Can a CharlieHebdo-type attack happen in the US?

I'd have to say choosing not to say something you think is important and something you want to say because you're afraid of being brutalized by death squads isn't quite in the spirit of a constitutionally protected right of free expression.

Correct. Everyone has a right to say,indeed shout,his or her opinion. Some opinions are nasty and horrible. Some things should perhaps be unsaid. But to curb free speech just because someone may be so offended as to start machine-gunning people is unthinkable. The person carrying out a act of violence over words,drawings etc is always completely and uterlly to blame.
You always have a choice. If you get angry over some stupid drawings you are responsible for your anger and any ultimate outcome. Those who get even just angry over drawings of a long dead guy are already extremists. Why would anyone get angry over drawings of someone they have never met-thats extremism.
If someone is ridiculous we as a species and democratic peoples mock and laugh at them. Believing you should not draw pics of a dead medieval cult leader is ridiculous, there for we should, and indeed must mock these idiots and there idiotic beliefs.
What's next don't mock xenu and the intergalactic empire because it will make tom cruise and travolta angry. If someone is ridiculous they serve and must be mocked. Otherwise what's the point free speech,free expression, free voting etc. None of those things would mean anything if we could not ridicule those that deserve to be ridiculed. For pittys sake Muslims think flying horses are real, in 2015,they deserve our mockery for that alone.
 
Last edited:
Well, they do vigorously defend the right of people to not to speak...

The folks in North Korea are capable of speaking. They just look at the likely consequences and refrain from doing so.

That the consequences are governmental death squads rather than religious death squads doesn't diminish their glorious affirmation of their responsible usage of non-speaking speech.
 
The folks in North Korea are capable of speaking. They just look at the likely consequences and refrain from doing so.

That the consequences are governmental death squads rather than religious death squads doesn't diminish their glorious affirmation of their responsible usage of non-speaking speech.
Which is the way several posters here want everyone to be, apparently.
Living in constant fear ain't living, to me...
 
Correct. Everyone has a right to say,indeed shout,his or her opinion. Some opinions are nasty and horrible. Some things should perhaps be unsaid. But to curb free speech just because someone may be so offended as to start machine-gunning people is unthinkable. The person carrying out a act of violence over words,drawings etc is always completely and uterlly to blame.
You always have a choice. If you get angry over some stupid drawings you are responsible for your anger and any ultimate outcome. Those who get even just angry over drawings of a long dead guy are already extremists. Why would anyone get angry over drawings of someone they have never met-thats extremism.
If someone is ridiculous we as a species and democratic peoples mock and laugh at them. Believing you should not draw pics of a dead medieval cult leader is ridiculous, there for we should, and indeed must mock these idiots and there idiotic beliefs.
What's next don't mock xenu and the intergalactic empire because it will make tom cruise and travolta angry. If someone is ridiculous they serve and must be mocked. Otherwise what's the point free speech,free expression, free voting etc. None of those things would mean anything if we could not ridicule those that deserve to be ridiculed. For pittys sake Muslims think flying horses are real, in 2015,they deserve our mockery for that alone.

Very well said.
 
I'd have to say choosing not to say something you think is important and something you want to say because you're afraid of being brutalized by death squads isn't quite in the spirit of a constitutionally protected right of free expression.

Well of course if you put it like that. My comment was general, not specific. Just like the right to vote is important, I'm not sure requiring people to vote would be that great an idea.
 
Ditto, I'm not sure what the subtle nuance is that got glossed over?

Presumably the nuance by which Belz... makes it reasonably clear that people in North Korea who avoid violence by keeping silent are having their rights infringed, but people in the US who do the same are not.

I confess I'm also missing that nuance, but perhaps if someone asks him nicely, Belz... will explain it in explicit detail so that we can all understand and (hopefully) agree with his conclusion.
 
Bomb-throwing language is a hell of a lot better than actually throwing bombs.

(Not that Geller has actually called for any violence anyway AFAIK)

I've seen a lot of disagreements on this forum but this thread has surely topped them all for weaselly, reprehensible attempts to minimize attempted murder just because the targets had different, politically incorrect, views.

Christ, it's disgusting.



I 100% agree. Geller is a contemptible bigot,but this whole idea that somehow excuses the Jihadi attackers is really,really, beyond the pale.
 
Bomb-throwing language is a hell of a lot better than actually throwing bombs.

(Not that Geller has actually called for any violence anyway AFAIK)

I've seen a lot of disagreements on this forum but this thread has surely topped them all for weaselly, reprehensible attempts to minimize attempted murder just because the targets had different, politically incorrect, views.

Christ, it's disgusting.

this
 
Wait a second. Exercising your right to free speech doesn't necessarily entail speaking. Not speaking is also an option, so I don't see how doing that is foregoing your right.

Salient point, that. After all, women who are pro-choice may still have babies.
 
Keeping silent = exercising your freedom of speech just like not walking is exercising your right to walk.

Truly we are in a Brave New World.

And like being an atheist is an expression of my freedom of religion. :)
 
Can you prove that it was her goal to be attacked by gunmen (roughly analogous to being robbed)? In your opinion the utility in keeping large amounts of cash available for people to withdraw at a bank outweighs the risk of being robbed, and in some instances, for security/tellers/customers to be wounded or killed. We could go to a purely cashless society, it is possible, and then the risks incurred from bank robbery are nullfied. However, in your opinion the utility of lampooning a religious figure is not enough to risk security/ contestants/ bystanders being wounded or killed. Its entirely subjective to what you view as important enough for the risks incurred.

Should I have clarified that? The things I express are my opinions. I have no other opinions to post than the ones I actually hold. I'm sorry if anyone was confused by this point.

Also, as a corollary, any links I post to other's opinions are there because I think those people agree (at least partly) with me. I do not post links to material with contrary opinions (or try not to), except to demonstrate some attribute they have which in some way supports my own opinion.

I took this situation to be the default here, but if someone else in the thread is a shill and bound by duty and remuneration to express an opinion they do not hold, I think it would be honest if they mentioned this.
 
Last edited:
First of all, her free speech rights have been attacked, and they are being abridged. Drawing a cartoon of Muhammad or holding a convention to exhibit cartoons of Muhammad is absolutely an exercise of protected speech. And yet, in order to do that, she not only has to spend tens of thousands of dollars on security, but she has to risk her life as well. Plus, attendance will be muted not because people don't want to hear her speech or take part in it, but because they are frightened by threats of violence.

This is not entirely true. She has had a website for at least 5 years where she expresses her ideas. She's been on television and elsewhere doing the same. She chose this method and decided to spend the money. But, like me, she could have spoken freely for free - here on this forum, for example.

Unless you are proposing there is some right to hold a conference without expense - perhaps publicly subsidized? - I don't see how the mechanism, and the restrictions we all face, limit her free speech in the general sense.

Second, whatever her "end" was, it was not morally impoverished in my view. She did not trick people into risking their lives, nor did she act negligently. On the contrary, I think the evidence shows that she made sure there was adequate security (perhaps Hillary Clinton could learn a lesson from her).

To the extent she didn't act negligently, she acts purposefully and thereby becomes even more reprehensible.

Third, even if her "end" was two dead jihadists, which I doubt, that was a huge positive for the country. Don't you think those two guys were serious threats? It seems likely that her little "stunt" had the effect of saving lives in the long run. Plus with her acting as a lightning rod for jihadist outrage, it makes all of the rest of us marginally safer. Our transgressions of sharia law, whether accidental or intentional, are less likely to be noticed if the enforcers of sharia law are focused like a laser beam on what that notorious Islamophobe will do next.

I disagree with this for several reasons, but the one that jumps out is that I don't think "suicidal/homicidal Jihadists" is a fixed set and that killing two will necessarily, or permanently, lower the total.

If you have the skills, you could find out (for both of us and for the general edification of the thread participants) how these deaths are being spun in the extremist camp. Are the two deaths a cautionary tale, or are they lauded as noble acts to be imitated? I don't know, although I would guess the latter is closer to the truth.

My question would be: To what extent does Geller's shenanigans root out and kill the extremists, and to what extent do her activities create extremists?
 
Last edited:
Salient point, that. After all, women who are pro-choice may still have babies.
The in-context example would be a pro-choice woman who gives birth because she's been terrorized into not seeking an abortion. Still a salient point?

And like being an atheist is an expression of my freedom of religion. :)
The question, in my opinion, is what role violent intimidation played in the choice to become an atheist.
 
Presumably the nuance by which Belz... makes it reasonably clear that people in North Korea who avoid violence by keeping silent are having their rights infringed, but people in the US who do the same are not.

The very obvious difference is the presence of choice.

Seriously, I'm amazed that I have to point this out, but then that would assume that people are discussing in good faith, here.

The in-context example would be a pro-choice woman who gives birth because she's been terrorized into not seeking an abortion.

Who the **** said anything about being terrified ? Did ANY of you even read my post ?
 
She wasn't just offending the two killers who arrived though, the cartoons offend a broad swath of Muslims. So...

As you say "So?"

No-one has the right to not be offended. (Or the John Cleese version "Everyone has the right to be offended")
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom