Not going to step into such an artificial hypothetical. I'll just say that modern medicine seems to indicate that the "just eating too much" model of obesity is a distinct minority of cases. And even where it is the cause, is often due to psychological dysfunction rather than sheer gluttony.
All I need you to accept is that some people who were obese subsequently made choices that resulted in no longer being obese. That means that, at the time they were obese, there was something they could have done (and eventually did do) that would result in not being obese anymore. Therefore, so long as they chose not to do whatever was necessary to stop being obese, their obesity was a product of their choices.
You
do agree that obesity isn't a life sentence for everyone, right?
That aside, it is always irrational to be offended. That is the nature of being offended. It's an emotional response, not a rational one.
I see nothing that makes emotions irrational, personally. Seems to me that some emotions are reasonable, valuable, motivate us to do what is in our interests and so on.
But very well: let's take for granted that emotional responses are literally irrational. Is that sufficient for us to conclude that there's no onus on us to consider the emotional responses of others when choosing our actions?
Or, perhaps you think that one can reasonably ignore emotional responses if they are the result of mere beliefs (like religion), but not of physical conditions beyond one's control (like skin color). Is that the idea?
All of them, I thought I was quite clear on that. Offense is by it's very nature an irrational, emotional response. That's why it's offense, instead of rational evaluation and argument.
No. Yes, it clearly is a challenge to the beliefs of those who believe that doing so is blasphemy or something similar.
How is it a challenge to their beliefs? If I draw Mohammed, I am doing something they think I shouldn't do, but I haven't given them any reason to reconsider their beliefs in the slightest. (I'm talking about simple pictures of Mohammed -- obviously, some images could convey particular messages aimed at sparking reconsideration, but I'm talking about images generally, independently of any such messages.)
Of course it is, why wouldn't it be? Part of the definition of emotion is that it's not rational. How could it be otherwise?
Non-rational and irrational are different. If emotion is merely not rational, then it isn't irrational, it is non-rational. Cheese isn't rational, but we wouldn't call it irrational.
Emotions furthermore play important motivational roles, directing us towards some actions and away from others. When emotions happen to be in tune with what we would choose in a rational state of detachment, then they work well in our favor and could even be called reasonable, despite being more or less outside the realm of rationality.
Emotions of loyalty can be among the reasonable emotions. It is in our interest to be a full-fledged member of a tight, supportive group, because there are benefits to this arrangement. Part of the benefit is mutual defense, which is tied with the abstract notion of loyalty and also with the emotions connected with loyalty (love of your other members, offense at threats to them, etc.). I don't think that there's anything at all wrong in feeling offense when a loved one is insulted. I think that's a good and appropriate response.