edited:
That's a fair summary. I do not think it matches this situation however. What, for example, is Geller forbidden to do that other people are doing but which she cannot because of her racial/ethnic/whatever heritage?


Did you miss the rest of the thread? Two fanatical Islamists tried to suppress her freedom of expression, because as a non-Muslim she deliberately violated a particular Islamic religious taboo. Much the same as fanatical Muslims have done to non-Muslims and less-fanatical Muslims worldwide. Go read the OP and you'll find more information about this particular incident.

Just because a particular group has been less effective at imposing their will at a particular time and place than they have been at other times and places does not necessarily make them less of a threat.
 
Last edited:
Reframe it as bullying and standing up to bullying if need be.

Some people bully(murder) others for doing something they don't like(having an unusual hairstyle, being fat, wearing unfashionable clothes, being effeminate or tomboyish, not showing Mahomet the "proper" amount of respect).

Is Pam Geller bullied? No, but she's standing up to the same bullies who have murdered at least a dozen people this year alone for their dissing of Mahomet in particular and Islam in general.

Maybe the solution to bullying is for the "weirdo" kids to stop being "weirdos" but, and I know this is now a humorous cliché with no real meaning, then the bullies win. If somebody has a better idea how to stand up to bullies aside from defying them and confronting them, then by all means, let's hear it.

ETA - Enh, that last sentence is redundant. Standing up to is defying and confronting. Let's go with "If somebody has a better idea how to end bullying aside from defying them and confronting them, then by all means, let's hear it"
 
Last edited:
And still I don't know what you mean by "take responsibility," other than that she should forego exercising her right to free expression because of the possible threat of violent reaction.


I don't think you are trying very hard. Our right to free speech does not exonerate us from any and every fault for the consequences of that speech.

The SCOTUS was verey clear in that regard when they decided Schenck (of 'fire in a crowded theater" fame.

In that case the speech was leaflets, and the incitement was to resist the draft.

Some have said that this is somehow different because it was inciting an illegal act (and some have said that that is tantamount to inciting violence anyway) but the "fire in a crowded theater" parallel makes it clear that the legality of the act was not part of the consideration.

I wholeheartedly defend Geller's right to say whatever she damned well pleases in this country, in public or in private or anywhere in between.

I do not, however, agree that she is innocent of any and all fault regarding the consequences of that speech, most especially when she not only knew full well that such consequences were possible, but was indeed uttering said speech specifically as a demonstration of her condemnation of such consequences elsewhere. It was clearly intended as provocation, and in this case it worked.

I don't concede her the right to pick and choose what social privileges she decides to indulge in while simultaneously willfully disregarding the responsibilities attached to those rights.

If passing out leaflets is an abuse of free speech responsibilities (and the SCOTUS has made it clear that it is) then setting out to create ( or more properly repeat) a blatant provocation of a known and active group of religious psychotics certainly must as well.

Save me the inevitable straw man. This is in no way a sanction or excuse of any sort for the religious psychotics and their reactions. Their actions stand alone and are unquestioningly egregious and unforgivable.

These two positions are not at all incompatible. The fault of one does not ameliorate or offset the fault of the other.

Both parties are reprehensible. Hiding behind false equivalence ('Well, shooting at people is more reprehensible than trying to provoke them into doing it, or even to create a situation where they might be inspired to.') is a willful evasion.

The reprehensibility of one does not add to or diminish the reprehensibility of the other. They are separate acts whose relationship is irrelevant to the quality of the acts themselves.

Each is to be taken on its own, Conflating them is sophistry.
 
Well said.

Maybe, except for the fact that quadraginta didn't actually answer the question. What would he like the consequences to be for Pamela Geller? Would he like her to be prosecuted? To be sued (and by whom)? To be prevented from doing this again? To be denounced and slandered with vile rhetoric (it's been done, by the way)?
 
Poorly reasoned. The Schenck v United States decision ruled that, "The most stringent protection of free speech would not protect a man in falsely shouting fire in a theatre and causing a panic."

You're missing three important parts of that statement:
1) The fraud of the speech. It is a false claim of fire: a fraud.
2) The proximity of the injured parties crowd to the speaker. The people that heard the speech react immediately and that causes them to be injured.
3) Panic. The speech caused the crowd to panic, not become outraged and try to kill the speaker.

It's the exact opposite of offending Islamic law.
 
Sunmaster,

I think that the idea that her freedom of speech is being abridged is a bit of a stretch. As pointed out, she's flapping her jaws on every damned TV station in the country. She has a blog that is available to anyone who wishes to read it.
She elected to get into the field of Muhammad Cartooning for a reason. Even partisans must realize that it was because this was the one that would get the greatest reaction. And.... no one stopped her, not anyone that is actually subject to the US Constitution. And she is free (and was free moments afterwards) to Tweet and Blog and get her face on CNN and Fox and ABC... which she did.

Geller's speech has not been materially restricted only because she is unusually brave, as well as rich enough to pay for the necessary security. That does not mean it hasn't been abridged in theory, or that the speech of others has been curtailed. In particular, cowardly Muhammad cartoonists have been completely silenced.

No one here has actually said they want her to be muzzled. I see people proposing that individuals like Geller be asked to think about muzzling themselves. But since neither Marplots nor Librul Lights Weekly actually has any authority over Geller, this is just discussion of philosophy of politics.

In a country of 320 million people, it's unrealistic to expect everybody to adhere to Islamic taboos simply out of politeness. Enforcing those taboos requires either exceptions in the law or credible threats of violence be made. So it is simply a fool's errand to make appeals solely based on etiquette. That is why I suspect ulterior motives in the people who claim that's what they're doing.
 
Maybe, except for the fact that quadraginta didn't actually answer the question. What would he like the consequences to be for Pamela Geller? Would he like her to be prosecuted? To be sued (and by whom)? To be prevented from doing this again? To be denounced and slandered with vile rhetoric (it's been done, by the way)?

Well, I can't answer for quadraginta, but I can for me. I think the consequences should be "Meh." Anything else just elevates her status and visibility. I don't think her ideas are "cause-worthy."

Those who do can donate at www.pamelageller.com
 
I don't think you are trying very hard. Our right to free speech does not exonerate us from any and every fault for the consequences of that speech.

The SCOTUS was verey clear in that regard when they decided Schenck (of 'fire in a crowded theater" fame.

In that case the speech was leaflets, and the incitement was to resist the draft.

Some have said that this is somehow different because it was inciting an illegal act (and some have said that that is tantamount to inciting violence anyway) but the "fire in a crowded theater" parallel makes it clear that the legality of the act was not part of the consideration.

I wholeheartedly defend Geller's right to say whatever she damned well pleases in this country, in public or in private or anywhere in between.

I do not, however, agree that she is innocent of any and all fault regarding the consequences of that speech, most especially when she not only knew full well that such consequences were possible, but was indeed uttering said speech specifically as a demonstration of her condemnation of such consequences elsewhere. It was clearly intended as provocation, and in this case it worked.

I don't concede her the right to pick and choose what social privileges she decides to indulge in while simultaneously willfully disregarding the responsibilities attached to those rights.

If passing out leaflets is an abuse of free speech responsibilities (and the SCOTUS has made it clear that it is) then setting out to create ( or more properly repeat) a blatant provocation of a known and active group of religious psychotics certainly must as well.

Save me the inevitable straw man. This is in no way a sanction or excuse of any sort for the religious psychotics and their reactions. Their actions stand alone and are unquestioningly egregious and unforgivable.

These two positions are not at all incompatible. The fault of one does not ameliorate or offset the fault of the other.

Both parties are reprehensible. Hiding behind false equivalence ('Well, shooting at people is more reprehensible than trying to provoke them into doing it, or even to create a situation where they might be inspired to.') is a willful evasion.

The reprehensibility of one does not add to or diminish the reprehensibility of the other. They are separate acts whose relationship is irrelevant to the quality of the acts themselves.

Each is to be taken on its own, Conflating them is sophistry.

SCOTUS ruled that the first amendment doesn't protect one from encouraging illegal behaviour. Yes, our first amendment rights are not an absolute protection. No one here that I know of is claiming that. More relevant to that is they have ruled that speech cannot be banned just for being offensive, for example see the Westboro Church ruling.

I have to echo hgc, what do you mean "take responsibility"? You defend her right to hold the contest, but she's still at fault. What does that mean, should she be punished somehow for being at fault? Should she apologize? She obviously held this contest knowing full well there could be violence directed at it. So she hired security. Other than not hold the contest what else was there to be done? Its not as if she held this at an unprotected elementary school in the hopes a bunch of kids would get slaughtered to start a holy war.

I completely disagree that the contest itself was reprehensible (Geller from other comments she has made, sure). It "took the piss" out of a religion that undoubtedly deserves it IMO. What if a group from this forum was threatened for making fun of Scientology, would you really hold them at fault if John Travolta organized a hit squad against them, even if they were warned not to do it first?

Geller believes (or so she says) that the US is in imminent danger of having Sharia law enforced on us. I think shes a crackpot. However, if I really believed it, or indeed if there was a law passed banning Mohammed from being displayed, I'd be sure and walk about with his face on a T-shirt... with some good quality Kevlar underneath it.
 
Last edited:
The SCOTUS was verey clear in that regard when they decided Schenck (of 'fire in a crowded theater" fame.

In that case the speech was leaflets, and the incitement was to resist the draft.

Some have said that this is somehow different because it was inciting an illegal act (and some have said that that is tantamount to inciting violence anyway) but the "fire in a crowded theater" parallel makes it clear that the legality of the act was not part of the consideration.


You're flat wrong in this, as usual. The illegality of the act was, in fact, the basis of the decision. Passing out anti-draft leaflets was considered incitement to commit an illegal act. Holmes' ruling directly addressed this fact, and found against Schenck because the leafleting posed a "clear and present danger" of succeeding in inciting others to commit a crime; and only applied to successfully obstructing a draft.

Shouting "Fire" is a crowded theatre was considered incitement to cause a panic, which could potentially cause harm in the resultant rush. It was not the basis of the ruling; but an illustration of the limits of protections of free speech, to wit:

The most stringent protection of free speech would not protect a man in falsely shouting fire in a theatre and causing a panic. [...] The question in every case is whether the words used are used in such circumstances and are of such a nature as to create a clear and present danger that they will bring about the substantive evils that Congress has a right to prevent.
(emphasis added)

It's quite clear from actually reading the text of the ruling, and the specific reference to "clear and present danger", that it was the illegality of the act, and the potential for legal or physical harm that could result, that was the basis of the ruling. And the emphasis here is on falsely causing a panic; ie. committing a fraud likely to cause harm to others. Shouting "Fire" in a crowded theatre where there is actually a fire would be protected, regardless of the panic caused by the fire.

I would be very careful about using this as a basis for opposing protests such as Gellar's, since there is still a huge debate over the "clear and present danger" qualification; and typically it must have a more imminent nature and clear incitement to action. In this case, there was no clear incitement; and the expression of the dangers she believed was posed by the drawings was in no way false, as has been amply demonstrated by reactions to similar illustrations in the recent past.
 
Last edited:
Well, I can't answer for quadraginta, but I can for me. I think the consequences should be "Meh."
Huh. Given the amount of effort you've put into making and defending your arguments in this thread, I was going to order a much larger teapot. However, based on this latest development, I think we can safely contain your tempest in one of these.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom