Can a CharlieHebdo-type attack happen in the US?

Can you provide evidence that we buy oil from and sell arms to ISIS and the Taliban?

No.

Does that mean that our interactions with other Muslim nations, nations that presumably support some version of Sharia law, do not count as appeasement? It would be interesting to see how the line is drawn.
 
No, marplots. We are playing their game if we give in to their threats and stop drawing Mohammed as a result. Reverse psychology does not work by giving a child what they want in response to a temper tantrum.

We aren't stopping something so much as not starting it in the first place. If it didn't bother Muslims, no one would do it.

When a child swears and gets a reaction from mom, he doesn't care what the swear word means or why it's forbidden, he only knows he can say it and get a reaction. It becomes a tool to generate a certain response, to influence mom's behavior.
 
We aren't stopping something so much as not starting it in the first place. If it didn't bother Muslims, no one would do it.

What you mean "we", white man?

When a child swears and gets a reaction from mom, he doesn't care what the swear word means or why it's forbidden, he only knows he can say it and get a reaction. It becomes a tool to generate a certain response, to influence mom's behavior.

And so what does a parent do? You would have the parent provide the response that the child desires.

But the whole notion that we're dealing with children here is itself racist. Radical Islam is not an ideology of morons. It is barbaric, it is horrific, but it is not ignorant, it is not stupid. There is a vast body of intellectual work supporting it. Its most dangerous adherents are not toothless hicks with barely enough sense to wipe their own asses, but educated scholars. I don't care that the belief that we even can treat them like children is insulting to them, the real problem is that it's dangerously naive on our part if we even try.
 
Malala Yousef brought it on herself. She knew the risks and she endangered innocent bystanders when she provoked the Taliban to shoot her in the head for introducing girls to education. If the average Muslim is one Mohammed cartoon away from supporting mass murder or becoming a mass murderer then Muslims are animals. The fact that local Muslims ignored the event is very reassuring that the average Muslim probably doesn't need the amount of deference they are receiving in this thread.


Excellent point!

Many posters here are trying their hardest to come up with a good reason why the freedom of expression we enjoy should be limited, including BBQing pork!

Two people reacted violently to this event. Those people are called terrorists. People here are correct to compare this to the burning of an abortion clinic. It's a few radicals who want to use fear to get what they want, that is all. We don't change abortion laws for them, we open more clinics.

After reading and participating in this thread, it's no wonder our government is able to trample privacy rights in this country so easily. This is bringing Political Correctness to a dangerous extreme.
 
What you mean "we", white man?

It's the royal we. Or it's whatever "we" is required to make the statement true. Or it's a linguistic device meaning, "I think you'll agree with this part."

But the whole notion that we're dealing with children here is itself racist. Radical Islam is not an ideology of morons. It is barbaric, it is horrific, but it is not ignorant, it is not stupid. There is a vast body of intellectual work supporting it. Its most dangerous adherents are not toothless hicks with barely enough sense to wipe their own asses, but educated scholars. I don't care that the belief that we even can treat them like children is insulting to them, the real problem is that it's dangerously naive on our part if we even try.

I think what you wrote is particularly good, except I didn't mean "children" in a derogatory way necessarily. I don't think we completely abandon our childlike attributes. (There's that troublesome "we" again!)

I certainly agree with you that Islam has some deep thinkers, as does any religion worth the title (save maybe Scientology). But none of this means they, and we, don't sometimes act rashly or have outliers prone to violence. I think it is a mistake to link violence only with the more neanderthal leaning among us as well.

But even divorced from the larger sphere of Islam, these terrorists would present the same choice to us: Do this thing and risk that response, or don't do this thing.

I propose that the west has its own brand of extremist, and Geller represents that sect in some measure. In the same fashion that I would expect moderate Muslims to reject the terrorists, I reject Geller's organization. There are more than two sides here, more than the poles.
 
Excellent point!

Many posters here are trying their hardest to come up with a good reason why the freedom of expression we enjoy should be limited, including BBQing pork!

Two people reacted violently to this event. Those people are called terrorists. People here are correct to compare this to the burning of an abortion clinic. It's a few radicals who want to use fear to get what they want, that is all. We don't change abortion laws for them, we open more clinics.

After reading and participating in this thread, it's no wonder our government is able to trample privacy rights in this country so easily. This is bringing Political Correctness to a dangerous extreme.

As far as I can tell, no one is advocating any ban or imposed limit on free speech, or free expression. At most, I am pointing out that someone should accept the foreseeable consequences of their expressions and bear the responsibility for those consequences to some extent.
 
And if you'd looked, you would have seen that they did. Spent a shut pile of money on security, preparing for the eventuality that someone would.go bananas very it. Accepting the potential consequences and preparing for them, while continuing on course is known as responsible exercise of rights.
Cowering and/or abandoning the.project over fear that someone might take offense is cowardice. .
 
And if you'd looked, you would have seen that they did. Spent a shut pile of money on security, preparing for the eventuality that someone would.go bananas very it. Accepting the potential consequences and preparing for them, while continuing on course is known as responsible exercise of rights.
Cowering and/or abandoning the.project over fear that someone might take offense is cowardice. .

Are those the only two alternatives? If I do not do the one, am I necessarily doing the other?
 
And if you'd looked, you would have seen that they did. Spent a shut pile of money on security, preparing for the eventuality that someone would.go bananas very it. Accepting the potential consequences and preparing for them, while continuing on course is known as responsible exercise of rights.
Cowering and/or abandoning the.project over fear the understanding that someone might take offense is cowardice kind.

Its amazing how quickly someone cowering in the corner can change into someone who doesn't want to be a dick if you just change the language up a bit.

Not surprisingly, it's also that easy to actually do it.
 
Yeah, that was disgusting.

Foolmewunz should pause and consider what his reaction would have been if a Teapartier had been shooting at some Liberal/Democrat function, say an Obama fundraiser. Presumably he would find any conservatives hoping that Democrat VIPs in attendance received a 'flesh wound' reprehensible.

You should hope and support safety of assembly and speech both for those you do and do not agree with. That's a key, perhaps the foundational, virtue for a healthy diverse democracy.

And that people on both sides of the poltical specturm seem not to understand this ,or ,worse,want actively to supress those of opposing opinions,is truly scary.
 
And if you'd looked, you would have seen that they did. Spent a shut pile of money on security, preparing for the eventuality that someone would.go bananas very it. Accepting the potential consequences and preparing for them, while continuing on course is known as responsible exercise of rights.
Cowering and/or abandoning the.project over fear that someone might take offense is cowardice. .

Glad someone finally used the word to describe what a lot of people here are advocating:Cowardice.

I think my signature line has some meaning here.
 
Its amazing how quickly someone cowering in the corner can change into someone who doesn't want to be a dick if you just change the language up a bit.

Not surprisingly, it's also that easy to actually do it.

Kindness has nothing to do with it. These terrorists feel the same way about drawings of Mohammed that are favorable (or even proselytizing) as ones that mock him. The Hadith forbids it and context doesn't matter.

Scenes that honor Muhammad for historical and legal significance, such as the frieze above the Supreme Court Justices, or statues outside of courthouses, are also forbidden, and have been changed or removed to appease Muslims.

They are using violence to try and force non-members of their religion to follow their religious tenants. I take offense at that. And to use your logic, they should just change the language of their religious laws to stop being such dicks.
 
Scenes that honor Muhammad for historical and legal significance, such as the frieze above the Supreme Court Justices, or statues outside of courthouses, are also forbidden, and have been changed or removed to appease Muslims.

Wait, what? The frieze in the SCOTUS building hasn't been changed or removed.
 
Wait, what? The frieze in the SCOTUS building hasn't been changed or removed.

The intent of it has. It was originally depicting Mohammad. It is now depicting someone else according to official tourist literature.

ETA:
An information sheet published by the Supreme Court’s curator office said the 80-year-old statue is “a well-intentioned attempt by the sculptor, Adolph Weinman, to honor Muhammad and it bears no resemblance to Muhammad.”

source: http://blogs.wsj.com/law/2015/01/14/muhammad-sculpture-inside-supreme-court-a-gesture-of-goodwill/
 
Last edited:
Wait, what? The frieze in the SCOTUS building hasn't been changed or removed.

Hey! Don't quash the vibe.

If you need proof, just look at the base of the Statue of Liberty. I wager you will be unable to find the depiction of Mohammed there. It's simply gone. No doubt removed by cowardly appeasers. (That latter might be redundant.)

And what about our coinage? Does even one of the new State quarters have an image of Mohammed? Nope. Redacted pre-production by Obama in a gesture of respect toward Islam.

It's all right there, staring us in the face by not staring us in the face.
 
The intent of it has. It was originally depicting Mohammad. It is now depicting someone else according to official tourist literature.

So what you meant by "the frieze...changed or removed" was really "tourist brochures have been edited."

When will the appeasement stop? :rolleyes:
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom