Can a CharlieHebdo-type attack happen in the US?

The government decides it. Offensive speech is generally allowed (I think there's some "fighting words" exception). Speech that puts people in danger needlessly (i.e., yelling, "Fire in a crowded theater" when there is no fire) is not allowed.

It seems to me that violent extremists decide which offensive speech is needless and which is not.
 
Violence is certainly one indicator of just how much you've ticked someone off, so yes. If I think a cop is going to punch me if I call them a "dirty pig," I will be less likely to voice my opinion, even if I think that particular cop really is a dirty pig.

I don't see the word "respect" here. I responded to a post where you claimed all that's required is to:

treat them with the respect you would give to any of your fellow human beings.
 
It seems to me that violent extremists decide which offensive speech is needless and which is not.

I reckon we have been looking at political repression in nazi Germany and the communist bloc all wrong. Political dissidents should have just stopped "being a dick" to hitler, stalin etc. they knew the gulags were waiting. Call sharansky courageous? More like a foolish dick. At least ancient Athens knew how to deal with Socrates.
 
Lesson learned:
The best and most effective place to hold your free speech rally is in a basement, where you talk quietly amongst yourselves and avoid anything controversial. Don't advertise it, or in any way draw attention to it or people who disagree with you might not like it.

Now that's being fiscally responsible. You just saved $50,000 on security.
 
No, but mine includes ignoring or avoiding such people, not killing them.

Exactly. Geller should heed your advice.

As far as I can tell, Geller believes that one cannot ignore the threat of Muslims imposing Sharia in the US (of which, cartoon Mohammed is one example), nor can we avoid becoming a Muslim nation if we do not react in the way her organization did. And the outcome is indeed killing them.

I think she's paranoid when it comes to Muslims, but I also think there's a huge swath of Americans who lean in her direction. Who are willing to consider her position has some merit. We do so love an old fashioned "us vs. them" scenario.
 
Keyboard warriors would definitely tell that cop that he's a dirty pig.

You're missing the point. The keyboard warriors may or may not tell that cop he's a dirty pig. What they wouldn't do is criticize, let alone denounce, somebody else for being brave enough to do it, assuming of course the cop really is a dirty pig.
 
Remember the guy who legally brought a loaded assault rifle to an Obama rally? (actually, it was more than one person)

PHP4A8F02C11C4E2.jpg


Was that a good idea? In other words, if you were a friend of his, and he told you he was planning on bringing a loaded AR15 to an Obama speech (or as near as he could get to the speech), and asked you whether he should go ahead or not...

Would anyone have encouraged him?
 
I reckon we have been looking at political repression in nazi Germany and the communist bloc all wrong. Political dissidents should have just stopped "being a dick" to hitler, stalin etc. they knew the gulags were waiting. Call sharansky courageous? More like a foolish dick. At least ancient Athens knew how to deal with Socrates.

"Look, Mrs. Parks, just stop being a dick and move to the back of the bus already."


Selma Alabama, 7 March 1965, a bunch of dicks who were denied permission to march, do so anyways. 17 are hospitalized. What did they think was going to happen?


Dicks change things, pussies don't.
 
Last edited:
Exactly. Geller should heed your advice.

As far as I can tell, Geller believes that one cannot ignore the threat of Muslims imposing Sharia in the US (of which, cartoon Mohammed is one example), nor can we avoid becoming a Muslim nation if we do not react in the way her organization did. And the outcome is indeed killing them.

I think she's paranoid when it comes to Muslims, but I also think there's a huge swath of Americans who lean in her direction. Who are willing to consider her position has some merit. We do so love an old fashioned "us vs. them" scenario.

That's Frickin insane. Yikes
 
you really ought to respond to what I actually post and not what you think I hinted at.

I was referring to Pamela and the fact that she is more courageous than those who say she should be silenced but to not have the guts to do what she does.

1) Who said she should be silenced ?
2) Since you put posters here in the latter group, which group are you in ?
 
Someone doesn't.

You're obviously confused about what's being discussed. You are not giving up your right to free speech by exercising your right to not speak.

All that _some_ people in this thread are saying is that beign a dick sometimes results in the other person punching you in the face. It might be that person's fault for doing so, but trying to avoid that situation isn't dumb or cowardly.
 
Is this really so strange? Do others reserve their dickishness only for those who are directly able to harm them? I find that remarkable.

Well, yes, many of us do. Because not doing so is beyond dickish.

I don't go around punching little kids who throw things at me, because they can't really harm me. If an adult my size engaged in similar behaviour, then they would be capable of harming me, and I would definitely defend myself with physical force if needed.

Likewise I don't go around insulting and attacking the beliefs of children or developmentally-disabled adults; as they do not have the intellectual wherewithal to defend themselves. But I have no problem insulting or attacking the BS beliefs of intelligent adults, because they are, or should be, capable of defending their beliefs. That is part of being an adult.

I won't call an un-vaccinated child a child killer, because it's not his choice, and because he can't defend against it. I will call, and have called, adult anti-vaxxers child killers to their faces; because they should be able to defend their actions.

If you reserve your most forceful and incisive behavior only for those who are unable to effectively respond to it or defend themselves against it... well... there's a word for that, it's called bullying. Plain and simple bullying. If you only go around insulting or attacking those who cannot fight back, you are the most reprehensible sort of coward. Most of us learned as children to "only pick on someone our own size". Only a bully attacks those smaller and weaker, or otherwise unlikely to fight back.

And refusal to do so with someone who actually is capable of defending themselves is not "civilized", it's cowardly toadying.

And for all that she's a bigot, that is exactly what Gellar did. She attacked the religion of adults who should be able to defend themselves; or who could simply ignore her as a bigot.

I find it remarkable that you would consider attacking someone who is weaker than you, or less able to defend themselves than you, to be laudable. The fact that you consider this preferable to attacking someone who can defend themselves is beyond vile. If your so-called "reasonable civilization" is based on this type of toadying and bullying dynamic; I want nothing to do with it.
 
Last edited:
"Look, Mrs. Parks, just stop being a dick and move to the back of the bus already."


Selma Alabama, 7 March 1965, a bunch of dicks who were denied permission to march, do so anyways. 17 are hospitalized. What did they think was going to happen?


Dicks change things, pussies don't.

For that analogy to work, one would have to equate cartoon Mohammed with race relations and the struggle for civil rights. I am not really getting the parallel. Perhaps you could make it plainer?

For example, in the analogy, who takes the place of the intrenched racist demanding blacks remain second-class citizens? Geller or the Jihadists or someone else? Is the poor security guard who got shot Rosa Parks?

I can't tell if the analogy inappropriately elevates the cartoon Mohammed event or diminishes the civil rights movement. Both?
 
"Look, Mrs. Parks, just stop being a dick and move to the back of the bus already."


Selma Alabama, 7 March 1965, a bunch of dicks who were denied permission to march, do so anyways. 17 are hospitalized. What did they think was going to happen?


Dicks change things, pussies don't.


Didn't realize the word "pussies" was allowed here - I would have used it many pages ago. Thank you for using it so well.
 
Well, yes, many of us do. Because not doing so is beyond dickish.

I don't go around punching little kids who throw things at me, because they can't really harm me. If an adult my size engaged in similar behaviour, then they would be capable of harming me, and I would definitely defend myself with physical force if needed.

Likewise I don't go around insulting and attacking the beliefs of children or developmentally-disabled adults; as they do not have the intellectual wherewithal to defend themselves. But I have no problem insulting or attacking the BS beliefs of intelligent adults, because they are, or should be, capable of defending their beliefs. That is part of being an adult.

I won't call an un-vaccinated child a child killer, because it's not his choice, and because he can't defend against it. I will call, and have called, adult anti-vaxxers child killers to their faces; because they should be able to defend their actions.

If you reserve your most forceful and incisive behavior only for those who are unable to effectively respond to it or defend themselves against it... well... there's a word for that, it's called bullying. Plain and simple bullying. If you only go around insulting or attacking those who cannot fight back, you are the most reprehensible sort of coward. Most of us learned as children to "only pick on someone our own size". Only a bully attacks those smaller and weaker, or otherwise unlikely to fight back.

And refusal to do so with someone who actually is capable of defending themselves is not "civilized", it's cowardly toadying.

You have replaced, in the analysis above, "capable of harming you" (my phrasing) with "capable of defending themselves." This is not the position I took.

And for all that she's a bigot, that is exactly what Gellar did. She attacked the religion of adults who should be able to defend themselves; or who could simply ignore her as a bigot.

And they did defend themselves. I don't think you meant that you supported the terrorists' response here.

I find it remarkable that you would consider attacking someone who is weaker than you, or less able to defend themselves than you, to be laudable. The fact that you consider this preferable to attacking someone who can defend themselves is beyond vile. If your so-called "reasonable civilization" is based on this type of toadying and bullying dynamic; I want nothing to do with it.

Your confusion revolves around the use of "defend" here. In one sense, I think you are using it to mean "respond in kind," but that's not what happened in the Geller case.

But even in that milder sense, I am guilty as charged. I have strong criticism for Geller and her organization on a forum where she is not a member and cannot defend herself against my charges. You should read some of the horrible stuff I've said about homeopaths and Dr. Oz - it would curl your hair. In this sense, I am very much guilty of attacking without concern of response. I wouldn't say it was particularly laudable.

If you are able to hold your criticism only for those who can respond in kind, I think that's laudable. Even saintly.
 
You have replaced, in the analysis above, "capable of harming you" (my phrasing) with "capable of defending themselves." This is not the position I took.


This is nonsense. Anyone capable of defending against me, physically, is ipso facto capable of harming me. Again, you are trying to artificially alter and re-define scope to either avoid having to address the logical consequence of your expressed philosophy; or to admit that you are simply not expressing yourself very well.

If I insult someone who is "capable of harming" me as a result of that insult, then I am just a dick. If I insult someone who is not, then I go beyond being a dick, and become a bully.


And they did defend themselves. I don't think you meant that you supported the terrorists' response here.


I fail to see how you could possibly think I did. Further, they did not defend themselves, they attacked and attempted to murder. A true defense would have been to respond in kind. Attack words with words, and insults with insults.


Your confusion revolves around the use of "defend" here. In one sense, I think you are using it to mean "respond in kind," but that's not what happened in the Geller case.


The confusion is yours, not mine. As has been noted in many other incidents like this one, they clearly thought of what they were doing as defending the "honor" of the prophet and their belief system. Whether they were right to think that does not change what they believed.


But even in that milder sense, I am guilty as charged. I have strong criticism for Geller and her organization on a forum where she is not a member and cannot defend herself against my charges.


Irrelevant, as she is still capable of doing so should she discover the comments; unless you retract or hide them to make them impossible to respond to. Even so, this is kind of a nothing venue, with little impact either way.

I have no great love for Gellar either; but as Mencken said, defending freedom very often means defending jackasses, because oppression is almost always targeted at them first, and oppression has to be stopped in the beginning if it is to be stopped at all. My right to call Gellar a bigot is a direct result of her right to spew her bigotry. You can't have one without the other.

You should read some of the horrible stuff I've said about homeopaths and Dr. Oz - it would curl your hair.


I doubt it would. I've engaged in some fairly strong language regarding sCAM woo to friends who were heavily into it; some of whom are no longer my friends because they didn't like having those beliefs challenged. I have friend who are anti-vaxxers; and I have come out and explicity called anti-vaxxers in general child-killers after the latest spate of child deaths resulting from the anti-vax movement.

I've even called a out police officer for acting like a religious bigot and homophobe; because he was defending legislation that was intended to permit open discrimination against homosexuals. Though, to be fair, it was on Facebook, and he considered me a friend at the time (and dropped me as a friend immediately after). He still knows where I live, and was perfectly capable of being violent had he chosen to be (fortunately, he's not that sort of person).

I'll happily stand up in front of any adult church gathering that preaches homophobia and call them un-Christian bigots (and back up my accusation with scripture, at that). I'm not about to go into a Sunday School and do the same. I don't have any interest in setting foot inside such a church; of course, but I've not passed up opportunities to argue with religious bigots when available.


In this sense, I am very much guilty of attacking without concern of response. I wouldn't say it was particularly laudable.


Nor would I; but it's not particularly bad either. Especially since there are those here who are more than capable of defending her, and clearly willing to do so.

If you are able to hold your criticism only for those who can respond in kind, I think that's laudable. Even saintly.


I'm going to assume you're not being sarcastic here. I'd hardly call it saintly, I'd call simple reasonable human decency. Don't attack those weaker and less able to defend themselves than you are. And it's hardly uncommon (though, admittedly, less common than I'd like). I think most of us are able to grow up and function without becoming bullies.
 
Last edited:
For that analogy to work, one would have to equate cartoon Mohammed with race relations and the struggle for civil rights. I am not really getting the parallel. Perhaps you could make it plainer?
I really don't see how.

For example, in the analogy, who takes the place of the intrenched racist demanding blacks remain second-class citizens? Geller or the Jihadists or someone else? Is the poor security guard who got shot Rosa Parks?
Jihadis, Jihadis and their fellow travelers and no.

I can't tell if the analogy inappropriately elevates the cartoon Mohammed event or diminishes the civil rights movement. Both?
Neither, that's not its purpose.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom