Can a CharlieHebdo-type attack happen in the US?

The time frames involved here are cutting it so close that I don't think it'd be fair to the FBI to say they should have acted sooner. What I want to know is how someone can be under investigation for lying about wanting to join a mother-international ******* terrorist group - and one of the most vicious and anti-human ones at that - and only get sentenced to probation.

Here are two links, one with the FBI angle and another about links between a hacker and this case, because it's starting to sound like an echo chamber in here.

http://www.cnn.com/2015/05/07/politics/fbi-warning-elton-simpson-cartoon-event-attack/

http://www.cnn.com/2015/05/06/us/who-is-junaid-hussain-garland-texas-attack/
 
That wasn't bigotry. That was an example of the developers being dicks and Mayor Bloomberg being a mega-dick (of course, it was already well-known that if you give Bloomberg a backrub, he gets taller).

Do you know how *********** hard it is to get approved to build an 11-story complex in downtown Manhattan when you don't even have financing in place? Don't you think the city has an interest in not having a half-assed construction project abandoned after ground is broken? This was nothing but government subsidization of religion in disguised form, so that Bloomberg could flaunt his warped sense of noblesse oblige.

And no, it's not bigotry to be offended by the building of a mosque (which is clearly a prominent symbol of Islam) near the site of an atrocity committed in the name of Islam, especially when the location was chosen specifically to be near that site.

I think somebody's bigotry is showing..and it' not just Gellar's.

The other great Mosque controversy was in Murfressboro Tennesee.If you want to see a case of pure bigotry aided and abbeted by pandering politicians in action.
Managed to give Murfreesboro a black eye in the first time it made the headlines since the Battle of Murfreesobro in 1862.
 
I suppose I should start a thread on Pamela Geller to give the evidence of her vile bigotry a fair hearing. I keep asking her detractors why they think she's a bigot, and nobody has ever been able to give me a good reason.

Here's Geraldo going on about wanting to take a shower every time he sees her on TV. No doubt the feeling is mutual. I know that I feel all itchy whenever I see his mustache twitch. Probably because it means he's about to saying something obnoxious and stupid.

Did you become politically active after 2008? I can't believe you've never heard of her. An interesting tidbit factoid, Little Green Footballs (yeah, THAT Little Green Footballs) and the rest of the Pajamas Media group which included Atlas Shrugs (Pamela Geller) use to be the ne plus ultra of Right Wing nuttery. After Obama was elected she went further off the deep end and the LGF decided not to go with her.

Anyway, this didn't take to long to find:
http://www.nytimes.com/2010/10/10/nyregion/10geller.html?pagewanted=all
 
In which particular statement(s) do you see evidence of bigotry?

Well,I think de facto denying Muslims their basic right to build a house of Worship is a good one for starters.
If Anti Muslim bigtoty is becoming a litmus test for being a Conservative, then I do not want to be called a Conservative.
 
Did you become politically active after 2008? I can't believe you've never heard of her. An interesting tidbit factoid, Little Green Footballs (yeah, THAT Little Green Footballs) and the rest of the Pajamas Media group which included Atlas Shrugs (Pamela Geller) use to be the ne plus ultra of Right Wing nuttery. After Obama was elected she went further off the deep end and the LGF decided not to go with her.

I didn't say I never heard of her. In fact, I have known of her for many years, although I never really knew anything about her. I had never clicked over to her blog, until a couple of days ago. If you're reading LGF, then I submit you're getting a very distorted view of the right wing blogosphere. Charles Johnson is as nutty as David Brock.


And what of it? Do you want to quote a section for me to focus on?
 
I think somebody's bigotry is showing..and it' not just Gellar's.

The other great Mosque controversy was in Murfressboro Tennesee.If you want to see a case of pure bigotry aided and abbeted by pandering politicians in action.
Managed to give Murfreesboro a black eye in the first time it made the headlines since the Battle of Murfreesobro in 1862.

I've already discussed both mosque controversies in thread. If you would like to make an actual argument in favor of your proposition, be my guest.
 
That wasn't bigotry. That was an example of the developers being dicks and Mayor Bloomberg being a mega-dick (of course, it was already well-known that if you give Bloomberg a backrub, he gets taller).

Do you know how *********** hard it is to get approved to build an 11-story complex in downtown Manhattan when you don't even have financing in place? Don't you think the city has an interest in not having a half-assed construction project abandoned after ground is broken? This was nothing but government subsidization of religion in disguised form, so that Bloomberg could flaunt his warped sense of noblesse oblige.

And no, it's not bigotry to be offended by the building of a mosque (which is clearly a prominent symbol of Islam) near the site of an atrocity committed in the name of Islam, especially when the location was chosen specifically to be near that site.


You asked for an example of Geller's bigotry, and I gave it to you. You may think differently about that situation, but I'm not going to debate it all over again here. If you want to bump that old thread or start a new thread about the ground zero mosque, then maybe I'll join that discussion.
 
No one (that I'm aware of) is arguing that offensive Islamic cartoons should be banned. Certainly I'm not.

Rather, the issue is what other people have brought up: was the contest a "dick move"? To me a dick is someone who needlessly upsets another person. Was organizing a Mohammed caricature contest as much a dick move as a KKK rally in a black neighborhood?

I claim it was simply because there is no good reason to sponsor cartoons of Mohammed or hold a KKK rally. There is no upside and a huge potential downside. In both cases there's the foreknowledge that a large number of people will become upset (possibly upset enough to do something violent). So why do it? To show we won't be cowed? To show we won't be bullied into not making Mohammed cartoons?

For those who disagree (who think the cartoon contest wasn't "dickish") I would like to know what the upside was to organizing this cartoon contest.
 
Only if you redefine "appeasement" so as to be completely unrelated to its current meaning. It's an exchange of goods, nothing more.

Do you buy into the "US created Al Qaeda" nonsense?

I am unfamiliar with the arguments. It sounds unlikely though.
 
In the case of Schenck the SCOTUS believed it meant handing out leaflets.

Leaflets encouraging people to break the law.

If Pam Gellar was out on the front steps telling an assembled crowd "The only good Moslem is a dead Moslem. If you're driving your car and one crosses the street ahead of you, speed up! He's probably on his way to suicide bomb a day care center anyways...hold on...there's one now! Get him! Get that filthy meteorite worshippin' idolator! Don't let him get away boys, someone get some rope over here!"

That would be a pretty clear cut case of incitement that wouldn't be protected speech.
 
No one (that I'm aware of) is arguing that offensive Islamic cartoons should be banned. Certainly I'm not.

Rather, the issue is what other people have brought up: was the contest a "dick move"? To me a dick is someone who needlessly upsets another person. Was organizing a Mohammed caricature contest as much a dick move as a KKK rally in a black neighborhood?

I claim it was simply because there is no good reason to sponsor cartoons of Mohammed or hold a KKK rally. There is no upside and a huge potential downside. In both cases there's the foreknowledge that a large number of people will become upset (possibly upset enough to do something violent). So why do it? To show we won't be cowed? To show we won't be bullied into not making Mohammed cartoons?

For those who disagree (who think the cartoon contest wasn't "dickish") I would like to know what the upside was to organizing this cartoon contest.

The dick move is threatening violence.
 
Why should I respect their beliefs? Maybe we should respect Scientology's beliefs and quit lampooning L. Ron?

Only if the army of LRON can present a credible and violent enough threat to its blasphemers. After which lampooning Scientology qualifies you as an instigating dick.
 
Why should I respect their beliefs? Maybe we should respect Scientology's beliefs and quit lampooning L. Ron?

You don't have to respect their beliefs. You don't have to go that far. All that is required is to treat them with the respect you would give to any of your fellow human beings.
 
Did you become politically active after 2008? I can't believe you've never heard of her. An interesting tidbit factoid, Little Green Footballs (yeah, THAT Little Green Footballs) and the rest of the Pajamas Media group which included Atlas Shrugs (Pamela Geller) use to be the ne plus ultra of Right Wing nuttery. After Obama was elected she went further off the deep end and the LGF decided not to go with her.

Anyway, this didn't take to long to find:
http://www.nytimes.com/2010/10/10/nyregion/10geller.html?pagewanted=all

Who ever considered LGF to be extreme right wing nuttery? I'm progressive, and I never thought it was even close to that. The Geller wing, however, are racist filth.
 
No one (that I'm aware of) is arguing that offensive Islamic cartoons should be banned. Certainly I'm not.

Rather, the issue is what other people have brought up: was the contest a "dick move"? To me a dick is someone who needlessly upsets another person. Was organizing a Mohammed caricature contest as much a dick move as a KKK rally in a black neighborhood?

As I've said, I despise Geller and the rest of her team Jackass. But the highlighted word is extraordinarily subjective.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom