Can a CharlieHebdo-type attack happen in the US?

Well don't I look like an idiot, now. I didn't interpret "Noah" in that way at all.



NoahFence, yes. Yes, my mistake.

Noah, why introduce a left-vs-right dichotomy, here ? :p

The default xenophobic crowd is on the right. That's why I mentioned them as the US society equivalent of radical (aka dick) Muslims.

I wasn't comparing left vs. right.
 
Then when they demand that pork be removed from the groceries or they will burn them down you'll be alright with that?

Speaking of not having a conversation, did you really think I wouldn't notice that you changed the parameters of the discussion ? Marplots sure noticed it, too. I never said it was alright.

You continue to conflate pragmatic considerations and objective statements with value judgments and opinions. Stop that.
 
OK, here's my protocol. Pick a convenience store at random. I predict I can present an item to the cashier and they will tell me how much I have to pay to obtain that item. I'll even propose a 95% confidence interval for predicting their behavior.

Still wanna bet a million?


Disingenuous non sequitor. That was not the context, which you are well aware of. Changing the context of a debate is both dishonest, and a logical fallacy.

It is the fact that they are rational actors that makes them somewhat predictable.


Except that wasn't your claim, you exact claim was that they are absolutely predictable. Would you like me to quote the post where you said that?

The responsibility is distributed in the same way, yes. The critical difference is comparing the right to draw insulting cartoons of Mohammed to the right to have an abortion. The second is worth risking lives over. The first is not.


First, that's a particularly bad piece of moral relativism. Second, you're making a value judgement that you have yet to provide support for. You keep making the assertion, but provide no justification for it, aside from your personal preference.

Are you willing to assert that a cartoon Mohammed contest is equivalent to a woman's right to have an abortion? Because that's what your question requires.


They are both examples of things that are considered fundamental freedoms: the right of free expression, and the right of self-determination.

If you cannot distinguish between the two, no answer I give will satisfy.


Again, this is just a cop-out to evade the fact that you cannot effectively support your assertion with evidence or logic.
 
Well, it's obvious that this is going nowhere, and I suggest we drop it.


Since you've resorted to supercilious insults and mental masturbation instead of actually addressing the issues; then you're right.
 
Last edited:
So we've meandered into the Ground Zero Mosque, now Abu Ghraib... What else is there?

Oooh! I know!

Muslims started the Crusades!
 
The meat of the question is highlighted. I am willing to concede that I don't know the political leanings of the torturers. However, that does not change the fact that we HAVE seen this actually happen. At Abu Grhaib.

Wow, that's quite a goalpost move. The question wasn't about whether any muslims got tortured. You claimed that there were lots of conservatives who wanted to torture and murder Muslims, so the question (obviously) was why we weren't seeing conservatives torturing AND murdering Muslims because they are muslims. You have conceded that you do not know the politics of the people an Abu Ghraib, but you also don't know that they were tortured because they were Muslim. And there's little reason to think that had any relevance.

They're mutually exclusive? Bush and Rummy started a WAR. For chrissake they're as close to war criminals as this country can produce. We have the biggest stick which is the only reason either of those two cretins are still alive.

Still not relevant to your claim that lots of conservatives want to kill muslims.

Then this goes back to the top. Fine.

In which case Gardner and England are off your list, and you're left with just Bush and Rumsfeld. And you've given zero evidence that either of these people were interested in torturing and murdering Muslims because they are Muslims.

You can't back up your original claim at all.
 
Except that wasn't your claim, you exact claim was that they are absolutely predictable. Would you like me to quote the post where you said that?

If I said that, I was overstating the case. I won't require any evidence that I said it, so long as my position is clearer now.

Marplots:
The responsibility is distributed in the same way, yes. The critical difference is comparing the right to draw insulting cartoons of Mohammed to the right to have an abortion. The second is worth risking lives over. The first is not.

First, that's a particularly bad piece of moral relativism. Second, you're making a value judgement that you have yet to provide support for. You keep making the assertion, but provide no justification for it, aside from your personal preference.

On what basis, other than my personal preferences, can I ever assert a moral claim? My expectation is that another moral agent would agree with me, but it is true that my moral opinions are mine. I have no holy book to consult.

If you believe that abortion and drawing cartoons of Mohammed are equivalent, then we simply disagree on the relative merits. It's perhaps worth noting that some types of abortion are illegal, whereas no type of Mohammed cartoon is illegal to draw. So we already accept limits on abortion rights.


They are both examples of things that are considered fundamental freedoms: the right of free expression, and the right of self-determination.

It doesn't matter, does it? The fact that I have a right to do something does not compel me to do it. Those who support the right to have an abortion call it "freedom of choice" - pregnant women are free to choose to have the kid. So too, the Geller-yellers have the right to hold their event. This doesn't mean they must hold it. They have a choice. That choice is bound up with the consequences of choosing one way or another.

Choice comes with responsibility. If I choose to have the kid and not get the abortion, I am then responsible for that child. I must bear the burden, the consequences, of choosing one way or another.

Do you disagree with this?
 
How did we move from "I'll change my behavior in light of the negative consequences" to "alright with that?"

The two are separate. I can drive the speed limit because I don't want to risk getting a ticket, and still think the speed limit is set too low. If I had to agree with every demand made on me before I'd alter my behavior, I'd shortly be in jail.

There's a fundamental difference here that you haven't come to terms with.

Suppose you don't like the speed limit as it is, and think that it should be higher (or perhaps even non-existent). You contemplate whether or not to break it. The consequence for breaking it is that you might get a ticket.

But what's the consequence for not breaking it? Does obeying the speed limit risk producing further reductions in the speed limit? Would breaking the speed limit help to get the speed limit lifted? Well, no.

But do not imagine that the Islamists will be satisfied if only we don't draw any more Mohammed cartoons.
 
But do not imagine that the Islamists will be satisfied if only we don't draw any more Mohammed cartoons.

It really is just a basic economic analysis of incentive. "If threatening violence makes them stop drawing Mohammad, and I don't want them holding gay pride parades either, then..."
 
There's a fundamental difference here that you haven't come to terms with.

Suppose you don't like the speed limit as it is, and think that it should be higher (or perhaps even non-existent). You contemplate whether or not to break it. The consequence for breaking it is that you might get a ticket.

But what's the consequence for not breaking it? Does obeying the speed limit risk producing further reductions in the speed limit? Would breaking the speed limit help to get the speed limit lifted? Well, no.

But do not imagine that the Islamists will be satisfied if only we don't draw any more Mohammed cartoons.

You analogy fails for this reason:
With the speed limit, the behavior is identical and a matter of degree. With the Mohammed cartoon, there is no equivalent. I don't think you are arguing that if we capitulate and not draw Mohammed, we will then have to stop drawing other things.

What I get from your analogy is that capitulation for Mohammed cartoons is in a set of behaviors bound up with Islam and the religious requirements. If we take that same tone with the speed limits we would say, "If you obey a speed limit and agree to be subject to that law, what's to prevent the legislature from making other laws they will expect you to follow?" And the answer to that is: that's exactly what happens. We do obey the small laws and they do expect us to obey other laws. But each law is judged on it's merits. There is no direct correlation between obeying the speed limit and cutting my grass to avoid a fine.

Your second point is that resistance has the opposite effect. I don't think this is demonstrable, and here's why: The attacks increased, not decreased, without a change of behavior on our part. I mean that broadly, in the sense of Al Queda and ISIS emerging over the last decade or so as a threat. The threat arose without the stimulus you are proposing - they felt perfectly free to impose their beliefs on us regardless of our behaviors. Which means that even without provocation, there would be some level of attacks.

And if targeted behavior on our part (the provocation of insulting the prophet) only increases this base-level of attacks that would otherwise exist, it accomplishes nothing - our normal behavior is enough to piss off Muslim extremists. Rather than being a series of capitulations, the cartoon Mohammed bit is an add-on, designed to anger extremists. And, if the objective is to do that, well, score one for Geller. But what value do I lose if I do not draw Mohammed? Who here will spend their weekend lampooning the prophet of Islam? The entire exercise is artificial, fake.
 
Last edited:
It really is just a basic economic analysis of incentive. "If threatening violence makes them stop drawing Mohammad, and I don't want them holding gay pride parades either, then..."

And, in fact, that kind of escalation is exactly what we've seen in areas where radical Islamists like the Taliban and ISIS have asserted their violent influence. It has been a natural tendency of radicals throughout history, violent radicals in particular, to keep pushing for more and more accommodation until they achieve sufficient power to impose their worldview in full. Fortunately, most of the time these sorts of radicals have been forcibly resisted. Appeasement has never brought peace. At best, a "pax Romana" where all opponents have been killed or beaten to the point they were unable to resist.
 
Remember the "reverse psychology" we find so effective when controlling children? When they want to be contentious and disobedient, so we tell them some nonsense, knowing they will react in the opposite way and thereby doing what we wanted?

Drawing Mohammed is meaningless to me. Unless I am informed that it irritates Muslims and I want to irritate Muslims. So the Muslims who want to show how terrible I am make a big deal out of it. And when I do it, because, darn it, I'm free to do it, then they can say, "Look at these people, they don't have any respect for us or our beliefs, they are evil and it is right to attack them."

We are playing their game here.
 
And, in fact, that kind of escalation is exactly what we've seen in areas where radical Islamists like the Taliban and ISIS have asserted their violent influence. It has been a natural tendency of radicals throughout history, violent radicals in particular, to keep pushing for more and more accommodation until they achieve sufficient power to impose their worldview in full. Fortunately, most of the time these sorts of radicals have been forcibly resisted. Appeasement has never brought peace. At best, a "pax Romana" where all opponents have been killed or beaten to the point they were unable to resist.

You don't even need Taliban/ISIS-style extremism. India, for example, has tried to quell religious disagreement by criminalizing religious offense. It has only served to exacerbate the problem. Slight offenses are met with large riots.

If I had to play arm-chair psychologist, the reason would be a mix of two factors: One, the rioters know that the extreme response will serve to validate their personal feeling of offense. And two, such laws reinforce the notion that religious feelings are deserving of special protection.
 
And, in fact, that kind of escalation is exactly what we've seen in areas where radical Islamists like the Taliban and ISIS have asserted their violent influence. It has been a natural tendency of radicals throughout history, violent radicals in particular, to keep pushing for more and more accommodation until they achieve sufficient power to impose their worldview in full. Fortunately, most of the time these sorts of radicals have been forcibly resisted. Appeasement has never brought peace. At best, a "pax Romana" where all opponents have been killed or beaten to the point they were unable to resist.

You know we buy oil from these folks, right? And we sell them arms and such? If you are looking for appeasement, you need to look at the bigger picture, how we deal with Islamic nations, not just disorganized individuals.

However, if we accept that the Islamic worldview exists as part of the fabric of humanity, then perhaps we should continue our policy of negotiation and compromise. Or not. Maybe to avoid the slur of "appeasement" we should nuke the lot of them?
 
*Bolding mine*

Source the bolded bit please. Who are the members here, on ISF, that have said that shooting Geller is OK?

Name names.

Well, there is this, FWIW:

And, of course, Breitbart's ancillary prize (to the 10,000 that Geller was to award the "winning" cartoon) for "most popular".

I suppose it's too much to hope that they could've at least winged Geller and Wilder before getting killed? I don't wish death on anyone, but at least a little flesh wound? That's what they want, isn't it? Her tweet after the event.... no mention of the valiant cops or relief that the attendees weren't harmed... just a call to arms! She's only a slight step above the intended shooters.
 
Last edited:
You analogy fails for this reason:

It was your analogy, not mine.

With the speed limit, the behavior is identical and a matter of degree.

Not relevant. The same applies to any other law, including ones which cover binary behavior (you either are or are not doing the illegal action): does compliance with the law lead to more restrictive laws? No, it doesn't.

Your second point is that resistance has the opposite effect. I don't think this is demonstrable, and here's why: The attacks increased, not decreased, without a change of behavior on our part.

Did American casualties in WW2 increase or decrease after we declared war on Japan?

They increased.

A naive reading of events would suggest that we would be better off not having declared war on Japan after Pearl Harbor. Sure, we lost a few thousand soldiers in the attack, but that was nothing compared to our subsequent casualties.

But that isn't the way conflict works.

I mean that broadly, in the sense of Al Queda and ISIS emerging over the last decade or so as a threat. The threat arose without the stimulus you are proposing - they felt perfectly free to impose their beliefs on us regardless of our behaviors. Which means that even without provocation, there would be some level of attacks.

Quite true. Which is why it's a fool's errand to try to avoid giving offense.

But what do you suppose limits the rate of terrorist attacks? Do you think it's a lack of pretext? "Well, they haven't pissed us off THAT much, so let's only attack them once!" Or is it perhaps constrained by other factors? Do cartoons of Mohammed make any other constraints disappear?

And if targeted behavior on our part (the provocation of insulting the prophet) only increases this base-level of attacks that would otherwise exist

But it doesn't only do this. Those two terrorists killed in Texas were determined to become terrorists, one way or another. That they attacked now rather than a year from now is not a bad thing.

Rather than being a series of capitulations, the cartoon Mohammed bit is an add-on, designed to anger extremists. And, if the objective is to do that, well, score one for Geller.

I'm glad she pissed them off. They deserve to be pissed off.

But what value do I lose if I do not draw Mohammed?

If you never wanted to draw Mohammed, you lose nothing, and you gain nothing, by not drawing Mohammed. But I'm not demanding that you draw Mohammed. I'm saying that, in a general sense, it is a good thing that Mohammed cartoons are drawn. If you choose not to do so because you don't care about drawing Mohammed, that's fine. If you choose not to do so because you're scared of being attacked, that's a bad thing, though I can understand the choice. I don't pretend that I would be personally brave enough to accept the risk that Geller is accepting, but I'm glad she's accepting it. If you try to dissuade others from drawing Mohammed, I think that's also a bad thing, and I don't have sympathy for that choice.
 
Your second point is that resistance has the opposite effect. I don't think this is demonstrable, and here's why: The attacks increased, not decreased, without a change of behavior on our part. I mean that broadly, in the sense of Al Queda and ISIS emerging over the last decade or so as a threat. The threat arose without the stimulus you are proposing - they felt perfectly free to impose their beliefs on us regardless of our behaviors. Which means that even without provocation, there would be some level of attacks.

And if targeted behavior on our part (the provocation of insulting the prophet) only increases this base-level of attacks that would otherwise exist, it accomplishes nothing - our normal behavior is enough to piss off Muslim extremists. Rather than being a series of capitulations, the cartoon Mohammed bit is an add-on, designed to anger extremists. And, if the objective is to do that, well, score one for Geller. But what value do I lose if I do not draw Mohammed? Who here will spend their weekend lampooning the prophet of Islam? The entire exercise is artificial, fake.


Except that you're the one using artificial constraints to create a straw man you can refute. But the fact is that you're wrong. Your comments demonstrate both a redefinition of the context, and profound ignorance of history, both recent and ancient.

The ISIS and Al Qaeda threats are not even remotely new. They have multiple precedents throughout history. In fact, in many ways they mirror the history of the Nizari Isma'ili Muslims. The reason that they "feel perfectly free" to engage in violent attacks is because they have not yet met sufficient resistance. Skirmishes have been limited and small scale for the most part. This almost exact same pattern was seen with the Nizaris during the time of the Crusades. The Nizaris were a very small mystical and esoteric splinter sect of of Shi'a Islam, which engaged in campaigns of terror attacks on opposing Islamic sects to destabilize their larger and more powerful enemies. This went on for centuries, until the European Crusaders joined the battle with their invasions of the Middle East.

The Nizaris discovered that their campaign of terror did not work nearly as effectively on the Crusaders, due to a hierarchical structure less reliant on cult of personality than the dominant Islamic power structure; and found themselves the target of a much more effective and relentless campaign. They maintained a standoff, but lost much of their power, and agreed to truces with the invaders. Eventually, they were broken by the invading Mongol armies, with huge numbers of their people slaughtered, including nearly all of their leaders. Eventually, the Nizaris recovered, and reformed as a much more moderate sect emphasizing spiritual and intellectual growth.

We've seen similar results today with Al Qaeda. Concerted military effort has resulted in the elimination of their leader and all their major operatives, greatly reducing their power and reach. To the point where they are no longer anywhere near as significant a threat as they were just a couple decades ago. Similarly decisive military action will have the same effect on ISIS if and when anyone makes the decision to pursue it. The IRA is another example which eventually ended its terrorist activities and emphasized political action through it's Sinn Fein arm. The remaining hardliners have become increasingly factionalized and less effective in their violence; though they have not ended it entirely.

Again, this is reflected throughout history, with small terrorist organizations either being effectively wiped out, or eventually mutating into political organizations. It is purely a modern innovation that such groups are not killed off wholesale by their more powerful opponents as a matter of course.

Again, your comment that this sort of opposition to the extremists cannot have have any effect on their willingness to engage in violence and terror is refuted by millennia of historical examples.
 
Well, there is this, FWIW:

Yeah, that was disgusting.

Foolmewunz should pause and consider what his reaction would have been if a Teapartier had been shooting at some Liberal/Democrat function, say an Obama fundraiser. Presumably he would find any conservatives hoping that Democrat VIPs in attendance received a 'flesh wound' reprehensible.

You should hope and support safety of assembly and speech both for those you do and do not agree with. That's a key, perhaps the foundational, virtue for a healthy diverse democracy.
 
You know we buy oil from these folks, right? And we sell them arms and such? If you are looking for appeasement, you need to look at the bigger picture, how we deal with Islamic nations, not just disorganized individuals.


Can you provide evidence that we buy oil from and sell arms to ISIS and the Taliban?

However, if we accept that the Islamic worldview exists as part of the fabric of humanity, then perhaps we should continue our policy of negotiation and compromise. Or not. Maybe to avoid the slur of "appeasement" we should nuke the lot of them?


This is such a straw man I don't even know where to begin. Perhaps you could try responding to what I actually said, that would make it easier.

I will address this, when have you ever seen a fanatical terrorist group actively accept a compromise? I mean, that's pretty much the definition of a fanatic, after all.

I can't address anything else in that post. I'll let whoever actually said the things you're apparently responding to address them.
 
Remember the "reverse psychology" we find so effective when controlling children?

No, I don't remember that, because it doesn't actually work well. Seriously, have you ever tried using it on a two-year-old throwing a tantrum? It's about the stupidest parenting idea ever. There are actually very limited circumstances in which it will work.

Drawing Mohammed is meaningless to me. Unless I am informed that it irritates Muslims and I want to irritate Muslims. So the Muslims who want to show how terrible I am make a big deal out of it. And when I do it, because, darn it, I'm free to do it, then they can say, "Look at these people, they don't have any respect for us or our beliefs, they are evil and it is right to attack them."

We are playing their game here.

No, marplots. We are playing their game if we give in to their threats and stop drawing Mohammed as a result. Reverse psychology does not work by giving a child what they want in response to a temper tantrum.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom