Can a CharlieHebdo-type attack happen in the US?

What you seem to be saying here is that the essence of the dickishness isn't bothering your neighbor and refusing to refrain from such behavior when asked, but rather why the neighbor is bothered.

If it's just smoke then you're being a dick, but if it is religious smoke then you aren't.

Got it.


That has to be one of the most ridiculous distortions I've seen so far in this thread; and that's really saying a lot. Well done!

Either that, or it's the worst example of reading comprehension in this thread; in which case, try again.
 
Last edited:
You are not listening. I do not mention guilt, blame, or should. There is an unasked question in what you wrote above. Did those people increase their risk of harm by taking those actions? Is that an appropriate level of risk management?

You wrote it could be other than victim blaming. No it can't be,if you even suggest someone drawing a guy no one has even met has in any way increased the risk of a attack on themselves, that's victim blaming.
You wrote about risk aversion. They drew pictures,PICTURES, any increase of risk is on the attackers heads,completely.
It is possible I have the wrong end of the stick. So I will clarify. Do you think the attackers are completely, utterly to blame or not. Any fudging here is victim blaming. Its removing responsibility from the attackers and putting it on the attacked
 
Last edited:
These hypothetical almost-mass-murderers are the problem

I would instead argue that hypotheticals are never an actual problem. They are a hypothetical problem.

And if you want to play that game, everyone is a potential murderer.

not the people or expressions that trigger them.

I agree, but it seems that this thread has now come down to two statements:

Person 1: "Perhaps we should avoid insulting people, less they come back to kill us."
Person 2: "Oh, so you want to stifle free speech ? The killers are the problem, not the people who insult them."

See, both of the affirmations are true, but the question has nothing to do with the first person's statement. No one is suggesting stifling free speech, and no one is suggesting that the killers aren't the evil party, here. What _some_ posters are suggesting is a means to avoid the killing, like locking your doors to prevent theft even though it's not your job to get the thief to stop stealing.
 
A man is wearing a rebel flag t shirt with a racist slogan.

A second man states " **** your rebel flag.", then gets punched in the face, the second man wins the fight.

I highly doubt anyone would say anything against the second man other than maybe he was being a bit opinionated. And further i doubt that many would disagree that the first man received what he was due (for the punch not the shirt).

This is the same situation, albeit with higher stakes. If you want to use violence and intimidation to get what you wasn't, be prepared to have Pepe who normally wouldn't use such methods follow suit.

I absolutely agree. However, I would also agree with someone who refrains from saying "**** your rebel flag" to avoid a confrontation. Do you think that this person is a coward or an idiot ?
 
That makes no sense,wether you lock your door or not. If someone breaks-or sneaks-in and steals your stuff they are 100%to blame. That's like saying that if you cross over a very bad area of a town with a high crime rate and get mugged its at least partly your fault-it isn't,its completely the muggers fault.
 
Geller is odious,that's obvious. But let's be clear,any even upset reaction to drawings is a extreme reaction. If you get upset over drawings of guy that died 1400 years ago,you are a extremist, its a extreme reaction. You are completely 100% to blame for getting the hump over a drawing of some guy you-clearly-have never even met. If your upset turns to violence, you are again 100%to blame.
I'm surprised that anyone with two brain cells to rub together would say that the drawers or orginizors have even 1% of the blame. They dont-period. Anything else is victim blaming and excuse of terrorism. They were drawing pictures of a someone who died one and a half millennia ago. Its your right to express yourself in a democracy. And as extremist as it is-and let's e clear if someone gets upset over a drawing of a man they never met then they are a extremist-its your right to express your disapproval of drawings of a dead cult leader. But your right to object ends long before violence.
You cannot be responsible in any way if someone does violence because you drew a long dead guy,the full responsibility lies with the terrorist. I said it before,I'll say it again-when someone gets even just upset over a drawing of a man who has been dead for 1400yrs then that someone is already a extremist.
Why do people feel he need to be apologists for Islamic terror and its crazy beliefs . The only people to blame for the hebdo attacks and the recent u.s attack are the terrorists.

Your argument is self-refuting. If Muslim extremists are crazy - as evidenced by what you refer to as crazy beliefs - then by definition they do not act rationally. If they do not act rationally, in our society, they cannot be blamed for what they do. We do not prosecute crazy people for murder, we treat them.

If I am dealing with someone who is crazy, I'm the only responsible, rational actor in the transaction. Hence, doing something I expect will trigger the crazy person to act violently is very much on my account. There is no other input into the equation.

You might escape this analysis by proposing Geller is also crazy and not responsible for her actions, although arguably she is less crazy than our pair of Jihadis.

I do agree with you about "anyone with two brain cells to rub together." I think it takes a few more than two to understand the situation.
 
Last edited:
You wrote it could be other than victim blaming. No it can't be,if you even suggest someone drawing a guy no one has even met has in any way increased the risk of a attack on themselves, that's victim blaming.
You wrote about risk aversion. They drew pictures,PICTURES, any increase of risk is on the attackers heads,completely.
It is possible I have the wrong end of the stick. So I will clarify. Do you think the attackers are completely, utterly to blame or not. Any fudging here is victim blaming. Its removing responsibility from the attackers and putting it on the attacked

Victim has zero blame.

My post is not talking about blame.
 
Your argument is self-refuting. If Muslim extremists are crazy - as evidenced by what you refer to as crazy beliefs - then by definition they do not act rationally. If they do not act rationally, in our society, they cannot be blamed for what they do. We do not prosecute crazy people for murder, we treat them.

If I am dealing with someone who is crazy, I'm the only responsible, rational actor in the transaction. Hence, doing something I expect will trigger the crazy person to act violently is very much on my account. There is no other input into the equation.

You might escape this analysis by proposing Geller is also crazy and not responsible for her actions, although arguably she is less crazy than our pair of Jihadis.

Muslims,extremist or moderate think the Pegasus is a real creature. While this may not make them clinically insane,it is a insane thing-so is getting upset over drawings of a man none of them can possibly know.
 
Things are spinning around past each other not ever quite lining up.

Did Pam Geller expose herself to risk by holding a Draw Mahomet contest? Yes, of course, that is the entire point. If there was no risk there'd be no reason to do it.

This Garland TX event is the THIRD TIME this year already(Paris 7 Jan., Copenhagen 14 Feb.) that men with guns have shown up to kill people over drawings of Mahomet. The major difference this time is only the bad guys died. Unless you think Finn Nørgaard, documentary filmmaker, was a bad guy for attending a debate entitled "Art, Blasphemy and Freedom of Expression" or the staff at Charlie Weekly were bad people deserving execution. If that's the case...

Can the risk of being killed by jihadis for drawing Mahomet or criticizing Islam be reduced to zero? Yes, by not criticizing Islam or drawing Mahomet. Which is what the killers want.
 
Muslims,extremist or moderate think the Pegasus is a real creature. While this may not make them clinically insane,it is a insane thing-so is getting upset over drawings of a man none of them can possibly know.

And you advocate taunting the insane? Aren't they victims of their insanity, and, if so, isn't that victim blaming?
 
(much snipped)

Can the risk of being killed by jihadis for drawing Mahomet or criticizing Islam be reduced to zero? Yes, by not criticizing Islam or drawing Mahomet. Which is what the killers want.

The interesting bit for me is the idea that we cannot do what the killers want, no matter how miniscule or tangential that "thing" might be. Because that would be capitulation and an abridgement of free speech rights on par with civil rights demonstrations.

It is as if Geller is driven by the Muslim zealots to do what she did. Each side controlling the behavior of the other in a twisted, scripted dance.
 
Like I said before,if I went to a Islamic country and set up a stall selling pics of Mohammed I would be killed. Even though I would have known this would be the outcome I still would not have the tiniest share of the blame. The blame would lie completely with the mob,that undoubtedly, would tear me to bits. They would have made the choice to kill,no one would be forcing them,they would be 100%to blame.
 
The interesting bit for me is the idea that we cannot do what the killers want, no matter how miniscule or tangential that "thing" might be. Because that would be capitulation and an abridgement of free speech rights on par with civil rights demonstrations.

It is as if Geller is driven by the Muslim zealots to do what she did. Each side controlling the behavior of the other in a twisted, scripted dance.


Except that was Geller did was legal and protected free expression. What the other guys did was attempted murder. How minuscule or tangential either's demands are is subjective.
 
Like I said before,if I went to a Islamic country and set up a stall selling pics of Mohammed I would be killed. Even though I would have known this would be the outcome I still would not have the tiniest share of the blame. The blame would lie completely with the mob,that undoubtedly, would tear me to bits. They would have made the choice to kill,no one would be forcing them,they would be 100%to blame.

I think I got that. You feel you are not responsible for the predictable outcome of your actions. I disagree. Because if the people you want to blame are responsible for their actions and the outcome (a murder), then why are you absolved?

If you performed the experiment you wrote above, I would tend to classify it along the lines of "suicide by cop" - a classic type of victim blaming generally accepted as justified.

If I pull a gun on a police officer and get shot for my troubles, who gets the blame? Surely not me, for my gun wasn't loaded and I had no intention of shooting the cop. But not the cop, either, for their actions were driven by mine. I'm dead, but am I the victim or the offender?

Geller sets a trap. Her trap catches the animals it was intended to catch. But this type of animal is capable of learning. I don't expect her next efforts will play out so well. Which is tragic.
 
And you advocate taunting the insane? Aren't they victims of their insanity, and, if so, isn't that victim blaming?

No,because despite there insane beliefs they are still in control of there actions. Your definition of insane fails to take into account that it is perfectly possible to have delusions but still know the difference between right and wrong.
Muslims have crazy beliefs but are not frothing at the mouth or baying at the moon therefore despite there weird beliefs they still have a choice of actions. They can shrug and say "sticks and stones"but they chose to get upset and some who get upset chose violence.
The 9/11 murderers had insane beliefs but were paradoxically sane,they could have decided that morning to just go home,they tragically did not.
 
Except that was Geller did was legal and protected free expression. What the other guys did was attempted murder. How minuscule or tangential either's demands are is subjective.

Nothing changes if it's illegal, other than she risks arrest as well as an attack. And yes, it is subjective. Here's something else which is subjective - the value of the lives lost. No matter who ends up dead, someone will be happy about it.
 
The interesting bit for me is the idea that we cannot do what the killers want, no matter how miniscule or tangential that "thing" might be. Because that would be capitulation and an abridgement of free speech rights on par with civil rights demonstrations.

It is as if Geller is driven by the Muslim zealots to do what she did. Each side controlling the behavior of the other in a twisted, scripted dance.

Because what the killers(and the people manipulating them) want is for Islam to be protected from criticism. That just ain't gonna happen. For any person, idea or belief system.
 
No,because despite there insane beliefs they are still in control of there actions. Your definition of insane fails to take into account that it is perfectly possible to have delusions but still know the difference between right and wrong.

And, if as a Jihadist I believe I am doing the right thing by attacking those who insult the Prophet? Do I know the difference between right and wrong?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom