Can a CharlieHebdo-type attack happen in the US?

You're obviously confused about what's being discussed. You are not giving up your right to free speech by exercising your right to not speak.

All that _some_ people in this thread are saying is that beign a dick sometimes results in the other person punching you in the face. It might be that person's fault for doing so, but trying to avoid that situation isn't dumb or cowardly.

How would you feel if you lived next door to a Muslim who was one Mohammed cartoon contest away from becoming a mass murderer? How would you feel if you lived next door to a Social Justice Warrior who was one problematic-behavior or micro-aggression away from becoming a mass murderer? How would you feel if you lived next door to a [special interest group member] who was one [personally offensive but perfectly legal expression of a second or third party] away from becoming a mass murderer?
 
Last edited:
How would you feel if you lived next door to a Muslim who was one Mohammed cartoon contest away from becoming a mass murderer? How would you feel if you lived next door to a Social Justice Warrior who was one problematic-behavior or micro-aggression away from becoming a mass murderer? How would you feel if you lived next door to a [special interest group member] who was one [personally offensive but perfectly legal expression of a second or third party] away from becoming a mass murderer?

Tough neighborhood!
 
How would you feel if you lived next door to a Muslim who was one Mohammed cartoon contest away from becoming a mass murderer? How would you feel if you lived next door to a Social Justice Warrior who was one problematic-behavior or micro-aggression away from becoming a mass murderer? How would you feel if you lived next door to a [special interest group member] who was one [personally offensive but perfectly legal expression of a second or third party] away from becoming a mass murderer?

I wouldn't be very comfortable with it, I suspect. Why ?
 
When the government arrests, prosecutes, convicts and punishes your attackers they are affirming your right to express yourself free of violent reprisal.

<snip>


Wrong. They are affirming your right to be free of violence.

The rest is just window dressing. Getting mugged earns the same affirmation, and expressing yourself has nothing to do with it.
 
The "don't be a dick" thing has been brought up a lot; and IMO is completely specious.

If you're BBQing a rack of pork ribs and heavy smoke from the grill bothers your neighbor because the grill is too close to his house, he asks you to be a little more considerate, and you refuse because it's your right to BBQ whenever and wherever you want in your own yard; then you're being a dick. Your neighbor is making a reasonable complaint, and it would be good manners to accommodate his request to the extent you are able.

If you're BBQing a rack of pork ribs, and the neighbor complains because it's an unclean animal and he should have to be subjected to the smell, and you refuse it's your right to BBQ whenever and wherever you want in your own yard; you're not being a dick (unless you go out of your way to denigrate him for making the request, then that's kind of dickish). His request that you adhere to the tenets of a religious belief that you do not share is unreasonable. It doesn't harm him in any way, it's only his religious sensibilities that are being affected.

<snip>


What you seem to be saying here is that the essence of the dickishness isn't bothering your neighbor and refusing to refrain from such behavior when asked, but rather why the neighbor is bothered.

If it's just smoke then you're being a dick, but if it is religious smoke then you aren't.

Got it.
 
Leaflets encouraging people to break the law.


Which in this case meant resisting the draft.

If Pam Gellar was out on the front steps telling an assembled crowd "The only good Moslem is a dead Moslem. If you're driving your car and one crosses the street ahead of you, speed up! He's probably on his way to suicide bomb a day care center anyways...hold on...there's one now! Get him! Get that filthy meteorite worshippin' idolator! Don't let him get away boys, someone get some rope over here!"

That would be a pretty clear cut case of incitement that wouldn't be protected speech.


And these examples are exactly like resisting the draft?

Right.
 
Lesson learned:
The best and most effective place to hold your free speech rally is in a basement, where you talk quietly amongst yourselves and avoid anything controversial. Don't advertise it, or in any way draw attention to it or people who disagree with you might not like it.

Now that's being fiscally responsible. You just saved $50,000 on security.

I recommend it for all rallies likely to upset violent people. Like civil rights marches during the fifties and anti-police brutality demonstrations today. That stupid Malala should have expressed her feelings in whispers, and in a dark corner of a hidden basement somewhere.
 
"Look, Mrs. Parks, just stop being a dick and move to the back of the bus already."


Selma Alabama, 7 March 1965, a bunch of dicks who were denied permission to march, do so anyways. 17 are hospitalized. What did they think was going to happen?


Dicks change things, pussies don't.

Those folks should have stopped whining about their precious "rights" and owed up to their part in the violence.
 
I recommend it for all rallies likely to upset violent people. Like civil rights marches during the fifties and anti-police brutality demonstrations today. That stupid Malala should have expressed her feelings in whispers, and in a dark corner of a hidden basement somewhere.

The Revolution really offended the British and lots of offensive things were said, shame really.
 
Could you answer the questions I asked?

Would the clan rally in Baltimore be a stupid event you would have nothing to do with? Yes/No.
If an attack happened at the event that killed innocent people, would the KKK share any of the blame? Yes/No.

I'll give you my answers: Yes, and yes.

I would answer "yes" and "no". As I said before, nobody makes the attacker do anything. But for sake of argument, let's suppose the answer to the second question is "yes" - it's still an apples to oranges comparison between gang-bangers in Baltimore shooting at a Klan rally and jihadi fecal matter shooting at a cartoon contest.

With Baltimore - or anywhere with a large black population in the US (because this is really a domestic issue within the US) - there's a well-known history of the KKK committing acts of violence and intimidation against black people, many of which are in living memory, and which is also only part of an even longer history of similar and worse horrors. The KKK would be in someone else's home telling them they are not welcome there. This context of course wouldn't justify any violent attack, even if only Klan garbage and not innocent bystanders were attacked, but it would make it at least a little understandable.

Contrast that with two idiots driving 15 hours to murder strangers for drawing cartoons. Cartoons. That is in no way, shape or form understandable, not in the way the Baltimore/KKK analogy would be.

If anything, the better analogy for the Garland attack would be if the KKK went into Baltimore and started attacking the protestors after the Freddie Gray death. They'd be butting into someone else's non-violent event to commit violence in order to prevent similar non-violent events in the future. And I'm sure somebody somewhere would chide the non-violent protestors for inviting violence into the community. "Well you knew the KKK would probably show up, why'd you have to be dicks about it?"

That's the factor that gets missed here, I think. It's not just about Geller. It's about making sure that Islam gets more equal treatment than other religions by committing acts of violence against people who don't adhere to its tenets. There have been other attacks and attempts, recall, against much less venomous people than Geller, for things that aren't just not less provocative, but not provocative at all (naming a Teddy bear "Mohammad", specifically).

The Garland attack didn't happen in a vacuum, is what I'm saying. I consider it misguided, to say the least, to focus any blame for a violent reaction to speech and expression on anybody but the violent party, with a heavy implication that people should self-censor to avoid hurting the precious little feeling of this or that group because they just might set off a bomb or open fire on a crowd.

Rather, the reaction, our reaction, ought to be a resounding "**** YOU" to anybody who would use terror to prevent criticism of ideas - we've seen the results of that in the past and we should fight its recurrence tooth and nail, not cower.
 
Wrong. They are affirming your right to be free of violence.

The rest is just window dressing. Getting mugged earns the same affirmation, and expressing yourself has nothing to do with it.

No. Not all assaults are criminal. If someone pushes a old woman down a flight of stairs to steal her purse or because he's that special type that gets his kicks from pushing old women down stairs he's a bounder and a cad. If someone else pushes an old woman out of the path of an oncoming runaway bus, he's a goddam hero. But the overlap in a Venn diagram of the two is "pushes old women"
 
How would you feel if you lived next door to a Muslim who was one Mohammed cartoon contest away from becoming a mass murderer? How would you feel if you lived next door to a Social Justice Warrior who was one problematic-behavior or micro-aggression away from becoming a mass murderer? How would you feel if you lived next door to a [special interest group member] who was one [personally offensive but perfectly legal expression of a second or third party] away from becoming a mass murderer?


I'd probably feel compelled to prove my psychic abilities to the public...
 
Tough neighborhood!

I wouldn't be very comfortable with it, I suspect. Why ?

These hypothetical almost-mass-murderers are the problem, not the people or expressions that trigger them. If there had never been an attempted attack on the event we could still be having a debate about whether Pamela Geller is a bigot or an idiot or a patriot or whatever. That would be a valid outcome of Pamela Geller's actions. In the U. S., the almost-mass-murderers could debate the topic, too, instead of becoming mass murderers. That would be the correct outcome of Pamela Gellar's actions. I believe that without an attack there would probably be very little debate about her because the event would have received very little attention. That seems to be what the apparently very reasonable local Muslim population wanted.
 
Last edited:
Someone should tell that to Mike Brown's step dad.

I'm sure it's been brought up with him unofficially. A whole "we understand you were upset but you really need to be more careful with what you say" kind of talk. Optics is what's keeping him at liberty. That and the state would have to prove that the people who did indeed "burn [that] bitch down" actually heard his call to "burn this bitch down" and would not have done it without his encouragement.
 
I'd probably feel compelled to prove my psychic abilities to the public...

This is not a hypothetical. This actually happened recently. It may be a bit of an off-topic derail but there were two ostensibly Muslim men from Arizona who drove to a city in Texas to attack a Mohammed cartoon contest. The two men had neighbors who now must cope with the fact that they were living in the proximity of religious mass murderers and that there are probably many more (according to Islamic State and other groups of their ilk). I am not suggesting punishing people for thought crimes. I am suggesting that people should not kowtow or defer to supposed Muslim moderates in the same way that people do not kowtow or defer to Christian or other moderates when they intentionally offend them. I am pro-mockery of religion and other silly superstitions, traditions, and ideas.

What would you do if your Muslim neighbor was offended by your daughter's education? Would you disenroll her from school? Did Malala have any responsibility for the attack on her? Did the Freedom Riders have any responsibility for the attacks on them in Birmingham in 1961?
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom