Can a CharlieHebdo-type attack happen in the US?

abu ghraib?

Where's your evidence that the perpetrators were conservative? Where's your evidence that they did what they did because the victims were Muslim? Where's your evidence that they wanted to do what they did to all Muslims in general?

Your claim is unsupported.

George W. Bush
Donald Rumsfeld
Charles Graner
Lynndie England

probably more.

If Bush and Rumsfeld wanted to torture and kill muslims, why were they so chummy with the Saudis? Do you imagine that they didn't know the Saudis were Muslim?

And does your accusation against Graner and England indicate then that you believe they were not instructed to do this by their superiors? Because if they were following orders, then you can't conclude that they wanted to do this. Of course, all my above questions apply to them as well. And they never murdered anyone.
 
Where's your evidence that the perpetrators were conservative? Where's your evidence that they did what they did because the victims were Muslim? Where's your evidence that they wanted to do what they did to all Muslims in general?

Your claim is unsupported.

Bush and Rummy weren't conservative?

If Bush and Rumsfeld wanted to torture and kill muslims, why were they so chummy with the Saudis? Do you imagine that they didn't know the Saudis were Muslim?

$$ Talks.

And does your accusation against Graner and England indicate then that you believe they were not instructed to do this by their superiors? Because if they were following orders, then you can't conclude that they wanted to do this. Of course, all my above questions apply to them as well. And they never murdered anyone.

They sure as hell looked like they were enjoying themselves.
 
Seems pretty honest to me. "We're going to air your straight-up racist justification, not your Godwin defense or the twenty minutes of back and forth it took to get you to say it outright."

You think the Daily Show producers actually said that? Also, he was asked the question "What is wrong with a Muslim Batman?" and he gave a reasonable and nuanced answer (which is actually contained in the original blog post that brought him to the attention of TDS) . Subsequently, and several times, the interviewer prompted him to say that "Nightrunner could be a jihadist." Of course when he finally did, the video was edited to make it seem like he was answering the question "What is wrong with a Muslim Batman?" with "Nightrunner could be a jihadist." How can that possibly seem honest to you?
 
Did you actually read his description of the Daily Show interview? It's fascinating, and it just goes to show the power of editing and how incredibly dishonest the Daily Show is.

Yes, I read the description. That's part of what makes the page worthwhile - you get a chance to see the edited clip and the interviewee's comments too.

What did you think of a superhero who dresses in pig skin to fight Muslims?

ETA: I have not read "Infidel" - the comic book in question. Too cheap to pay for it.
 
Now why would you make this topic into a left-vs-right dishotomy, now ?

That sub-text is commonly in play. It is very difficult to make an argument without getting tagged with an assumed agenda.
 
Bush and Rummy weren't conservative?

Bush and Rummy personally tortured people at Abu Ghraib?

More fundamentally, your claim is self-contradictory: either Garner and England took it upon themselves to abuse prisoners, in which case Bush and Rumsfeld cannot be responsible for their actions, or Bush and Rumsfeld directed the torture, in which case you cannot claim that Garner or England wanted to do it.

Your incoherence is not surprising, though. You're just throwing **** at the wall and hoping something sticks.

$$ Talks.

In other words, Bush and Rumsfeld care about money, and not killing Muslims. Huh.

They sure as hell looked like they were enjoying themselves.

So maybe then they weren't following orders. You still haven't established that they are conservative, or that they did what they did because their victims were Muslims, let alone that they're part of a large group of conservatives who feel likewise.
 
Bush and Rummy weren't conservative?



$$ Talks.



They sure as hell looked like they were enjoying themselves.

Just like the twin towers looked like CD and clouds looked like UFO's?
 
Well, if I were to take a guess I'd say that it's because Noah didn't write your post.

Way to miss the point, Belz. I didn't introduce partisanship here, Noah did. Yet you're blaming me for doing so, and ignoring him. Why? The fact that he didn't write my post is irrelevant, he still wrote his post.
 
Good for them. Are you one of these brave keyboard warriors ?



I've answered this before: if I had reason to believe that harm would come to me or my loved ones were I to continue, yes, I might.

Then when they demand that pork be removed from the groceries or they will burn them down you'll be alright with that?
 
Then when they demand that pork be removed from the groceries or they will burn them down you'll be alright with that?

How did we move from "I'll change my behavior in light of the negative consequences" to "alright with that?"

The two are separate. I can drive the speed limit because I don't want to risk getting a ticket, and still think the speed limit is set too low. If I had to agree with every demand made on me before I'd alter my behavior, I'd shortly be in jail.

Do people really think they are not embedded in a network of social interactions that have real force? That's as foolish as believing one can avoid the laws of physics because they don't care for the consequences.

How could anyone make it to adulthood and not know this?
 
Do you really believe that this schoolyard insult is an argument ? Everybody has their threshold of cowardice. Calling others cowards behind the comfort of a computer is amusing, but when your family (or strangers, really) is jeopardised by your actions, your reality is a bit different.

Good for them. Are you one of these brave keyboard warriors ?

I've answered this before: if I had reason to believe that harm would come to me or my loved ones were I to continue, yes, I might.


Do you really believe that this schoolyard insult is an argument ?
 
Bush and Rummy personally tortured people at Abu Ghraib?

More fundamentally, your claim is self-contradictory: either Garner and England took it upon themselves to abuse prisoners, in which case Bush and Rumsfeld cannot be responsible for their actions, or Bush and Rumsfeld directed the torture, in which case you cannot claim that Garner or England wanted to do it.

The original question was this:

I always hear the argument from the left that muslim terrorists represent a fringe element. If these conservatives who want to kill and torture muslims just for being muslim are so common, why aren't we seeing that actually happen, like we see actual muslim terrorism?


The meat of the question is highlighted. I am willing to concede that I don't know the political leanings of the torturers. However, that does not change the fact that we HAVE seen this actually happen. At Abu Grhaib.


Your incoherence is not surprising, though. You're just throwing **** at the wall and hoping something sticks.

Yea, and the wall smells like asterisks, too. You just don't want to see it.

In other words, Bush and Rumsfeld care about money, and not killing Muslims. Huh.

They're mutually exclusive? Bush and Rummy started a WAR. For chrissake they're as close to war criminals as this country can produce. We have the biggest stick which is the only reason either of those two cretins are still alive.

So maybe then they weren't following orders. You still haven't established that they are conservative, or that they did what they did because their victims were Muslims, let alone that they're part of a large group of conservatives who feel likewise.

Then this goes back to the top. Fine.
 
:confused: Ziggurat was responding to Noah. Noah's post was quoted right there in Ziggurat's post.

Well don't I look like an idiot, now. I didn't interpret "Noah" in that way at all.

Way to miss the point, Belz. I didn't introduce partisanship here, Noah did.

NoahFence, yes. Yes, my mistake.

Noah, why introduce a left-vs-right dichotomy, here ? :p
 
Do you really believe that this schoolyard insult is an argument ?

You think it's an insult ? I'm asking you if you believe you are as brave as you'd want me to be.

Instead of trying to make "clever" comebacks, it would be nice if you'd try to have an actual discussion and understand what people are telling you.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom