Can a CharlieHebdo-type attack happen in the US?

Now that is a truly trenchant criticism. Exactly the sort of thing that needs to be said.

I'm afraid I didn't think the same thing at all. Came off as rather petty and childish. More so than necessary, I think.
 
Well, I have a new-found disrespect for the NY Times thanks to this incredibly dishonest and craven editorial:

Charlie Hebdo is a publication whose stock in trade has always been graphic satires of politicians and religions, whether Catholic, Jewish or Muslim. By contrast, Pamela Geller, the anti-Islam campaigner behind the Texas event, has a long history of declarations and actions motivated purely by hatred for Muslims.

So the editors of Charlie Hebdo are not vile haters because they insult all religions and religious people and don't just single out an oppressed minority comprising 1/4 of the planet's population? But Pamela Geller is a vile hater because she insults a benighted political ideology that just happens to be grafted on to a set of stupid religious beliefs. And if she is motivated purely by hatred, is it really hatred of Muslims, or is it hatred of what some Muslims do in the name of their religion and those that do it or incite them to do it. Do these pusillanimous publishers really believe that Geller hates Kurds or Druze or pro-Western Muslims? Do they really think Geller hates Muslims qua Muslims, or rather Muslims who subscribe to the political ideology that commands punishment for blasphemy and apostasy? Actually I think I know the answer and it is that the NY Times editors are lying sacks of ****.

Some of those who draw cartoons of the Prophet Muhammad may earnestly believe that they are striking a blow for freedom of expression, though it is hard to see how that goal is advanced by inflicting deliberate anguish on millions of devout Muslims who have nothing to do with terrorism. As for the Garland event, to pretend that it was motivated by anything other than hate is simply hogwash.

Some? Probably all. And maybe it's hogwash to pretend that the Garland event was motivated by anything other than hate, but I don't have to pretend. It clearly was motivated by a desire to stand up to intimidation. And to the extent it was motivated by hatred as well, it was motivated by hatred of Jihadists, not Muslims (hopefully a sizable majority) who wouldn't dream of imposing their religious beliefs on somebody else.

As for the anguish it causes, how terrible. Somebody drew a cartoon of Muhammad somewhere in the world. Oh, noes. My guess is that in each person who gives a rat's ass, the anguish it causes is roughly proportional to the intensity with which he hates non-Muslims, or perhaps (as demonstrated here) the intensity with which he hates that "hateful bigot" Pamela Geller. So perhaps the anguish is self-inflicted? After all, if you have to accept the predictable consequences of your actions (as some wise people have argued here), it seems you should also have to accept the consequences of your own attitudes and beliefs.

Actually, you know what causes me anguish? When ignorant, sanctimonious poseurs get to use an undeserved platform to spread their politically correct idiocy across the country simply because some leftist, ****-for-brains got lucky with his choice of great grandfather. And yet, some way, somehow, I accept that and manage to go on with my life. Well, what can I say? I'm a survivor.
 
I don't know if it's been mentioned already or not (it's a long thread for an event that just happened a few days ago) but in reference to the thread title and Charlie Hebdo... it was reported on the local news that in trying to find a connection to ISIS it was discovered that emails had been exchanged with a man that suggested this event as a target and made reference to Charlie Hebdo. So it's possible it was at least on their minds.
 
(much snipped)
Actually, you know what causes me anguish? When ignorant, sanctimonious poseurs get to use an undeserved platform to spread their politically correct idiocy across the country simply because some leftist, ****-for-brains got lucky with his choice of great grandfather. And yet, some way, somehow, I accept that and manage to go on with my life. Well, what can I say? I'm a survivor.

Have you considered capturing your feelings in the form of a cartoon?
 
Regrettably, if I recall correctly, I was one who criticized Charlotte Hebdo as needlessly fueling a fire that was sure to inflame those with violent intent.

I'm pretty sure it was my conclusion that they were simply baiting.

Don't know when or why my position changed but it certainly has.
 
Regrettably, if I recall correctly, I was one who criticized Charlotte Hebdo as needlessly fueling a fire that was sure to inflame those with violent intent.

I'm pretty sure it was my conclusion that they were simply baiting.

Don't know when or why my position changed but it certainly has.

Perhaps it was stories like this one? The punchline is that the woman who was accused of burning a Koran and was beaten and burned to death by a crowd in response actually didn't do anything of the sort. But, hey, blasphemy is really just a pretext for violence against inconvenient people anyway, so what does it matter if the accusations of blasphemy are true?
 
Here is the counter argument. Any 9/11 family that took offense is a cry baby idiot and I will tell that to their face

I would if it provoked my ire, but nothing gets me fuming mad like 9/11 families and accompanying bs.

Glenn Beck, is that you?


I am scared that some people seriously advocate giving up Freedom OF Speech to placate a few fanatics. Once you start doing that, you might as well throw out the first admendment.

This shallow argument was addressed upthread.
 
But never mind that debate, since I think it will distract us and promises no easy resolution. Let me suggest an alternative comparison. I suppose that, barring a physical condition, obesity is more or less the product of one's choices, similar to religion. Would you agree with this? If so, do you believe that it is irrational to be offended when a stranger calls me a disgusting tub o' lard?

Not going to step into such an artificial hypothetical. I'll just say that modern medicine seems to indicate that the "just eating too much" model of obesity is a distinct minority of cases. And even where it is the cause, is often due to psychological dysfunction rather than sheer gluttony.

That aside, it is always irrational to be offended. That is the nature of being offended. It's an emotional response, not a rational one.

I'm just trying to figure out precisely which kinds of offenses are "irrational, emotional response(s)".
All of them, I thought I was quite clear on that. Offense is by it's very nature an irrational, emotional response. That's why it's offense, instead of rational evaluation and argument.

Is it only offenses from "challenges to beliefs" that are irrational? Is drawing Mohammed a challenge to belief at all?

No. Yes, it clearly is a challenge to the beliefs of those who believe that doing so is blasphemy or something similar.

Is it irrational to become upset when someone calls your mother a whore?

Of course it is, why wouldn't it be? Part of the definition of emotion is that it's not rational. How could it be otherwise?
 
Regrettably, if I recall correctly, I was one who criticized Charlotte Hebdo as needlessly fueling a fire that was sure to inflame those with violent intent.

I'm pretty sure it was my conclusion that they were simply baiting.

Don't know when or why my position changed but it certainly has.

You certainly weren't the only one.

“Charlie Hebdo has a long record of mocking, baiting and needling French Muslims. If the magazine stops just short of outright insults, it is nevertheless not the most convincing champion of the principle of freedom of speech. France is the land of Voltaire, but too often editorial foolishness has prevailed at Charlie Hebdo.”

“This is not in the slightest to condone the murderers, who must be caught and punished, or to suggest that freedom of expression should not extend to satirical portrayals of religion. It is merely to say that some common sense would be useful at publications such as Charlie Hebdo, and Denmark’s Jyllands-Posten, which purport to strike a blow for freedom when they provoke Muslims, but are actually just being stupid.”
 
Perhaps it was stories like this one? The punchline is that the woman who was accused of burning a Koran and was beaten and burned to death by a crowd in response actually didn't do anything of the sort. But, hey, blasphemy is really just a pretext for violence against inconvenient people anyway, so what does it matter if the accusations of blasphemy are true?

Hey, she knew the risks involved by appearing to have burned a book.
 
Regrettably, if I recall correctly, I was one who criticized Charlotte Hebdo as needlessly fueling a fire that was sure to inflame those with violent intent.

I'm pretty sure it was my conclusion that they were simply baiting.

Don't know when or why my position changed but it certainly has.

You certainly weren't the only one.

Whereas I can remain smug in my self-righteous assurance that I was right all along. Neener neener neener. ;)
 
Well, I have a new-found disrespect for the NY Times thanks to this incredibly dishonest and craven editorial
It also smacks of the idea that only a Real Journalist has the privilege of reporting, or editorializing, or satirizing. Regular citizens aren't properly trained to exercise the right to free expression as it is supposed to be exercised. Only a Real Journalist understands the great responsibility, and only a Real Journalist is worthy of the privilege.

Offensive satire from Charlie Hebdo is permitted, because it suits the New York Times's prejudices to anoint them Real Journalists. Offensive satire from others is not permitted, because they have not been initiated into the Cult of Real Journalism, and so their work is unclean.
 
This is a fast-moving thread and things I wanted to comment on this morning are already moot. I just want to say, when I got interested in Islam 40+ years ago there was no hint that "the West" had to fight any particular ideology from "Islam." The Islamists gained a power base largely due to events in Israel and aggression from the Soviets. Those events were framed as disputes over territory, until the mid-'80s or so when the U.S. began supporting the "mujahadeen" because they supported the U.S. in its own ideological war with the Soviet Union. U.S. ideology against Communism then was co-opted by Islamic ideology vs. "the West" (including the USSR).

I'm not sure, but I believe it was marsplots who pointed out that if you hold a demonstration that might provoke a violent response (no matter how irrational), you have at least peripherally endangered bystanders. So, the Muhammad art contest sponsors promoted an exhibition that might be considered irresponsible.

If you think Muslims from time immemorial have been provoking free-speech activists for decades, at least pause to remember this dispute is of relatively recent origin. Islamic extremist are a fairly recent phenomenon. They have, IMO, been 100 percent wrong for the past couple of decades, despite U.S. aid in the '80s. But that, IMO, obscures a larger reality - that peaceful coexistence had actually been the norm for several hundred years. By that I mean, conflicts by and large have not involved religion, but that territorial disputes stemming largely from decisions made during WWI festered, eventually helping create extremism. Before that, to my knowledge there were no heated ideological conflicts between "Western" and "Islamic" values, for at least several hundred years.

I don't mind being dubbed an "apologist" in such matters. Real grievances have been obscured by hotheads determined to provoke hostile responses. IOW haters gonna hate and probably IS will be happy to have them. But I think this is haters drawn to other haters ... not Islamist idealists drawn to other idealists. Just my opinion. Discovering Iran's frank depictions of a very appealing adolescent Muhammad tells me that Muslim opinion of this matter is far from universal. The shooters in Texas were used, I believe, and disposed off by powers eager to keep adversarial emotions running high.
 
Not going to step into such an artificial hypothetical. I'll just say that modern medicine seems to indicate that the "just eating too much" model of obesity is a distinct minority of cases. And even where it is the cause, is often due to psychological dysfunction rather than sheer gluttony.

All I need you to accept is that some people who were obese subsequently made choices that resulted in no longer being obese. That means that, at the time they were obese, there was something they could have done (and eventually did do) that would result in not being obese anymore. Therefore, so long as they chose not to do whatever was necessary to stop being obese, their obesity was a product of their choices.

You do agree that obesity isn't a life sentence for everyone, right?

That aside, it is always irrational to be offended. That is the nature of being offended. It's an emotional response, not a rational one.

I see nothing that makes emotions irrational, personally. Seems to me that some emotions are reasonable, valuable, motivate us to do what is in our interests and so on.

But very well: let's take for granted that emotional responses are literally irrational. Is that sufficient for us to conclude that there's no onus on us to consider the emotional responses of others when choosing our actions?

Or, perhaps you think that one can reasonably ignore emotional responses if they are the result of mere beliefs (like religion), but not of physical conditions beyond one's control (like skin color). Is that the idea?

All of them, I thought I was quite clear on that. Offense is by it's very nature an irrational, emotional response. That's why it's offense, instead of rational evaluation and argument.



No. Yes, it clearly is a challenge to the beliefs of those who believe that doing so is blasphemy or something similar.

How is it a challenge to their beliefs? If I draw Mohammed, I am doing something they think I shouldn't do, but I haven't given them any reason to reconsider their beliefs in the slightest. (I'm talking about simple pictures of Mohammed -- obviously, some images could convey particular messages aimed at sparking reconsideration, but I'm talking about images generally, independently of any such messages.)


Of course it is, why wouldn't it be? Part of the definition of emotion is that it's not rational. How could it be otherwise?

Non-rational and irrational are different. If emotion is merely not rational, then it isn't irrational, it is non-rational. Cheese isn't rational, but we wouldn't call it irrational.

Emotions furthermore play important motivational roles, directing us towards some actions and away from others. When emotions happen to be in tune with what we would choose in a rational state of detachment, then they work well in our favor and could even be called reasonable, despite being more or less outside the realm of rationality.

Emotions of loyalty can be among the reasonable emotions. It is in our interest to be a full-fledged member of a tight, supportive group, because there are benefits to this arrangement. Part of the benefit is mutual defense, which is tied with the abstract notion of loyalty and also with the emotions connected with loyalty (love of your other members, offense at threats to them, etc.). I don't think that there's anything at all wrong in feeling offense when a loved one is insulted. I think that's a good and appropriate response.
 
I'm not sure, but I believe it was marsplots who pointed out that if you hold a demonstration that might provoke a violent response (no matter how irrational), you have at least peripherally endangered bystanders. So, the Muhammad art contest sponsors promoted an exhibition that might be considered irresponsible.

What Zionist extremists need to do is to begin a program systematically hitting anti-Israeli demonstrations with machine-gun fire and high explosives. That way, those who organize anti-Israeli demonstrations can be considered irresponsible for endangering bystanders.
 
What Zionist extremists need to do is to begin a program systematically hitting anti-Israeli demonstrations with machine-gun fire and high explosives. That way, those who organize anti-Israeli demonstrations can be considered irresponsible for endangering bystanders.

Sorry, I'm having trouble following your analogy. Anti-Israel demonstrators assembled as a mob probably do endanger bystanders. Certainly, those Palestinians who fire missiles at Israel endanger Palestinian civilians, who may be targeted in retaliation.
 
It was my opinion from the beginning because of the sensitivity of the so-called hallowed ground around the WTC site and the lack of any need for an Islamic center downtown, let alone right there. Also, there was no funding in place at all. It seemed like the aim was to create controversy and raise funds off of the publicity that followed. Finally, as I've already pointed out, failing to back off once 9/11 families expressed their feelings indicates bad faith.

The concept of "hallowed ground" is ridiculous from the get go. The area around the WTC is no different from anywhere else. Anything legal to build elsewhere should be legal to build there.

If people took offense, tough.

Well, I would say the people who supported the Ground Zero Mosque (GZM) and yet call Pamela Geller a hateful bigot and her event a hateful provocation are being a touch more hypocritical than I am, don't ya think?

Pamela Geller is a hateful bigot. She established that long before this event. Her event was a hateful provocation based on her long history of rhetoric. That doesn't mean I excuse an attack on her event. If people did take offense, tough.

I believe that she had the legal right to do what she did. I wouldn't have done it the way she did but that is beside the point. She had the right and no one, NO ONE, had the right to respond with violence. I'm not surprised someone responded with violence but she had the right to express her opinions without a violent response. I believe people that respond with violence are rightly to be condemned and all efforts should be made to stop or incarcerate such people lest they pollute the rhetorical landscape with equal parts fear, hate and retribution.

I don't like Pamela Geller for what she says and the views she espouses. I don't like most of the things Islam stands for in the same way I disapprove of Christianity. In the same way I would be upset if construction of a Christian church was opposed for specious and prejudicial reasons I am upset when a mosque suffers the same fate. And while I might think someone is a loon to stand right outside a Christian church or mosque and pontificate on the evils taking place in the building I feel such a person has that right. And I have the right to denounce said person for their actions.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom