You analogy fails for this reason:
It was your analogy, not mine.
With the speed limit, the behavior is identical and a matter of degree.
Not relevant. The same applies to any other law, including ones which cover binary behavior (you either are or are not doing the illegal action): does compliance with the law lead to more restrictive laws? No, it doesn't.
Your second point is that resistance has the opposite effect. I don't think this is demonstrable, and here's why: The attacks increased, not decreased, without a change of behavior on our part.
Did American casualties in WW2 increase or decrease after we declared war on Japan?
They increased.
A naive reading of events would suggest that we would be better off not having declared war on Japan after Pearl Harbor. Sure, we lost a few thousand soldiers in the attack, but that was nothing compared to our subsequent casualties.
But that isn't the way conflict works.
I mean that broadly, in the sense of Al Queda and ISIS emerging over the last decade or so as a threat. The threat arose without the stimulus you are proposing - they felt perfectly free to impose their beliefs on us regardless of our behaviors. Which means that even without provocation, there would be some level of attacks.
Quite true. Which is why it's a fool's errand to try to avoid giving offense.
But what do you suppose limits the rate of terrorist attacks? Do you think it's a lack of pretext? "Well, they haven't pissed us off THAT much, so let's only attack them once!" Or is it perhaps constrained by other factors? Do cartoons of Mohammed make any other constraints disappear?
And if targeted behavior on our part (the provocation of insulting the prophet) only increases this base-level of attacks that would otherwise exist
But it doesn't
only do this. Those two terrorists killed in Texas were determined to become terrorists, one way or another. That they attacked
now rather than a year from now is not a bad thing.
Rather than being a series of capitulations, the cartoon Mohammed bit is an add-on, designed to anger extremists. And, if the objective is to do that, well, score one for Geller.
I'm glad she pissed them off. They deserve to be pissed off.
But what value do I lose if I do not draw Mohammed?
If you never wanted to draw Mohammed, you lose nothing, and you gain nothing, by not drawing Mohammed. But I'm not demanding that
you draw Mohammed. I'm saying that, in a general sense, it is a good thing that Mohammed cartoons are drawn. If you choose not to do so because you don't care about drawing Mohammed, that's fine. If you choose not to do so because you're scared of being attacked, that's a bad thing, though I can understand the choice. I don't pretend that I would be personally brave enough to accept the risk that Geller is accepting, but I'm glad she's accepting it. If you try to dissuade others from drawing Mohammed, I think that's
also a bad thing, and I don't have sympathy for that choice.