Can a CharlieHebdo-type attack happen in the US?

Yes, she's a hypocritical bag of racist garbage.


Sure, but she's our hypocritical bag of racist garbage. White, allegedly Christian, and By-god Conservative™ racist garbage. That makes it okay.

It's the brown, rag-headed, hypocritical bags of racist garbage that believe in weird, un-Christian stuff that are the only ones we have to watch out for.

Surely you can see the difference.
 
The concept of "victim blaming" is itself deeply flawed. It requires we frame the incident in terms of victim and victimizer, drawing the lines carefully to poison the well, without allowing for the nuances required. It's a bad model, a caricature, and a misleading assignment of roles. In short, the phrase only serves to expose poor thinking.

She's the victim of attempted murder.

But that seems to be OK by some posters, just as long as the victim is on the "opposing side".

There is no victim according to marplots.
 
Yup, bad reading comprehension it is. The person in luchog's second hypothetical isn't complaining about the smoke, they're complaining that an unclean animal is being cooked.


Look again.

They are complaining about the smoke from the animal. Just like the other neighbor.

The reason they are bothered by it has nothing to do with whether the guy barbecuing is a dick or not.

The guy is making smoke. The neighbor is bothered by the smoke. The neighbor could be a vegetarian, or a COPD patient. There are all sorts of reasons the neighbor could be bothered.

Why is the guy being a dick for bothering one neighbor, but not a different one? What makes the reason the neighbor is bothered some sort of exonerating condition?
 
Sure, but she's our hypocritical bag of racist garbage. White, allegedly Christian, and By-god Conservative™ racist garbage. That makes it okay.

It's the brown, rag-headed, hypocritical bags of racist garbage that believe in weird, un-Christian stuff that are the only ones we have to watch out for.

Surely you can see the difference.

It's pretty clear to me: she wasn't trying to murder someone for drawing a cartoon.
 
Sure, but she's our hypocritical bag of racist garbage. White, allegedly Christian, and By-god Conservative™ racist garbage. That makes it okay.

It's the brown, rag-headed, hypocritical bags of racist garbage that believe in weird, un-Christian stuff that are the only ones we have to watch out for.

Surely you can see the difference.

difference = speech versus murder
 
She's the victim of attempted murder.


You know ... for a fact ... that Geller herself was the specific target?

But that seems to be OK by some posters, just as long as the victim is on the "opposing side".


People keep saying this here, and they continue to be asked to provide examples of those posters.

So far none have done so.

Can you provide examples? Will you?

Or are you just making stuff up, like all the others?

If you don't have a real argument then lying about one isn't the best alternative, you know. Even if it does seem to be popular with the racist crowd.
 
You know ... for a fact ... that Geller herself was the specific target?

Everyone there was a target. That includes Geller.

People keep saying this here, and they continue to be asked to provide examples of those posters.

So far none have done so.

Can you provide examples? Will you?

Or are you just making stuff up, like all the others?

If you don't have a real argument then lying about one isn't the best alternative, you know. Even if it does seem to be popular with the racist crowd.

Well, someone appeared to think that our focus shouldn't be on gunmen turning up to murder folks engaged in speech, nor should we focus on attempted murder. No, our focus should be on the "White, allegedly Christian, and By-god Conservative™ racist garbage."
 
difference = speech versus murder


Nope. That's just you making crap up. Nobody is sanctioning murder in this thread, and Geller's spittle flecked rants are nothing but thinly disguised (if that) incitements for the same sort of extremist behavior.

It has already been shown that she will duck and cover just as soon as some poor nutcase is driven over the edge by her style of raging bigotry. I see no difference between the two.
 
Nope. That's just you making crap up. Nobody is sanctioning murder in this thread, and Geller's spittle flecked rants are nothing but thinly disguised (if that) incitements for the same sort of extremist behavior.

It has already been shown that she will duck and cover just as soon as some poor nutcase is driven over the edge by her style of raging bigotry. I see no difference between the two.

They wanted to kill her because she was drawing Mohammad, not because she was saying mean, racist, correct, or incorrect things about their religion.
 
My "objection" is to none of those things. My objection is to Geller (and her organization) getting a free pass when their actions resulted in the injury of an innocent security guard.

The argument you quoted was about whether or not her actions were necessary to incite some subset of violent extremists to take action against her, or whether they would have attacked in any case, regardless of Geller's actions.

The scenario parallels the logic of entrapment. To what extent does providing the opportunity for a crime lead to that crime, and to what extent would the crime have occurred anyhow?

Why are you blaming Geller for the injury to an "innocent" security guard. Surely the security guard is responsible for the consequences of his own actions. He understood the risks and he willingly assumed them in exchange for money. Or do you normally show so much concern for mercenaries?
 
Everyone there was a target. That includes Geller.



Well, someone appeared to think that our focus shouldn't be on gunmen turning up to murder folks engaged in speech, nor should we focus on attempted murder. No, our focus should be on the "White, allegedly Christian, and By-god Conservative™ racist garbage."

Two step process to identifying the "One True Victim"(tm):
1. Identify which party has the most privilege.
2. Blame that party. The other party is the victim.
 
Nope. That's just you making crap up. Nobody is sanctioning murder in this thread, and Geller's spittle flecked rants are nothing but thinly disguised (if that) incitements for the same sort of extremist behavior.

It has already been shown that she will duck and cover just as soon as some poor nutcase is driven over the edge by her style of raging bigotry. I see no difference between the two.

If Geller is inciting extremist behavior against Muslims by speaking out against Islamic extremism, antisemitism and misogyny does that also mean that her critics are inciting extremist behavior against her by speaking out against her alleged extremism, Islamophobia, and bigotry?
 
If Geller is inciting extremist behavior against Muslims by speaking out against Islamic extremism, antisemitism and misogyny does that also mean that her critics are inciting extremist behavior against her by speaking out against her alleged extremism, Islamophobia, and bigotry?

Nah, she doesn't murder her critics, so we can all criticize her with a clean conscience.
 
Giz; said:
Well, someone appeared to think that our focus shouldn't be on gunmen turning up to murder folks


So I guess your answer is "No", you won't provide any examples.

Responding by offering up an entirely different class of imaginary posters isn't very clever.

engaged in speech, nor should we focus on attempted murder. No, our focus should be on the "White, allegedly Christian, and By-god Conservative™ racist garbage."

Who said that? What "focus"?

More imaginary arguments against imaginary people?

You aren't very good at honest arguments, are you?
 
Why are you blaming Geller for the injury to an "innocent" security guard. Surely the security guard is responsible for the consequences of his own actions. He understood the risks and he willingly assumed them in exchange for money. Or do you normally show so much concern for mercenaries?


I wasn't "blaming Geller" for anything. I was wondering about the validity of her victim status.

Can't any of you engage in honest discussion?
 
If Geller is inciting extremist behavior against Muslims by speaking out against Islamic extremism, antisemitism and misogyny does that also mean that her critics are inciting extremist behavior against her by speaking out against her alleged extremism, Islamophobia, and bigotry?


Depends. What sort of responses to her are those critics suggesting?

I don't think disagreeing and pointing out her fallacies and reprehensible accusations counts as inciting extremist behavior against her.
 
I wasn't "blaming Geller" for anything. I was wondering about the validity of her victim status.

Can't any of you engage in honest discussion?

Are you for real? Gunmen turned up to try and kill the attendees and you are quibbling over whether one of the more prominent attendees could count as the victim of attempted murder?


"Miss, I'm not blaming you for anything but can we focus on how short your skirt was?"
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom