Can a CharlieHebdo-type attack happen in the US?

The truth is we absolutely are able to predict one another's behaviors. This is the rule, not the exception. It requires neither infantilizing, bigotry, nor painting our fellows as automatons.


I know an organization that will pay you a million dollars if you can demonstrate that under controlled conditions.

It merely requires us to treat them as consistent.


As consistent what? That's the question here, and the one you are most steadfastly evading addressing. As consistently human adults, with adult human agency and rationality? Or as sub-rational, sub-adult, and possibly sub-human beings that cannot be held to the same standard?

I notice you've still refused to answer the rest of the issue. Do you think abortion clinics are responsible for the harm to innocent people caused by fanatics bombing the clinics?

This is especially true when I have evidence of consistent behavior in the past. It is even more true when I understand the basis for that behavior. I do not have to agree with the moral content of the behavior for this to be so. The charge of reverse-bigotry fails.


And yet, nothing whatsoever you've posted in any way contradicts the fact that lowering expectations for a particular group is still bigotry. Not "reverse-bigotry", because there is no such thing. It's holding one group to a lower standard, for the sole reason of their membership in that group. Your entire post is nothing but vague evasions and special pleading fallacies.
 
If we've gotten off track, you could have mentioned that first - before typing the rest of your post ;)

I never notice when I've gotten way off track until I near the end of my ramblings. In the middle, I keep hoping that something will happen and it will all be quite clearly relevant.

Doesn't seem to work that way.

As for the rest of your post, same answer as before. Acting violently over such a thing would be irrational. Feeling offended is up to the individual, and would be understandable. Perhaps in certain cases a lawsuit could be filed. I'm not a lawyer so I don't know.

I don't really see what you're getting at with this example. I have never become violent because of anything that was ever said to me or about me. I can't imagine a situation that would provoke me to that extreme. We're all human though - if I were pushed to that point it would be entirely my fault. It's very simple. Sticks and stones...

Sorry, it's obvious the context has been lost. I've not been defending violence as an appropriate result of being offended.
 
I for one would like to see marplots discuss the case of Bull Connor and the Freedom Riders in some detail. I think we could all gain a better understanding of the principles he is advocating by seeing how he would apply them in similar scenarios.

As would I. But he seems to be ducking that example (I wasn't the first to bring it up).
 
I agree! But that doesn't mean that the first entry in a general purpose dictionary is necessarily the most appropriate meaning for the context.


Since English is the language we are conversing in, then yes, it is the most appropriate meaning, since it's the one the word contains. The definition used is the one that is appropriate to the context. There was also a definition for "irrational" as it applied to mathematics; that was not included because it was a technical term specific to a particular contact, and not relevant in this one.

(I should also note that the definition of "emotion" neither entailed "irrational" nor "not rational", without some argument regarding intuitions that you did not provide.)


Huh? Did you actually read the definition, because it explicitly said "not rational". There rest was just examples.


First, let us ask what kind of things are rational.


Reason and logic, by definition.

In the sense that I mean "rational",


And here we have the root of the problem. The Humpty Dumpty Fallacy; or more appropriately, the Arbitrary Definition Fallacy. Redefining terms to meet an external agenda, rather than using the most appropriate language to express the concept.

Words have meanings. Meaningful communication is only possible when using a single standard for the language of communication.

I think that beliefs may be rational or not, and actions (or perhaps intentions to act) may be rational or not. (Other things, such as persons, may be called "rational", but that is a different sense.)
Pointless truism. We're not talking about beliefs, we're talking about emotions. Emotions are not beliefs.

Skipping the rest of your post, since it is little more than post-modernist pseudo-intellectual nonsense. Rational and Irrational already have meanings; and they are well-established. You don't get to redefine the language to support your agenda. If you are unable to express your point in common standard language, the problem is with your point, not the language.

And it's an even further and less relevant digression. We're not talking about objects or actions or reflexes. We're talking about emotions, and specifically the emotion of offense.

A thing, regardless of what it is, is rational when it is based on logic and reason. A thing is irrational when it is not. Emotions are by definition not logic or reason, therefore irrational. Beliefs can be rational or irrational; or, for the vast majority of people, a combination of both rational and irrational thoughts.

(And "phobia" is a medical term, whose definition does not include "irrational fear", since, as you so aptly pointed out, that is redundant. A phobia is a form of anxiety disorder which results in a fear reaction disproportionate to the threat caused by the object of the fear. The colloquial definition, which is what you referred to, of phobia as "irrational fear" isn't particularly informative or useful.)
 
As would I. But he seems to be ducking that example (I wasn't the first to bring it up).

And multiple other real-world examples. Such as Civil Rights marches, abortion clinics, and Gay Pride events.

It's starting to sound more and more like post-modernist relativism.
 
Did Geller know the event was likely to draw the attention of Muslim extremists?

"Know" is perhaps too strong. "Think it highly likely" is better.

I saw news reports that pegged the security bill at $10,000. In the interview above, she says it was $50,000. I think this is good evidence that she did understand what was likely to happen. And it did happen.

Those who are supporting her on free speech grounds are being played here. This isn't a free speech issue at all. It's an issue of one hate group provoking another to gain attention for their cause. She got the attention, and two zealots became martyrs. The only thing preventing this from being a win/win is the security guard caught up in Geller's agenda. But that's par for the course - the principals don't usually get their hands dirty anyhow.

I there any way you could consider pictures of Mohammed OK?
 
I guess that's the difference between you and Pam. She has the courage of her convictions.

Do you really believe that this schoolyard insult is an argument ? Everybody has their threshold of cowardice. Calling others cowards behind the comfort of a computer is amusing, but when your family (or strangers, really) is jeopardised by your actions, your reality is a bit different.
 
Do you really believe that this schoolyard insult is an argument ? Everybody has their threshold of cowardice. Calling others cowards behind the comfort of a computer is amusing, but when your family (or strangers, really) is jeopardised by your actions, your reality is a bit different.


Yours may be but some aren't so easily intimidated.

Would you also quit cooking pork on your deck to avoid offending religious beliefs?
 
Rude Pundit summed all this up nicely. Conservatives won't like it. Strong language.

It would be a tragedy if Lee Papa would have his front door broken down, and be shot to death for these statements by terrorists incensed by his clear provocation. However, there would be a silver lining in the form of some important lessons for others:

1. You have freedom to express stupid insults, but don't be surprised if there are consequences for that... like getting shot to death.

2. Two wrongs don't make a right.

3. Choose civility. Otherwise, you might get shot to death.
 
Marplots: The truth is we absolutely are able to predict one another's behaviors. This is the rule, not the exception. It requires neither infantilizing, bigotry, nor painting our fellows as automatons.
I know an organization that will pay you a million dollars if you can demonstrate that under controlled conditions.

OK, here's my protocol. Pick a convenience store at random. I predict I can present an item to the cashier and they will tell me how much I have to pay to obtain that item. I'll even propose a 95% confidence interval for predicting their behavior.

Still wanna bet a million?

As consistent what? That's the question here, and the one you are most steadfastly evading addressing. As consistently human adults, with adult human agency and rationality? Or as sub-rational, sub-adult, and possibly sub-human beings that cannot be held to the same standard?

It is the fact that they are rational actors that makes them somewhat predictable.

I notice you've still refused to answer the rest of the issue. Do you think abortion clinics are responsible for the harm to innocent people caused by fanatics bombing the clinics?

The responsibility is distributed in the same way, yes. The critical difference is comparing the right to draw insulting cartoons of Mohammed to the right to have an abortion. The second is worth risking lives over. The first is not.

Are you willing to assert that a cartoon Mohammed contest is equivalent to a woman's right to have an abortion? Because that's what your question requires. If you cannot distinguish between the two, no answer I give will satisfy.

This might help: Do you think people have abortions for the sole purpose of pissing off Christians? That, if Christianity disappeared, no one would bother having an abortion?

Now, what if Islam disappeared? Would anyone hold an event with a contest to draw insulting cartoons of Mohammed?
 
Last edited:
Does something upset a large group of people? If yes, and a person decides to go ahead and do that, for the expressed purpose of upsetting those same people, that person is a dick. It's actually not complicated in the slightest bit. There's not one aspect of "don't be a dick" that's at all complicated. None.

Now, that's interesting. Jon Stewart is a dick who, if and when he gets his head blown off, should have not been a dick by trying to upset large groups of people.

You're right, it's not complicated at all.
 
If you don't want Islamists to shoot(beat, stab, behead) people then don't draw pictures of Mahomet(burn Korans, watch soccer during Ramadan, be homosexual).

Mrs. Smith, if you don't want to get smacked again then make your husband's sandwich right the first time.

Why is Islamist violence being considered an evergreen thing? Why shouldn't they have to modify their behavior?

Should Mrs. Smith just make the sandwich properly or should Mr. Smith stop hitting his wife? Don't get me wrong, I strongly support Mrs. Smith's rights of bodily autonomy buuuut, she really needs to start getting that sandwich right.
 
The logic there seems to be that the foreseeable results of some action should not be attached to the actor. But the same logic would have us excuse the terrorists who showed up on the grounds that they aren't responsible for the foreseeable results of arriving with guns and shooting up the place. How is it that we can say one party is responsible for what happens and the other not?

The problem arises when "moral fault" is forced into an "either-or" framework instead of accepting the theory of partial negligence or distributed blame. If I see some fault with the event promoters, it is not the case that the terrorists are absolved of fault. It is not the case that the fault is equally distributed either.

The real question is whether holding the event justifies the risk. Placing blame is secondary.

As I've said before, terrorists should systematically attempt to increase the risk associated in holding events they wish not to be held. If they can manage to increase that risk to a high enough level, they can create a situation with virtually no justification for holding the event, no matter how important the participants feel it is.
 
If you don't want Islamists to shoot(beat, stab, behead) people then don't draw pictures of Mahomet(burn Korans, watch soccer during Ramadan, be homosexual).

Mrs. Smith, if you don't want to get smacked again then make your husband's sandwich right the first time.

Why is Islamist violence being considered an evergreen thing? Why shouldn't they have to modify their behavior?
Should Mrs. Smith just make the sandwich properly or should Mr. Smith stop hitting his wife? Don't get me wrong, I strongly support Mrs. Smith's rights of bodily autonomy buuuut, she really needs to start getting that sandwich right.

They absolutely should. They're even bigger idiots than Geller and her ilk, for reasons that are pretty obvious. Although, given a bigger set of nuts I'd bet a lot of folks in on the far right would like to torture and kill muslims, just because they're muslims.
 
As I've said before, terrorists should systematically attempt to increase the risk associated in holding events they wish not to be held. If they can manage to increase that risk to a high enough level, they can create a situation with virtually no justification for holding the event, no matter how important the participants feel it is.

Yes, if they are willing to die for their cause and I am not, then they have a tool I cannot access.

But it's even worse. Since I don't think drawing cartoons of Mohammed constitutes a "cause," there's hardly even a conflict in the first place.
 
Since English is the language we are conversing in, then yes, it is the most appropriate meaning, since it's the one the word contains. The definition used is the one that is appropriate to the context. There was also a definition for "irrational" as it applied to mathematics; that was not included because it was a technical term specific to a particular contact, and not relevant in this one.




Huh? Did you actually read the definition, because it explicitly said "not rational". There rest was just examples.





Reason and logic, by definition.




And here we have the root of the problem. The Humpty Dumpty Fallacy; or more appropriately, the Arbitrary Definition Fallacy. Redefining terms to meet an external agenda, rather than using the most appropriate language to express the concept.

Words have meanings. Meaningful communication is only possible when using a single standard for the language of communication.


Pointless truism. We're not talking about beliefs, we're talking about emotions. Emotions are not beliefs.

Skipping the rest of your post, since it is little more than post-modernist pseudo-intellectual nonsense. Rational and Irrational already have meanings; and they are well-established. You don't get to redefine the language to support your agenda. If you are unable to express your point in common standard language, the problem is with your point, not the language.

And it's an even further and less relevant digression. We're not talking about objects or actions or reflexes. We're talking about emotions, and specifically the emotion of offense.

A thing, regardless of what it is, is rational when it is based on logic and reason. A thing is irrational when it is not. Emotions are by definition not logic or reason, therefore irrational. Beliefs can be rational or irrational; or, for the vast majority of people, a combination of both rational and irrational thoughts.

(And "phobia" is a medical term, whose definition does not include "irrational fear", since, as you so aptly pointed out, that is redundant. A phobia is a form of anxiety disorder which results in a fear reaction disproportionate to the threat caused by the object of the fear. The colloquial definition, which is what you referred to, of phobia as "irrational fear" isn't particularly informative or useful.)

Well, it's obvious that this is going nowhere, and I suggest we drop it.

But I think it's positively adorable that you call me a post-modernist. You've no idea what analytic philosophy is, I guess, but I promise you that I don't do post-modernism. What I was trying to do, before I was trumped by the wisdom of Funk & Wagnalls, is a simple example of conceptual analysis.

I also note that the second highlighted passage seems to confirm that reflexes, breathing and a beating heart, since they are not the product of deliberation, are "irrational". And, contrary to your earlier balk, so is cheese. Amazing what we learn!

But never mind. I'm sure we both feel there's not point in carrying on at this point, and we're likely both right.
 
Last edited:
Only in the most pedantic sense. Life has inferences that sometimes aren't spelled out. If they refused to prosecute someone on the grounds of their victim "should have known better" or "he had it coming for what he said" then the victim's right of expression is not being protected.

Or in the sense that when I arrested someone for assault or worse it wasn't to affirm the rights of the victim, it was to get the bad actor off the street so the public at large wasn't at risk.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom