Can a CharlieHebdo-type attack happen in the US?

What! In what sane world is a child murderer not responsible for there actions. I don't believe what you wrote. If someone carries out a child murder they bear full responsibility, I can't understand why anyone would think different.

Actually, I would be in a highly-qualified agreement with that view. If you knowing take a child anywhere you are aware that you have reason to believe there is a credible high risk of harm to the child, then you are partially responsible. Adults are capable of making informed decisions regarding their own well-being; children are not, and rely heavily on adult decision-making.
 
If the good Muslims are taking offense at cartoons how can you say they are not holding the same corrupt set of values as the killers?

There's a huge difference in being offended and acting out on that offense. The Muslim population in the area decided that the offense was not worth acting on, and was best ignored. Sounds like a reasonable set of values to me.
 
Look again.

They are complaining about the smoke from the animal. Just like the other neighbor.

Nope, you fail at reading comprehension. I only used "smoke" for the first example. The word for the second is "smell". I realize the fact that they contain some of the same letters, and are the same length, may be profoundly confusing; but with a bit of effort I'm sure you'll eventually be able to tell them apart.
 
Nope, you fail at reading comprehension. I only used "smoke" for the first example. The word for the second is "smell". I realize the fact that they contain some of the same letters, and are the same length, may be profoundly confusing; but with a bit of effort I'm sure you'll eventually be able to tell them apart.


Interesting evasion. Weak, but still creative.

Are you saying that in the first example there was smoke but no smell, and in the second there was smell but no smoke?

Can you explain how that would be relevant to the issue of bothering the neighbor in both cases? It's still 'bothering the neighbor', is it not?
 
Interesting evasion. Weak, but still creative.

Are you saying that in the first example there was smoke but no smell, and in the second there was smell but no smoke?

Can you explain how that would be relevant to the issue of bothering the neighbor in both cases? It's still 'bothering the neighbor', is it not?

When caught in an error, the rational thing to do is admit it and move on, not to double down.

Tell me, do you understand the different between smoke and odors? I'll explain in case you don't.

Smoke is the product of incomplete combustion (in this case of wood/charcoal and grease from the meat being grilled) and consists of large amounts of microscopic particulate matter, predominantly carbon. This particulate matter can cause significant irritation of lungs, nasal passages, and other mucus membranes. It can also cause irritation of corneal and conjunctival membranes, and minor abrasion of the cornea. In those susceptible, it can also trigger inflammation of lung tissue and corresponding respiratory distress. Given that, objection to being subjected to large amounts of smoke is quite reasonable.

Odors can cause, um... annoyance at having to smell them I guess. In this case, the objection is purely religious, so, unreasonable.

Were you able to understand it that time?
 
Last edited:
If the good Muslims are taking offense at cartoons how can you say they are not holding the same corrupt set of values as the killers?

I don't know. How can you? Apparently, you're trying to establish a straw man defense. Taking offense /= assassinate/murder. One subset is people who take offense. The other subset is people who murder or assassinate(but murder is more accurate). There may be some overlap. I'm sure Bundy took offense at certain things. That doesn't mean that everyone who took offense at those same things was a mass murder or supported mass murderers.
 
Why are you blaming Geller for the injury to an "innocent" security guard. Surely the security guard is responsible for the consequences of his own actions. He understood the risks and he willingly assumed them in exchange for money. Or do you normally show so much concern for mercenaries?

Do we have evidence that the security guard was aware of the risk? Certainly Geller was - it's her thesis of choice: that Muslims are out to kill free speech by way of attacks on cartoonists and others who criticize Islam.
 
Do we have evidence that the security guard was aware of the risk? Certainly Geller was - it's her thesis of choice: that Muslims are out to kill free speech by way of attacks on cartoonists and others who criticize Islam.

Believe it or not, Most people in Texas can read. Especially people who work for School Districts, even as Security Guards.
And, if there is a person in Texas who is unaware of the threat that Islam poses to all that is right and holyTM, they have managed not to read any local newspaper, or watch to any television, or listen to the radio
 
Even ignoring how that is victim blaming, how is Geller any more responsible than the security guard himself? Or are you trying to make the case that he didn't know the risks involved in working security at such an event?

This is correct as far as it goes. If I know the risks of such a job and take on the job, I am accepting money to take the risk - I have a choice to take the job or not. I do not know whether this is the case or not. But if it is, the guard still doesn't create the situation - Geller does.

Its not remotely parallel to entrapment. Maybe its parallel to a bank being robbed. If they hadn't kept large amounts of cash around the robber's would never have targeted them, and the security guard on shift would not have been wounded.

The difference revolves around the purpose of Geller's little event. If you think drawing Mohammed serves some function other than to draw the ire of Islamic zealots, then it would be a good parallel. After all, a bank and money transfers are separate activities with separate goals - goals unrelated to getting robbed.

On the other hand, if Geller intends to stir up trouble - and that is the point of the exercise, it serves no other purpose than the one that played out. A demonstration of how dangerous Muslims are (as she might frame it).
 
So far every time I have looked at one of them it looks like her opponents are building elaborate straw men if not outright lying.

You do realize that she cleanses her site after her particularly stupid posturing turns out to be based on her assumptions of evil on the parts of anyone who is a Muslim? She spent a day attributing the Norway massacres to Muslims. She accused a heart attack victim of "vehicular jihad" because after his heart attack his car drove into a mall. Both of those were ethnically cleansed from her site and the only remaining posts are about what a poor victim she's become because some crazy person in Norway loved her writings and spoke of her as one of the people who most influenced his "education".
 
I'll take Rhetorical Questions for four hundred, Alex.

Ironic though isn't it? I mean quadraginta implies that I'm being dishonest, and when I point out that he misread my post, he not only fails to apologize, he doubles down on his ridiculous allegation of dishonesty.
 
Do we have evidence that the security guard was aware of the risk? Certainly Geller was - it's her thesis of choice: that Muslims are out to kill free speech by way of attacks on cartoonists and others who criticize Islam.

Do you have evidence that the security guard was not aware of the risk? Are security guards really like extras in a movie? Are they just hired to look the part, or are they actually supposed to be trained professionals?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom