Can a CharlieHebdo-type attack happen in the US?

Because what the killers(and the people manipulating them) want is for Islam to be protected from criticism. That just ain't gonna happen. For any person, idea or belief system.

I think they want more than that. I think this pair wanted an opportunity to become martyrs for a cause they believe in. Geller presented that opportunity to them.
 
I think I got that. You feel you are not responsible for the predictable outcome of your actions. I disagree. Because if the people you want to blame are responsible for their actions and the outcome (a murder), then why are you absolved?

If you performed the experiment you wrote above, I would tend to classify it along the lines of "suicide by cop" - a classic type of victim blaming generally accepted as justified.

If I pull a gun on a police officer and get shot for my troubles, who gets the blame? Surely not me, for my gun wasn't loaded and I had no intention of shooting the cop. But not the cop, either, for their actions were driven by mine. I'm dead, but am I the victim or the offender?

Geller sets a trap. Her trap catches the animals it was intended to catch. But this type of animal is capable of learning. I don't expect her next efforts will play out so well. Which is tragic.

Your comparisons are poor,very poor. The cop could not know the gun was not loaded, you would be to blame. The fact that you think that there is a similar comparison between pointing a gun at a human being,and drawing pictures is staggering.
The rational reaction to having a weapon pointed at you is violent retaliation. The cops actions in shooting would be normal not extreme.
The rational reaction to a drawing of a guy you have never met and who has been dead for 1400yrs is just not to care one iota. The Muslim reaction to these drawings is abnormal and extremist.
 
And, if as a Jihadist I believe I am doing the right thing by attacking those who insult the Prophet? Do I know the difference between right and wrong?

Yes,otherwise It would be easy to find these people. But they hide,if they were so insane to not realize right from wrong they would not be the threat they are. As I said having insane beliefs does not make you necesseraly insane.
When these people are caught they are capable of helping there lawyers etc. This proves that despite there insane views the are not themselves insane.
They are responsible for there actions 100%.

I'm off to read,if you want to post more I will eave answers tommorow. Goodnight,or day depending on where you are.
 
Last edited:
...And what of it? Do you want to quote a section for me to focus on?

OK, how about this:

The back story:http://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politics/frame_game/2011/07/christian_terrorism.html
excerpt:
Now you know how it feels, Ms. Geller. When the terrorist is a Christian—in his own words, a "Crusader" for "Christendom"—and when the preacher to whom he has been linked is you, you suddenly discover the injustice of group blame and guilt by association. The citations you didn't create, the intermediaries you didn't recognize, the transactions you didn't know about, the violent interpretations you didn't condone—these exonerating facts suddenly matter.


The email:http://pamelageller.com/2007/06/email-from-norw.html/#comment-6a00d8341c60bf53ef00e008cc03258834

The unedited original post from Pamela Geller blaming the summer camp victims because the camp is part of an "anti-Israel 'indoctrination training center.'":http://thinkprogress.org/security/2011/08/01/284011/pam-geller-race-mixing-breivik-right/

and here:

http://littlegreenfootballs.com/article/38960
 
The interesting bit for me is the idea that we cannot do what the killers want, no matter how miniscule or tangential that "thing" might be. Because that would be capitulation and an abridgement of free speech rights on par with civil rights demonstrations.

Yet again, you're grossly oversimplifying.

Abstaining from a particular behaviour because we are afraid of being harmed by religious fanatics, is indeed capitulation. We are modifying our behaviour as a direct result of the threat of harm from said fanatics.

Abstaining from a particular behaviour because we just can't be arsed to spend the time and effort it on it, is something else entirely.

Do you see the difference there?

I don't go out drawing pictures of Mohammad because I have too many other things to spend my time on right now; and in any case, my artistic skills are somewhere slightly below non-existent. However, I fully support those who do have the skills, and who decide that this is an appropriate use of them.
 
Nothing changes if it's illegal, other than she risks arrest as well as an attack. And yes, it is subjective. Here's something else which is subjective - the value of the lives lost. No matter who ends up dead, someone will be happy about it.


There's a huge difference. We as a society value being able to do what's legal to do without coming under threat of violence by private actors for doing so (and for that matter not suffering illegitimate force from the government either).

Additionally, we value (or at least I do) that freedom of expression such as exhibited by Geller is legally protected.

So no, these things are not in the least the same.
 
OK, how about this:

The back story:http://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politics/frame_game/2011/07/christian_terrorism.html
excerpt:



The email:http://pamelageller.com/2007/06/email-from-norw.html/#comment-6a00d8341c60bf53ef00e008cc03258834

The unedited original post from Pamela Geller blaming the summer camp victims because the camp is part of an "anti-Israel 'indoctrination training center.'":http://thinkprogress.org/security/2011/08/01/284011/pam-geller-race-mixing-breivik-right/

and here:

http://littlegreenfootballs.com/article/38960

Yes, she's a hypocritical bag of racist garbage.
 
OK, how about this:

Ok, I guess you're admitting that you wasted my time with that NY Times hit piece on Geller from 2010. I hope you're not wasting my time again.


Yup, you wasted my time again. So William Saletan, whom I have come to know as a dishonest leftist shill, writes an entire piece linking Pamela Geller to a mass murderer and then at the end notes how unfair it is and that Geller does the same thing to the targets of her criticism. I'll have to take Saletan's word for it that Geller is indeed linking, for example, Rauf to extremist Islam unfairly, but even if that is true, it could be that her critical reasoning skills are impaired. What is Saletan's and her other critics' excuse? Just malice I guess.

As for the accusation from Think Progress and LGF that she sought to justify Breivik's mass murder, she obviously did no such thing. Giving background on the summer camp that was attacked, and arguing that it was anti-Israel and even antisemitic, may be in poor taste to do so close to the incident, but it was quite different from trying to justify the mass murder of children. She was quite forceful in her denunciations. Perhaps you should compare and contrast her denunciations with the kinds of denunciations that people like Rauf give after an Islamist terrorist attack.
 
Last edited:
I suppose I should start a thread on Pamela Geller to give the evidence of her vile bigotry a fair hearing. I keep asking her detractors why they think she's a bigot, and nobody has ever been able to give me a good reason.

Here's Geraldo going on about wanting to take a shower every time he sees her on TV. No doubt the feeling is mutual. I know that I feel all itchy whenever I see his mustache twitch. Probably because it means he's about to saying something obnoxious and stupid.

She was among the first to report on the idea of European cities as so called "no go zones."

http://www.wnd.com/2014/08/islam-expert-u-s-groomed-for-shariah-law/

The Muslim population, for example, in France is over 10 percent,” she said. “You see outside of Paris … it can be very frightening. The no-go zones, the Shariah zones, where firefighters and police cannot go. They are many times lured by particular criminal activity into these zones, only to be ambushed. We see it in the U.K., increasingly, the imposition of Shariah law. And people think it can’t happen here, but it is happening here.

When a town settled a lawsuit with a Muslim group after admitting they refused their right to build a mosque was due to anti-Muslim sentiment she called the payment a "Jizya" tax by Muslims on Christians and Jews.

http://www.trunews.com/wednesday-december-10-2014-eric-lichtblau-pamela-geller/

“That’s the jizya, that’s the poll tax we see all through Islamic history imposed upon Christians and Jews living under Islamic law,”

She claimed that immigration reform would allow terrorists to infiltrate American from Mexico.

http://janetmefferdpremium.com/2014/11/18/janet-mefferd-radio-show-20141118-hr-2/

She claimed a woman beheaded over a work feud was the "next 9/11."

http://janetmefferdpremium.com/2014/10/01/janet-mefferd-radio-show-20141001-hr-3/

She claimed that the UN was part of a plot to turn America into an Islamic plot to take over America.

http://www.wnd.com/2014/09/u-n-to-dump-flood-of-muslim-refugees-on-u-s/

Pamela Geller, author of “Stop the Islamization of America: A Practical Guide to the Resistance,” said it should come as no surprise that the U.N. would do everything in its power to flood the United States with as many Muslim refugees as possible.
She said the Organization of Islamic Cooperation, or OIC, which is comprised of 56 Muslim countries and the Palestinian Authority, makes up the largest voting bloc at the U.N. General Assembly.
“They’re very powerful, they’re very dangerous,” Geller said. “You can’t make this stuff up.”

When Obama objected to Israel shelling a UN school in Gaza she called him the "Jihadist in the White House."

http://www.wnd.com/2014/08/obama-the-indefensible-president/

I have said for years that Obama had switched sides and was aligned with the jihad force.
This horrible war has not only exposed Hamas’ terror tunnels; it has unmasked and unmosqued Barack Hussein Obama.
Jihadist in the White House. At home and abroad, Jew-hatred is policy.

She claimed that Subway restaurants having halal meat as an option is part of a plot to push Islamization. http://janetmefferdpremium.com/2014/05/06/janet-mefferd-radio-show-20140506-hr-1/ While ignoring that Subway has entire Kosher restaurants in Jewish areas of New York. http://online.wsj.com/news/articles/SB10001424052970204010604576595260577457854

She denounced the USC Shoah Foundation for giving an award to Obama.

http://www.wnd.com/2014/05/steven-spielberg-just-doesnt-get-it/

Geller said the attitude “is illustrative of the willful blindness of liberal Jews.” “They have traded their religion for their politics. They have traded G-d (and their morality) for whomever is carrying the torch for human secularism. And now it is Obama,” she said.

She warned that Obama, through his action, or inaction, regarding Iran, is “single-handedly paving the way for the next holocaust.”

She claimed that hate crime research done by the NTIA will be used to silence critics of Islam. She also has an interesting alternative take on the Matthew Sheppard killing.

http://janetmefferdpremium.com/2014/04/22/janet-mefferd-radio-show-20140422-hr-1/

This is completely and utterly unacceptable because at the end of the day, this is the Sharia, that’s exactly what this is. Believe me, they’ll package it the way they packaged hate crimes. If you recall they used Matthew Shepard as a vicious gay killing when we then found out that it was really a drug deal gone bad with a previous lover, it doesn’t matter, this is the steaming pile of dung they package in a Tiffany box with a little white ribbon.

She blew a gasket when Obama mentioned Muslims during his Easter Sunday address. A speech where he also mentioned Hindus and Sihks as part of "The common thread of humanity that connects us all".

http://pamelageller.com/2014/04/obama-praises-muslims-easter-message.html/

She called for banning Muslims from piloting commercial airliners.

http://pamelageller.com/2014/03/hijacked-plane-may-sent-signals-ground.html/

She claimed Obama didn't want to kill Osama Bin Laden and hates our military. Also Prince Charles is a secret Muslim.

http://www.vcyamerica.org/blog/2014/01/30/islamizations-threat-to-america

I mean I really could go on and on.
 
Originally Posted by Scopedog
How would you feel if you lived next door to a Muslim who was one Mohammed cartoon contest away from becoming a mass murderer? How would you feel if you lived next door to a Social Justice Warrior who was one problematic-behavior or micro-aggression away from becoming a mass murderer? How would you feel if you lived next door to a [special interest group member] who was one [personally offensive but perfectly legal expression of a second or third party] away from becoming a mass murderer?

I wouldn't be very comfortable with it, I suspect. Why ?

Why would you be uncomfortable with it? It will only after he kills someone that you will be in a postion to tell people "He was a little weird, but quiet and he kept to himself"
 
Ok, I guess you're admitting that you wasted my time with that NY Times hit piece on Geller from 2010. I hope you're not wasting my time again...


Ah, no, I'm adding to the list. Like Travis has done above.



Yup, you wasted my time again... Snip


Dude, that was masterful! I haven't seen a handwave so deftly applied since having to deal with all the Lance Armstrong fanboys circa October, 2012.

Looks like Fox News is even distancing themselves from her. Is a Breitbart link, OK?

http://www.breitbart.com/big-journa...d-religion-a-lot-more-than-pamela-geller-has/
 
Well she sure seems to be inferring the proper response is to ban them, which she then says can't happen.
 
I absolutely agree. However, I would also agree with someone who refrains from saying "**** your rebel flag" to avoid a confrontation. Do you think that this person is a coward or an idiot ?

The person is certainly more cowardly than someone willing to risk violence to stand up for what they believe in.
 
Yet again, you're grossly oversimplifying.

Abstaining from a particular behaviour because we are afraid of being harmed by religious fanatics, is indeed capitulation. We are modifying our behaviour as a direct result of the threat of harm from said fanatics.

Abstaining from a particular behaviour because we just can't be arsed to spend the time and effort it on it, is something else entirely.

Do you see the difference there?

I don't go out drawing pictures of Mohammad because I have too many other things to spend my time on right now; and in any case, my artistic skills are somewhere slightly below non-existent. However, I fully support those who do have the skills, and who decide that this is an appropriate use of them.

Thank you,not drawing a dead guy just because some people go in the huff,is giving in to terrorism. That being said-as you point out-most folk,me included,have never drawn nutty mo and have no desire to do so.
These people want us dead anyway. The very fact that we are rational human beings is what offends them. They ALREADY want us dead. They don't make a secret of this,indeed they scream it from the rooftops. You can't provoke someone like that. They have already made up there minds to kill.
You can however satirize and mock them,showing them up for the sickos they are.
 
Like I said before,if I went to a Islamic country and set up a stall selling pics of Mohammed I would be killed. Even though I would have known this would be the outcome I still would not have the tiniest share of the blame. The blame would lie completely with the mob,that undoubtedly, would tear me to bits. They would have made the choice to kill,no one would be forcing them,they would be 100%to blame.


Hmmm.. Maybe. But what if you took your kid with you and they killed the kid too. Then I think that's on you.
 
Hmmm.. Maybe. But what if you took your kid with you and they killed the kid too. Then I think that's on you.

What! In what sane world is a child murderer not responsible for there actions. I don't believe what you wrote. If someone carries out a child murder they bear full responsibility, I can't understand why anyone would think different.
Would taking a kid into that situation be stupid-yes. But the mob or person who did the child murder would have made the clear choice to do so. You would not be to blame-the murdering mob would be 100%.
There is no possible reason to murder a child. It can't be put in "context" or understood from a social or geopolitical angle. Its child murder,and the person committing the murder has complete and total responsibility.
A parent should be able to take there child,a sketchpad and pencil and draw a dead early medieval cult leader. The fact they cannot go to Kabul and do so safely is 100% the fault of the Muslim community, moderates included. If they were to do so and they and the child are killed that is first degree murder with no extenuating circumstances.
A child murder is completely the responsibility of the murderer and no one else.
 
Out of interest, do those people who condemned Geller for being deliberately provocative believe that if she had not done so these two would never have found anyone else offensive (whether intentionally or not) or that if they had they would have restrained themselves to a really pointed letter writing campaign? Maybe it's just me, but I think someone who arms up with machine guns and travels two states to commit murder because someone has cartoons a thousand miles from them was actively looking for something to take offence at.
 
Out of interest, do those people who condemned Geller for being deliberately provocative believe that if she had not done so these two would never have found anyone else offensive (whether intentionally or not) or that if they had they would have restrained themselves to a really pointed letter writing campaign? Maybe it's just me, but I think someone who arms up with machine guns and travels two states to commit murder because someone has cartoons a thousand miles from them was actively looking for something to take offence at.

No, it is not just you.

I posted this in another thread but it is a good read, even if from the dead, sadly.

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/wor...attack-on-left-wing-French-intellectuals.html
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom