Can a CharlieHebdo-type attack happen in the US?

That's actually why the analogy works, I think: we restrict speech for good reasons, sometimes; we refrain from doing some things sometimes out of respect, or for other pragmatic reasons.

Ah I'm looking at this from another perspective, I think perhaps. There are some limited and very specific restrictions on freedom of speech that I support. For example libel, and threats of violence. I refrain from speech out of respect all the time, and I think it's a good idea that others do as well.

However, I find it puzzling, and indeed offensive, that anyone thinks the government should determine and ban speech that is disrespectful to someone. No one has the right to not be offended, and no one has the right to assault or kill someone that has offended them in this country.

ETA: actually I still don't find it a good analogy. Refraining from playing "Imagine all The People" in his rock band because some religious people find it offensive would be a good analogy.
 
Last edited:
Ah I'm looking at this from another perspective, I think perhaps. There are some limited and very specific restrictions on freedom of speech that I support. For example libel, and threats of violence. I refrain from speech out of respect all the time, and I think it's a good idea that others do as well.

However, I find it puzzling, and indeed offensive, that anyone thinks the government should determine and ban speech that is disrespectful to someone. No one has the right to not be offended, and no one has the right to assault or kill someone that has offended them in this country.

To be fair I don't think anybody is arguing that.
 
To be fair I don't think anybody is arguing that.

Well, I could point out at least one poster here that more or less does. But I am struggling to pinpoint just what the argument on this thread is if its not that.
 
Well, I could point out at least one poster here that more or less does. But I am struggling to pinpoint just what the argument on this thread is if its not that.

Do I have the right to be a dick? Yes.

Should I be a dick? No.

that's it. No government involvement needed.
 
Amusing. Attacking Muslims is racist. Defending them is racist. That word means less and less as time passes.

Nope, that's not what I said. I never said defending Muslims is racists, I said making excuses for them may be racists.

It's call the "bigotry of soft expectations". Giving a particular group a pass on destructive anti-social behaviour solely because of their membership in that group. Excusing Muslims for lashing out violently at people who violate their religious proscriptions, because they were "offended" by those violations, is to say that they are, at some level, less capable than we are of behaving rationally. It is to create a lower standard of behaviour more appropriate for young children or animals; and claiming that they're too different from us to be expected to meet our standards for behaviour. It is infantilizing, and denigratory; as it treats such people as being without full human agency or self-determination. It is also one of the very few examples of bigotry that is still widely considered acceptable in the West.
 
Do I have the right to be a dick? Yes.

Should I be a dick? No.

that's it. No government involvement needed.

The topic is a lot more complicated than that. It's about what constitutes dickishness, or whether being a dick to a person or a group can be healthy for society as a whole (and even for the people you're being a dick to).

Actually, the more I learn about the case at issue here, the less I think Pamela Geller is a dick and the more I think her critics are.
 
I just double-checked my Koran. They're not worried about dog walking....

Most of what the fanatics are killing people over is not in the Quran. Some of it is in hadiths that are not universally agreed on among Muslims, and some of it is traditions that are also not agreed upon. There are also issues of interpretation among sects, and if or how the proscriptions apply to non-believers.

Killing people over drawings is already down the slippery slope, since it's not something that is agreed upon by all Muslims, but only a minority of the most fanatical; and at one time was not even a notable issue.
 
All this BS does is give radicals yet another reason.

Nonsense. The fanatics don't need a reason, that's why they're fanatics. The fact that there are people who do not adhere to their particular brand of fanaticism is enough. All the rest is just excuses.
 
For the folks here who aren't quite sure:


What Does Free Speech Mean?




I think I'll rent a hall and invite every white supremesist and KKK member in the state to all get together and engage in activities that will probably seriously piss off the African American community. Maybe we'll draw offensive pictures, burn effigies, hang mannequins that look like black people from nooses, etc. I'll advertise it also, so that way there could very well be be a Back Panther, Bloods, Crips or Nation of Islam presence there too. Remember, it's my freedom of speech!

Sure hope nobody gets hurt, but if they do, well too bad; price of freedom must be paid.

Right?

Here's a more modern case:

Clarence Brandenburg, a Ku Klux Klan (KKK) leader in rural Ohio, contacted a reporter at a Cincinnati television station and invited him to cover a KKK rally that would take place in Hamilton County in the summer of 1964.[6] Portions of the rally were filmed, showing several men in robes and hoods, some carrying firearms, first burning a cross and then making speeches. One of the speeches made reference to the possibility of "revengeance" [sic] against "*******", "Jews", and those who supported them.

...

The U.S. Supreme Court reversed Brandenburg's conviction, holding that government cannot constitutionally punish abstract advocacy of force or law violation.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brandenburg_v._Ohio
 
The topic is a lot more complicated than that. It's about what constitutes dickishness, or whether being a dick to a person or a group can be healthy for society as a whole (and even for the people you're being a dick to).

Does something upset a large group of people? If yes, and a person decides to go ahead and do that, for the expressed purpose of upsetting those same people, that person is a dick. It's actually not complicated in the slightest bit. There's not one aspect of "don't be a dick" that's at all complicated. None.

Actually, the more I learn about the case at issue here, the less I think Pamela Geller is a dick and the more I think her critics are.

Not very shocking.
 
Does something upset a large group of people? If yes, and a person decides to go ahead and do that, for the expressed purpose of upsetting those same people, that person is a dick. It's actually not complicated in the slightest bit. There's not one aspect of "don't be a dick" that's at all complicated. None.

What if the large group of people is the Tea Party?
 
This thread is interesting because of the numbers of posters who somehow can't understand the difference between "freedom of speech" and "freedom from consequences".

What? You mean I can't go to the bad parts of town dressed in blackface shouting "**** the N-words!" without fear of being beaten or killed? My freedom of speech is being limited! No, it's not.

What? You mean I can't call the White House and (jokingly) tell them I'm gonna kill president Obama without the Secret Service visiting me? My freedom of speech is being limited! Death threats have never been protected speech

There's a section of town here that has an MS13 element. Maybe I should roll down there and announce loudly my hatred for hispanics. And should they respond negatively, well shucks; My freedom of speech is being limited! No, really, it's not.

How's about this tactic: Don't be a dick. Especially if your dickish behavior is hidden behind "Freedom of speech!". And don't expect not to be called out at some point, maybe even physically.

Finally, maybe some here should take the time to learn what freedom of speech means, who it protects, and from whom.

Because from this side of my computer screen, some of you "freedom-loving" types appear to have no clue what it is you're blathering about.

When the government arrests, prosecutes, convicts and punishes your attackers they are affirming your right to express yourself free of violent reprisal.

Simpson and Soofi weren't a pair of locals who were walking by minding their own business when Pam Geller ran out into the street screaming "**** off back to Araby, sand ******!" in their faces. They loaded up with guns and body armor and drove 1000 miles to go to kill some people who were doing something they didn't like. Those are exactly the kind of people you should be a dick to.

The local Moslem population, which is fairly large I hear, didn't even stage a counter protest. They appear to have shrugged their shoulders and turned their backs to it. Maybe a few of them cried themselves to sleep that night but I doubt it.
 
Does something upset a large group of people? If yes, and a person decides to go ahead and do that, for the expressed purpose of upsetting those same people, that person is a dick. It's actually not complicated in the slightest bit. There's not one aspect of "don't be a dick" that's at all complicated. None.

The KKK is a large group of people, or at least it used to be. The Nazis at one time constituted a large group of people. Would it have been wrong to "be a dick" to them? Obama quite often does things with the express purpose of annoying Republicans, and he has even reveled in it. Should he stop "being a dick?"

Not very shocking.

It shouldn't be. Quite often people are slandered as bigots by their political opponents as a tactic to suppress their ideas.
 
Perhaps, but that's missing the point I was aiming at.

Let us change the situation slightly. Suppose someone is spreading lies about your mother's life as a whore, and others believe it. Suppose further that dear ol' Mom is dead, and that it is not well-known that she is your mother, so she will not suffer due to the rumors (being dead, she has no interest) and you will not suffer either (because it will not reflect on you).

In this case, many people are coming to believe something false and widely regarded as despicable about a person you love.

According to luchog, it is irrational to feel offense here -- because luchog thinks all emotion is irrational. I blame Star Trek. And I think that, even though there are no obvious interests involved, offense is an appropriate response.

I think we've gotten a bit off the track at this point.


If we've gotten off track, you could have mentioned that first - before typing the rest of your post ;)

As for the rest of your post, same answer as before. Acting violently over such a thing would be irrational. Feeling offended is up to the individual, and would be understandable. Perhaps in certain cases a lawsuit could be filed. I'm not a lawyer so I don't know.

I don't really see what you're getting at with this example. I have never become violent because of anything that was ever said to me or about me. I can't imagine a situation that would provoke me to that extreme. We're all human though - if I were pushed to that point it would be entirely my fault. It's very simple. Sticks and stones...
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom