Can a CharlieHebdo-type attack happen in the US?

I can't recall if anyone did a captcha on any missing posts from the Brevik fiasco, only know it was referred to. I'll concede a maybe on that one because she's often accused (even in this thread) of saying things she's quoting or that are from the "comments". But see parenthetical paragraph below.

And the missing posts on the Vehicular Jihad? No. They've been scrubbed. Apparently Geller has a homebrew cowboy server so she can control her words post posting. There are references to it, but those wouldn't be deemed acceptable.

(Of what you can find on her Norway spiels, you're not, shall we say, "impressed" by her rush to not only make judgement but to use her bully pulpit to slander her favorite target in the assumption... "Hey, it's violence; it's got to be Mooslims"? And the commenters? Frothing at the mouth lunatics, all. Everyone sees fit to drop a comment about succumbing to terrorism or how this was all to be expected. All with the assumption that their favorite bogie man done the deed.)


Say what??
 
Bomb-throwing language is a hell of a lot better than actually throwing bombs.

(Not that Geller has actually called for any violence anyway AFAIK)

I've seen a lot of disagreements on this forum but this thread has surely topped them all for weaselly, reprehensible attempts to minimize attempted murder just because the targets had different, politically incorrect, views.

Christ, it's disgusting.

Read the paper I linked to above. It explains the psychology well enough to enlighten you. I think the disgust will evaporate once the issues become clear.
 
Read the paper I linked to above. It explains the psychology well enough to enlighten you. I think the disgust will evaporate once the issues become clear.

The conclusion is sweet...


"By understanding types, origins, and the mode of operation of victims therapists and non-therapists alike will be able to recognize, prevent, and intervene in violent systems, enabling all participants to live better lives. For this to happen, victims must overcome their feelings of helplessness, hopelessness, and low self-esteem. They must not focus on blame, and avoid moral self-righteousness. They have to believe that they have a part in what happens to them and overcome their victim patterns. The healing process should empower them to become conscious contributors to the unfolding of their lives, which can become dignified and meaningful."


ISIS and Geller both need therapy and all will be well :rolleyes:
 
When caught in an error, the rational thing to do is admit it and move on, not to double down.

Tell me, do you understand the different between smoke and odors? I'll explain in case you don't.

Smoke is the product of incomplete combustion (in this case of wood/charcoal and grease from the meat being grilled) and consists of large amounts of microscopic particulate matter, predominantly carbon. This particulate matter can cause significant irritation of lungs, nasal passages, and other mucus membranes. It can also cause irritation of corneal and conjunctival membranes, and minor abrasion of the cornea. In those susceptible, it can also trigger inflammation of lung tissue and corresponding respiratory distress. Given that, objection to being subjected to large amounts of smoke is quite reasonable.

Odors can cause, um... annoyance at having to smell them I guess. In this case, the objection is purely religious, so, unreasonable.

Were you able to understand it that time?


Do you understand the difference between "bothered by" and "bothered by"?
 
Bomb-throwing language is a hell of a lot better than actually throwing bombs.

(Not that Geller has actually called for any violence anyway AFAIK)

I've seen a lot of disagreements on this forum but this thread has surely topped them all for weaselly, reprehensible attempts to minimize attempted murder just because the targets had different, politically incorrect, views.

Christ, it's disgusting.

This.
Whatever happened to "I may not like what you say but I'll defend your right to say it"?

I guess it's changed to "I don't like what you say so when someone tries to shut you up, I'll look the other way"
 
This.
Whatever happened to "I may not like what you say but I'll defend your right to say it"?

I guess it's changed to "I don't like what you say so when someone tries to shut you up, I'll look the other way"

We have to defend Geller's right to say what she says. Otherwise, she would be just as invisible an idiot as the two terrorists were. It's much better to see what her views are.

No one wants her to shut up. I just want her to take responsibility for the things she says and does. You know, like an adult.
 
We have to defend Geller's right to say what she says. Otherwise, she would be just as invisible an idiot as the two terrorists were. It's much better to see what her views are.

No one wants her to shut up. I just want her to take responsibility for the things she says and does. You know, like an adult.
What a blind, selfserving statement
She accepted responsibility by ARRANGING FOR SECURITY at the event. No more needs to be done. You PREPARE for eventuality, that's all you *********** can do short of shutting up.
 
We have to defend Geller's right to say what she says. Otherwise, she would be just as invisible an idiot as the two terrorists were. It's much better to see what her views are.

No one wants her to shut up. I just want her to take responsibility for the things she says and does. You know, like an adult.

This is just trolling for kicks, right?
 
What a blind, selfserving statement
She accepted responsibility by ARRANGING FOR SECURITY at the event. No more needs to be done. You PREPARE for eventuality, that's all you *********** can do short of shutting up.

This is not what I have been reading in this thread. In this thread I have been reading that giving her any responsibility at all is "victim blaming."
 
This is not what I have been reading in this thread. In this thread I have been reading that giving her any responsibility at all is "victim blaming."

At this point it would be helpful if you describe exactly what you mean by "take responsibility." As was noted, she arranged for security. What else is she supposed to do? Admit it was all her fault? Admit that she should restrict herself from free expression of her ideas because it might engender murderous revenge from people who are not under her control?
 
At this point it would be helpful if you describe exactly what you mean by "take responsibility." As was noted, she arranged for security. What else is she supposed to do? Admit it was all her fault? Admit that she should restrict herself from free expression of her ideas because it might engender murderous revenge from people who are not under her control?

The outcome of this event is two dead Jihadists and a wounded security guard - and, I suppose, a bunch of cartoons on her website. These results had antecedents, some of which were proximate causes, some less so.

I have been arguing that when she undertook to hold the event, she could have (and I think likely did) foresee a risk of attack. She did it anyhow. Because of this, she bears some responsibility for the outcome. I've even said that the outcome was a win/win for both sides - she gets to point out how violent Muslims are and a couple of Jihadists get their desire for martyrdom.

In none of this are her free speech rights attacked or abridged. The major criticism is in her willingness to manipulate affairs to gain a end I think is morally impoverished - the death of two and the risk of death for many more. If there is a right I do not think she has, it is the right to risk the lives of others in service to her cause.
 
We have to defend Geller's right to say what she says. Otherwise, she would be just as invisible an idiot as the two terrorists were. It's much better to see what her views are.

No one wants her to shut up. I just want her to take responsibility for the things she says and does. You know, like an adult.

She has arranged a public whipping followed by an abjuration of everything she has ever said critical of Muslims.

That be OK?
 
She has arranged a public whipping followed by an abjuration of everything she has ever said critical of Muslims.

That be OK?

That's not what I've seen. I've seen her on Hannity defending her position. Granted, that show is a kind of virtual flogging, an intellectual punishment.
 
Do you have evidence that the security guard was not aware of the risk? Are security guards really like extras in a movie? Are they just hired to look the part, or are they actually supposed to be trained professionals?

My experiences with run-of-the-mill security guards places them somewhere between the two extremes. Not nearly as much training as, say, police; but more than the average citizen. I'm sure there are better trained security guards out there; but I've never been in a position to encounter one.
 
Those who are having difficulty with the nuances in play are invited to read Rethinking 'Don't Blame the Victim': The Psychology of Victimhood. Although the focus is on interpersonal relationships, I think it does a good job exposing a dynamic in play which is more nuanced than mere labeling.


And, once again, you provide a complete non sequitor. This paper is not particularly focused, and covers two types of victims. The type that were victimized in youth, and grow up seeking victim status because they're comfortable; like women who were abused as children and continuously end up in abusive relationships because they don't understand any other kind. The other is what some of us here would call the "cult of victimhood". Wallowing in victim status; which is a long and ongoing process. The most obvious example is all the "Internet PTSD" folks demanding "trigger warnings" everywhere, instead of getting actual therapy.

It has nothing to do with the subject of people being attacked by religious fanatics for failing to adhere to extremist religious tenets. Trying to apply it to such a situation is stretching to beyond breaking point.

The only way that this paper relates to the subject at hand here is that they both use the word "victim".


You might want to be a little more careful about your cites as well. Not trying to poison the well, because much of what I did see in that paper seems pretty solid; but this is also a guy who advocates for sexual relationships between medical therapists and patients. I'd take anything from him with a fairly large grain of salt unless and until supported by peer review. Not seeing a lot of peer review for this paper on a quick google search; but perhaps you can provide some links.
 
Last edited:
And, once again, you provide a complete non sequitor. This paper is on what some of us here would call the "cult of victimhood". Wallowing in victim status; which is a long and ongoing process. The most obvious example is all the "Internet PTSD" folks demanding "trigger warnings" everywhere.

It has nothing to do with the subject of people being attacked by religious fanatics for failing to adhere to extremist religious tenets.

The only way that this paper relates to the subject at hand here is that they both use the word "victim".

I thought section 4 applied particularly well. It starts this way:
The basic assumption of the legal system is that there is one party in a dispute who is guilty and 100% responsible for the crime, and another party who is totally innocent. While in some cases the responsibility is clear, in most cases the situation is more complex.

The following is an attempt, based partly on Mendelson's (1974) original formulation, to classify victims according to their relative degree of responsibility and power to control or affect situations. These categories also judge the degree of guilt or responsibility, ranging from total innocence/no guilt, to 100% responsibility /total guilt.

In one of the categories, he has an almost perfect match, saying there is an equal responsibility: "Victims who seek, challenge, tease, or entice the perpetrator."
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom