Can a CharlieHebdo-type attack happen in the US?

So the "respect you would give to any of your fellow human beings" is actually dependent on how violent your fellow human beings happen to be. Fair enough.

Violence is certainly one indicator of just how much you've ticked someone off, so yes. If I think a cop is going to punch me if I call them a "dirty pig," I will be less likely to voice my opinion, even if I think that particular cop really is a dirty pig.

I assumed others modified their behaviors depending on the likely outcome as well. Is this not so? Am I some kind of outlier?
 
Wow. So you'll be a dick... to those who can't hit back. Way to tackle the big issues sport.

Is this really so strange? Do others reserve their dickishness only for those who are directly able to harm them? I find that remarkable.

Unless... perhaps we aren't talking about how any of us actually operate in the real world? Is it too much to bear?
 
Again, this is the relevant question. I had the courtesy to answer yours, how about doing the same.

No, the question is who gets to decide which speech intended to offend is needless and which isn't. The guy with the biggest stick, I guess.

Where such speech acts are not prohibited, the speaker decides. We are free to criticize that decision.

I think Geller would say the event served a necessary purpose. I disagree.
 
Again, this is the relevant question. I had the courtesy to answer yours, how about doing the same.

No, the question is who gets to decide which speech intended to offend is needless and which isn't. The guy with the biggest stick, I guess.

The government decides it. Offensive speech is generally allowed (I think there's some "fighting words" exception). Speech that puts people in danger needlessly (i.e., yelling, "Fire in a crowded theater" when there is no fire) is not allowed.
 
That's progress. You agree that the cartoon contest was about insulting their prophet then?

No. It was about insulting the Islamists. One way to do that is to draw cartoons which insult Mohammed. Another way to do that is to draw cartoons which include but do not insult Mohammed. The contest only required the cartoon to contain Mohammed, whether the artist chose to make it insulting or not was a decision left to each artist.
 
No. It was about insulting the Islamists. One way to do that is to draw cartoons which insult Mohammed. Another way to do that is to draw cartoons which include but do not insult Mohammed. The contest only required the cartoon to contain Mohammed, whether the artist chose to make it insulting or not was a decision left to each artist.

Agreed. Although I would actually say that it was about defying the Islamists, not insulting them. Of course, Islamists would consider defiance to be an insult, but they're not strictly the same thing.
 
No. It was about insulting the Islamists. One way to do that is to draw cartoons which insult Mohammed. Another way to do that is to draw cartoons which include but do not insult Mohammed. The contest only required the cartoon to contain Mohammed, whether the artist chose to make it insulting or not was a decision left to each artist.

Agreed. Although I would actually say that it was about defying the Islamists, not insulting them. Of course, Islamists would consider defiance to be an insult, but they're not strictly the same thing.

It is framed quite well by the winning entry.

The cartoon shows Mohammed saying, "You can't draw me!" and the response from the artist, "That's why I draw you."

This is a video clip of the Sean Hannity show where she and an imam talk over one another about the aftermath of the event, including a Fatwah issued against Geller.



I can't find anyone to support in that (including the host), but the imam does refer to the images as insulting.
 
I'm not the one who has said he will defer to Muslim wishes

It wasn't me, either.

so your continued attempts to make this about me are not well done.

YOU made it about you when you hinted that you were so much more courageous than me, when this discussion isn't about either of us. If you can't take it, you shouldn't dish it out.
 
That does seem to be the final argument of the appeasers, be nice to Muslims or they'll kill you.

And yet another strawman. It would really be nice if you were able to properly follow a conversation and contribute to it rather than find a "side" in a debate to insult.
 
Violence is certainly one indicator of just how much you've ticked someone off, so yes. If I think a cop is going to punch me if I call them a "dirty pig," I will be less likely to voice my opinion, even if I think that particular cop really is a dirty pig.

I assumed others modified their behaviors depending on the likely outcome as well. Is this not so? Am I some kind of outlier?

Keyboard warriors would definitely tell that cop that he's a dirty pig.
 
The freedom of speech surely means one is free to be an a-hole if one chooses too. The fault here is not in the a-holes but in the perpetrators. We should never forget that or make allowances for people who feel free to kill someone for simply saying what they want to - whatever their motivation.

A vitally important point which is overlooked or denied too often in these cases.In a civilised society being an a-hole is NOT a capital offence.
 
You don't have to ban anything. You also don't have to be surprised when incitement incites. And, if the consequences can be inferred, then there's a negligence element in play.

If I know a dog is likely to bite me and I taunt the dog, then where's my complaint when I get bit? I am left to complain that dogs bite. Well, duh.


No. Sorry, but human beings should have greater awareness of consequences than dogs and be able to judge the appropriateness of their actions. To suggest otherwise for a specific demographic could be considered religionist. (I know that is not your intention and you are a very fair minded person from previous interactions). If Christians attacked a Piss Christ exhibition with machine guns I really doubt anyone here would be suggesting the artist was responsible.

I'd also point out that this isn't 'in your face' taunting such as would provoke a dog (or many people who are otherwise restrained) but very indirect and out of sight unless you choose to go see it. That point is however secondary.
 
Last edited:
Lesson learned:
The best and most effective place to hold your free speech rally is in a basement, where you talk quietly amongst yourselves and avoid anything controversial. Don't advertise it, or in any way draw attention to it or people who disagree with you might not like it.
 
It wasn't me, either.



YOU made it about you when you hinted that you were so much more courageous than me, when this discussion isn't about either of us. If you can't take it, you shouldn't dish it out.

you really ought to respond to what I actually post and not what you think I hinted at.

I was referring to Pamela and the fact that she is more courageous than those who say she should be silenced but to not have the guts to do what she does.
 
Lo and behold:



Word salad. Maybe you should stop digging?

This is the same nonsense that conservatives tried when the Duck Dynasty moron got "fired" from A&E. Yes, conservatives love themselves some freedom, so long as it's their brand of freedoms.

No one is limiting your freedom of speech. No. One.

If you want to engage in rhetoric and dickish behavior intended to elicit (or that you know damn well will elicit) a response of pissing people off (kinda like real-ife trolling), then by all means feel free.

But when your freedom of speech gets you punched in the face, don't come whining about how your rights are being quashed.

Or, don't be a dick. That works too.

Lesson learned:
The best and most effective place to hold your free speech rally is in a basement, where you talk quietly amongst yourselves and avoid anything controversial. Don't advertise it, or in any way draw attention to it or people who disagree with you might not like it.

Who said anything about giving up free speech ? Do you even know what's being discussed here ?

Someone doesn't.
 
Lesson learned:
The best and most effective place to hold your free speech rally is in a basement, where you talk quietly amongst yourselves and avoid anything controversial. Don't advertise it, or in any way draw attention to it or people who disagree with you might not like it.

Even that might not be enough.
 
Where such speech acts are not prohibited, the speaker decides. We are free to criticize that decision.

I think Geller would say the event served a necessary purpose. I disagree.

The final arbiter on which events serve a necessary purpose are those who decide which events to fatally attack and which not to.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom