Can a CharlieHebdo-type attack happen in the US?

Depends. What sort of responses to her are those critics suggesting?

I don't think disagreeing and pointing out her fallacies and reprehensible accusations counts as inciting extremist behavior against her.

Agreed, and I don't think she has done anything to incite extremist behavior against Muslims. I haven't even seen a good example of her alleged bigotry. She does strike me as a little shrill and a little meshuggah. But so far I think her views are defensible.
 
Are you for real? Gunmen turned up to try and kill the attendees and you are quibbling over whether one of the more prominent attendees could count as the victim of attempted murder?


"Miss, I'm not blaming you for anything but can we focus on how short your skirt was?"

Not only that, but she now as a fatwa on her head (an even larger or harsher or more Islamic one than she had had before). Having never had a fatwa directed against me, I can't say for sure if it is an unpleasant thing, but Salman Rushdie has said that it's rather inconvenient.
 
Nope. That's just you making crap up. Nobody is sanctioning murder in this thread, and Geller's spittle flecked rants are nothing but thinly disguised (if that) incitements for the same sort of extremist behavior.

It has already been shown that she will duck and cover just as soon as some poor nutcase is driven over the edge by her style of raging bigotry. I see no difference between the two.

BS. There's nothing "poor" about religious terrorists willing to drive across two time zones to murder strangers for drawing cartoons. This is about as close to excusing them for what they attempted to do as I've seen on this thread.

If you can't see the difference between drawing cartoons and attempting to fire assault rifles into a crowd, well, that's deserving of pity.
 
You should get your arguments in order. It was dishonest regardless of whether it was directed toward Marsplot or me.

:confused: Marplots clearly assigned some blame to Geller for the security guard's injury, not only in the post to which I was responding, but throughout this thread. He has consistently made the point that she is at least partly responsible for the reasonably foreseeable consequences of her actions. I'm just wondering why he doesn't apply the same reasoning to the security guard, whom he labeled "innocent."

Logically, the order of responsibility for the security guard's injury runs as follows: Islamic extremist attackers > ISIS recruiters > security guard > Geller. Marplots has only focused on the attackers and Geller. Arguably, even Barack Obama bears greater responsibility for the security guard's injury than Geller does. Domestic terrorism falls under the purview of the Department of Justice and the Department of Homeland Security, and both are under his jurisdiction.
 
The concept of "victim blaming" is itself deeply flawed. It requires we frame the incident in terms of victim and victimizer, drawing the lines carefully to poison the well, without allowing for the nuances required. It's a bad model, a caricature, and a misleading assignment of roles. In short, the phrase only serves to expose poor thinking.


Driving across two states to seek out an 'insult' and attempt to murder people..... That's about as much nuance as I can stomach. But that's me, cartoons/bullets, black/white, I probably need re-education on how drawing a *********** picture makes you a legitimate target.
 
Nope. That's just you making crap up. Nobody is sanctioning murder in this thread, and Geller's spittle flecked rants are nothing but thinly disguised (if that) incitements for the same sort of extremist behavior.

It has already been shown that she will duck and cover just as soon as some poor nutcase is driven over the edge by her style of raging bigotry. I see no difference between the two.

There isn't an honest argument among the bunch of you, is there?

Perhaps you could honestly explain how those two bolded statements are not equivocation.

If both parties are equivalent, there's been overwhelmingly more scorn heaped upon the non-violent of the two. I wonder why that is.

You want honesty? Here's some of the brutal variety - I think if Geller and others were actually shot and killed, there'd be crocodile tears aplenty from the bunch of you.
 

Yup. I had already read that piece. Her treatment of Jasser sounds more like a falling out between friends. She had praised him in the past. Like I said, she strikes me as a bit paranoid and vengeful, and I don't doubt she's difficult to get along with. Linking to Charles Johnson's blog doesn't do the author any credit, by the way. I think he's even loonier and more paranoid than Geller.
 
Perhaps you could honestly explain how those two bolded statements are not equivocation.

If both parties are equivalent, there's been overwhelmingly more scorn heaped upon the non-violent of the two. I wonder why that is.

You want honesty? Here's some of the brutal variety - I think if Geller and others were actually shot and killed, there'd be crocodile tears aplenty from the bunch of you.

I despise Geller as a garden variety bigot, but drawing a moral equvilelency....and let's make no mistake, that is what is happening with some posters here....between Geller and the shooters....is just plain insane.

On the other hand I find the attempts of some people here to prove that Geller is not a bigot to be pretty damn silly.
 
Last edited:
My "objection" is to none of those things. My objection is to Geller (and her organization) getting a free pass when their actions resulted in the injury of an innocent security guard.

The argument you quoted was about whether or not her actions were necessary to incite some subset of violent extremists to take action against her, or whether they would have attacked in any case, regardless of Geller's actions.

The scenario parallels the logic of entrapment. To what extent does providing the opportunity for a crime lead to that crime, and to what extent would the crime have occurred anyhow?

Even ignoring how that is victim blaming, how is Geller any more responsible than the security guard himself? Or are you trying to make the case that he didn't know the risks involved in working security at such an event?

Its not remotely parallel to entrapment. Maybe its parallel to a bank being robbed. If they hadn't kept large amounts of cash around the robber's would never have targeted them, and the security guard on shift would not have been wounded.
 
I despise Geller as a garden variety bigot, but drawing a moral equvilelency....and let's make no mistake, that is what is happening with some posters here....between Geller and the shooters....is just plain insane.

On the other hand I find the attempts of some people here to prove that Geller is not a bigot to be pretty damn silly.

Yes. This event taken in isolation is no proof of bigotry IMO. But given the myriad of other quotes attributed to her, there is no question she is a rather bigoted individual.
 
So brave.
Do you know how to draw, even just stick figures? Do you hate bigotry? Then I hope you enter my “Draw your favorite Islamphobe contest” that I announced on my show this past Saturday. You can draw a cartoon or image of any person or group that is actively stoking flames of hate towards Muslims. It can be Pam Geller or an elected official like Republican Oklahoma State Rep. John Bennett who has called for cutting American Muslims out of our country like a “cancer” to media figures (I’m looking at you Fox News) or ISIS, which is truly one of the most anti-Muslim groups out there.http://blog.siriusxm.com/2015/05/11/dean-obeidallah-show-draw-your-favorite-islamophobe-contest/

It's nice he included ISIS in there I guess.
 
Yes. This event taken in isolation is no proof of bigotry IMO. But given the myriad of other quotes attributed to her, there is no question she is a rather bigoted individual.

So far every time I have looked at one of them it looks like her opponents are building elaborate straw men if not outright lying.
 
Perhaps you could honestly explain how those two bolded statements are not equivocation.


Largely because you seem to have no clue what the term "equivocation" actually means. (Hint; Aside from sharing a common Latin root it is unrelated to the term "equivalent".)

If both parties are equivalent, there's been overwhelmingly more scorn heaped upon the non-violent of the two. I wonder why that is.


I wonder if it is. How would you propose we quantify that.

It seems to me that the largest helping of "scorn" is coming from the group here that has to rely on that as a debating tool because aside from making crap up about what other people are saying they have nothing else to contribute.

You want honesty? Here's some of the brutal variety - I think if Geller and others were actually shot and killed, there'd be crocodile tears aplenty from the bunch of you.


You've outdone yourself. Prescient straw-manning.

I guess that saves time.
 
I despise Geller as a garden variety bigot, but drawing a moral equvilelency....and let's make no mistake, that is what is happening with some posters here....between Geller and the shooters....is just plain insane.

<snip>


That's like a Whack-a-Mole. Can't keep it down.

You want to be the one who finally provides some examples of this claim.

No one else seems to be able to.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom