I know almost nothing abt Pamela Gellar, so after reading the earl reports what she was some sort of hate monger I went to the SPLC website to see why they thought so. This seems to be among their earliest claims against her, in the context of the ground-zero mosque issue.
Hmmm - is it really hate speech to claim that some group will turn to intimidation & violence if they can't achieve some goal otherwise ? What if the claim is demonstrated to be true by fact, that they did use intimidation and violence to prevent expression of a political right ?
Who made the SPLC the national arbiter of hate speech ? What does it even mean ? The definition of "hate speech" seem to encompass a lot of things I see on the internet, and even this forum.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hate_speech
So for example saying NAMBLA is despicable or that deists are silly & illogical is hate speech in the non-legal sense.
The interpretation in the US is worth a read. I think it's vastly superior to the Canadian approach for example. "Fighting words" the 'imminent danger' test, and especially the prohibition of the state to restrict content.
So Gellars group seems well within the law. They weren't expressing their ideas by taunting the faithful in front of a Mosque. There were expressing their views in a private venue that was clearly not meant to incite imminent violence.
Here is the Cair response:
http://www.cair.com/press-center/pr...emns-attack-on-anti-islam-event-in-texas.html
Well - duh! That's the low-bar, minimal concession possible.
It seems more of an insult-fest, a counter-attack, than an apology or position statement.
"Anti-Islam": The event was meant to advertise the factual intolerance of Muslims wrt aniconism. The same interpretation that causes some Muslim groups to destroy centuries old artifacts. It's not anti-Islamic any more than a Monty Python skit abt large families & contraception is anti-Catholic; it does not indict the religious belief systems, it lampoons it and challenges their views based on results, or social implication.
Defamatory: The cartoons were far less defamatory toward Islam than the intolerance of Islamists. Anyone reviewing the thoughtful & inciteful winning cartoon won't see defamation as the goal. Holding a mirror to a problem is not defamation. Cair is free to rebut, but this is an attempt to re-frame and distort.
AFAIK there is no way to challenge any belief without pointing out the problems. Religions are famously closed belief systems that reject alternative information & evidence. Any VOLUNTARY adherent has every right to put their fingers in their ears and sing "la-la-la", when someone challenges their view. They have zero right to stifle the debate, the challenge.
The "Bigoted speech" is apparently supposed to be the fact of a Mohammed cartoon event. I disagree. Bigotry is defined intolerance of alternative ideas. The main & problematic bigotry here is that
some Muslims are bigoted and intolerant of others rights to free speech, to the point of committing murders. There is a fundamental problem wrt tolerance of the intolerant that needs to be aired.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paradox_of_tolerance
----
The cartoon event was socially rude. Dung-covered Madonna was socially rude. When the net Islamic response is closer to the Catholic response wrt DCM, then they might have an argument that their belief system is compatible with life in a pluralistic secular society.