Can a CharlieHebdo-type attack happen in the US?

Yes, if they are willing to die for their cause and I am not, then they have a tool I cannot access.

But it's even worse. Since I don't think drawing cartoons of Mohammed constitutes a "cause," there's hardly even a conflict in the first place.

Hopefully, religious extremists will never focus their ruthless terrorist campaigns against activities you think are important. Like maybe, for example, educating young girls.
 
They absolutely should. They're even bigger idiots than Geller and her ilk, for reasons that are pretty obvious. Although, given a bigger set of nuts I'd bet a lot of folks in on the far right would like to torture and kill muslims, just because they're muslims.

That's a serious accusation. Do you have anyone specific in mind?
 
Hopefully, religious extremists will never focus their ruthless terrorist campaigns against activities you think are important. Like maybe, for example, educating young girls.

Oh yes, certainly. There are many such hopes. I hope they don't start spreading Ebola around where I shop; hope they don't detonate a nuke in the city where I live; hope they don't start blowing up oil pipelines and tankers so that gas prices jump up... so many hopes.
 
They absolutely should. They're even bigger idiots than Geller and her ilk, for reasons that are pretty obvious. Although, given a bigger set of nuts I'd bet a lot of folks in on the far right would like to torture and kill muslims, just because they're muslims.

And I'm sure given any nuts at all there's a lotta folks on the far left that would like to torture and kill Christians, just because they're Christians. Weeee! Wild, baseless accusations are fun!
 
Malala Yousef brought it on herself. She knew the risks and she endangered innocent bystanders when she provoked the Taliban to shoot her in the head for introducing girls to education. If the average Muslim is one Mohammed cartoon away from supporting mass murder or becoming a mass murderer then Muslims are animals. The fact that local Muslims ignored the event is very reassuring that the average Muslim probably doesn't need the amount of deference they are receiving in this thread.
 
Or in the sense that when I arrested someone for assault or worse it wasn't to affirm the rights of the victim, it was to get the bad actor off the street so the public at large wasn't at risk.

That's just the arrest, I believe I also mentioned prosecuting, convicting, incarcerating or punishing.

And all those sure are to affirm the rights of the inflicted. Murder is wrong because a person has a right to life. Robbery is wrong because a person has a right to property. Kidnapping is wrong because a person has a right to liberty.


Consider, a guy goes out to the park, gets on a soapbox and starts running his mouth commenting on the social issues of the day. Some people ignore him, some jeer, some laugh, some get really angry and attack him, knock him down and kick him. By the time the police arrive they only catch three of the mob. Now they're charged with assault and appear before a judge. Do they cop to it or do they plead Not Guilty? Hell yeah, they plead NG, the other guy started it,they were provoked. So it goes to trial.

Their defense is his speech made them do it so his speech is entered into record and the judge and the DA remind the jury that no matter how much we might disagree with what the man said, no matter how repugnant or vile, it wasn't illegal, he wasn't threatening anyone, he wasn't inciting anyone to break the law. What is illegal, is assaulting him for exercising his rights. The defendants don't have the right to use violence to shut him or anyone else up.

That's how rights get affirmed by the justice system.
 
Not missing a beat the $PLC plans to add the winning artist to its list of hate groups next year.
The Southern Poverty Law Center, which includes AFDI on its annual list of U.S. hate groups, plans to add Fawstin to its 2016 report, Heidi Beirich, director of the tracking effort, told Reuters on Monday.

She said he would have been listed previously, but the center did not know Fawstin's location in order to encourage attacks on him. The organization has since learned that his website is registered in New York City.
http://www.reuters.com/article/2015/05/05/us-usa-shooting-texas-cartoonist-idUSKBN0NP1ZS20150505

I might have editorialized that a little. >cough<Floyd Corkins>cough< 'scuse me.
 
Last edited:
She has certainly shown more courage than some of the posters here who would be cowering under the bed if they thought a picture of Mohammed was in the neighborhood.
Can you quote the comments that support your claim? I may have missed something but none of the comments struck me that way.
 
Rule #1 for Extremists: Always try to present a "Moderate" image.

Once again, I despise Geller but would defend her right to say what she wants.
And once again, if we start to say "well, this person;s opinion is bad so he/she should not be protected in their right to free speech" who will decide what is "bad" speech.

What is scary is how militants on both the Right and the Left seem willing to throw individual rights down the drain in pursuit of their ideologies.

And, guaranteed, if somebody was to ridicule Jesus, and some wackjob was to shoot him, some of the people here who seem to think that shooting Geller is somehow OK would be screaming for the Christian Fanantics head.
*Bolding mine*

Source the bolded bit please. Who are the members here, on ISF, that have said that shooting Geller is OK?

Name names.

The topic is a lot more complicated than that. It's about what constitutes dickishness, or whether being a dick to a person or a group can be healthy for society as a whole (and even for the people you're being a dick to).

Actually, the more I learn about the case at issue here, the less I think Pamela Geller is a dick and the more I think her critics are.
*Bolding Mine*

She's a bigot. There's no mystery about it. She's also a dick. There's no denying that. The more you learn about her, the harder it will be for you to pretend she isn't. That doesn't mean that she didn't have a right to organize this event. She had every right to do so, and can say and do as she pleases, within the law of course.
But like others here, I'm in the camp that her critics can call her out on her being a dick.
Those nut-jobs who attacked the event are scum of the highest order. Anyone who responds to dickheads like Geller with violence are scum. But she's still a dick.



And I'm sure given any nuts at all there's a lotta folks on the far left that would like to torture and kill Christians, just because they're Christians. Weeee! Wild, baseless accusations are fun!

You may be making a baseless accusation here, and responding in kind to another post, but I just feel the need to remind people that there are a lot, and I mean a lot of people on the left and on the far left that are x-tians. Being x-tian or believing in fictitious garbage like god or gods or jesus or zeus and those things aren't exclusive to those on the right.
 
Yours may be but some aren't so easily intimidated.

Good for them. Are you one of these brave keyboard warriors ?

Would you also quit cooking pork on your deck to avoid offending religious beliefs?

I've answered this before: if I had reason to believe that harm would come to me or my loved ones were I to continue, yes, I might.
 
I don't think I've ever seen a thread where everyone talked past each other so much.

How about people start responding to things actually said and not things imagined?
 
They absolutely should. They're even bigger idiots than Geller and her ilk, for reasons that are pretty obvious. Although, given a bigger set of nuts I'd bet a lot of folks in on the far right would like to torture and kill muslims, just because they're muslims.

I always hear the argument from the left that muslim terrorists represent a fringe element. If these conservatives who want to kill and torture muslims just for being muslim are so common, why aren't we seeing that actually happen, like we see actual muslim terrorism?

For some reason, you're more scared of people that will vote the wrong way than you are of people who actually want to kill you.
 
I always hear the argument from the left that muslim terrorists represent a fringe element. If these conservatives who want to kill and torture muslims just for being muslim are so common, why aren't we seeing that actually happen, like we see actual muslim terrorism?

For some reason, you're more scared of people that will vote the wrong way than you are of people who actually want to kill you.

Now why would you make this topic into a left-vs-right dishotomy, now ?
 
<snip>

She's a bigot. There's no mystery about it. She's also a dick. There's no denying that. The more you learn about her, the harder it will be for you to pretend she isn't. That doesn't mean that she didn't have a right to organize this event. She had every right to do so, and can say and do as she pleases, within the law of course.
But like others here, I'm in the camp that her critics can call her out on her being a dick.
Those nut-jobs who attacked the event are scum of the highest order. Anyone who responds to dickheads like Geller with violence are scum. But she's still a dick.

No doubt her critics are allowed to call her out as being a dick, or even a bigot. Such accusations are not subject to libel laws as far as I know. That doesn't mean they're right to do it, however. I'll note that you spent quite a number of words asserting the proposition that she's a dick and a bigot, without actually, you know, providing any evidentiary or logical support for it.

It seems to me that she speaks out against those parts of Islamic ideology, which, to put it mildly, encourage intolerance and violence. She also speaks out against those Muslims who support or advocate those parts of Islamic ideology. Liberals speak out against those parts of conservative/Republican ideology which they don't like, as well as against conservatives/Republicans that support or advocate that ideology. Perhaps you can help me understand why she is a dick and a bigot, and outspoken liberals (many of whom are participating in this thread) are not dicks and bigots.
 
Did you actually read his description of the Daily Show interview? It's fascinating, and it just goes to show the power of editing and how incredibly dishonest the Daily Show is.
Seems pretty honest to me. "We're going to air your straight-up racist justification, not your Godwin defense or the twenty minutes of back and forth it took to get you to say it outright."
 
I always hear the argument from the left that muslim terrorists represent a fringe element. If these conservatives who want to kill and torture muslims just for being muslim are so common, why aren't we seeing that actually happen, like we see actual muslim terrorism?

For some reason, you're more scared of people that will vote the wrong way than you are of people who actually want to kill you.

abu ghraib?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom