Can a CharlieHebdo-type attack happen in the US?

By the way, do any of the conservatives in this thread remember Florida Pastor Terry Jones and his Koran burning BS threat he announced on July 12, 2010?



What was the conservative position on an activity that could very well have put US personnel in harm's way because free speech?
What, coalition service members in Afghanistan weren't at risk of Talibani violence, except for this one guy's protest in Florida? And Obama seriously tried to tell us that there were no real excuses to attack US personnel in Afghanistan, without this guy in Florida?

Thank you for reminding us that Obama is possibly the biggest douchebag we've had as President since Nixon said "I am not a crook." I mean, even Clinton didn't go on morning TV talk shows to tell America "It depends upon what the meaning of the word 'is' is". What an ass.
 
What, coalition service members in Afghanistan weren't at risk of Talibani violence, except for this one guy's protest in Florida? And Obama seriously tried to tell us that there were no real excuses to attack US personnel in Afghanistan, without this guy in Florida?

Holy crap man. That's how you read that statement?l Not "Don't be a dick, dude, we've got enough trouble as it is"?

talk about blinders. WOW.
 
By the way, do any of the conservatives in this thread remember Florida Pastor Terry Jones and his Koran burning BS threat he announced on July 12, 2010?



What was the conservative position on an activity that could very well have put US personnel in harm's way because free speech?

He cancelled that, but did another later:

Then as with Garland, the content of the expression is a completely separate point from violence resulting from expression which caused no harm. Recall that we're talking about drawing cartoons and burning a book of fairy tales from before people understood the concept of soap.

Violent reactions to harmless expressions - which these are, you cannot claim that the expressions themselves cause anybody any harm - only show the backwardness of those who would do violence in response. All blame and onus is on the violent actors, and they are the only ones who should be called on to grow up and forced to if they don't.
 
Would you quit if Muslims told you it offends them?

"Musims". A Muslim neighbor or many muslims? Is me BBQing pork on my deck insulting to their faith as described in their holy book? Has it been repeatedly demonstrated worldwide that BBQing on your deck upsets Muslims to the point some will resort to violence? If so, then yeah, I probably would.

But if I say "**** 'em!" and do it anyway because freedom, and I'm doing it to piss them off on purpose, well now I'm just being a dick (see above).

What I would most likely do then is cook it indoors.

But then again I do many things so as to not bother my neighbors. I'm a guitarist; you think my neighbors want to listen to that all day and all night? Is my freedom to play guitar at loud volumes being denied because it bothers someone else? I simply don't play at loud volumes when I'm at home.

A few years ago I had a neighbor who worked third shift so I mowed late in the afternoons because I didn't want to wake him. Had nothing to do with fear, just respecting my neighbors.

Apparently being respectful of others is for chumps.
 
Last edited:
Wow.

That's a damn nice slippery slope fallacy you've created.

This is not technically a slippery slope argument by the way, and certainly not a fallacy. Although it could be argued that if you give somebody an inch, they'll take a yard (and I do believe that in this case), my central point was about the arbitrariness of the activity which caused the "offense." You may not care so much because you have no desire to draw Muhammad cartoons, or have no fear that you'll accidentally draw an image of Muhammad. But some people do. And there may be an activity which you enjoy which it turns out causes some group offense. I'm trying to make you understand that bit.
 
What, coalition service members in Afghanistan weren't at risk of Talibani violence, except for this one guy's protest in Florida? And Obama seriously tried to tell us that there were no real excuses to attack US personnel in Afghanistan, without this guy in Florida?



Here, I'll highite the parts that will help you understand.


U.S. Secretary of State Hillary Clinton said, "It's regrettable that a pastor in Gainesville, Florida with a church of no more than fifty people can make this outrageous and distressful, disgraceful plan and get, you know, the world's attention."[40]

The commander of the International Security Assistance Force in Afghanistan, General David Petraeus said, "It is precisely the kind of action the Taliban uses and could cause significant problems. Not just here, but everywhere in the world we are engaged with the Islamic community." The pastor responded to Petraeus' statement that, "We understand the General's concerns. We are sure that his concerns are legitimate. [Nonetheless] [w]e must send a clear message to the radical element of Islam. We will no longer be controlled and dominated by their fears and threats."[41][42][43]

President Barack Obama was asked on September 9, 2010, on ABC's Good Morning America about the Quran burning controversy. He said, "You could have serious violence in places like Pakistan or Afghanistan. This could increase the recruitment of individuals who would be willing to blow themselves up in American cities or European cities." He said, "I just want him to understand that this stunt that he is talking about pulling could greatly endanger our young men and women in uniform who are in Iraq, who are in Afghanistan. We're already seeing protests against Americans just by the mere threat that he's making." "I just hope he understands that what he is proposing to do is completely contrary to our values as Americans, that this country has been built on the notions of religious freedom and religious tolerance," Obama said. "He says he's someone who is motivated by his faith ... I hope he listens to those better angels and understands that this is a destructive act that he's engaging in.” Asked if the event could be stopped, Obama replied, "My understanding is that he can be cited for public burning … but that's the extent of the laws that we have available to us."[44]

US Secretary of Defense Robert Gates called Jones asking him not to go through with his Koran burning.[45]

All this BS does is give radicals yet another reason.


Thank you for reminding us that Obama is possibly the biggest douchebag we've had as President since Nixon said "I am not a crook." I mean, even Clinton didn't go on morning TV talk shows to tell America "It depends upon what the meaning of the word 'is' is". What an ass.

OK. Angry conservative is angry. Noted.
 
What was the conservative position on an activity that could very well have put US personnel in harm's way because free speech

Uhh, that he shouldn't do it, but it was his legal right to do so. Also Obama's position if I'm not mistaken.
 
Uhh, that he shouldn't do it, but it was his legal right to do so. Also Obama's position if I'm not mistaken.

Interesting.

That's my positon on these matters as well; you have the freedom to do all sorts of things. You are not free from the consequences.

Weird that.

ETA: And with that, I'm out. The conservatives can continue to parrot the (R)wing echo chamber on this all they want.
 
Last edited:
There's a CNN interview with Pamela Geller here:
http://www.mediaite.com/tv/pamela-g...r-garland-shooting-why-is-media-targeting-us/

I think Ms. Geller was offended by the interview.

In the tap dance to simultaneously claim Islam is OK, I only dislike Jihadist's, one wonders why the cartoons weren't of ISIS leaders instead of Mohammed.

Rule #1 for Extremists: Always try to present a "Moderate" image.

Once again, I despise Geller but would defend her right to say what she wants.
And once again, if we start to say "well, this person;s opinion is bad so he/she should not be protected in their right to free speech" who will decide what is "bad" speech.

What is scary is how militants on both the Right and the Left seem willing to throw individual rights down the drain in pursuit of their ideologies.

And, guaranteed, if somebody was to ridicule Jesus, and some wackjob was to shoot him, some of the people here who seem to think that shooting Geller is somehow OK would be screaming for the Christian Fanantics head.
 
But then again I do many things so as to not bother my neighbors. I'm a guitarist; you think my neighbors want to listen to that all day and all night? Is my freedom to play guitar at loud volumes being denied because it bothers someone else? I simply don't play at loud volumes when I'm at home.

A few years ago I had a neighbor who worked third shift so I mowed late in the afternoons because I didn't want to wake him. Had nothing to do with fear, just respecting my neighbors.

Apparently being respectful of others is for chumps.

Terrible analogy. No one is saying Pamela Geller has the right to yell out anti-Islamic propaganda at the top of her lungs outside of a Muslims persons home, because that would be disturbing the peace, as is playing your guitar at such volumes that your neighbours are disturbed. It has nothing at all do to with the content of speech.
 
Interesting.

That's my positon on these matters as well; you have the freedom to do all sorts of things. You are not free from the consequences.

Weird that.

ETA: And with that, I'm out. The conservatives can continue to parrot the (R)wing echo chamber on this all they want.

OK, I don't even understand what you are arguing exactly then.
 
What, coalition service members in Afghanistan weren't at risk of Talibani violence, except for this one guy's protest in Florida? And Obama seriously tried to tell us that there were no real excuses to attack US personnel in Afghanistan, without this guy in Florida?

Thank you for reminding us that Obama is possibly the biggest douchebag we've had as President since Nixon said "I am not a crook." I mean, even Clinton didn't go on morning TV talk shows to tell America "It depends upon what the meaning of the word 'is' is". What an ass.

Can you cite something for me that shows President Obama saying that there were no real excuses to attack US personnel in Afghanistan, without this guy in Florida?

He has paid attention to social issues in a way that to me were a bit bungled, but he's always had his heart in the right place.
I'd hardly equate any aspect of his presidency with Nixon's douchebaggery.

Obama doesn't even rate "douchebagguete".
 
Interesting.

That's my positon on these matters as well; you have the freedom to do all sorts of things. You are not free from the consequences.

Weird that.

ETA: And with that, I'm out. The conservatives can continue to parrot the (R)wing echo chamber on this all they want.

If the consequences are violent, you might not be free from them but you're in no way responsible for them.
 
Terrible analogy. No one is saying Pamela Geller has the right to yell out anti-Islamic propaganda at the top of her lungs outside of a Muslims persons home, because that would be disturbing the peace, as is playing your guitar at such volumes that your neighbours are disturbed.

That's actually why the analogy works, I think: we restrict speech for good reasons, sometimes; we refrain from doing some things sometimes out of respect, or for other pragmatic reasons.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom