Can a CharlieHebdo-type attack happen in the US?

The very obvious difference is the presence of choice.

Seriously, I'm amazed that I have to point this out, but then that would assume that people are discussing in good faith, here.

How is the choice meaningfully different? Get killed by government goons or religious goons. Either way, you remain silent because of the consequences (getting killed). That's intimidation and it is to be deplored, whether in garland or North Korea.
 
The in-context example would be a pro-choice woman who gives birth because she's been terrorized into not seeking an abortion. Still a salient point?

I think you have modified the point, but I'll address it anyhow. The analogy breaks down unless I think drawing cartoons of Mohammed is on par with carrying a child to term. That's a leap I am unwilling to make.

The question, in my opinion, is what role violent intimidation played in the choice to become an atheist.

Again, I think this is a mischaracterization.

Suppose there was a fanatical subset of Scientology which felt that hiding in a coffin and chanting "Xenu, Xenu, Xenu..." was worth killing someone over. (This is designed to be at least as ridiculous as drawing cartoon Mohammed.)

In light of this, am I then bound to hold an event where I do exactly the forbidden behavior? If so, why? What could be my purpose, other than to rile up Scientologists - in effect, to dare them to act?
 
Of course Freedom of Speech includes the right not to speak but as soon as someone tells you, you can't speak, then it becomes imperative to speak. After all, front of the bus or the back, everybody's getting there the same time, what's the difference?
 
Of course Freedom of Speech includes the right not to speak but as soon as someone tells you, you can't speak, then it becomes imperative to speak. After all, front of the bus or the back, everybody's getting there the same time, what's the difference?

Does that really work, with other than obstreperous children? That if something is forbidden, it must be done?

It doesn't appear to be the case where I'm at, where women are not expected to go around naked, even when it's hot out. I think it might even be forbidden. Does that mean it is imperative for them to do so?

Or does the imperative element only attach when the reaction would be an attack?
 
Does that really work, with other than obstreperous children? That if something is forbidden, it must be done?

It doesn't appear to be the case where I'm at, where women are not expected to go around naked, even when it's hot out. I think it might even be forbidden. Does that mean it is imperative for them to do so?

Or does the imperative element only attach when the reaction would be an attack?

Hey man, take it up with Gandhi, Rosa Parks, MLK... tell them they were wrong and being jackasses, sorry, being "obstreperous children".
 
Hey man, take it up with Gandhi, Rosa Parks, MLK... tell them they were wrong and being jackasses, sorry, being "obstreperous children".

That's an interesting take on the civil rights movement - people were doing things because other people said they couldn't. I'm amazed so much has been written about civil rights when there's such a tidy summary available.

It kind of explains the Civil and Revolutionary Wars too, if you think about it. It's probably the reason my dog occasionally poops in the house. Well, either that or my dog is an *******.
 
That's an interesting take on the civil rights movement - people were doing things because other people said they couldn't. I'm amazed so much has been written about civil rights when there's such a tidy summary available.

In the case of Rosa Parks or the Greensbro food counter protesters that's a pretty good summary, if you stop there. The stories of people allowed to sit where they wanted or who didn't sit where people told them they couldn't would hardly have inspired the changes to US society that these people's gestures of non-violent defiance did.
 
This is not entirely true. She has had a website for at least 5 years where she expresses her ideas. She's been on television and elsewhere doing the same. She chose this method and decided to spend the money. But, like me, she could have spoken freely for free - here on this forum, for example.

Unless you are proposing there is some right to hold a conference without expense - perhaps publicly subsidized? - I don't see how the mechanism, and the restrictions we all face, limit her free speech in the general sense.

The fact that other avenues of speech are open to her, as well as the one she chose, is not what matters. What matters is whether or not her speech is unduly burdened because of the content, which otherwise is legal. If she had held an art show displaying cartoons of Jesus Christ, she wouldn't have needed to spend $50K on security. Now, whether or not there is a legal remedy is another question. I imagine she has a colorable legal argument to force the federal government to pick up some of her security tab. The logic would be similar to the logic behind compensating 9/11 families with billions of dollars. In any case, I was not claiming that her constitutional rights were being abridged. Only that her right to free speech was.

There is one interesting twist, however. Since the incident and ramped up threats on her life, she claims that the Federal government so far has shown no interest in protecting her. If true, then I think she definitely has a case that her constitutional rights are being violated. It reminds me of the flag burning case from 1990 or so. After the Supreme Court ruled that flag burning was protected speech, the state legislature of Louisiana briefly considered passing a law that reduced the criminal penalty for beating up a flag-burner to a $25 fine. Such a law would obviously have been unconstitutional.

To the extent she didn't act negligently, she acts purposefully and thereby becomes even more reprehensible.

Well, there's no accounting for taste I guess. I think she's heroic. Actually, the more I learn about her, the more I like her. I think she has been unfairly smeared by pro-Islam groups like CAIR which are doing it as part of a deliberate strategy.

I disagree with this for several reasons, but the one that jumps out is that I don't think "suicidal/homicidal Jihadists" is a fixed set and that killing two will necessarily, or permanently, lower the total.

If you have the skills, you could find out (for both of us and for the general edification of the thread participants) how these deaths are being spun in the extremist camp. Are the two deaths a cautionary tale, or are they lauded as noble acts to be imitated? I don't know, although I would guess the latter is closer to the truth.

My question would be: To what extent does Geller's shenanigans root out and kill the extremists, and to what extent do her activities create extremists?

It's quite hard to believe that an otherwise normal person would be incited to become an extremist just because a 56-year old divorcee says some mean things about Islam on her blog and subsidizes the drawings of Muhammad cartoons. I mean I can see somebody becoming radicalized because his relatives were blown to bits by a drone missile. Or that he was treated badly by a foreign occupying army. Or that he becomes convinced of a zero-sum theory of economics so that he comes to believe that the extravagant wealth in the West was accumulated at the expense of his own people. No doubt that happens to some extent. Those are traumatic insults that can affect your worldview. But being turned to jihad because a harmless nobody in the US is doing obnoxious things? I seriously doubt that has happened.

No, I suspect that before this incident, there were X dangerous terrorists in the US, and now there are X-2. More importantly perhaps, the US security apparatus has awakened to a very real threat that they had been underestimating previously.
 
Does that really work, with other than obstreperous children? That if something is forbidden, it must be done?

Well, I would rephrase that to "if something is forbidden unreasonably, then it should be done." But, yes, in general, I think that strategy works. Taboos are only discarded after they've been violated. If the taboo was reasonable, then the people will see the harmful effects of violating the taboo, and the taboo will be reinforced. If the taboo was unreasonable, then the people will see that there are no negative consequences to violating the taboo, and perhaps lots of upside, and the taboo will cease being a taboo. Right now, there is a taboo against violating certain aspects of Sharia law which are not consistent with our law. I think these taboos should be challenged and broken until they are not taboos anymore.

And by "people," I also mean Muslims who live halfway around the world and want to live under Sharia law. Once they realize that they're not actually harmed by infidels drawing cartoons of their prophet in the US, they'll stop caring.
 
Sunmaster,

I think that the idea that her freedom of speech is being abridged is a bit of a stretch. As pointed out, she's flapping her jaws on every damned TV station in the country. She has a blog that is available to anyone who wishes to read it.
She elected to get into the field of Muhammad Cartooning for a reason. Even partisans must realize that it was because this was the one that would get the greatest reaction. And.... no one stopped her, not anyone that is actually subject to the US Constitution. And she is free (and was free moments afterwards) to Tweet and Blog and get her face on CNN and Fox and ABC... which she did.

No one here has actually said they want her to be muzzled. I see people proposing that individuals like Geller be asked to think about muzzling themselves. But since neither Marplots nor Librul Lights Weekly actually has any authority over Geller, this is just discussion of philosophy of politics.
 
Does that really work, with other than obstreperous children? That if something is forbidden, it must be done?

It's called "protest", and it's a time-honoured tradition; with recorded public protests occurring as far back as ancient Sumer and Egypt.

Dismissing such people as "obstreperous children" is condescending and elitist, and common to the rhetoric of oppressors throughout
history. "They're just ignorant savages, incapable of acting civilized like we do; so we must rule them for their own good, and discipline them the same as any rebellious child." Sound familiar?
 
Last edited:
No one here has actually said they want her to be muzzled. I see people proposing that individuals like Geller be asked to think about muzzling themselves. But since neither Marplots nor Librul Lights Weekly actually has any authority over Geller, this is just discussion of philosophy of politics.

Hypothetical, would this seem ok, or outrageous to you:
"Dear miss attempted rape victim, no one wants to force you to stay in the kitchen but some of us feel that you should consider staying in the kitchen voluntarily, lest someone try to rape you again. We feel it would be best all round if you didn't inflame the situation in future."
 
That's an interesting take on the civil rights movement - people were doing things because other people said they couldn't. I'm amazed so much has been written about civil rights when there's such a tidy summary available.

You do know what "Jim Crow" laws were, right? And "Separate but Equal"? What were those if they were not prohibiting people from doing things, based solely on the colour of their skins?

Your condescending dismissal is pure ignorance. A simplification, yes; but that is exactly what the Civil Rights movement was, boiled down to its essential core: People protesting and exercising their rights to do things that other people did, but which were forbidden to them specifically on account of their racial heritage. To eat at the same restaurants, to go to the same schools, to walk down the same sidewalk, to enjoy the same legal protections, to just as freely speak their minds, to live their lives the same as anyone else; all without fear of legal or violent private reprisals. Everything else is just details. That has been exactly the same anywhere and everywhere throughout history where people have fought for their rights and freedoms.
 
I think some people are confused about what a dangerous extremist is. If you get angry and upset over drawings of a early medieval man you have never met,you are already a dangerous extremist. You are just looking for a "reason"to turn violent.
Many peoples are more disadvantaged than say,Palestinians,have there own religion they hold dear and yet they DONT wage a worldwide terror campaign. Its Islam that is violent,and Muslims get all upset because we "let" women work,vote and have equal rights. They hate us because we DONT hang homosexuals and stone adulterers.
So called "honour" (ha!) Killings are a great example. These killings could not possibly take place without the support of large numbers of ordinary Muslims in the areas they occur. Could you imagine if say Scotish or Swedish politicians started hanging gays and stoning women,the government would collapse, the army would support the people along with the police. The fact that this does not happen in Iran is wholly at the feet of the Muslim population of Iran. They-along with the Muslim religion are to blame.
For Pitts sake they march in the streets crying for joy when they get news of a terror attack in the west. They openly say our way of life is evil and wrong. Its bizzare that any right thinking person defends Islam. If scientologists carried out multiple terror attacks we would not hesitate to put the blame on Scientology as a whole. If the heavens gate cult flew passenger jets into downtown new York no one would say "ah but heavens gate is peace full",of course they would not. Why should Islam get special treatment,put blame where it deserves-with Islam as a whole.
 
I think some people are confused about what a dangerous extremist is. If you get angry and upset over drawings of a early medieval man you have never met,you are already a dangerous extremist. You are just looking for a "reason"to turn violent.
Many peoples are more disadvantaged than say,Palestinians,have there own religion they hold dear and yet they DONT wage a worldwide terror campaign. Its Islam that is violent,and Muslims get all upset because we "let" women work,vote and have equal rights. They hate us because we DONT hang homosexuals and stone adulterers.
So called "honour" (ha!) Killings are a great example. These killings could not possibly take place without the support of large numbers of ordinary Muslims in the areas they occur. Could you imagine if say Scotish or Swedish politicians started hanging gays and stoning women,the government would collapse, the army would support the people along with the police. The fact that this does not happen in Iran is wholly at the feet of the Muslim population of Iran. They-along with the Muslim religion are to blame.
For Pitts sake they march in the streets crying for joy when they get news of a terror attack in the west. They openly say our way of life is evil and wrong. Its bizzare that any right thinking person defends Islam. If scientologists carried out multiple terror attacks we would not hesitate to put the blame on Scientology as a whole. If the heavens gate cult flew passenger jets into downtown new York no one would say "ah but heavens gate is peace full",of course they would not. Why should Islam get special treatment,put blame where it deserves-with Islam as a whole.

The blame isn't deserved by the *lots* of Muslims who don't care about that stuff.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom