lobosrul
Master Poster
- Joined
- Nov 17, 2011
- Messages
- 2,313
(Assuming you're American) I don't think you have that right. Your scenario would probably fall under the fighting wordsWP (as in "them's") exception to the First Amendment; basically, as i read it (not a lawyer), there to deny just that sort of up close and personal, in your face name-calling protection as free speech.
It's an interesting exception in the context of the Muhammad cartoons, the ways it might apply, and the ways it doesn't.
It looks to me based on your own wiki link, and the case law it references, that depicting a religious figure derogatively doesn't even come close to fulfilling the "fighting words" exception to free speech in the USA. Canada perhaps though.
ETA: Reading back I see you were replying to someone's hypothetical situation, not the main topic. But even so, as I understand it, "fighting words" is not generally accepted as a defense for assault or murder. Also it has to be a personal attack to fall under "fighting words". Just saying racist or sexit things, doesn't satisfy the requirment.
Last edited: