Can a CharlieHebdo-type attack happen in the US?

This is correct as far as it goes. If I know the risks of such a job and take on the job, I am accepting money to take the risk - I have a choice to take the job or not. I do not know whether this is the case or not. But if it is, the guard still doesn't create the situation - Geller does.



The difference revolves around the purpose of Geller's little event. If you think drawing Mohammed serves some function other than to draw the ire of Islamic zealots, then it would be a good parallel. After all, a bank and money transfers are separate activities with separate goals - goals unrelated to getting robbed.

On the other hand, if Geller intends to stir up trouble - and that is the point of the exercise, it serves no other purpose than the one that played out. A demonstration of how dangerous Muslims are (as she might frame it).

No, that wasn't the point of the exercise. The a priori probability of an attack was pretty low. The fact that it happened at all has the FBI scrambling. As I've explained before, the point of the exercise was defiance. It's similar to those "Take Back the Night" rallies by women that started in the 1970s. If Muhammad cartoon drawing becomes a common enough occurrence, then jihadists simply won't have enough resources to create a credible threat. Why do you think that jihadists haven't threatened Google with violence in order to force them to take down the literally tens of thousands of videos on Youtube which blaspheme against Islam? It's because it's completely impractical. Google won't do it, and the jihadists know that Google won't do it and that Google is powerful enough to ignore them. The jihadists can only get their way enforcing their restrictions when there isn't a critical mass of people willing to defy them.
 
Do you have evidence that the security guard was not aware of the risk? Are security guards really like extras in a movie? Are they just hired to look the part, or are they actually supposed to be trained professionals?

I don't know any of this. I haven't seen much reported on the guy. For all I know, he's an undercover operative for ISIS trying to infiltrate Geller's organization.
 
No, that wasn't the point of the exercise. The a priori probability of an attack was pretty low. The fact that it happened at all has the FBI scrambling. As I've explained before, the point of the exercise was defiance. It's similar to those "Take Back the Night" rallies by women that started in the 1970s. If Muhammad cartoon drawing becomes a common enough occurrence, then jihadists simply won't have enough resources to create a credible threat. Why do you think that jihadists haven't threatened Google with violence in order to force them to take down the literally tens of thousands of videos on Youtube which blaspheme against Islam? It's because it's completely impractical. Google won't do it, and the jihadists know that Google won't do it and that Google is powerful enough to ignore them. The jihadists can only get their way enforcing their restrictions when there isn't a critical mass of people willing to defy them.

If that's so, then it is not much like a security guard moving money for a bank at all, is it? Unless we suppose banks are out to defy robbers?
 
You do realize that she cleanses her site after her particularly stupid posturing turns out to be based on her assumptions of evil on the parts of anyone who is a Muslim? She spent a day attributing the Norway massacres to Muslims. She accused a heart attack victim of "vehicular jihad" because after his heart attack his car drove into a mall. Both of those were ethnically cleansed from her site and the only remaining posts are about what a poor victim she's become because some crazy person in Norway loved her writings and spoke of her as one of the people who most influenced his "education".

I actually can still find her posts during the Norway massacre. Do you have evidence that they've been scrubbed? I can't find the vehicular jihad heart attack post, but then again I can't find it anywhere. Can you link to it?
 
I don't know any of this. I haven't seen much reported on the guy. For all I know, he's an undercover operative for ISIS trying to infiltrate Geller's organization.

I tend to go with the odds in situations like this. In fact, I tend to go with the odds in any situation.
 
If that's so, then it is not much like a security guard moving money for a bank at all, is it? Unless we suppose banks are out to defy robbers?

It wasn't my analogy. I think her cartoon contest was more like a protest or a demonstration. In fact, that's exactly what it was.
 
The concept of "victim blaming" is itself deeply flawed. It requires we frame the incident in terms of victim and victimizer, drawing the lines carefully to poison the well, without allowing for the nuances required. It's a bad model, a caricature, and a misleading assignment of roles. In short, the phrase only serves to expose poor thinking.

It's not flawed in the slightest. There's no missing "nuance". Religious extremists are attempting to silence blasphemers through violent intimidation. Period.
 
Nope. That's just you making crap up. Nobody is sanctioning murder in this thread, and Geller's spittle flecked rants are nothing but thinly disguised (if that) incitements for the same sort of extremist behavior.

It has already been shown that she will duck and cover just as soon as some poor nutcase is driven over the edge by her style of raging bigotry. I see no difference between the two.

Some poor nutcase driven over the edge? You see no difference between offensive speech and the kind of sadistic scumbags who wish to shut people up by killing and maiming them? Are fathers who bury their daughters alive just some poor nutcases driven over the edge by offensively whorish fashion style? Are christian terrorists who bomb abortion clinics just poor nut cases driven over the edge by infanticide?
 
Why are you blaming Geller for the injury to an "innocent" security guard. Surely the security guard is responsible for the consequences of his own actions. He understood the risks and he willingly assumed them in exchange for money. Or do you normally show so much concern for mercenaries?

I agree. This so called "security guard" needs to assume responsibility for what happened.
 
It's not flawed in the slightest. There's no missing "nuance". Religious extremists are attempting to silence blasphemers through violent intimidation. Period.

Well then, I suppose the pro-radical side would say the religious extremists are being victimized by the blasphemers? :D

As Curly, from the Three Stooges put it:

 
Last edited:
Well then, I suppose the pro-radical side would say the religious extremists are being victimized by the blasphemers? :D

Yes, that's exactly what the pro-radical folks are saying. When they're not busy saying that rapists are being victimized by sluts, and clinic bombers are being victimized by women seeking abortions.
 
Yes, that's exactly what the pro-radical folks are saying. When they're not busy saying that rapists are being victimized by sluts, and clinic bombers are being victimized by women seeking abortions.

Which makes the word suspiciously like the kind of bomb-throwing language that doesn't help discourse much. I think Geller uses the same technique when she talks about the "Islamization" of America.
 
Which makes the word suspiciously like the kind of bomb-throwing language that doesn't help discourse much. I think Geller uses the same technique when she talks about the "Islamization" of America.

Except she's not actually shooting, bombing, suffocating, and raping. Which is sorta the entire point.
 
Except she's not actually shooting, bombing, suffocating, and raping. Which is sorta the entire point.

No, the point was that identifying one party as the sole victim then absolves that party of any responsibility for their actions. It's a weasel move, by way of language.

She's not shooting, bombing, suffocating, and raping anyone. Is she then innocent, or are there other things on the menu worth pointing out? Perhaps not, perhaps the existence of even worse people in the world gives her a pass. Except those even worse people are now dead. They won't be bothering us anymore. Geller, however, will.

What is it about her victimhood that excuses her from any criticism? Is the concept so narrow that she cannot simultaneously be a victim in one sense and a victimizer in another? Or would that add too much depth?

Now that she has her own Fatwah, I expect she will always have the trump card of victimhood to play. The enemy of my enemy is my friend, after all.
 
Last edited:
Those who are having difficulty with the nuances in play are invited to read Rethinking 'Don't Blame the Victim': The Psychology of Victimhood. Although the focus is on interpersonal relationships, I think it does a good job exposing a dynamic in play which is more nuanced than mere labeling.

Traditionally, two main approaches have dominated the way we look at victimization in the modern West. In the first approach, the finger points the blame at the victim (Brownmiller, 1975; Ryan, 1971; Sundberg, Barbaree, & Marshall, 1991; Walker, 1979). This may be a battered wife, a woman who was raped, a person of color, or an economically disadvantaged person. The second approach views men as solely responsible for violence, whether as soldiers on the battlefields, politicians in government, or husbands in domestic violence (Hughes, 1993; Keen, 1991; Zur & Glendinnning, 1987). These two approaches of blame have not only failed to resolve the violence and suffering but in fact, as this paper explains, have tended to perpetuate and exacerbate them.

This investigation attempts to describe the complex relationship between the diverse and complementary roles that perpetrators and victims in general and men and women in particular assume in the dynamics of violence. It does not seek to blame, but rather to apply systems analysis to increase our understanding of the dynamics and origins of victimhood and the different types of victims. It concentrates on adult victims and on patterns of victimhood established early in life, rather than on the effects of a single trauma. It focuses on intimate violence and not on random incidents among parties who have no past relationship to each other.

Full paper here: http://www.zurinstitute.com/victimhood.html

Those who aren't interested in the subject other than as a "gotcha game," shouldn't bother.
 
Last edited:
Ironic though isn't it? I mean quadraginta implies that I'm being dishonest, and when I point out that he misread my post, he not only fails to apologize, he doubles down on his ridiculous allegation of dishonesty.

You are no longer taken seriously. Your Geller Apologetics act places you beyond reach, so it doesn't surprise me that with your political blinders on you cannot see that the "Free Speech!!" proponents are assembling straw man arguments so they can claim debate victory on the internet. Any poster daring to point out the log on your collective eye - that Geller is an unapologetic bigot - immediately gets asked why they support terrorism or are against free speech.

Since that's not what anyone is arguing, it's pretty obvious that you can't have a genuine discussion in this thread (nor any when the words "Muslim" and "Rational" are used in the same post, let alone same paragraph or sentence).

Let's try this again:
Geller is a bigot, supported by bigots, selling bigotry to bigots and stirring up bigots wherever possible.1The Islamic Fundie Psychos were/are Islamic Fundie Psycho Murderers. 2
It is possible to dislike either or both groups for different reasons. Geller's bigotry is not ameliorated by "Oh, yeah, well the bad guys were terrorists" and the terrorists' terrorism is not given a pass "Because she's a bigot!"

1. This does not mean that anyone who supports Geller's right to free speech is a bigot nor a supporter of bigots.... only the "rights" of everyone, and that unfortunately may include bigots
2. This does not mean that anyone who looks to find causes or to understand the mindset or mentality of the perps is an apologist for terrorism.

Homework: Explain to us mere high school dropouts how Geller's support of the murderous war criminal from Serbia is "reasonable", as you seem to view her concerns.
 
Which makes the word suspiciously like the kind of bomb-throwing language that doesn't help discourse much.

Bomb-throwing language is a hell of a lot better than actually throwing bombs.

(Not that Geller has actually called for any violence anyway AFAIK)

I've seen a lot of disagreements on this forum but this thread has surely topped them all for weaselly, reprehensible attempts to minimize attempted murder just because the targets had different, politically incorrect, views.

Christ, it's disgusting.
 
I actually can still find her posts during the Norway massacre. Do you have evidence that they've been scrubbed? I can't find the vehicular jihad heart attack post, but then again I can't find it anywhere. Can you link to it?

I can't recall if anyone did a captcha on any missing posts from the Brevik fiasco, only know it was referred to. I'll concede a maybe on that one because she's often accused (even in this thread) of saying things she's quoting or that are from the "comments". But see parenthetical paragraph below.

And the missing posts on the Vehicular Jihad? No. They've been scrubbed. Apparently Geller has a homebrew cowboy server so she can control her words post posting. There are references to it, but those wouldn't be deemed acceptable.

(Of what you can find on her Norway spiels, you're not, shall we say, "impressed" by her rush to not only make judgement but to use her bully pulpit to slander her favorite target in the assumption... "Hey, it's violence; it's got to be Mooslims"? And the commenters? Frothing at the mouth lunatics, all. Everyone sees fit to drop a comment about succumbing to terrorism or how this was all to be expected. All with the assumption that their favorite bogie man done the deed.)
 
Oh, and in my drive to save on straw (Won't Somebody Think of the Endangered North American Scarecrow!!), let me state that I cannot pin "responsibility", much less "blame" on the security guard.

He may moonlight for a security company that was hired for this detail and have been told, "Oh, a few hours on Sunday. Some group having a cartoon contest." He could have been assigned the job thinking it was a Texas State Guard type gig... managing the parking lot. It was a paid gig. Whomever employed him was responsible for detailing the assignment and assessing him of the situation. We don't know if that happened or not. To me, he's the unfortunate person in the right place at the wrong time. Apparently it was regular cops who shot the perps, but this dude evidently took his job seriously enough that he attempted to intervene.

I'm divided (yeah, I'm a conflicted person) on the responsibility of Geller and Associates. Are they playing for reaction? Yes. Are they playing to get people killed? I don't actually believe that. I think they got what many see as the inevitable outcome (some day) of their bigoted harangues. But I honestly feel (purely subjective) that they got more than they ever expected.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom