Can a CharlieHebdo-type attack happen in the US?

"‘I disapprove of what you say, but I will defend to the death your right to say it" - Beatrice Evelyn Hall, misattributed to Voltaire (by the author of the quote).

For an actual Voltaire quote, “The supposed right of intolerance is absurd and barbaric. It is the right of the tiger; nay, it is far worse, for tigers do but tear in order to have food, while we rend each other for paragraphs.”

But he did say "To learn who rules over you, simply find out who you cannot criticize", right?
 
Of course, this isn't the first time a group branded by the $PLC as a "hate group" has been targeted for violence...

The $PLC sure does seem to inspire people to act out violently. Maybe they should include themselves on their list.

I know almost nothing abt Pamela Gellar, so after reading the earl reports what she was some sort of hate monger I went to the SPLC website to see why they thought so. This seems to be among their earliest claims against her, in the context of the ground-zero mosque issue.

She warned that Muslims will “turn to further intimidation, murder and terrorism” if they can’t achieve a political takeover.

Hmmm - is it really hate speech to claim that some group will turn to intimidation & violence if they can't achieve some goal otherwise ? What if the claim is demonstrated to be true by fact, that they did use intimidation and violence to prevent expression of a political right ?

Who made the SPLC the national arbiter of hate speech ? What does it even mean ? The definition of "hate speech" seem to encompass a lot of things I see on the internet, and even this forum.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hate_speech

Hate speech is, outside the law, speech that attacks a person or group on the basis of attributes such as gender, ethnic origin, religion, race, disability, or sexual orientation.[1][2]

So for example saying NAMBLA is despicable or that deists are silly & illogical is hate speech in the non-legal sense.

In law, hate speech is any speech, gesture or conduct, writing, or display which is forbidden because it may incite violence or prejudicial action against or by a protected individual or group, or because it disparages or intimidates a protected individual or group. The law may identify a protected individual or a protected group by certain characteristics.

The interpretation in the US is worth a read. I think it's vastly superior to the Canadian approach for example. "Fighting words" the 'imminent danger' test, and especially the prohibition of the state to restrict content.

So Gellars group seems well within the law. They weren't expressing their ideas by taunting the faithful in front of a Mosque. There were expressing their views in a private venue that was clearly not meant to incite imminent violence.

Here is the Cair response:
http://www.cair.com/press-center/pr...emns-attack-on-anti-islam-event-in-texas.html


CAIR-logo(WASHINGTON, D.C., 5/4/15) – The Council on American-Islamic Relations (CAIR), the nation's largest Muslim civil rights and advocacy organization, today condemned an attack Sunday on an anti-Islam event in Texas.

In a statement, CAIR said:

"We condemn yesterday's attack on an anti-Islam event in Garland, Texas, without reservation.

Well - duh! That's the low-bar, minimal concession possible.

"We also reiterate our view that violence in response to anti-Islam programs like the one in Garland is more insulting to our faith than any cartoon, however defamatory. Bigoted speech can never be an excuse for violence.

It seems more of an insult-fest, a counter-attack, than an apology or position statement.

"Anti-Islam": The event was meant to advertise the factual intolerance of Muslims wrt aniconism. The same interpretation that causes some Muslim groups to destroy centuries old artifacts. It's not anti-Islamic any more than a Monty Python skit abt large families & contraception is anti-Catholic; it does not indict the religious belief systems, it lampoons it and challenges their views based on results, or social implication.

Defamatory: The cartoons were far less defamatory toward Islam than the intolerance of Islamists. Anyone reviewing the thoughtful & inciteful winning cartoon won't see defamation as the goal. Holding a mirror to a problem is not defamation. Cair is free to rebut, but this is an attempt to re-frame and distort.

AFAIK there is no way to challenge any belief without pointing out the problems. Religions are famously closed belief systems that reject alternative information & evidence. Any VOLUNTARY adherent has every right to put their fingers in their ears and sing "la-la-la", when someone challenges their view. They have zero right to stifle the debate, the challenge.

The "Bigoted speech" is apparently supposed to be the fact of a Mohammed cartoon event. I disagree. Bigotry is defined intolerance of alternative ideas. The main & problematic bigotry here is that some Muslims are bigoted and intolerant of others rights to free speech, to the point of committing murders. There is a fundamental problem wrt tolerance of the intolerant that needs to be aired.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paradox_of_tolerance


----

The cartoon event was socially rude. Dung-covered Madonna was socially rude. When the net Islamic response is closer to the Catholic response wrt DCM, then they might have an argument that their belief system is compatible with life in a pluralistic secular society.
 
Last edited:
Is it irrational to become upset when someone calls your mother a whore?


Absolutely! Even if my Mom wasn't a whore it wouldn't bother me. One may initially have a negative reaction to any insult, but a rational person will see it for what it is - an ignorant moron whose opinion is not worthy of any consideration.
 
Sorry, I'm having trouble following your analogy. Anti-Israel demonstrators assembled as a mob probably do endanger bystanders. Certainly, those Palestinians who fire missiles at Israel endanger Palestinian civilians, who may be targeted in retaliation.

Well, first off, my hypothetical has nothing to do with Palestinian militia in the ME or out of control mobs. I'm talking about legally organized, peacefully assembled anti-Israel demonstrators in, say, the US for example. Following your method of assigning responsibility for violent attacks, Zionist extremists, whose goal would be to discredit and eventually shut down these demonstrations ought to systematically and brutally attack as many of these demonstrations as they can. That way, the ambassadors of responsibility and civility can hold the anti-Israeli demonstrators to account for their part in provoking these attacks upon themselves.

That is, if they were to be consistent. Which, of course, I'm sure they would be.
 
Well, first off, my hypothetical has nothing to do with Palestinian militia in the ME or out of control mobs. I'm talking about legally organized, peacefully assembled anti-Israel demonstrators in, say, the US for example. Following your method of assigning responsibility for violent attacks, Zionist extremists, whose goal would be to discredit and eventually shut down these demonstrations ought to systematically and brutally attack as many of these demonstrations as they can. That way, the ambassadors of responsibility and civility can hold the anti-Israeli demonstrators to account for their part in provoking these attacks upon themselves.

That is, if they were to be consistent. Which, of course, I'm sure they would be.

Hypothetical consistency is the easiest kind.
 
Absolutely! Even if my Mom wasn't a whore it wouldn't bother me. One may initially have a negative reaction to any insult, but a rational person will see it for what it is - an ignorant moron whose opinion is not worthy of any consideration.

Perhaps, but that's missing the point I was aiming at.

Let us change the situation slightly. Suppose someone is spreading lies about your mother's life as a whore, and others believe it. Suppose further that dear ol' Mom is dead, and that it is not well-known that she is your mother, so she will not suffer due to the rumors (being dead, she has no interest) and you will not suffer either (because it will not reflect on you).

In this case, many people are coming to believe something false and widely regarded as despicable about a person you love.

According to luchog, it is irrational to feel offense here -- because luchog thinks all emotion is irrational. I blame Star Trek. And I think that, even though there are no obvious interests involved, offense is an appropriate response.

I think we've gotten a bit off the track at this point.
 
I'm talking about legally organized, peacefully assembled anti-Israel demonstrators in, say, the US for example. Following your method of assigning responsibility for violent attacks, Zionist extremists, whose goal would be to discredit and eventually shut down these demonstrations ought to systematically and brutally attack as many of these demonstrations as they can.

It helps your argument that you used the word "responsibility" vs. "blame." "Responsibility" is much closer to what I was thinking than "blame." Several pages back a poster asked whether a college student who dressed like a "slut," who gets drunk at a frat party, and who then is gang-raped, needs to change her behavior. I didn't respond in a timely way and the thread moved on. Of course I don't "blame" the victim there. In a world without predators she wouldn't have to change her behavior (and the word "slut" might never have been invented). But we don't live in that world and getting drunk to the point of incapacitation is dangerous and presumably within the victim's control. I'm not talking about date rape drugs slipped in a drink, obviously.

But to your point: Do you really think the motivation of Islamist extremists who fire into a crowd is to discredit bands of Muhammad mockers? IMO, they are not thinking on that level. If they are thinking at all, they would realize such violence discredits only them. I still think we are looking at haters, not strategists. Violent haters who glom onto an ideology that validates and celebrates such violence. I felt the same way about people who have shot at or bombed abortion clinics. They were looking for an excuse to use violence that would be condoned in some circles. I think it had very little (if anything) to do with being pro-life.
 
Last edited:
I know almost nothing abt Pamela Gellar, so after reading the earl reports what she was some sort of hate monger I went to the SPLC website to see why they thought so. This seems to be among their earliest claims against her, in the context of the ground-zero mosque issue.



Hmmm - is it really hate speech to claim that some group will turn to intimidation & violence if they can't achieve some goal otherwise ? What if the claim is demonstrated to be true by fact, that they did use intimidation and violence to prevent expression of a political right ?

Who made the SPLC the national arbiter of hate speech ? What does it even mean ? The definition of "hate speech" seem to encompass a lot of things I see on the internet, and even this forum.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hate_speech



So for example saying NAMBLA is despicable or that deists are silly & illogical is hate speech in the non-legal sense.



The interpretation in the US is worth a read. I think it's vastly superior to the Canadian approach for example. "Fighting words" the 'imminent danger' test, and especially the prohibition of the state to restrict content.

So Gellars group seems well within the law. They weren't expressing their ideas by taunting the faithful in front of a Mosque. There were expressing their views in a private venue that was clearly not meant to incite imminent violence.

Here is the Cair response:
http://www.cair.com/press-center/pr...emns-attack-on-anti-islam-event-in-texas.html




Well - duh! That's the low-bar, minimal concession possible.



It seems more of an insult-fest, a counter-attack, than an apology or position statement.

"Anti-Islam": The event was meant to advertise the factual intolerance of Muslims wrt aniconism. The same interpretation that causes some Muslim groups to destroy centuries old artifacts. It's not anti-Islamic any more than a Monty Python skit abt large families & contraception is anti-Catholic; it does not indict the religious belief systems, it lampoons it and challenges their views based on results, or social implication.

Defamatory: The cartoons were far less defamatory toward Islam than the intolerance of Islamists. Anyone reviewing the thoughtful & inciteful winning cartoon won't see defamation as the goal. Holding a mirror to a problem is not defamation. Cair is free to rebut, but this is an attempt to re-frame and distort.

AFAIK there is no way to challenge any belief without pointing out the problems. Religions are famously closed belief systems that reject alternative information & evidence. Any VOLUNTARY adherent has every right to put their fingers in their ears and sing "la-la-la", when someone challenges their view. They have zero right to stifle the debate, the challenge.

The "Bigoted speech" is apparently supposed to be the fact of a Mohammed cartoon event. I disagree. Bigotry is defined intolerance of alternative ideas. The main & problematic bigotry here is that some Muslims are bigoted and intolerant of others rights to free speech, to the point of committing murders. There is a fundamental problem wrt tolerance of the intolerant that needs to be aired.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paradox_of_tolerance


----

The cartoon event was socially rude. Dung-covered Madonna was socially rude. When the net Islamic response is closer to the Catholic response wrt DCM, then they might have an argument that their belief system is compatible with life in a pluralistic secular society.

All well said, except for the highlighted part. In giving it more thought, I don't think the cartoon event was socially rude at all. Because of the political and religious significance of drawing caricatures of Muhammad, it is a fertile area for cartoon-based satire and commentary. Furthermore, and perhaps ironically, the factor that makes it most relevant is what makes it under-explored. It is relevant in large part because it is dangerous to do, but because it is dangerous to do, there is not enough of it done. This idea is wonderfully encapsulated in the winning cartoon, which I think is brilliant.

In summary, this conference was not some worthless hate-fest as so many liberal commentators in the media are asserting (almost entirely without any factual or logical support whatsoever). In addition to making an important political statement, it was culturally enriching. Far more so than a typical political protest or conference. Actually, far more so than the schlock I've seen from Charlie Hebdo to be frank.
 
There's a CNN interview with Pamela Geller here:
http://www.mediaite.com/tv/pamela-g...r-garland-shooting-why-is-media-targeting-us/

I think Ms. Geller was offended by the interview.

In the tap dance to simultaneously claim Islam is OK, I only dislike Jihadist's, one wonders why the cartoons weren't of ISIS leaders instead of Mohammed.

The more I learn about Pamela Geller, the more I am coming to understand that she has been intentionally slandered by her opponents, and the media have been carrying the slanderers' water for them. stevea's reference to the Paradox of Tolerance is key to understanding the dynamic here. Most people accused of being Islamophobes and anti-Islam bigots are in fact simply intolerant of the intolerance they see as endemic in the Islamic world. These are good and tolerant and civilized people who would open their hearts and their homes to tolerant people of all faiths, including Muslims. However, the goal of the accusers is to conflate their intolerance of intolerance with the taboo of intolerance for harmless ethnic and cultural (even racial) differences. In large part they've been successful in a way that, for example, political groups in the US have not.

Take the fight over abortion as an example. Arguably, abortions are more offensive to devout Catholics than the drawing of Muhammad is to devout Muslims. And yet if these pro-life Catholics protest abortion clinics, let alone commit violence, they are subject to withering criticism by a large part of the American public, the vast majority of a major political party, and much of the mainstream media. Could the pro-life people get away with calling their critics "haters" and "bigots?" So far they haven't. In fact, posters in this forum routinely declare their hatred of pro-life activists, or even political conservatives generally, but they don't seem to fear being labeled as haters or bigots.

As for your question about why the cartoons weren't of ISIS leaders instead of Muhammad, well, the answer should be obvious. There is no taboo on drawing cartoons of ISIS leaders. There are plenty of such cartoons, and, to my knowledge, there are no media outlets in the West which would fear publishing them. Furthermore, the cultural significance of cartoons of ISIS leaders is pretty low. In addition to the fact that the names and the faces of ISIS leaders are practically unknown (I couldn't identify one, for example, either by name or by face), the group and its leaders are practically self-parodying. It would be like drawing a cartoon of the village idiot. It hardly stimulates any thinking.
 
In summary, this conference was not some worthless hate-fest as so many liberal commentators in the media are asserting (almost entirely without any factual or logical support whatsoever). In addition to making an important political statement, it was culturally enriching. Far more so than a typical political protest or conference. Actually, far more so than the schlock I've seen from Charlie Hebdo to be frank.

Talk about putting lipstick on a pig! Well, actually,... no, you've gone from merely putting lipstick on it to getting its hair and nails done, buying it a prom dress and a corsage, and getting a limo to get it to the ball on time!

Culturally enriching?
 
Talk about putting lipstick on a pig! Well, actually,... no, you've gone from merely putting lipstick on it to getting its hair and nails done, buying it a prom dress and a corsage, and getting a limo to get it to the ball on time!

Culturally enriching?

I'm sorry. Did you want to make an argument or something? I must have missed it.
 
I'm sorry. Did you want to make an argument or something? I must have missed it.

I'm just exercising my free speech, man. It's a parody, maybe even a mockery of your inflated description of this publicity stunt staged by a bunch of hate mongers. Cartoons are cool. So, parody is cool. I'm doing this to culturally enrich the forum. If you're too blinded by your ideology to see how that was an important post on an important cultural issue, that's probably your problem. Maybe you're too sensitive to criticism and free speech?
 
I see nothing that makes emotions irrational, personally. Seems to me that some emotions are reasonable, valuable, motivate us to do what is in our interests and so on.


Well, no, if they're reasonable, then they're not emotions. That's the very definition of emotions.

English words have established meanings, you don't get to redefine them because they're inconvenient for you.

ir·ra·tion·al
i(r)ˈraSH(ə)nəl/
adjective
adjective: irrational

1.
not logical or reasonable. synonyms: unreasonable, illogical, groundless, baseless, unfounded, unjustifiable; More
absurd, ridiculous, ludicrous, preposterous, silly, foolish, senseless
"an irrational fear of insects"
antonyms: reasonable, logical
not endowed with the power of reason.


The primary meaning and most common usage of "irrational" is "not rational". That is what irrational means. It's from the Latin 'ir', meaning "not", and 'rationalis', meaning "having the ability to reason" - ir-rationalis, not having the ability to reason.

e·mo·tion
əˈmōSH(ə)n/
noun
noun: emotion; plural noun: emotions

a natural instinctive state of mind deriving from one's circumstances, mood, or relationships with others.
"she was attempting to control her emotions"
synonyms: feeling, sentiment; More
reaction, response
"she was good at hiding her emotions"
passion, strength of feeling, warmth of feeling
"overcome by emotion, she turned away"
instinctive or intuitive feeling as distinguished from reasoning or knowledge.
"responses have to be based on historical insight, not simply on emotion"
synonyms: instinct, intuition, gut feeling;


Words have meanings, those are the meanings of those words. Very little you say in your post is valid once you understand that.

But very well: let's take for granted that emotional responses are literally irrational. Is that sufficient for us to conclude that there's no onus on us to consider the emotional responses of others when choosing our actions?


Who here is not considering the emotional responses? The entire thread is about considering emotional responses, and the most valid response to those responses. One can consider another's emotional response without being bound to change one's behaviour to accommodate it.


How is it a challenge to their beliefs? If I draw Mohammed, I am doing something they think I shouldn't do, but I haven't given them any reason to reconsider their beliefs in the slightest.


Doing anything that violates someone else's beliefs, that has no impact otherwise, is always a challenge to those beliefs. And you don't know that it hasn't caused them to reconsider their beliefs; that's merely your unsupported belief.


Non-rational and irrational are different. If emotion is merely not rational, then it isn't irrational, it is non-rational.


No they're not. Again, we're back to English words having established meanings. See above.

Cheese isn't rational, but we wouldn't call it irrational.


Erm, what? Cheese isn't sentient, so we cannot call it rational or irrational. It's an object. People are not objects, they are sentient beings with agency, and can choose rationality or irrationality. This is not rocket surgery.

Emotions furthermore play important motivational roles, directing us towards some actions and away from others.


Irrelevant to the fact that they're irrational.

Everything else you say in this post is clearly nonsense once your specious redefinitions are accounted for.
 
Here is the Cair response:
http://www.cair.com/press-center/pr...emns-attack-on-anti-islam-event-in-texas.html

Well - duh! That's the low-bar, minimal concession possible.

It seems more of an insult-fest, a counter-attack, than an apology or position statement.


Well, no, I think that is a fairly reasonable response.

"We reiterate the American Muslim community's support for freedom of speech - even bigoted speech – and its repudiation of terrorism in any form."


Their perception is that the speech is bigoted and hateful. That may be open for debate, but that is their perception, and perception is what matters in this context. The important part is that they acknowledge that violence is not an appropriate response to being offended. Further, the acknowledge that censorship is also not an appropriate response.

I'd say that is a very reasonable, rational position to take. "Yes, I'm offended, but they have a right to offend me. I have no right to kill or censor them; though I do have the equal right to speak out agaisnt their bigotry."

Whether the event is "objectively" offensive or not is completely irrelevant. What matters is how people response to it when do find themselves offended by it. Some use their offense as an excuse to censor and harm the offenders; others take a more rational approach, acknowledge the offenders right to free speech, and respond with more free speech opposing and denouncing the offenders.

That is about as reasonable as it gets with humans, right there.
 
Talk about putting lipstick on a pig! Well, actually,... no, you've gone from merely putting lipstick on it to getting its hair and nails done, buying it a prom dress and a corsage, and getting a limo to get it to the ball on time!

Culturally enriching?

You have to look beyond the hate.
 
The more I learn about Pamela Geller, the more I am coming to understand that she has been intentionally slandered by her opponents, and the media have been carrying the slanderers' water for them. stevea's reference to the Paradox of Tolerance is key to understanding the dynamic here. Most people accused of being Islamophobes and anti-Islam bigots are in fact simply intolerant of the intolerance they see as endemic in the Islamic world. These are good and tolerant and civilized people who would open their hearts and their homes to tolerant people of all faiths, including Muslims. However, the goal of the accusers is to conflate their intolerance of intolerance with the taboo of intolerance for harmless ethnic and cultural (even racial) differences. In large part they've been successful in a way that, for example, political groups in the US have not.

Take the fight over abortion as an example. Arguably, abortions are more offensive to devout Catholics than the drawing of Muhammad is to devout Muslims. And yet if these pro-life Catholics protest abortion clinics, let alone commit violence, they are subject to withering criticism by a large part of the American public, the vast majority of a major political party, and much of the mainstream media. Could the pro-life people get away with calling their critics "haters" and "bigots?" So far they haven't. In fact, posters in this forum routinely declare their hatred of pro-life activists, or even political conservatives generally, but they don't seem to fear being labeled as haters or bigots.

As for your question about why the cartoons weren't of ISIS leaders instead of Muhammad, well, the answer should be obvious. There is no taboo on drawing cartoons of ISIS leaders. There are plenty of such cartoons, and, to my knowledge, there are no media outlets in the West which would fear publishing them. Furthermore, the cultural significance of cartoons of ISIS leaders is pretty low. In addition to the fact that the names and the faces of ISIS leaders are practically unknown (I couldn't identify one, for example, either by name or by face), the group and its leaders are practically self-parodying. It would be like drawing a cartoon of the village idiot. It hardly stimulates any thinking.

She has certainly shown more courage than some of the posters here who would be cowering under the bed if they thought a picture of Mohammed was in the neighborhood.
 
I'm just exercising my free speech, man. It's a parody, maybe even a mockery of your inflated description of this publicity stunt staged by a bunch of hate mongers. Cartoons are cool. So, parody is cool. I'm doing this to culturally enrich the forum. If you're too blinded by your ideology to see how that was an important post on an important cultural issue, that's probably your problem. Maybe you're too sensitive to criticism and free speech?

We thank you for your participation, the gun teams have been dispatched.
 
Making cartoons about a long-dead historical figure is not bullying.

It could be viewed as bullying in the form of "ehy, this offends you ? Well, I'll just do it againd and again and again."

Mind you, I fully agree with the right of free speech in this instance, and the violence that this 'generates' is a greater evil, for sure.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom