Can a CharlieHebdo-type attack happen in the US?

I'm sure it's been brought up with him unofficially. A whole "we understand you were upset but you really need to be more careful with what you say" kind of talk. Optics is what's keeping him at liberty. That and the state would have to prove that the people who did indeed "burn [that] bitch down" actually heard his call to "burn this bitch down" and would not have done it without his encouragement.

Good explanation. Thanks
 
>snip< I am pro-mockery of religion and other silly superstitions, traditions, and ideas.>snip<

Now is that dickery or defiance? Probably a little bit of both. And that's okay.

Which actually brings up a bit of a chicken or the egg type question. Ground Zero for all this(Pam Geller, CharlieHebdo) is the Danish cartoons in '05. Did they know that depictions of Mahomet would "make" people riot and kill? Was that even a thing back then?
 
Yeah, that was disgusting.

Foolmewunz should pause and consider what his reaction would have been if a Teapartier had been shooting at some Liberal/Democrat function, say an Obama fundraiser. Presumably he would find any conservatives hoping that Democrat VIPs in attendance received a 'flesh wound' reprehensible.

You should hope and support safety of assembly and speech both for those you do and do not agree with. That's a key, perhaps the foundational, virtue for a healthy diverse democracy.

That was hyperbole.

If you can't recognize exaggeration and a sick sense of humor, you must have difficulty dealing with adults on a regular basis. I'm a borderline pacifist.
 
The meat of the question is highlighted. I am willing to concede that I don't know the political leanings of the torturers. However, that does not change the fact that we HAVE seen this actually happen. At Abu Grhaib.

And you can prove that this was due to them being specifically Muslim rather than just enemy combatants engaged in a struggle to kill each other?
 
You should hope and support safety of assembly and speech both for those you do and do not agree with. That's a key, perhaps the foundational, virtue for a healthy diverse democracy.

And the foundation of a civilised society. Well said.
 
And you can prove that this was due to them being specifically Muslim rather than just enemy combatants engaged in a struggle to kill each other?

You'd think if they just wanted to kill some Moslems for just being Moslem-y they could do it without invading a country on the other side of the world. There wasn't enough visa violators in the US to lock up and abuse to satisfy their lust for the blood of innocents?
 
Exactly. Geller should heed your advice.

As far as I can tell, Geller believes that one cannot ignore the threat of Muslims imposing Sharia in the US (of which, cartoon Mohammed is one example), nor can we avoid becoming a Muslim nation if we do not react in the way her organization did. And the outcome is indeed killing them.

I think she's paranoid when it comes to Muslims, but I also think there's a huge swath of Americans who lean in her direction. Who are willing to consider her position has some merit. We do so love an old fashioned "us vs. them" scenario.

Actually, Geller did,, she ignored those who presumed that she should be subject to their religious taboos (pretty dickish in my book) and so far as I am aware didn't try to kill anyone.
 
Geller is odious,that's obvious. But let's be clear,any even upset reaction to drawings is a extreme reaction. If you get upset over drawings of guy that died 1400 years ago,you are a extremist, its a extreme reaction. You are completely 100% to blame for getting the hump over a drawing of some guy you-clearly-have never even met. If your upset turns to violence, you are again 100%to blame.
I'm surprised that anyone with two brain cells to rub together would say that the drawers or orginizors have even 1% of the blame. They dont-period. Anything else is victim blaming and excuse of terrorism. They were drawing pictures of a someone who died one and a half millennia ago. Its your right to express yourself in a democracy. And as extremist as it is-and let's e clear if someone gets upset over a drawing of a man they never met then they are a extremist-its your right to express your disapproval of drawings of a dead cult leader. But your right to object ends long before violence.
You cannot be responsible in any way if someone does violence because you drew a long dead guy,the full responsibility lies with the terrorist. I said it before,I'll say it again-when someone gets even just upset over a drawing of a man who has been dead for 1400yrs then that someone is already a extremist.
Why do people feel he need to be apologists for Islamic terror and its crazy beliefs . The only people to blame for the hebdo attacks and the recent u.s attack are the terrorists.
 
No. Not all assaults are criminal. If someone pushes a old woman down a flight of stairs to steal her purse or because he's that special type that gets his kicks from pushing old women down stairs he's a bounder and a cad. If someone else pushes an old woman out of the path of an oncoming runaway bus, he's a goddam hero. But the overlap in a Venn diagram of the two is "pushes old women"


You're trying way too hard.

It's kinda cute.

Silly, but cute.
 
Which in this case meant resisting the draft.




And these examples are exactly like resisting the draft?

Right.

Doesn't matter what the law is, it's the encouraging people to break it that's the crime.


I though it was about "To incite actions that would harm others" and "shouting fire in a crowded theater.

Oh, yeah. Those were those other goalposts.

Keep them doggies movin'.
 
A man is wearing a rebel flag t shirt with a racist slogan.

A second man states " **** your rebel flag.", then gets punched in the face, the second man wins the fight.

I highly doubt anyone would say anything against the second man other than maybe he was being a bit opinionated. And further i doubt that many would disagree that the first man received what he was due (for the punch not the shirt).

This is the same situation, albeit with higher stakes. If you want to use violence and intimidation to get what you wasn't, be prepared to have Pepe who normally wouldn't use such methods follow suit.
 
Geller is odious,that's obvious. But let's be clear,any even upset reaction to drawings is a extreme reaction. If you get upset over drawings of guy that died 1400 years ago,you are a extremist, its a extreme reaction. You are completely 100% to blame for getting the hump over a drawing of some guy you-clearly-have never even met. If your upset turns to violence, you are again 100%to blame.
I'm surprised that anyone with two brain cells to rub together would say that the drawers or orginizors have even 1% of the blame. They dont-period. Anything else is victim blaming and excuse of terrorism. They were drawing pictures of a someone who died one and a half millennia ago. Its your right to express yourself in a democracy. And as extremist as it is-and let's e clear if someone gets upset over a drawing of a man they never met then they are a extremist-its your right to express your disapproval of drawings of a dead cult leader. But your right to object ends long before violence.
You cannot be responsible in any way if someone does violence because you drew a long dead guy,the full responsibility lies with the terrorist. I said it before,I'll say it again-when someone gets even just upset over a drawing of a man who has been dead for 1400yrs then that someone is already a extremist.
Why do people feel he need to be apologists for Islamic terror and its crazy beliefs . The only people to blame for the hebdo attacks and the recent u.s attack are the terrorists.

It can be a reason other than victim blaming. I work for a huge company that puts out PowerPoints on international travel. You won't have a fun time if you follow it. But its goal is risk mitigation. Is it victim blaming if this same org provides training to marketers saying don't do something like this?

It doesn't have to be blame or responsibility. It can be she as an unreasonable lack of risk aversion.
 
You're trying way too hard.

It's kinda cute.

Silly, but cute.

I guess when you ain't got nothin', you're reduced to childlike dismissals. Try convincing me Geller is the bad guy and not the two losers with rifles and body armor come to kill her.
 
I though it was about "To incite actions that would harm others" and "shouting fire in a crowded theater.

Oh, yeah. Those were those other goalposts.

Keep them doggies movin'.

No goalposts have moved. You're just squinting too hard. Encouraging people to break the law is inciting an action to harm others.

What you want is "fighting words" which are separate from incitement.
 
It can be a reason other than victim blaming. I work for a huge company that puts out PowerPoints on international travel. You won't have a fun time if you follow it. But its goal is risk mitigation. Is it victim blaming if this same org provides training to marketers saying don't do something like this?

It doesn't have to be blame or responsibility. It can be she as an unreasonable lack of risk aversion.

There's usually a risk attached to protests otherwise there'd be no need for the protest. I'm sure your company would've advised people not to march across Edmund Pettus bridge because of the danger inherent in the action but then where would we be?
 
There's usually a risk attached to protests otherwise there'd be no need for the protest. I'm sure your company would've advised people not to march across Edmund Pettus bridge because of the danger inherent in the action but then where would we be?

Risk management does not address that nor is it designed to.
 
Remember the guy who legally brought a loaded assault rifle to an Obama rally? (actually, it was more than one person)

[qimg]http://i.azcentral.com/i/sized/2/E/4/e298/j350/PHP4A8F02C11C4E2.jpg[/qimg]

Was that a good idea? In other words, if you were a friend of his, and he told you he was planning on bringing a loaded AR15 to an Obama speech (or as near as he could get to the speech), and asked you whether he should go ahead or not...

Would anyone have encouraged him?

Me going up to you displaying a loaded gun is a little bit different then me drawing an offensive cartoon of you in a private meeting hall no where near you. Legality is not the issue.
 
It can be a reason other than victim blaming. I work for a huge company that puts out PowerPoints on international travel. You won't have a fun time if you follow it. But its goal is risk mitigation. Is it victim blaming if this same org provides training to marketers saying don't do something like this?

It doesn't have to be blame or responsibility. It can be she as an unreasonable lack of risk aversion.

No it is victim blaming. A young woman should be able to go out,dress how she likes,flirt with men and get as drunk as she likes knowing she is safe from sexual assault. If she is raped the rapist is utterly 100%,completely to blame. She is not"asking for it"she has not"led men on"she is the victem-and she is completely blameless.
A human being should be able to draw any historical personage they like. In any rude manner they like. And if they are assaulted or worse,the person who carried out the attack is completely 100% to blame.
Now i-or you-can not go to Karachi and set up a street stall selling mocking pictures of nutty mo . That is because halfwits would kill us. If however I was to do this and be killed for it then my killers would be,again,100% responsible for my death and I would bear no responsibility in any way at all.
Some people are,like you,making invalid comparisons,forgetting that a violent attack is always optional. Someone has to make the decision to attack. Either to rape a girl or kill someone drawing a long dead guy,or any similar case. The person that attacks someone for drawing pictures of someone they have never met always bears complete guilt.
 
No it is victim blaming. A young woman should be able to go out,dress how she likes,flirt with men and get as drunk as she likes knowing she is safe from sexual assault. If she is raped the rapist is utterly 100%,completely to blame. She is not"asking for it"she has not"led men on"she is the victem-and she is completely blameless.
A human being should be able to draw any historical personage they like. In any rude manner they like. And if they are assaulted or worse,the person who carried out the attack is completely 100% to blame.
Now i-or you-can not go to Karachi and set up a street stall selling mocking pictures of nutty mo . That is because halfwits would kill us. If however I was to do this and be killed for it then my killers would be,again,100% responsible for my death and I would bear no responsibility in any way at all.
Some people are,like you,making invalid comparisons,forgetting that a violent attack is always optional. Someone has to make the decision to attack. Either to rape a girl or kill someone drawing a long dead guy,or any similar case. The person that attacks someone for drawing pictures of someone they have never met always bears complete guilt.

You are not listening. I do not mention guilt, blame, or should. There is an unasked question in what you wrote above. Did those people increase their risk of harm by taking those actions? Is that an appropriate level of risk management?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom