Can a CharlieHebdo-type attack happen in the US?

Finally, maybe some here should take the time to learn what freedom of speech means, who it protects, and from whom.

Because from this side of my computer screen, some of you "freedom-loving" types appear to have no clue what it is you're blathering about.


Lo and behold:

This shallow analysis has already been addressed in the thread. In fact, I tackled it in a post you tried to ridicule (lamely, IMHO), so I know you saw it. The problem with responding violently to offensive speech is that what constitutes offensive speech is inherently subjective, and reasonable people can disagree about it. One man's "dick" is another man's "prophet," or vice versa. I would like to live in a world where speech is not met with violence simply because it causes hurt feelings. I guess my view was shaped in kindergarten by the wise old adage "Sticks and stones can break my bones, but words can never hurt me." Or maybe it was "I'm rubber and you're glue ..." I'll have to think about that.

Anyway, I recognize that freedom (meaning freedom from physical harm) of speech is limited, unjustly and illegally, under certain circumstances in this country, and that's unfortunate. Crime of all kinds is an unfortunate reality, and it's impossible to eradicate completely. But it is generally thought of as a bit rude to blame the crime victim for the fact that the crime happened. In some cases, and particularly with respect to freedom of speech, blaming the victim is not just rude, but counterproductive. It ends up encouraging others to commit the same crime by diminishing the moral culpability of the criminal. So, yes, it would be wrong (indeed it is almost certainly a crime, unless there can be some reasonable claim of self-defense) for a gang of Hispanics to beat you up for standing on a street corner in their neighborhood hurling racial slurs at them. This is a matter of degrees though. It would be even more wrong for them to charge into your house and beat you up because you were hurling slurs at them through your window. It would be wronger yet if they overheard you uttering racial slurs at a private party in your own home and still beat you up. What Pamela Geller did (or has done), at worst, is equivalent to that last bit, and it's absurd to think that she "deserved" the response she got.

Word salad. Maybe you should stop digging?

This is the same nonsense that conservatives tried when the Duck Dynasty moron got "fired" from A&E. Yes, conservatives love themselves some freedom, so long as it's their brand of freedoms.

No one is limiting your freedom of speech. No. One.

If you want to engage in rhetoric and dickish behavior intended to elicit (or that you know damn well will elicit) a response of pissing people off (kinda like real-ife trolling), then by all means feel free.

But when your freedom of speech gets you punched in the face, don't come whining about how your rights are being quashed.

Or, don't be a dick. That works too.
 
For the folks here who aren't quite sure:


What Does Free Speech Mean?

Freedom of speech does not include the right:

To incite actions that would harm others (e.g., “hout[ing] ‘fire’ in a crowded theater.”).
Schenck v. United States, 249 U.S. 47 (1919).



I think I'll rent a hall and invite every white supremesist and KKK member in the state to all get together and engage in activities that will probably seriously piss off the African American community. Maybe we'll draw offensive pictures, burn effigies, hang mannequins that look like black people from nooses, etc. I'll advertise it also, so that way there could very well be be a Back Panther, Bloods, Crips or Nation of Islam presence there too. Remember, it's my freedom of speech!

Sure hope nobody gets hurt, but if they do, well too bad; price of freedom must be paid.

Right?
 
Oh look, another person who doesn't understand what "To incite actions that would harm others" means.
 
Edited by Agatha: 
Edited moderated content


Because I'm not a dick. I don't use my "freedom of speech" to piss people off because I can.

Edited by Agatha: 
Edited breach of rule 12
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Side A- We'll keep killing side B until they stop offending us.
Side B- We'll keep offending side A until they stop killing us.

Many Southpark episodes, Charlie Hebdo issues and a whole load of dead people later...nothing, no change. Pretty sure there's a overused quote that describes the above
 
Because I'm not a dick. I don't use my "freedom of speech" to piss people off because I can.

Assuming you mean "dick" in its figurative sense, not everybody is going to agree with that proposition. It's a subjective thing. Today, devout Muslims might think you're being a dick by drawing a cartoon of Muhummad. If you refrain from doing that, perhaps there will be no problem. Or perhaps next year, devout Muslims might think you're being a dick for walking your dog in their neighborhood. If you get rid of your dog, perhaps there will be no problem. Or perhaps the year after that, devout Muslims might think you're being a dick for barbecuing pork ribs on your patio because they can smell the aroma from the street. I hope that you can see that if you allow a group of people to define arbitrarily what constitutes "being a dick" that you might run into problems eventually, even if you're earnest about not "being a dick."
 
Assuming you mean "dick" in its figurative sense, not everybody is going to agree with that proposition. It's a subjective thing. Today, devout Muslims might think you're being a dick by drawing a cartoon of Muhummad. If you refrain from doing that, perhaps there will be no problem. Or perhaps next year, devout Muslims might think you're being a dick for walking your dog in their neighborhood. If you get rid of your dog, perhaps there will be no problem. Or perhaps the year after that, devout Muslims might think you're being a dick for barbecuing pork ribs on your patio because they can smell the aroma from the street. I hope that you can see that if you allow a group of people to define arbitrarily what constitutes "being a dick" that you might run into problems eventually, even if you're earnest about not "being a dick."

Wow.

That's a damn nice slippery slope fallacy you've created.
 
By the way, do any of the conservatives in this thread remember Florida Pastor Terry Jones and his Koran burning BS threat he announced on July 12, 2010?

U.S. Secretary of State Hillary Clinton said, "It's regrettable that a pastor in Gainesville, Florida with a church of no more than fifty people can make this outrageous and distressful, disgraceful plan and get, you know, the world's attention."[40]

The commander of the International Security Assistance Force in Afghanistan, General David Petraeus said, "It is precisely the kind of action the Taliban uses and could cause significant problems. Not just here, but everywhere in the world we are engaged with the Islamic community." The pastor responded to Petraeus' statement that, "We understand the General's concerns. We are sure that his concerns are legitimate. [Nonetheless] [w]e must send a clear message to the radical element of Islam. We will no longer be controlled and dominated by their fears and threats."[41][42][43]

President Barack Obama was asked on September 9, 2010, on ABC's Good Morning America about the Quran burning controversy. He said, "You could have serious violence in places like Pakistan or Afghanistan. This could increase the recruitment of individuals who would be willing to blow themselves up in American cities or European cities." He said, "I just want him to understand that this stunt that he is talking about pulling could greatly endanger our young men and women in uniform who are in Iraq, who are in Afghanistan. We're already seeing protests against Americans just by the mere threat that he's making." "I just hope he understands that what he is proposing to do is completely contrary to our values as Americans, that this country has been built on the notions of religious freedom and religious tolerance," Obama said. "He says he's someone who is motivated by his faith ... I hope he listens to those better angels and understands that this is a destructive act that he's engaging in.” Asked if the event could be stopped, Obama replied, "My understanding is that he can be cited for public burning … but that's the extent of the laws that we have available to us."[44]

US Secretary of Defense Robert Gates called Jones asking him not to go through with his Koran burning.[45]

What was the conservative position on an activity that could very well have put US personnel in harm's way because free speech?

He cancelled that, but did another later:

On March 21, 2011, Jones and some supporters held a mock trial of the Koran and set a copy on fire as a "punishment" for “crimes against humanity.” Jones was assisted by Ahmed Abaza, an Egyptian ex-Muslim, and a Texas Imam, Mohamed El Hassan who argued for and against the accusations. Reaction to the event resulted in riots and deaths in Afghanistan.[47][48][48]
 
I just double-checked my Koran. They're not worried about dog walking....

What's it say about BBQing pork on my deck?

I'd wager a bottle of Crown Royal that the conservatives bleating the loudest about Islam have the least experience interacting with or actually knowing any Muslims.

Call it a hunch.
 
For the folks here who aren't quite sure:


What Does Free Speech Mean?




I think I'll rent a hall and invite every white supremesist and KKK member in the state to all get together and engage in activities that will probably seriously piss off the African American community. Maybe we'll draw offensive pictures, burn effigies, hang mannequins that look like black people from nooses, etc. I'll advertise it also, so that way there could very well be be a Back Panther, Bloods, Crips or Nation of Islam presence there too. Remember, it's my freedom of speech!

Sure hope nobody gets hurt, but if they do, well too bad; price of freedom must be paid.

Right?

You could do that but that wasn't what was happening, it was a contest but facts fly away faster than bullets here.
 
Side A- We'll keep killing side B until they stop offending us.
Side B- We'll keep offending side A until they stop killing us.

While I see the value in this analysis, I gotta say that Cracking Down On Side A Killing People Who Offend Them is much much higher on my to-do list than Cracking Down on Side B Offending People. Indeed, outside of some fairly extreme edge cases, that second item isn't even on my to-do list at all. Free speech shall not be infringed without a compelling government interest and all that. The way I see it, using violence to suppress acts of speech creates a compelling government interest in infringing upon the attacker's right to life and liberty, not a compelling government interest in infringing upon the victim's right to free speech.

And even outside the narrow context of government intrusion, I think the quoted bit is explicitly inane and implicitly craven. To the extent that it is intended to suggest moral equivalence between Side A and Side B, it is also morally depraved.
 
Last edited:
What's it say about BBQing pork on my deck?

I'd wager a bottle of Crown Royal that the conservatives bleating the loudest about Islam have the least experience interacting with or actually knowing any Muslims.

Call it a hunch.

Would you quit if Muslims told you it offends them?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom