Can a CharlieHebdo-type attack happen in the US?

(Assuming you're American) I don't think you have that right. Your scenario would probably fall under the fighting wordsWP (as in "them's") exception to the First Amendment; basically, as i read it (not a lawyer), there to deny just that sort of up close and personal, in your face name-calling protection as free speech.

It's an interesting exception in the context of the Muhammad cartoons, the ways it might apply, and the ways it doesn't.

It looks to me based on your own wiki link, and the case law it references, that depicting a religious figure derogatively doesn't even come close to fulfilling the "fighting words" exception to free speech in the USA. Canada perhaps though.

ETA: Reading back I see you were replying to someone's hypothetical situation, not the main topic. But even so, as I understand it, "fighting words" is not generally accepted as a defense for assault or murder. Also it has to be a personal attack to fall under "fighting words". Just saying racist or sexit things, doesn't satisfy the requirment.
 
Last edited:
I am scared that some people seriously advocate giving up Freedom OF Speech to placate a few fanatics. Once you start doing that, you might as well throw out the first admendment.
 
At least you are honest about it. Too many others are laboring mightily to avoid admitting that is the only reason they don't support free speech in this instance.

I despise Geller as a religious bigot but defend her right to express her opinions.
 
I think it's an apt analogy for a certain mindset. There's an underlying belief that sufficient offense or outrage similarly impairs judgement and reduces human agency. That people suffering under such offense, through no fault of their own cease to be rational humans and become unthinking violent animals, and are not fully responsible for the harm they do in their rage.

Funnily enough, this only appears to apply to people of a certain colour.

It's actually a very similar mindset that is behind the disgusting hijab/burqa/chador practice - that if men see women they will be filled with uncontrollable lust by their feminine wiles and have no choice but to act on it. Of course it's all the woman's fault, and she'll have to pay with her life for making the man ruin her family's honor by having his way with her.
 
I am scared that some people seriously advocate giving up Freedom OF Speech to placate a few fanatics. Once you start doing that, you might as well throw out the first admendment.

Don't worry, the average US citizen has considerably more common sense than the average JREF/ISFer.

I think it goes to Orwell's dictum:
'There are some ideas so absurd that only an intellectual could believe them.'
 
I despise Geller as a religious bigot but defend her right to express her opinions.

"‘I disapprove of what you say, but I will defend to the death your right to say it" - Beatrice Evelyn Hall, misattributed to Voltaire (by the author of the quote).

For an actual Voltaire quote, “The supposed right of intolerance is absurd and barbaric. It is the right of the tiger; nay, it is far worse, for tigers do but tear in order to have food, while we rend each other for paragraphs.”
 
"‘I disapprove of what you say, but I will defend to the death your right to say it" - Beatrice Evelyn Hall, misattributed to Voltaire (by the author of the quote).

For an actual Voltaire quote, “The supposed right of intolerance is absurd and barbaric. It is the right of the tiger; nay, it is far worse, for tigers do but tear in order to have food, while we rend each other for paragraphs.”

Interesting. Hall seems like person of reason. Voltaire seems like a dunce--or possibly a satirist. By reputation, it's hard to imagine he didn't see and intend the irony of being intolerant of the right of intolerance.
 
"‘I disapprove of what you say, but I will defend to the death your right to say it" - Beatrice Evelyn Hall, misattributed to Voltaire (by the author of the quote).

For an actual Voltaire quote, “The supposed right of intolerance is absurd and barbaric. It is the right of the tiger; nay, it is far worse, for tigers do but tear in order to have food, while we rend each other for paragraphs.”

My respect for Voltaire just went down.

The whole problem is who decides what it intolerance and what is not; the old "Who will watch the wathcers" issue.
 
Don't worry, the average US citizen has considerably more common sense than the average JREF/ISFer.

I think it goes to Orwell's dictum:
'There are some ideas so absurd that only an intellectual could believe them.'

Intellectuals can be really,really stupid at times. Problem is many of them love theory and abstract thought,and get upset when reality ruins their castles in the sky. "When reality and theory collide,reality must be disposed of".
 
This really doesn't matter. The important point is that in both cases, free expression, harming nobody, by people who do not adhere to Islamic superstition was violently attacked by terrorists. Three cases really, since Lars Vilks was attacked for the same reason.

The content is an entirely separate issue.

Don't forget Theo Van Gogh, murdered on the street in Amsterdam for his film Submission that criticized the treatment of women in Islam.

But he made that with Ayaan Hirsi Ali and all the right people hate her too. I mean if you want to get invited to the best parties you have to hate her.
 
The head Ewok at Ace Of Spades HQ sums it all up thusly...
1. To speak of Islamist violence, or to suggest there is a problem in Islam, is racist, and hateful, and irrational, and "islamophobic."

2. It is so predictable that Islamists will kill you if you say something "anti-Islamic" that victims of murder attempts can be said to have brought their attacks on themselves.

Two other hard-to-reconcile claims:

1. Islam is compatible with Western values.

2. We're going to have to change some core Western values to avoid violence from our new Muslim friends.
http://ace.mu.nu/archives/356575.php
 
Interesting. Hall seems like person of reason. Voltaire seems like a dunce--or possibly a satirist. By reputation, it's hard to imagine he didn't see and intend the irony of being intolerant of the right of intolerance.

He was a piss-poor zoologist at any rate.
 
?
I see gay rights protesters at gay pride events hollering about Jesus, sin, and hell directly at people who gather around to listen and laugh at them.
Or take the Westboro Baptist nutjobs.
Unless I'm missing something?
Westboro is protected. Fighting words doctrine applies to directed, private-ish speech. Generally using fighting lime words in a public place as an act of speech is probably protected.

Yes. Westboro came before the SCOTUS in 2011, in Snyder v. Phelps. Justice Alito thought they were fighting words and so not protected, but he was the lone dissenter.

It looks to me based on your own wiki link, and the case law it references, that depicting a religious figure derogatively doesn't even come close to fulfilling the "fighting words" exception to free speech in the USA. Canada perhaps though.

ETA: Reading back I see you were replying to someone's hypothetical situation, not the main topic. But even so, as I understand it, "fighting words" is not generally accepted as a defense for assault or murder. Also it has to be a personal attack to fall under "fighting words". Just saying racist or sexit things, doesn't satisfy the requirment.

Right. My understanding of the hypothetical --
... Yes, I have the right to stand on a street corner and say horribly racist and sexist things, but can I really be surprised when I eventually get punched in the face for it? If you take a random group of people, and start insulting them in the worst way you know how, a few are going to react with more than just angry stares. ...
-- was a group has gathered and the person yelling insults continues, now insulting people directly, at which point it ceases to be protected speech. But that's probably my own misreading.

Regardless of whether Fudbucker's hypothetical falls under the "fighting words" exception to 1st amendment protections, this event most clear did NOT constitute fighting words. The scenarios are not equivalent. Geller didn't set up shop in front of a mosque and start screaming at people going to Friday prayers. This was an event that people who might be offended could trivially avoid, and in fact would need to make an effort to see. The attackers had to go out of their way to go to the event (it wasn't even in the state they lived in), and I suspect they never actually even saw any of the speech at the event.

Yes, that's a crucial distinction, and how I was reading it (the fw exception) also. Others: the cartoons' artistic merit and social commentary (vs being insults and nothing else), the event related to something other than just insult (arguably solidarity with CharlieHebdo and their stand on free speech, though I see CH wants nothing to do with them).

Anyway, apologies for the sidetrack - just my misreading of Fudbucker's hypothetical, I think. I do find these sorts of exceptions to the right to free speech interesting, though, in themselves.
 
Last edited:
Interesting. Hall seems like person of reason. Voltaire seems like a dunce--or possibly a satirist. By reputation, it's hard to imagine he didn't see and intend the irony of being intolerant of the right of intolerance.

Given that he was well-known as a satirist, I think it's perfectly acceptable to see him as a satirist. Candide is probably his best-known satirical work.

In any case, I don't really see how people can find irony in refusal to bow to the intolerant. "Intolerant of intolerance" is not irony, to say it is is to distort the term far beyond commonly accepted usage.

Voltaire was also well-known for his support of rationality, critical thinking, freedom of expression and belief, religious and racial tolerance, and his scathing attacks on the Catholic church, as well as Judaism and Islam; and was one of the key Enlightenment philosophers. He was one of the architects of modern Rationalist thought; and like many of them was a Deist, rather than an atheist.
 
Did you completely miss the rest of the post? And the fact that one is about religion and the other about race is a very important difference; one is a choice that can be changed, the other is not.

I'm not sure why you ask whether I read the rest of the post, since I not only responded to it, I told you to "see below" for my response.

Now, I have read the rest of this post, too, and I still think that choosing to change ones' beliefs is a bit more problematic than you suggest, since the primary (if not only) criterion for ones' beliefs is whether they are true -- and insofar as you think they are true, then you should certainly not change them.

But never mind that debate, since I think it will distract us and promises no easy resolution. Let me suggest an alternative comparison. I suppose that, barring a physical condition, obesity is more or less the product of one's choices, similar to religion. Would you agree with this? If so, do you believe that it is irrational to be offended when a stranger calls me a disgusting tub o' lard?

I'm just trying to figure out precisely which kinds of offenses are "irrational, emotional response(s)". Is it only offenses from "challenges to beliefs" that are irrational? Is drawing Mohammed a challenge to belief at all?

Is it irrational to become upset when someone calls your mother a whore? I'm not Muslim, but I often think that the offense taken when someone insults the prophet is similar to the offense taken when someone insults a loved one. I think that there is a cultural loyalty to the Prophet that is similar to family loyalty elsewhere.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom