Can a CharlieHebdo-type attack happen in the US?

I support Pamela Geller the way I support the KKK walking down Mainstreet, USA. They get to do it. But to call them heroes for saying truth to power and making a stand for whatever-would be a bit of a stretch.
 
I suppose I should start a thread on Pamela Geller to give the evidence of her vile bigotry a fair hearing. I keep asking her detractors why they think she's a bigot, and nobody has ever been able to give me a good reason.

Here's Geraldo going on about wanting to take a shower every time he sees her on TV. No doubt the feeling is mutual. I know that I feel all itchy whenever I see his mustache twitch. Probably because it means he's about to saying something obnoxious and stupid.
 
Kindness has nothing to do with it. These terrorists feel the same way about drawings of Mohammed that are favorable (or even proselytizing) as ones that mock him. The Hadith forbids it and context doesn't matter.

Scenes that honor Muhammad for historical and legal significance, such as the frieze above the Supreme Court Justices, or statues outside of courthouses, are also forbidden, and have been changed or removed to appease Muslims.

They are using violence to try and force non-members of their religion to follow their religious tenants. I take offense at that. And to use your logic, they should just change the language of their religious laws to stop being such dicks.

Agreed, 100%.
 
I suppose I should start a thread on Pamela Geller to give the evidence of her vile bigotry a fair hearing. I keep asking her detractors why they think she's a bigot, and nobody has ever been able to give me a good reason.

I've never heard of her before this thread, but according to wikipedia:

She also published many controversial claims, some of which she later distanced herself from, including that Obama's mother was involved in pornography, that his "spiritual father" was a child rapist, that Obama "was involved with a crack whore in his youth", and that Malcolm X had impregnated his mother.

I'm not interested enough to track down the original quotes, so I'll withhold judgement.

She's also got a blog called Atlas Shrugged which probably somehow equates to bigotry for many.
 
I've never heard of her before this thread, but according to wikipedia:



I'm not interested enough to track down the original quotes, so I'll withhold judgement.

She's also got a blog called Atlas Shrugged which probably somehow equates to bigotry for many.

I clicked on the source link at wikipedia for the Malcolm X quote, she claims that was written by someone else:

UPDATE January 2009: The “Atlas says that Barack Obama is Malcolm X’s love child” charge has gone viral among leftists and lizards. The only problem with it is that it is false. I am not the author of this post, and I posted it because the writer did a spectacular job documenting Obama’s many connections with the Far Left. The Malcolm X claim is one minor part of this story, and was of interest to me principally as part of the writer’s documentation that Stanley Ann Dunham could not have been where the Obama camp says she was at various times. I do not believe that Barack Obama is Malcolm X’s love child, and never did — but there remain many, many unanswered questions about his early life and upbringing.

source: http://pamelageller.com/2008/10/how-could-stanl.html/
 
To OP, yes.

In reference to the question that titles the thread? Then yeah, we agree. I think it's actually the first word of the post. It will eventually happen. Unless everybody buckles under. But I don't see that happening, there's always going to be firebrands and there will always be people who the only reason they do do something is because someone, somewhere told them not to. Usually they're teenagers though.

Do I think these two jokers were ISIS and ISIS was behind it? No way, no matter what ISIS says. I think it much more likely that they're "fellow travelers" or this was a Lee Oswald "Look how serious I am Fidel" kind of unsolicited audition.

But somebody will get lucky, eventually.
 
Speaking of not having a conversation, did you really think I wouldn't notice that you changed the parameters of the discussion ? Marplots sure noticed it, too. I never said it was alright.

You continue to conflate pragmatic considerations and objective statements with value judgments and opinions. Stop that.

I see, you are willing to give up free speech but not the bacon.
 
No.

Does that mean that our interactions with other Muslim nations, nations that presumably support some version of Sharia law, do not count as appeasement? It would be interesting to see how the line is drawn.

Only if you redefine "appeasement" so as to be completely unrelated to its current meaning. It's an exchange of goods, nothing more.

Do you buy into the "US created Al Qaeda" nonsense?
 
You may be making a baseless accusation here, and responding in kind to another post, but I just feel the need to remind people that there are a lot, and I mean a lot of people on the left and on the far left that are x-tians. Being x-tian or believing in fictitious garbage like god or gods or jesus or zeus and those things aren't exclusive to those on the right.

Don't go trying to upset the paradigm!

But the majority of people killed by Islamists are Moslems. Either for being the wrong kind of Moslem or just not Moslem enough. Intra religious strife is generally worse than the interreligious variety.


I thought more people might notice that I said the far left had no balls at all.
 
You think it's an insult ? I'm asking you if you believe you are as brave as you'd want me to be.

Instead of trying to make "clever" comebacks, it would be nice if you'd try to have an actual discussion and understand what people are telling you.

I'm not the one who has said he will defer to Muslim wishes so your continued attempts to make this about me are not well done.
 
I suppose I should start a thread on Pamela Geller to give the evidence of her vile bigotry a fair hearing. I keep asking her detractors why they think she's a bigot, and nobody has ever been able to give me a good reason.


The "ground zero mosque" controversy and protest was started up by Geller. That was bigotry, top to bottom. There was at least one thread about it back in the day. It can easily be resurrected if you care to search it out.
 
ETA: I have not read "Infidel" - the comic book in question. Too cheap to pay for it.

You and me both brother. And for some reason nobody's torrented it. Funny that.

But I have read Frank Miller's HOLY TERROR which began as a Batman v Bin Laden project and ended as something...I don't want to appear to have a poor vocabulary but I can't describe it. Let's leave it as bad, just so very bad.
 
Its amazing how quickly someone cowering in the corner can change into someone who doesn't want to be a dick if you just change the language up a bit.

The "don't be a dick" thing has been brought up a lot; and IMO is completely specious.

If you're BBQing a rack of pork ribs and heavy smoke from the grill bothers your neighbor because the grill is too close to his house, he asks you to be a little more considerate, and you refuse because it's your right to BBQ whenever and wherever you want in your own yard; then you're being a dick. Your neighbor is making a reasonable complaint, and it would be good manners to accommodate his request to the extent you are able.

If you're BBQing a rack of pork ribs, and the neighbor complains because it's an unclean animal and he should have to be subjected to the smell, and you refuse it's your right to BBQ whenever and wherever you want in your own yard; you're not being a dick (unless you go out of your way to denigrate him for making the request, then that's kind of dickish). His request that you adhere to the tenets of a religious belief that you do not share is unreasonable. It doesn't harm him in any way, it's only his religious sensibilities that are being affected.

In the case of this event, there was a mix of dickishness and non-dickishness. Some of the artwork was quite well done, and contained incisive criticisms of Islamic fundamentalism, particularly with regard to its treatment of women. Some of the artwork was crap, and nothing more than flat insults made by jackasses. But even the latter is in no way justification for violence.
 
Remember the "reverse psychology" we find so effective when controlling children? When they want to be contentious and disobedient, so we tell them some nonsense, knowing they will react in the opposite way and thereby doing what we wanted?

Drawing Mohammed is meaningless to me. Unless I am informed that it irritates Muslims and I want to irritate Muslims. So the Muslims who want to show how terrible I am make a big deal out of it. And when I do it, because, darn it, I'm free to do it, then they can say, "Look at these people, they don't have any respect for us or our beliefs, they are evil and it is right to attack them."

We are playing their game here.

Why should I respect their beliefs? Maybe we should respect Scientology's beliefs and quit lampooning L. Ron?
 
Hey! Don't quash the vibe.

If you need proof, just look at the base of the Statue of Liberty. I wager you will be unable to find the depiction of Mohammed there. It's simply gone. No doubt removed by cowardly appeasers. (That latter might be redundant.)

If any post in this thread is an example of being a dick, as well as spouting off sheer ignorance, it would be this one.
 
It's the royal we. Or it's whatever "we" is required to make the statement true. Or it's a linguistic device meaning, "I think you'll agree with this part."



I think what you wrote is particularly good, except I didn't mean "children" in a derogatory way necessarily. I don't think we completely abandon our childlike attributes. (There's that troublesome "we" again!)

I certainly agree with you that Islam has some deep thinkers, as does any religion worth the title (save maybe Scientology). But none of this means they, and we, don't sometimes act rashly or have outliers prone to violence. I think it is a mistake to link violence only with the more neanderthal leaning among us as well.

But even divorced from the larger sphere of Islam, these terrorists would present the same choice to us: Do this thing and risk that response, or don't do this thing.

I propose that the west has its own brand of extremist, and Geller represents that sect in some measure. In the same fashion that I would expect moderate Muslims to reject the terrorists, I reject Geller's organization. There are more than two sides here, more than the poles.

There are those that speak words and those that shoot bullets at the speakers.
 
The "ground zero mosque" controversy and protest was started up by Geller. That was bigotry, top to bottom. There was at least one thread about it back in the day. It can easily be resurrected if you care to search it out.

That wasn't bigotry. That was an example of the developers being dicks and Mayor Bloomberg being a mega-dick (of course, it was already well-known that if you give Bloomberg a backrub, he gets taller).

Do you know how *********** hard it is to get approved to build an 11-story complex in downtown Manhattan when you don't even have financing in place? Don't you think the city has an interest in not having a half-assed construction project abandoned after ground is broken? This was nothing but government subsidization of religion in disguised form, so that Bloomberg could flaunt his warped sense of noblesse oblige.

And no, it's not bigotry to be offended by the building of a mosque (which is clearly a prominent symbol of Islam) near the site of an atrocity committed in the name of Islam, especially when the location was chosen specifically to be near that site.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom