Can a CharlieHebdo-type attack happen in the US?

I thought section 4 applied particularly well. It starts this way:

In one of the categories, he has an almost perfect match, saying there is an equal responsibility: "Victims who seek, challenge, tease, or entice the perpetrator."

Yet the rest of the text doesn't support that assertion; and stretches the "victim responsibility" far beyond breaking point.

Again, not seeing the peer review here.
 
The outcome of this event is two dead Jihadists and a wounded security guard - and, I suppose, a bunch of cartoons on her website. These results had antecedents, some of which were proximate causes, some less so.

I have been arguing that when she undertook to hold the event, she could have (and I think likely did) foresee a risk of attack. She did it anyhow. Because of this, she bears some responsibility for the outcome. I've even said that the outcome was a win/win for both sides - she gets to point out how violent Muslims are and a couple of Jihadists get their desire for martyrdom.

In none of this are her free speech rights attacked or abridged. The major criticism is in her willingness to manipulate affairs to gain a end I think is morally impoverished - the death of two and the risk of death for many more. If there is a right I do not think she has, it is the right to risk the lives of others in service to her cause.


And still I don't know what you mean by "take responsibility," other than that she should forego exercising her right to free expression because of the possible threat of violent reaction.
 
And still I don't know what you mean by "take responsibility," other than that she should forego exercising her right to free expression because of the possible threat of violent reaction.

Wait a second. Exercising your right to free speech doesn't necessarily entail speaking. Not speaking is also an option, so I don't see how doing that is foregoing your right.
 
And doubling down yet again. At least you're consistent.


That isn't very difficult, since my question has remained the same, and you continue to try and evade it.

Your position seems to be that the fact that the neighbor is bothered is not what is germane to the 'dickishness' of the guy, but rather the reason the neighbor is bothered.

I don't understand why, in the circumstances described in this scenario, that that makes any difference.

You seem to be unable to intelligently articulate your position, and instead resort to snark and childish insults.

It doesn't appear to be me who is doing the "doubling down".
 
Wait a second. Exercising your right to free speech doesn't necessarily entail speaking. Not speaking is also an option, so I don't see how doing that is foregoing your right.


Uh, wow. Don't know what to say to that.
 
Uh, wow. Don't know what to say to that.

Well maybe you should think about it, then.

I would think that freedom to do something also includes the freedom to not do it. I'm not saying that she shouldn't have held the event. I'm simply not agreeing with you on your definitions, here.
 
Wait a second. Exercising your right to free speech doesn't necessarily entail speaking. Not speaking is also an option, so I don't see how doing that is foregoing your right.

Uh, wow. Don't know what to say to that.

Keeping silent = exercising your freedom of speech just like not walking is exercising your right to walk.

Truly we are in a Brave New World.
 
Keeping silent = exercising your freedom of speech just like not walking is exercising your right to walk.

Truly we are in a Brave New World.

You can show how much you disagree with the Islamist demand to not depict Mohammad by not depicting Mohammad.
 
Wait a second. Exercising your right to free speech doesn't necessarily entail speaking. Not speaking is also an option, so I don't see how doing that is foregoing your right.

Never before had I realized how much free speech there is in North korea.
 
l9zKYHF.gif
 
Never before had I realized how much free speech there is in North korea.

Do you really not see the difference between choosing not to do something and not having the right to do it ?

Seriously, three strawmen in a row. It seems like you guys are _looking_ to disagree and argue. I'm making a distinction, here, not arguing for Sharia law. :rolleyes:
 
Do you really not see the difference between choosing not to do something and not having the right to do it ?

Seriously, three strawmen in a row. It seems like you guys are _looking_ to disagree and argue. I'm making a distinction, here, not arguing for Sharia law. :rolleyes:


That's funny, because to say that Geller should refrain from what she did because of the threat of violent reprisal sounds a lot like saying she should abide by Sharia Law. The reason for refraining matters ... a lot.
 
You are no longer taken seriously.

Do you seriously expect me to believe that? With my ego?? :rolleyes:

Your Geller Apologetics act places you beyond reach, so it doesn't surprise me that with your political blinders on you cannot see that the "Free Speech!!" proponents are assembling straw man arguments so they can claim debate victory on the internet. Any poster daring to point out the log on your collective eye - that Geller is an unapologetic bigot - immediately gets asked why they support terrorism or are against free speech.

I challenge you to find a single post of mine in this thread which does that. You're just conflating me with other people you're taking issue with, same as you claim they are doing to you.

Since that's not what anyone is arguing, it's pretty obvious that you can't have a genuine discussion in this thread (nor any when the words "Muslim" and "Rational" are used in the same post, let alone same paragraph or sentence).

It's not obvious to me at all. This discussion has stayed on-topic far better than most, and it has been reasonably interesting and civil to boot. I'm not sure why you're so fed up.

Let's try this again:
Geller is a bigot, supported by bigots, selling bigotry to bigots and stirring up bigots wherever possible.1The Islamic Fundie Psychos were/are Islamic Fundie Psycho Murderers. 2
It is possible to dislike either or both groups for different reasons. Geller's bigotry is not ameliorated by "Oh, yeah, well the bad guys were terrorists" and the terrorists' terrorism is not given a pass "Because she's a bigot!"

1. This does not mean that anyone who supports Geller's right to free speech is a bigot nor a supporter of bigots.... only the "rights" of everyone, and that unfortunately may include bigots
2. This does not mean that anyone who looks to find causes or to understand the mindset or mentality of the perps is an apologist for terrorism.

Those are hardly disputed propositions. I only dispute the proposition that Geller is a bigot. It seems to me that her detractors here are not applying the appropriate amount of skepticism to that claim.

Homework: Explain to us mere high school dropouts how Geller's support of the murderous war criminal from Serbia is "reasonable", as you seem to view her concerns.

You'll have to document Geller's support for "the" (only one??) murderous war criminal from Serbia. I am so far only aware that she believes the Serbs have been unfairly demonized and that atrocities committed against them have been ignored. I do too. I was against the Kosovo War, for example, and I believe that the Clinton administration greatly exaggerated claims of ethnic cleansing and genocide in order to justify its intervention. I have always been somewhat skeptical of the official story of the wars in the former Yugoslavia. In part because I had a good friend in graduate school who was Serbian, and he was constantly pointing out to me various distortions in the media. I suppose in part I also have lingering biases dating to events during WWII, when the Croatians were allied with the Nazis, and the Serbs were their victims.
 
The difference revolves around the purpose of Geller's little event. If you think drawing Mohammed serves some function other than to draw the ire of Islamic zealots, then it would be a good parallel. After all, a bank and money transfers are separate activities with separate goals - goals unrelated to getting robbed.

Can you prove that it was her goal to be attacked by gunmen (roughly analogous to being robbed)? In your opinion the utility in keeping large amounts of cash available for people to withdraw at a bank outweighs the risk of being robbed, and in some instances, for security/tellers/customers to be wounded or killed. We could go to a purely cashless society, it is possible, and then the risks incurred from bank robbery are nullfied. However, in your opinion the utility of lampooning a religious figure is not enough to risk security/ contestants/ bystanders being wounded or killed. Its entirely subjective to what you view as important enough for the risks incurred.
 
That's funny, because to say that Geller should refrain from what she did because of the threat of violent reprisal sounds a lot like saying she should abide by Sharia Law. The reason for refraining matters ... a lot.

Indeed they do. However the fact remains that freedom to do a thing does not entail that one must do that thing, which is my point. Of course it's a valid point that she shouldn't have to bow to threats if she doesn't want to, which _wasn't_ my point, but this discussion is so charged and polarized, apparently it's impossible to speak of nuances, or disagree with any small sub-point without being assumed to disagree with the whole "side" of that argument.
 
I can't recall if anyone did a captcha on any missing posts from the Brevik fiasco, only know it was referred to. I'll concede a maybe on that one because she's often accused (even in this thread) of saying things she's quoting or that are from the "comments". But see parenthetical paragraph below.

And the missing posts on the Vehicular Jihad? No. They've been scrubbed. Apparently Geller has a homebrew cowboy server so she can control her words post posting. There are references to it, but those wouldn't be deemed acceptable.

You do realize that there's a big difference between email, which is meant to be private, and a public website, which is meant to be, er, ... public, right? Deleting private email off your private homebrew, cowboy server has a good chance of keeping it forever away from prying eyes because the only other copy is that which the recipient/sender has (which may in fact be on the same homebrew cowboy server). Expunging information from the world which had been posted on a public web server is a much dicier proposition. Web crawlers abound which take snapshots and archive the information almost immediately. Plus, various readers (especially detractors) will download information they find interesting. I'm not claiming that she didn't opine on the heart attack accident and then scrub it, but so far I've only been able to find broken links to the alleged offending post, which does not exactly inspire confidence that the post actually said what it was purported to have said, or even existed at all.

(Of what you can find on her Norway spiels, you're not, shall we say, "impressed" by her rush to not only make judgement but to use her bully pulpit to slander her favorite target in the assumption... "Hey, it's violence; it's got to be Mooslims"? And the commenters? Frothing at the mouth lunatics, all. Everyone sees fit to drop a comment about succumbing to terrorism or how this was all to be expected. All with the assumption that their favorite bogie man done the deed.)

Her rush to judgment was based on initial news reports. She gives a detailed and credible defense of her actions in the 4th link that I provided. In any case, her thesis is that Islamic extremism is a bigger threat to Western civilization than the conventional wisdom would have you believe. Most people, when they hear of a large-scale terrorist attack, are probably inclined to believe that Islamic extremists are behind it (and rationally so). She will probably be more so inclined than the average person. I'm not sure that counts as bigotry, but it's debatable.
 
I come from a Scottish traveller family. I don't like it when my people are called"pikeys" or referred to as gangs of theives. It upsets and offends me. But my right to protest against those things ends at the other mans nose. By and large I just ignore it. But if I did resort to violence I would be to blame,I would have made that choice of my own free will. I never have nor will.
In a democracy you can offend others and be offended,you can't however intimidate others to tow your line. Geller is odious, that's a given. But the gunmen are 100% to blame for the violence. This was not done in a whirl of rage. It was coldly planned. They could have stopped the car and said"hey were grown men getting angry over DRAWINGS of a guy who's been dead for 1400yrs,that's just silly let's go home" but they did not,they kept going.
I have said it before someone who gets upset over drawings of a guy who died in the early medieval world are THE extremists,they are already extremists. On another page I made the comparison with Australian aboriginal folk. They have been treated far worse in the last few centuries than any Muslims but they don't wage worldwide terror. They also have a religion, but they don't kill over it. This tells us the fault is with Islam itself,anything else is apologetics.

Quick edit to say plenty of people other than Geller blamed Muslims for the Norway attack before news that it was not filtered down. It was the wrong choice. It was however,whether anyone likes it or not,the rational choice given recent history. Not nice,but that's reality.
 
Last edited:
<snip>

In none of this are her free speech rights attacked or abridged. The major criticism is in her willingness to manipulate affairs to gain a end I think is morally impoverished - the death of two and the risk of death for many more. If there is a right I do not think she has, it is the right to risk the lives of others in service to her cause.

First of all, her free speech rights have been attacked, and they are being abridged. Drawing a cartoon of Muhammad or holding a convention to exhibit cartoons of Muhammad is absolutely an exercise of protected speech. And yet, in order to do that, she not only has to spend tens of thousands of dollars on security, but she has to risk her life as well. Plus, attendance will be muted not because people don't want to hear her speech or take part in it, but because they are frightened by threats of violence.

Second, whatever her "end" was, it was not morally impoverished in my view. She did not trick people into risking their lives, nor did she act negligently. On the contrary, I think the evidence shows that she made sure there was adequate security (perhaps Hillary Clinton could learn a lesson from her).

Third, even if her "end" was two dead jihadists, which I doubt, that was a huge positive for the country. Don't you think those two guys were serious threats? It seems likely that her little "stunt" had the effect of saving lives in the long run. Plus with her acting as a lightning rod for jihadist outrage, it makes all of the rest of us marginally safer. Our transgressions of sharia law, whether accidental or intentional, are less likely to be noticed if the enforcers of sharia law are focused like a laser beam on what that notorious Islamophobe will do next.
 
Wait a second. Exercising your right to free speech doesn't necessarily entail speaking. Not speaking is also an option, so I don't see how doing that is foregoing your right.

I'd have to say choosing not to say something you think is important and something you want to say because you're afraid of being brutalized by death squads isn't quite in the spirit of a constitutionally protected right of free expression.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom