Can a CharlieHebdo-type attack happen in the US?

You don't have to respect their beliefs. You don't have to go that far. All that is required is to treat them with the respect you would give to any of your fellow human beings.

Is that a yes or a no on lampooning L. Ron Hubbard. Because I'm pretty sure some people might find that needlessly offensive and disrespectful.
 
That's why I'm asking people how Geller's little stunt was different than a clan rally in, say, Baltimore.

Well, first off the klan is a murdering, raping terrorist group. But, even in their case, they can claim a need for their rally with no objective way to disqualify it as such.
 
Is that a yes or a no on lampooning L. Ron Hubbard. Because I'm pretty sure some people might find that needlessly offensive and disrespectful.

What are you asking me? If I would lampoon Scientology? Yes, I would and I have. Are you asking me to evaluate the "dickishness" of such a thing? From the perspective of a Scientologist, I'm pretty sure it's quite offensive, hence dickish. That's part of the point - to offend Scientologists.

Does any of that mean that being offensive should be a general policy? No. Like anything else, it's a weapon one should wield to achieve a certain result. In the case of Scientology, to mock the quasi-religion or LRon.

Now, what if I could reasonably expect to be attacked and possibly killed for mocking LRon? I think that would elevate my dickishness to an entirely new level, one based on the consequences.

Haven't many Scientologists who left the organization had to face something similar? Threats of legal action (maybe violence too, I'm not sure) if they talked negatively about their time in Scientology. And this worked to some degree. It probably still works. If Scientology has "the goods" on me by way of recorded sessions where I've confessed the nasty, I will be less prone to give them an excuse to publish my confessions.
 
Remember the "reverse psychology" we find so effective when controlling children? When they want to be contentious and disobedient, so we tell them some nonsense, knowing they will react in the opposite way and thereby doing what we wanted?

Drawing Mohammed is meaningless to me. Unless I am informed that it irritates Muslims and I want to irritate Muslims. So the Muslims who want to show how terrible I am make a big deal out of it. And when I do it, because, darn it, I'm free to do it, then they can say, "Look at these people, they don't have any respect for us or our beliefs, they are evil and it is right to attack them."

We are playing their game here.

Actually the better way for them to get you to stop doing something you don't care about, but irritates them, is to not display irritation - that way you look like a dick for doing something that doesn't work.

By getting bolshie about it, they are playing our game here. :dc_biggrin:
 
Well, first off the klan is a murdering, raping terrorist group. But, even in their case, they can claim a need for their rally with no objective way to disqualify it as such.

I'm not arguing what they can claim. We've already established they have a right to march down the street with their stupid hoods on.

I'm not arguing what they believe. It's disgusting. But then, so were a lot of the cartoons that were drawn. So are a lot of beliefs about Muslims.

The question is, is a KKK rally in a black neighborhood a really stupid thing that you would have nothing to do with? AND, if innocent people got killed in a drive-by shooting by some gangbangers who were targeting the KKK members, would you put any blame on the KKK?
 
What are you asking me? If I would lampoon Scientology? Yes, I would and I have. Are you asking me to evaluate the "dickishness" of such a thing? From the perspective of a Scientologist, I'm pretty sure it's quite offensive, hence dickish. That's part of the point - to offend Scientologists.

Does any of that mean that being offensive should be a general policy? No. Like anything else, it's a weapon one should wield to achieve a certain result. In the case of Scientology, to mock the quasi-religion or LRon.

Now, what if I could reasonably expect to be attacked and possibly killed for mocking LRon? I think that would elevate my dickishness to an entirely new level, one based on the consequences.

You don't have to respect their beliefs. You don't have to go that far. All that is required is to treat them with the respect you would give to any of your fellow human beings.

So the "respect you would give to any of your fellow human beings" is actually dependent on how violent your fellow human beings happen to be. Fair enough.
 
I'm not arguing what they can claim. We've already established they have a right to march down the street with their stupid hoods on.

I'm not arguing what they believe. It's disgusting. But then, so were a lot of the cartoons that were drawn. So are a lot of beliefs about Muslims.

The question is, is a KKK rally in a black neighborhood a really stupid thing that you would have nothing to do with? AND, if innocent people got killed in a drive-by shooting by some gangbangers who were targeting the KKK members, would you put any blame on the KKK?

It wasn't a klan rally so your whole post is irrelevant.
 
What are you asking me? If I would lampoon Scientology? Yes, I would and I have. Are you asking me to evaluate the "dickishness" of such a thing? From the perspective of a Scientologist, I'm pretty sure it's quite offensive, hence dickish. That's part of the point - to offend Scientologists.

Does any of that mean that being offensive should be a general policy? No. Like anything else, it's a weapon one should wield to achieve a certain result. In the case of Scientology, to mock the quasi-religion or LRon.

Now, what if I could reasonably expect to be attacked and possibly killed for mocking LRon? I think that would elevate my dickishness to an entirely new level, one based on the consequences.

Haven't many Scientologists who left the organization had to face something similar? Threats of legal action (maybe violence too, I'm not sure) if they talked negatively about their time in Scientology. And this worked to some degree. It probably still works. If Scientology has "the goods" on me by way of recorded sessions where I've confessed the nasty, I will be less prone to give them an excuse to publish my confessions.

Wow. So you'll be a dick... to those who can't hit back. Way to tackle the big issues sport.
 
I'm not arguing what they can claim. We've already established they have a right to march down the street with their stupid hoods on.

I'm not arguing what they believe. It's disgusting. But then, so were a lot of the cartoons that were drawn. So are a lot of beliefs about Muslims.

The question is, is a KKK rally in a black neighborhood a really stupid thing that you would have nothing to do with? AND, if innocent people got killed in a drive-by shooting by some gangbangers who were targeting the KKK members, would you put any blame on the KKK?

No, the question is who gets to decide which speech intended to offend is needless and which isn't. The guy with the biggest stick, I guess.
 
You don't have to respect their beliefs. You don't have to go that far. All that is required is to treat them with the respect you would give to any of your fellow human beings.

Well, plus that little extra respect to not insult their prophet.
 
But if you just drew a cartoon that incited those actions it would be OK, right?

No, because it's the difference between action and reaction. It's pretty difficult to look at those Mahomet cartoons as a call to violence against Moslems or anybody else. Keep in mind that the Junior Johnny Jihadi and his roommate shot dead in the street aren't the actual victims in this story. The real victim is the guard shot in the ankle, yes, but the intended victims were Geller, Wilders, Spencer, the artists and attendees.

If someone shouts "Come at me, bro!" The "bro" addressed has the choice to walk away unless he's an easily goaded tough guy itching for a fight. But it's still his lack of self control that's the issue.
 
Only if the army of LRON can present a credible and violent enough threat to its blasphemers. After which lampooning Scientology qualifies you as an instigating dick.

That does seem to be the final argument of the appeasers, be nice to Muslims or they'll kill you.
 
No, the question is who gets to decide which speech intended to offend is needless and which isn't. The guy with the biggest stick, I guess.

Could you answer the questions I asked?

Would the clan rally in Baltimore be a stupid event you would have nothing to do with? Yes/No.
If an attack happened at the event that killed innocent people, would the KKK share any of the blame? Yes/No.

I'll give you my answers: Yes, and yes.
 
Last edited:
Could you answer the questions I asked?

Would the clan rally in Baltimore be a stupid event you would have nothing to do with? Yes/No.
If an attack happened at the event that killed innocent people, would the KKK share any of the blame? Yes/No.

I'll give you my answers: Yes, and yes.

Yes to the first and no to the second. I answered your questions and they're not even relevant. Here is what's relevant:

No, the question is who gets to decide which speech intended to offend is needless and which isn't. The guy with the biggest stick, I guess.
 
Last edited:
Yes to the first and no to the second. I answered your questions and they're not even relevant. Here is what's relevant:

The KKK wouldn't share any of the blame? Really? I can imagine what the reaction of this board would be, and it isn't your reaction, but anyway.

Here's why I think they would (and why I think the organizers of the cartoon contest also share some responsibility for the attack that occurred).

We know that Mohammed cartoons and KKK rallies make people upset. Upset people sometimes violently attack the people/person making them upset. Violent attacks can kill innocent people. Ergo, Mohammed cartoons and KKK rallies put innocent people at risk.

As a rule of thumb, it's not a good idea to put innocent people at risk, unless you have a good reason for whatever it is you're doing. Is declaring white supremacy in a black neighborhood a good reason for putting people at risk? No. Are cartoons of Mohammed a good reason for putting people at risk...

And that's where I think a lot of you fall short. No one has given a good reason why holding a contest to see who can draw the best caricature of Mohammed outweighs the risks to innocent people of being attacked.
 
Again, this is the relevant question. I had the courtesy to answer yours, how about doing the same.

No, the question is who gets to decide which speech intended to offend is needless and which isn't. The guy with the biggest stick, I guess.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom