Can a CharlieHebdo-type attack happen in the US?

It could be viewed as bullying in the form of "ehy, this offends you ? Well, I'll just do it againd and again and again."

Mind you, I fully agree with the right of free speech in this instance, and the violence that this 'generates' is a greater evil, for sure.

Being offended is not being bullyed.
 
I think one way is for the Islamic moderates to stop pussyfooting and whining about how they cannot be held collectively responsible for the actions of terrorists.

What exactly should they be doing to stop total strangers from other countries to commit acts they find revolting ?
 
Well, no, I think that is a fairly reasonable response.




Their perception is that the speech is bigoted and hateful. That may be open for debate, but that is their perception, and perception is what matters in this context. The important part is that they acknowledge that violence is not an appropriate response to being offended. Further, the acknowledge that censorship is also not an appropriate response.

I'd say that is a very reasonable, rational position to take. "Yes, I'm offended, but they have a right to offend me. I have no right to kill or censor them; though I do have the equal right to speak out agaisnt their bigotry."

Whether the event is "objectively" offensive or not is completely irrelevant. What matters is how people response to it when do find themselves offended by it. Some use their offense as an excuse to censor and harm the offenders; others take a more rational approach, acknowledge the offenders right to free speech, and respond with more free speech opposing and denouncing the offenders.

That is about as reasonable as it gets with humans, right there.

As much as it pains me to say this, I have to agree with you on CAIR here. While I suspect they had to hold their noses tight to able to say it what they said, the fact is that they said it and I can't think of anything more that they could do and still be CAIR.
 
Indeed: surrender to the demands of violent maniacs, and they won't hurt you. Very simple.

Yes, that is one solution.

Thing is, there are three basic responses to situations like this:

- If you accept the risks, you can draw the prophet.
- If you don't, you can: A) not draw the prophet or B) eliminate the source of violence (in which case, I suspect, you'd have no reason to draw him in the first place).
 
This thread is interesting because of the numbers of posters who somehow can't understand the difference between "freedom of speech" and "freedom from consequences".

What? You mean I can't go to the bad parts of town dressed in blackface shouting "**** the N-words!" without fear of being beaten or killed? My freedom of speech is being limited!

What? You mean I can't call the White House and (jokingly) tell them I'm gonna kill president Obama without the Secret Service visiting me? My freedom of speech is being limited!

There's a section of town here that has an MS13 element. Maybe I should roll down there and announce loudly my hatred for hispanics. And should they respond negatively, well shucks; My freedom of speech is being limited!

How's about this tactic: Don't be a dick. Especially if your dickish behavior is hidden behind "Freedom of speech!". And don't expect not to be called out at some point, maybe even physically.

Finally, maybe some here should take the time to learn what freedom of speech means, who it protects, and from whom.

Because from this side of my computer screen, some of you "freedom-loving" types appear to have no clue what it is you're blathering about.
 
Last edited:
"If you insult Mahomet you have to expect that someone will try to kill you" is what the deep thinkers are telling us.

Depth has nothing to do with it: it's simply true.

I disagree. "Eroding" is too strong. Images of Mohammed weren't even a "thing" a couple of decades ago. They've only become worth drawing because of the reaction they get.

Precisely.

No, it's not. That word has a long history of association with violence against and oppression of a specific racial/ethnic minority. It is inherently a term of degradation. That said, there should be no official proscription of its use. Refusal to use it is to acknowledge the historical associations and cultural context, as a general rule, not fear of violence from that community.

Drawing pictures of Mohammed, by contrast, has no such history or cultural context.

True, but that's not the point: both could offend to the point where violence ensues.

There is no way to ever be completely safe from extremists as long as they exist. Worse, the more we capitulate to violence extremists, the more other irrational actors will see that violence is an effective tacit to obtain their desires.

Entirely agree.

Why is the responsibility of my speech proportional to the actions of other people?

An excellent question. I would say that when your actions run the risk of hurting others as collateral damage, your responsibility increases.
 
It's quite telling that, when confronted with the subject of injustice and oppression, your advice is to "run away". That's beyond cowardly, and beyond victim blaming.

Luchog, please. You and I may disagree with that solution, but how would capitulating in order to safeguard yourself and the people around you such a totally bad decision ?

I wonder how you would react if the threat to you and your loved ones was very, very present. I know I'd be a coward to you. But it's easy for us to be tough behind a keyboard.
 
This thread is interesting because of the numbers of posters who somehow can't understand the difference between "freedom of speech" and "freedom from consequences".

What? You mean I can't go to the bad parts of town dressed in blackface shouting "**** the N-words!" without fear of being beaten or killed? My freedom of speech is being limited!

What? You mean I can't call the White House and (jokingly) tell them I'm gonna kill president Obama without the Secret Service visiting me? My freedom of speech is being limited!

There's a section of town here that has an MS13 element. Maybe I should roll down there and announce loudly my hatred for hispanics. And should they respond negatively, well shucks; My freedom of speech is being limited!

How's about this tactic: Don't be a dick. Especially if your dickish behavior is hidden behind "Freedom of speech!". And don't expect not to be called out at some point, maybe even physically.

Finally, maybe some here should take the time to learn what freedom of speech means, who it protects, and from whom.

Because from this side of my computer screen, some of you "freedom-loving" types appear to have no clue what it is you're blathering about.

How about if you rent a private hall for a private event and someone comes armed to kill you?
 
You misunderstand: the offended party may interpret as bullying the repetitious and intentional nature of the offense.

By calling it an offense you are already making a judgement.

Should the truth be banned just because some are offended by it?
 
How about if you rent a private hall for a private event and someone comes armed to kill you?

I covered that in my post:

How's about this tactic: Don't be a dick. Especially if your dickish behavior is hidden behind "Freedom of speech!". And don't expect not to be called out at some point, maybe even physically.

And:

What? You mean I can't call the White House from the privacy of my own home and (jokingly) tell them I'm gonna kill president Obama without the Secret Service visiting me? My freedom of speech is being limited!


Highlighting added. Doesn't matter where the event is held.
 
Last edited:
On the one hand, women choose their clothing for many reasons (comfort, fashion, etc.). It may be that a woman chooses clothing realizing it will offend someone, but not for the sake of offense.

On the other hand, the sole reason to have a Mohammed cartoon contest is because the cartoons offend. Were it not for the offense, no contest would have occurred. The offense is the point.

Also, bear in mind that the people offended by said drawings _know_ that they are drawn to offend them.

I do see it as less reasonable, since being Muslim is a choice

Not always.

It is not an overreach. If muslims can stop speach they do not like with threats of violence, do you really imagine other groups will not adopt the same strategy to silence speech they oppose?

An excellent observation. What is the best way to reduce the violence ? To offend the violent ? To attack them ? To leave them alone ? All three seem to contain hidden consequences that may lead us right back to violence. I honestly don't know which answer is best, if any.
 
The excuses made for the terrorists by some of the people on this thread are bordering on racism.

Amusing. Attacking Muslims is racist. Defending them is racist. That word means less and less as time passes.

No, you don't understand free speech.

Really? You are that ignorant of history?

Perhaps this sort of rhetoric is not the best choice if you want an actual conversation. Of course, if that's not what you want...

No, marplots, it does NOT enhance free speech. How can it possibly enhance free speech when it by definition restricts speech? It's positively Orwellian to suggest otherwise.

As an analogy, would you agree that restricting the free market, and thereby prevent the creation of monopolies, actually helps it ?

Note that I am not arguing for limiting free speech, I'm simply addressing this one point of yours.

Apparently, the risk of attack was worth holding a contest to draw pictures of Mohammed for the people organizing the event. At least it was prospectively. We will have to wait and see if they hold the event again.

Indeed. In fact, Charlie Hebdo must have thought it was worth the attack because they made more drawings on the very next issue.
 
This thread is interesting because of the numbers of posters who somehow can't understand the difference between "freedom of speech" and "freedom from consequences".

What? You mean I can't go to the bad parts of town dressed in blackface shouting "**** the N-words!" without fear of being beaten or killed? My freedom of speech is being limited!

What? You mean I can't call the White House and (jokingly) tell them I'm gonna kill president Obama without the Secret Service visiting me? My freedom of speech is being limited!

There's a section of town here that has an MS13 element. Maybe I should roll down there and announce loudly my hatred for hispanics. And should they respond negatively, well shucks; My freedom of speech is being limited!

How's about this tactic: Don't be a dick. Especially if your dickish behavior is hidden behind "Freedom of speech!". And don't expect not to be called out at some point, maybe even physically.

Finally, maybe some here should take the time to learn what freedom of speech means, who it protects, and from whom.

Because from this side of my computer screen, some of you "freedom-loving" types appear to have no clue what it is you're blathering about.

This shallow analysis has already been addressed in the thread. In fact, I tackled it in a post you tried to ridicule (lamely, IMHO), so I know you saw it. The problem with responding violently to offensive speech is that what constitutes offensive speech is inherently subjective, and reasonable people can disagree about it. One man's "dick" is another man's "prophet," or vice versa. I would like to live in a world where speech is not met with violence simply because it causes hurt feelings. I guess my view was shaped in kindergarten by the wise old adage "Sticks and stones can break my bones, but words can never hurt me." Or maybe it was "I'm rubber and you're glue ..." I'll have to think about that.

Anyway, I recognize that freedom (meaning freedom from physical harm) of speech is limited, unjustly and illegally, under certain circumstances in this country, and that's unfortunate. Crime of all kinds is an unfortunate reality, and it's impossible to eradicate completely. But it is generally thought of as a bit rude to blame the crime victim for the fact that the crime happened. In some cases, and particularly with respect to freedom of speech, blaming the victim is not just rude, but counterproductive. It ends up encouraging others to commit the same crime by diminishing the moral culpability of the criminal. So, yes, it would be wrong (indeed it is almost certainly a crime, unless there can be some reasonable claim of self-defense) for a gang of Hispanics to beat you up for standing on a street corner in their neighborhood hurling racial slurs at them. This is a matter of degrees though. It would be even more wrong for them to charge into your house and beat you up because you were hurling slurs at them through your window. It would be wronger yet if they overheard you uttering racial slurs at a private party in your own home and still beat you up. What Pamela Geller did (or has done), at worst, is equivalent to that last bit, and it's absurd to think that she "deserved" the response she got.
 
Might makes right?

Unfortunately (or perhaps fortunately, I'm not sure), yes. It's simply a fact that the person with the bigger stick makes the rules (unless the people present just agree to cooperate or they have an incentive to do so).

Does she oppose the construction of all new mosques or only the one near Ground Zero? I opposed that too. I thought it was a deliberate provocation that was being facilitated by local government.

Except that it wasn't. There had been something there for a long time already, and it wasn't near ground zero.

Everyone has doubts, even the most fanatical.

In fact, I suspect the most fanatical have more doubts, and compensate with their fanaticism.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom