Can a CharlieHebdo-type attack happen in the US?

Well she sure seems to be inferring the proper response is to ban them, which she then says can't happen.

The appropriate word is "implying" not "inferring." And, no, your inference is going way too far.

As for your other 11 links to alleged examples of her bigotry, 6 of them are audio files of talk shows where she is interviewed. I'm not going to listen to the whole talk show to find out if your characterization is correct (especially as I have been burned by this before). One of the other 5 links has to do with the so-called "no-go" zones in Europe. I don't know if she is simply wrong here, guilty of exaggeration, or speaking the truth. I suspect that it's a mixture of truth and exaggeration.

As for the other stuff, she uses hyperbolic rhetoric at times, but I don't see any actual bigotry. I actually agree with her on the three links related to Obama, although, once again, I would be more measured in my criticism. I do feel that Obama has been pandering to Islamic sensibilities, and it strikes me as counterproductive and even patronizing. I disagree with Geller in that I think Obama is doing it with the best of intentions. I just think, as a strategy, it's ridiculously naive.
 
No goalposts have moved. You're just squinting too hard. Encouraging people to break the law is inciting an action to harm others.


No. It isn't. It is possible that it might be, but that doesn't mean it always must be.

Try again.

What you want is "fighting words" which are separate from incitement.


No, that isn't what "I want". Maybe it is what you want, but I am quite certain about my intent.

Passing out leaflets isn't "fighting words". In the particular case in question it might be termed 'encouraging civil disobedience', but that is a fundamental and time honored tradition in this country. As is the actual practice.

Some of the 'Founding Fathers" our conservatives are so eager to use as an authority even suggested that civil disobedience was an obligation and not merely a privilege.

I tend to concur with that assessment.
 
Thank you,not drawing a dead guy just because some people go in the huff,is giving in to terrorism. That being said-as you point out-most folk,me included,have never drawn nutty mo and have no desire to do so.
These people want us dead anyway. The very fact that we are rational human beings is what offends them. They ALREADY want us dead. They don't make a secret of this,indeed they scream it from the rooftops. You can't provoke someone like that. They have already made up there minds to kill.
You can however satirize and mock them,showing them up for the sickos they are.

She wasn't just offending the two killers who arrived though, the cartoons offend a broad swath of Muslims. So if these two were going to kill anyhow, what's the point of offending those other, milder folks? Or, do we hold with Geller, that there are no "good" Muslims at all?
 
She wasn't just offending the two killers who arrived though, the cartoons offend a broad swath of Muslims. So if these two were going to kill anyhow, what's the point of offending those other, milder folks? Or, do we hold with Geller, that there are no "good" Muslims at all?

Why do you care about offending moderate muslims? I mean, they won't shoot you, so it's all good right?

Or do you object to "life of brian", "piss christ", "book of mormon", "jerry springer the opera" etc being made?

I'm happy when my fellow citizens feel free to criticise.
 
She wasn't just offending the two killers who arrived though, the cartoons offend a broad swath of Muslims. So if these two were going to kill anyhow, what's the point of offending those other, milder folks? Or, do we hold with Geller, that there are no "good" Muslims at all?

Seems like you agree with her since you say "the cartoons offend a broad swath of Muslims".

So which is it are the cartoon killers an extreme fringe or do the cartoons offend a broad swath of Muslims.
 
Seems like you agree with her since you say "the cartoons offend a broad swath of Muslims".

So which is it are the cartoon killers an extreme fringe or do the cartoons offend a broad swath of Muslims.

It's both.
Nuts are nuts. But religious people who are peacefully offended by something are not the same as religious people who are offended by something and kill about it.
 
Seems like you agree with her since you say "the cartoons offend a broad swath of Muslims".

So which is it are the cartoon killers an extreme fringe or do the cartoons offend a broad swath of Muslims.

Seems like you're making no sense. These are not mutually exclusive options. The killers can very readily be seen to be vile proponents of a corrupt set of values and the cartoons can still offend Muslims who don't hold that view. Or is your definition of a "good Muslim" one who doesn't take offense? I think that's bordering on "know their place".
 
Why do you care about offending moderate muslims? I mean, they won't shoot you, so it's all good right?

Or do you object to "life of brian", "piss christ", "book of mormon", "jerry springer the opera" etc being made?

I'm happy when my fellow citizens feel free to criticise.

My "objection" is to none of those things. My objection is to Geller (and her organization) getting a free pass when their actions resulted in the injury of an innocent security guard.

The argument you quoted was about whether or not her actions were necessary to incite some subset of violent extremists to take action against her, or whether they would have attacked in any case, regardless of Geller's actions.

The scenario parallels the logic of entrapment. To what extent does providing the opportunity for a crime lead to that crime, and to what extent would the crime have occurred anyhow?
 
Seems like you're making no sense. These are not mutually exclusive options. The killers can very readily be seen to be vile proponents of a corrupt set of values and the cartoons can still offend Muslims who don't hold that view. Or is your definition of a "good Muslim" one who doesn't take offense? I think that's bordering on "know their place".

If the good Muslims are taking offense at cartoons how can you say they are not holding the same corrupt set of values as the killers?
 
My "objection" is to none of those things. My objection is to Geller (and her organization) getting a free pass when their actions resulted in the injury of an innocent security guard.
The argument you quoted was about whether or not her actions were necessary to incite some subset of violent extremists to take action against her, or whether they would have attacked in any case, regardless of Geller's actions.

The scenario parallels the logic of entrapment. To what extent does providing the opportunity for a crime lead to that crime, and to what extent would the crime have occurred anyhow?

Geller had guns?

Or is this the height of victim blaming?
 
My "objection" is to none of those things. My objection is to Geller (and her organization) getting a free pass when their actions resulted in the injury of an innocent security guard.

The argument you quoted was about whether or not her actions were necessary to incite some subset of violent extremists to take action against her, or whether they would have attacked in any case, regardless of Geller's actions.

The scenario parallels the logic of entrapment. To what extent does providing the opportunity for a crime lead to that crime, and to what extent would the crime have occurred anyhow?


So, Geller's perfectly legal and protected free expression resulted in injury to a security guard? I don't buy it. The perpetrators of the violent assault caused that. Geller, vicious bigot though she be, did not cause those people to do what they did. Their violent attempt to deny us all our freedom of expression caused it.
 
Geller had guns?

Or is this the height of victim blaming?

Victim blaming. Geller (or the staff she was working with) prepared for the event as a reasonable person would given the threats they were facing. There's no other reasonable course of action for her and her group to take to prevent the violence other than to obey Islamic law.
 
Geller had guns?

Or is this the height of victim blaming?

The concept of "victim blaming" is itself deeply flawed. It requires we frame the incident in terms of victim and victimizer, drawing the lines carefully to poison the well, without allowing for the nuances required. It's a bad model, a caricature, and a misleading assignment of roles. In short, the phrase only serves to expose poor thinking.
 
That has to be one of the most ridiculous distortions I've seen so far in this thread; and that's really saying a lot. Well done!

Either that, or it's the worst example of reading comprehension in this thread; in which case, try again.


Okay. Clear it up for me then.

In both cases a guy is barbecuing. In both cases a neighbor is offended by the smoke.

In one case if the guy isn't considerate of the neighbor then he is a dick.

In the other case the neighbor is a dick for being offended.

What is the fundamental difference between these two sets of circumstances?

If it isn't the reason that the neighbor is offended then what exactly is your point?
 
Like I said before,if I went to a Islamic country and set up a stall selling pics of Mohammed I would be killed. Even though I would have known this would be the outcome I still would not have the tiniest share of the blame. The blame would lie completely with the mob,that undoubtedly, would tear me to bits. They would have made the choice to kill,no one would be forcing them,they would be 100%to blame.


A mob wouldn't necessarily be required, since in some instances the government might take care of it for them.

Saudi Arabia routinely beheads people for things like drug dealing and witchcraft. Blasphemy isn't looked at very fondly either.

If you were to choose to voluntarily go to a sovereign state and intentionally commit a crime which is a capital offense by their laws, is that sovereign state to blame, or are you?
 
Okay. Clear it up for me then.

In both cases a guy is barbecuing. In both cases a neighbor is offended by the smoke.

In one case if the guy isn't considerate of the neighbor then he is a dick.

In the other case the neighbor is a dick for being offended.

What is the fundamental difference between these two sets of circumstances?

If it isn't the reason that the neighbor is offended then what exactly is your point?

Yup, bad reading comprehension it is. The person in luchog's second hypothetical isn't complaining about the smoke, they're complaining that an unclean animal is being cooked.
 
Geller is the victim?

Huh. I thought it was the guard.

I'm sure she'd like to be seen as a victim. That's a fairly common MO for her type of bigot.

She's the victim of attempted murder.

But that seems to be OK by some posters, just as long as the victim is on the "opposing side".
 
The concept of "victim blaming" is itself deeply flawed. It requires we frame the incident in terms of victim and victimizer, drawing the lines carefully to poison the well, without allowing for the nuances required. It's a bad model, a caricature, and a misleading assignment of roles. In short, the phrase only serves to expose poor thinking.

Nuances? One draws a cartoon and another draws a gun and shoots him, guess I missed the nuance that the shooter was truly offended for religious reasons.

Apparently being genuinely religiously offended is nuance enough to justify murder.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom