Can a CharlieHebdo-type attack happen in the US?

The consequences being escaped are the shouldering responsibility part and accepting some of the blame.
In what way are the consequences being escaped? What consequences would you like to see imposed, that have not been imposed on Geller and her associates?

What responsibility, exactly, do you think Geller and her associates need to shoulder? What would that shouldering of responsibility look like, in your opinion?
 
Last edited:
Who said anything about Moslems? We're talking about Voltaire.

Though it can be said that anyone for whom you accept restrictions on your rights and freedoms out of fear of retaliation can be said to be your de facto master or ruler, regardless of who else may claim that role.

In the US, the de novo ruler is the People. Whether the People are also the de facto ruler is a topic for debate.
 
When the government arrests, prosecutes, convicts and punishes your attackers they are affirming your right to express yourself free of violent reprisal.

Simpson and Soofi weren't a pair of locals who were walking by minding their own business when Pam Geller ran out into the street screaming "**** off back to Araby, sand ******!" in their faces. They loaded up with guns and body armor and drove 1000 miles to go to kill some people who were doing something they didn't like. Those are exactly the kind of people you should be a dick to.

The local Moslem population, which is fairly large I hear, didn't even stage a counter protest. They appear to have shrugged their shoulders and turned their backs to it. Maybe a few of them cried themselves to sleep that night but I doubt it.

100% incorrect.

In the event an individual commits an assault and is arrested, prosecuted and convicted it's because they violated the state's criminal statutes, they don't (outside of hate crime enhancements where such laws are on the books) care at all if the assault was predicated by speech or any other act that's considered "incitement" by the perp.

What the conviction "affirms" is the power of the state to convict and incarcerate individuals convicted of a crime.
 
Nope, that's not what I said. I never said defending Muslims is racists, I said making excuses for them may be racists.

It's call the "bigotry of soft expectations". Giving a particular group a pass on destructive anti-social behaviour solely because of their membership in that group. Excusing Muslims for lashing out violently at people who violate their religious proscriptions, because they were "offended" by those violations, is to say that they are, at some level, less capable than we are of behaving rationally. It is to create a lower standard of behaviour more appropriate for young children or animals; and claiming that they're too different from us to be expected to meet our standards for behaviour. It is infantilizing, and denigratory; as it treats such people as being without full human agency or self-determination. It is also one of the very few examples of bigotry that is still widely considered acceptable in the West.

Wonderfully constructed. Wrong, but still wonderfully constructed.

The truth is we absolutely are able to predict one another's behaviors. This is the rule, not the exception. It requires neither infantilizing, bigotry, nor painting our fellows as automatons. It merely requires us to treat them as consistent.

This is especially true when I have evidence of consistent behavior in the past. It is even more true when I understand the basis for that behavior. I do not have to agree with the moral content of the behavior for this to be so. The charge of reverse-bigotry fails.
 
100% incorrect.

In the event an individual commits an assault and is arrested, prosecuted and convicted it's because they violated the state's criminal statutes, they don't (outside of hate crime enhancements where such laws are on the books) care at all if the assault was predicated by speech or any other act that's considered "incitement" by the perp.

What the conviction "affirms" is the power of the state to convict and incarcerate individuals convicted of a crime.

Only in the most pedantic sense. Life has inferences that sometimes aren't spelled out. If they refused to prosecute someone on the grounds of their victim "should have known better" or "he had it coming for what he said" then the victim's right of expression is not being protected.
 
"Musims". A Muslim neighbor or many muslims? Is me BBQing pork on my deck insulting to their faith as described in their holy book? Has it been repeatedly demonstrated worldwide that BBQing on your deck upsets Muslims to the point some will resort to violence? If so, then yeah, I probably would.

But if I say "**** 'em!" and do it anyway because freedom, and I'm doing it to piss them off on purpose, well now I'm just being a dick (see above).

What I would most likely do then is cook it indoors.

But then again I do many things so as to not bother my neighbors. I'm a guitarist; you think my neighbors want to listen to that all day and all night? Is my freedom to play guitar at loud volumes being denied because it bothers someone else? I simply don't play at loud volumes when I'm at home.

A few years ago I had a neighbor who worked third shift so I mowed late in the afternoons because I didn't want to wake him. Had nothing to do with fear, just respecting my neighbors.

Apparently being respectful of others is for chumps.


Really? See I would not stop BBQing pork in my backyard unless perhaps the smoke was blowing through someones open window and choking them out. If my lawnmower is too loud for someone (mine has no engine), or my stereo is too loud, then I am infringing on their rights. My city has laws about noise, but I would also try and be considerate in these instances anyways. That is a reasonable complaint.

Being offended that I am cooking pork is their problem. Absolutely 100%. If my neighbor asked me to stop cooking pork for no other reason than that it offended their religion, I would politely say no. Give me a break that is just ridiculous. If they want to get violent then they are the problem, not me.

It's up to each person what they would do in such a situation, and I am courteous to my neighbors, but not to that extent, which I would consider an extreme.

This thread is a trip.
 
"Musims". A Muslim neighbor or many muslims? Is me BBQing pork on my deck insulting to their faith as described in their holy book? Has it been repeatedly demonstrated worldwide that BBQing on your deck upsets Muslims to the point some will resort to violence? If so, then yeah, I probably would. But if I say "**** 'em!" and do it anyway because freedom, and I'm doing it to piss them off on purpose, well now I'm just being a dick (see above).

What I would most likely do then is cook it indoors.

But then again I do many things so as to not bother my neighbors. I'm a guitarist; you think my neighbors want to listen to that all day and all night? Is my freedom to play guitar at loud volumes being denied because it bothers someone else? I simply don't play at loud volumes when I'm at home.

A few years ago I had a neighbor who worked third shift so I mowed late in the afternoons because I didn't want to wake him. Had nothing to do with fear, just respecting my neighbors.

Apparently being respectful of others is for chumps.

Then you will change your behavior to conform to the beliefs of anyone willing to kill for their beliefs?


Respect must be earned it cannot be demanded.
 
Wonderfully constructed. Wrong, but still wonderfully constructed.

The truth is we absolutely are able to predict one another's behaviors. This is the rule, not the exception. It requires neither infantilizing, bigotry, nor painting our fellows as automatons. It merely requires us to treat them as consistent.

This is especially true when I have evidence of consistent behavior in the past. It is even more true when I understand the basis for that behavior. I do not have to agree with the moral content of the behavior for this to be so. The charge of reverse-bigotry fails.

So Moslems are violent is what you're saying.
 
Did Geller know the event was likely to draw the attention of Muslim extremists?

"Know" is perhaps too strong. "Think it highly likely" is better.

I saw news reports that pegged the security bill at $10,000. In the interview above, she says it was $50,000. I think this is good evidence that she did understand what was likely to happen. And it did happen.

Those who are supporting her on free speech grounds are being played here. This isn't a free speech issue at all. It's an issue of one hate group provoking another to gain attention for their cause. She got the attention, and two zealots became martyrs. The only thing preventing this from being a win/win is the security guard caught up in Geller's agenda. But that's par for the course - the principals don't usually get their hands dirty anyhow.
 
So Moslems are violent is what you're saying.

Moslems are predictably violent, is what he's saying.

I'm saying that if you promote a contest to draw pictures of Mohammed, you may attract an attack from Muslim extremists. There is no need to make a general (and false) statement about Muslims.

The best you might do is to say that Muslims generally dislike insulting cartoons of their prophet, but we cannot say that all Muslims will react the same way. That would then slip over to bigotry, making up a broad-brush rule that is incorrect and only serves to denigrate Muslims.
 
"Musims". A Muslim neighbor or many muslims? Is me BBQing pork on my deck insulting to their faith as described in their holy book? Has it been repeatedly demonstrated worldwide that BBQing on your deck upsets Muslims to the point some will resort to violence? If so, then yeah, I probably would.

I understand and respect this position. It is, indeed, the position I might choose in many similar scenarios.

However, I would not condemn anyone who chose to cook pork in defiance of the threats against them, who armed themselves against the possibility of violence, and who confronted any such violence with deadly force.

Nor would I agree that by making this choice they have given up neither their right to prepare whatever meal they like, nor their right to self-defense. Nor would I ask that their government sanction anyone except those that act against them with violence on account of their food choices.
 
Did Geller know the event was likely to draw the attention of Muslim extremists?

"Know" is perhaps too strong. "Think it highly likely" is better.

I saw news reports that pegged the security bill at $10,000. In the interview above, she says it was $50,000. I think this is good evidence that she did understand what was likely to happen. And it did happen.

Those who are supporting her on free speech grounds are being played here. This isn't a free speech issue at all. It's an issue of one hate group provoking another to gain attention for their cause. She got the attention, and two zealots became martyrs. The only thing preventing this from being a win/win is the security guard caught up in Geller's agenda. But that's par for the course - the principals don't usually get their hands dirty anyhow.

You don't think that there is value to society in pointing out that works such as:
The Life of Brian,
The Book of Mormon,
Jerry Springer the Opera,
etc

Can be made about any religion... bar one? That is a concern that should be brought up, to both muslims and non-muslims.

Any violence that results is not the moral fault of the cartoonists any more than the brutal actions of Bull Connor were the moral fault of peaceful civil rights marchers.
 
Well, no, if they're reasonable, then they're not emotions. That's the very definition of emotions.

English words have established meanings, you don't get to redefine them because they're inconvenient for you.

I agree! But that doesn't mean that the first entry in a general purpose dictionary is necessarily the most appropriate meaning for the context.

Before we move forward, if you think that this digression is worth pursuing, I want to point out that not everything which is literally not rational is irrational, contrary to the dictionary entry you cited. (I should also note that the definition of "emotion" neither entailed "irrational" nor "not rational", without some argument regarding intuitions that you did not provide.)

First, let us ask what kind of things are rational. In the sense that I mean "rational", I think that beliefs may be rational or not, and actions (or perhaps intentions to act) may be rational or not. (Other things, such as persons, may be called "rational", but that is a different sense.)

Now, what is it that makes a belief rational? It is that the belief is warranted given the background beliefs of the agent and whatever observations he is currently making. That is, that the current cognitive state of the agent makes it plausible that the belief is true.

What makes an action rational? An action is rational if it is well-suited to produce the end(s) the agent is currently pursuing, with negative affects of less concern than the value of end itself.

In both cases, the kind of thing which might be rational (let's say potentially rational) is the sort of thing which is the product of deliberation, a weighing of the evidence or evaluation of the outcome, resp.

No other thing is potentially rational, and nothing which is not potentially rational is properly called irrational. Emotions may be appropriate for the situation or not, but they aren't the product of deliberation and do not aim at either the truth or a desired end. (Final desires are arguably not potentially rational either.) Emotions are not rational, nor irrational, but simply non-rational.

And they are not alone in this. Reflexes are obviously not "rational" in any sense I can see, but I don't conclude that they are therefore "irrational". This includes involuntary reflexive behavior, like breathing. Do you really want to say that breathing is a rational act, when there is no conscious decision involved at all? How about the beating of a heart, which we cannot help but do?

This was the point I was trying to make with "cheese", but it wasn't well-made.

By the way, since you are fond of dictionary definitions, let me point out the ways in which they can fail us in this discussion. You claim, on the basis of your dictionary definition, that all emotions are irrational. If you ask Google (or choose a dictionary of your choice) to define "fear" you will see that it is an emotion. If you also ask Google to define "phobia", you will see that it is an "irrational fear". But surely, that is redundant, since you've already told us that all emotions are irrational, and hence all fear is phobic.

(NOTE: The definition of phobia also contradicts what I said above, since I said emotions are not potentially rational. I would prefer to use the word "appropriate" in this context.)

In any case, I don't think that the distinction between non-rational and irrational is ground-breaking. I should think it is obvious that not all things are properly called either rational or irrational, not even all results of human brain activity.
 
Did Geller know the event was likely to draw the attention of Muslim extremists?

"Know" is perhaps too strong. "Think it highly likely" is better.

Actually, I think it was pretty unlikely, although still likely enough to justify extensive security. This was the United States after all, not Pakistan.

I saw news reports that pegged the security bill at $10,000. In the interview above, she says it was $50,000. I think this is good evidence that she did understand what was likely to happen. And it did happen.

The money spent on security is not a particularly good gauge of likelihood. The cost will scale with the size of the event and the number of weak points that need to be protected.

Those who are supporting her on free speech grounds are being played here. This isn't a free speech issue at all. It's an issue of one hate group provoking another to gain attention for their cause. She got the attention, and two zealots became martyrs. The only thing preventing this from being a win/win is the security guard caught up in Geller's agenda. But that's par for the course - the principals don't usually get their hands dirty anyhow.

First off, I think it's ridiculous to believe that she held the event in order to provoke violence. She held the event to show people that it could be done without catastrophic consequences. If 100,000 people followed her lead, people in the US would no longer fear drawing Muhammad cartoons because it would simply be impractical for the Jihadis to target everybody. As it turns out, she didn't really make much progress towards the goal of proving such cartoons could be drawn and displayed with impunity. She may regret that to some extent, yet still be hopeful that the result will discourage Jihadis from attacking the next time. Of course, on another level, I'm sure she's enjoying the publicity and perhaps some measure of vindication for her thesis that Jihadism is a present and growing threat in the US itself.

As for the security guard, I doubt very much he was some duped pawn in all of this. I'm sure he knew the risks and accepted them voluntarily. Geller bears absolutely no responsibility for his injury.

Finally, I'd like to know your reasons for referring to Geller's organization as a hate group. Are you just parroting what you hear in the mainstream media, or did you decide that it qualifies as a hate group based on your own research?
 
Any violence that results is not the moral fault of the cartoonists any more than the brutal actions of Bull Connor were the moral fault of peaceful civil rights marchers.

I for one would like to see marplots discuss the case of Bull Connor and the Freedom Riders in some detail. I think we could all gain a better understanding of the principles he is advocating by seeing how he would apply them in similar scenarios.
 
You don't think that there is value to society in pointing out that works such as:
The Life of Brian,
The Book of Mormon,
Jerry Springer the Opera,
etc

Can be made about any religion... bar one? That is a concern that should be brought up, to both muslims and non-muslims.

Any violence that results is not the moral fault of the cartoonists any more than the brutal actions of Bull Connor were the moral fault of peaceful civil rights marchers.

The logic there seems to be that the foreseeable results of some action should not be attached to the actor. But the same logic would have us excuse the terrorists who showed up on the grounds that they aren't responsible for the foreseeable results of arriving with guns and shooting up the place. How is it that we can say one party is responsible for what happens and the other not?

The problem arises when "moral fault" is forced into an "either-or" framework instead of accepting the theory of partial negligence or distributed blame. If I see some fault with the event promoters, it is not the case that the terrorists are absolved of fault. It is not the case that the fault is equally distributed either.

The real question is whether holding the event justifies the risk. Placing blame is secondary.
 
I just double-checked my Koran. They're not worried about dog walking....

I don't think it says not to draw Mohahammed either, yet people are killed for it and some American bigots were almost killed for it a few days ago. What the Koran does or not say about a topic does not appear to correlate with extremist trends in Islam.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom