Can a CharlieHebdo-type attack happen in the US?

That's absurd. Of course you would wonder why a white guy stood on a street corner for seven hours in Compton calling blacks n****** until he was shot by a couple of gangbangers. Is that normal behavior?
No, I'd just assume you were drunk or insane, and that would be the end of it.

Maybe you can tell me: What trenchant criticism are we making of Islam by drawing Mohammed getting ass-******? Is that going to encourage Muslims to think about the radical element within their communities?

I can't speak for the event, but in my case, it's a demonstration that I will not capitulate to those who think they can use violent threats to enforce the tenets of their religious worldview, which I do not share, on me.

As for whether Muslims think about radical elements, well, some will and some won't. Sometimes, all it takes is an opportunity for the worst elements of one's religion to demonstrate their fanaticism to cause people to examine what they believe and why.
 
From your point of view? No. No support I give will suffice.
[...]
You only have to run away to the extent you don't wish to suffer the harm that comes from not running away. You are free to put yourself at risk. Many do, for many reasons. What seems disingenuous is to then complain about suffering the foreseeable consequences of your own choices.

More cop-outs and evasions. You were the one who insisted such a place existed, yet you refuse to support that assertion. More pie-in-the-sky pipe dreams.

I'm done until you are able to actually provide some sort of support for your assertions.
 
The same kind of offense, but in one case you want to cater to the offended and in the other you want to cater to the offenders.

Well, I would say the people who supported the Ground Zero Mosque (GZM) and yet call Pamela Geller a hateful bigot and her event a hateful provocation are being a touch more hypocritical than I am, don't ya think?

In this case, my position isn't even hypocritical. I objected mainly to the government support and encouragement for the GZM. Getting approval to build anything in Manhattan is a nightmare and requires a considerable amount of bribery and influence, and yet the backers of this project got approval quickly, without even demonstrating that they had solid enough financing to complete it.

Another distinction is that the backers of the GZM claimed to be acting in the spirit of unity and harmony and healing. Their subsequent behavior put the lie to this claim. It would be like bringing a pork roast to a Jewish family sitting shiva, and when they say, "this is a kosher home, please take that away" you say "no, I won't because this pork roast is important as a token of my friendship and desire for your spiritual healing."

Finally, I see Geller's provocation as a good thing given the climate of fear that Islamic extremists have managed to create around committing blasphemy. If there wasn't such fear, I would oppose doing anything that gratuitously insulted Muslims.
 
Offense. A feeling of insult. You know, the same kind of trauma that so-called moderate Muslims might feel when Pamela Geller holds a "Draw Muhammad" contest.

So why, then, do you think that the Park51 organizers should have desisted from the actions that were causing offense and that their disregard of the people being offended by those actions showed "bad faith" on their part, while you support the organizers of the "Draw Muhammad" contest in their actions that were causing offense and think that the people being offended by those actions should be disregarded?
 
Well, I would say the people who supported the Ground Zero Mosque (GZM) and yet call Pamela Geller a hateful bigot and her event a hateful provocation are being a touch more hypocritical than I am, don't ya think?

Perhaps, but "you should ignore my hypocrisy because other people are also hypocritical" isn't much of an argument.

In this case, my position isn't even hypocritical. I objected mainly to the government support and encouragement for the GZM.

And yet the thing you took issue with the most was their disregard of the stated wishes of some families of 9/11 victims, which has nothing to do with government support and encouragement.

Another distinction is that the backers of the GZM claimed to be acting in the spirit of unity and harmony and healing. Their subsequent behavior put the lie to this claim. It would be like bringing a pork roast to a Jewish family sitting shiva, and when they say, "this is a kosher home, please take that away" you say "no, I won't because this pork roast is important as a token of my friendship and desire for your spiritual healing."

Your analogy fails because a mosque in Manhattan, even one just a few blocks from ground zero, is not equivalent to bringing a pork roast into a Jewish home (not least because "pork roasts" were already sitting on the table - there have been mosques just a few blocks from ground zero for decades before the 9/11 attacks even occurred).

You support the first amendment rights of some people over the nonexistent right to be offended, and reject the first amendment rights of other people in favor of the nonexistent right to be offended. The only consistency in your positions is that you favor whichever one happens to disadvantage Muslims.
 
Sure. Here's an example of the first: http://www.reuters.com/article/2015/03/19/us-target-settlement-idUSKBN0MF04K20150319 - $10 million in harm. Is that enough?

Nope. This is not speech, this is merely theft of personal data. Explain how that is an example of expression of a concept or viewpoint. You can't, because it isn't.

Here's an example of the second: http://www.wxyz.com/news/region/livingston-county/brighton-police-crackdown-on-disorderly-conduct-
The harm in this second case is called "breach of the peace."
Nope, another fail. Did you actually read the article? This had nothing to do with a breach of the peace, and everything to do with the officer feeling he had been "disrespected". This was clearly an abuse of power by an officer who had a bug up his butt about the kid's attitude. Nothing new there. The only harm done was by the officer overstepping his bounds, nothing the kid did caused any harm to anyone (except possible some minor vandalism caused by his skating, not his speech).

And a breach of the peace is not harm, it's merely annoyance. And enforcing restrictions does not suppress freedom of expression, it merely places limitations on the time and place and volume of that expression. It's not about what is said, it's about how intrusively it is said. That is the key difference you seem to be missing.

Freedom of expression is about content of speech; not manner of speech. Every single example you've provided have either been not remotely related to speech (such as the breech of data issue above); or they have been about the manner of said speech. The fanatics don't care about manner of expression, they are threatening and attacking people over the content of their expression. They are committing violence over what is said, not how it is said. That is the key factor you don't appear to grasp.

Restrictions on how something is said are problematic, but can be necessary and useful. Restrictions on what is said is always oppressive.

As far as any harm that stems from depictions of Mohammed, the question is more properly asked of an Islamist scholar. The pictures don't bother me. But, of course, being a mature adult, I understand others may feel differently. When those others feel so strongly they are going to attack on that basis, I tend to believe them.

Again, there is no evidence of harm to anything except feelings. And most of us learn to deal with that as we grow up and become reasonable adults.

Do you count "offense" and "insult" as harms? Some seem to do so. Whole nations do so. This isn't an idea manufactured to support a position, it actually exists in the world.
I've yet to see anyone demonstrate what actual harm comes from insult or offense. "But it does me no injury for my neighbour to say there are twenty gods, or no god. It neither picks my pocket nor breaks my leg." To quote from a highly relevant passage from Thomas Jefferson, on differences of religious beliefs. Or another relevant comment from that passage: "Reason and free enquiry are the only effectual agents against error." Indulging irrational feelings do not form anything like a useful basis for growth and maturation. Insult and offense do not do anything except bruise my poor tender feelings. Sorry, that's life, grow up and learn to deal with the fact that not everyone thinks the way you do.

There's a reason that the most fanatical are also commonly the young and immature; and the emotionally stunted with poor self-control, who are commonly recruited from prisons. Groups like ISIS depend heavily on these sorts of people.
 
So why, then, do you think that the Park51 organizers should have desisted from the actions that were causing offense and that their disregard of the people being offended by those actions showed "bad faith" on their part, while you support the organizers of the "Draw Muhammad" contest in their actions that were causing offense and think that the people being offended by those actions should be disregarded?

I answered above, but I'll note here the difference in scale as well. The GZM was supposed to be an 11-story building with a prayer room that accommodated up to 2,000 worshipers. It was to be built on ground where parts of the plane that hit the South Tower fell, and presumably some body parts as well (including those that have never been found). Geller's event was a small transitory affair with a few hundred attendees held in the middle of nowhere with very little publicity. On the grand scale of provocations, it would barely register with normal people, although obviously it does and did with the people who need to acclimatize to the modern world.

Finally, I'll note that the intensity of my disapproval or approval, respectively, is quite modest. I won't even go so far as to call the backers of the GZM hateful bigots or extremists, or their project a racist or hateful project, let alone take concerted action to stop it.
 
It was and it wasn't. What ever was to be built had thousands off supporters. I'm sure their motivations for supporting such a project were diverse and surely included at least some that were provocative in nature. Of course many supporters saw this as an act of planting their flag on ground they attacked.


Also.... you could not have a more accurate handle for someone coming to support the do not offend side in this.

Wait what? I was agreeing with Travis that the mosque in NY was perfectly fine.

Do not offend? What are you talking about? I live to offend.
 
The winning cartoon is the one with Mahomet swinging a sword shouting "You can't draw me!" and the cartoonist replying "That's why I draw you."

He is Bosch Fawstin, an apostate.

Now that is a truly trenchant criticism. Exactly the sort of thing that needs to be said.

Looking at the rest, the vast majority of them are garbage, plain and simple (ninety percent of everything is garbage, after all). But some of them are quite incisive critiques of Islam, especially Islamic fundamentalism, and its treatment of women in particular. A few even show some serious artistic talent as well.
 
I answered above, but I'll note here the difference in scale as well. The GZM was supposed to be an 11-story building with a prayer room that accommodated up to 2,000 worshipers. It was to be built on ground where parts of the plane that hit the South Tower fell, and presumably some body parts as well (including those that have never been found).

Yes, and? What, exactly, is the problem with a building with prayer spaces for Muslims, Jews, and Christians, as well as a 500-seat performing arts center, a swimming pool, basketball court, childcare and exhibition facilities, a library, restaurant and catering school on the site?

Finally, I'll note that the intensity of my disapproval or approval, respectively, is quite modest. I won't even go so far as to call the backers of the GZM hateful bigots or extremists, or their project a racist or hateful project, let alone take concerted action to stop it.

How generous of you.
 
Perhaps, but "you should ignore my hypocrisy because other people are also hypocritical" isn't much of an argument.



And yet the thing you took issue with the most was their disregard of the stated wishes of some families of 9/11 victims, which has nothing to do with government support and encouragement.



Your analogy fails because a mosque in Manhattan, even one just a few blocks from ground zero, is not equivalent to bringing a pork roast into a Jewish home (not least because "pork roasts" were already sitting on the table - there have been mosques just a few blocks from ground zero for decades before the 9/11 attacks even occurred).

It's an analogy. Not perfect, but pretty good I think. And, no, the pork roasts had not been already sitting at the table. There might have been some dishes which had had milk and meat mixed together, which were broken and which needed to be replaced, but I doubt that anybody would take offense to bringing replacement dishes which have the same (non-existent) flaw as before.

You support the first amendment rights of some people over the nonexistent right to be offended, and reject the first amendment rights of other people in favor of the nonexistent right to be offended. The only consistency in your positions is that you favor whichever one happens to disadvantage Muslims.

I don't reject anybody's first amendment rights. One hardly has a right to build an 11-story building in Manhattan just because he owns a parcel of land there. As I've said, getting approval for a project like that requires a massive thumb on the scale in favor of it. That's what I object to. The local government facilitated this offense to 9/11 families. If this was a place where building applications were routinely rubber-stamped, and property owners pretty much had the right to build whatever they wanted, I would have been far more supportive of the project. In fact, even though I would have taken a dim view of the developer's motives, my desire to champion his property rights would have outweighed my sympathy for the feelings of 9/11 families.
 
Last edited:
Yes, and? What, exactly, is the problem with a building with prayer spaces for Muslims, Jews, and Christians, as well as a 500-seat performing arts center, a swimming pool, basketball court, childcare and exhibition facilities, a library, restaurant and catering school on the site?

How generous of you.

How about prayer spaces for Muslims, Jews and Christians?
 
It's an analogy. Not perfect, but pretty good I think. And, no, the pork roasts had not been already sitting at the table. There might have been some dishes which had had milk and meat mixed together, which were broken and which needed to be replaced, but I doubt that anybody would take offense to bringing replacement dishes which have the same (non-existent) flaw as before.



I don't reject anybody's first amendment rights. One hardly has a right to build an 11-story building in Manhattan just because he owns a parcel of land there. As I've said, getting approval for a project like that requires a massive thumb on the scale in favor of it. That's what I object to. The local government facilitated this offense to 9/11 families. If this was a place where building applications were routinely rubber-stamped, and property owners pretty much had the right to build whatever they wanted, I would have been far more supportive of the project. In fact, even though I would have taken a dim view of the developer's motives, my desire to champion his property rights would have outweighed my sympathy for the feelings of 9/11 families.

Here is the counter argument. Any 9/11 family that took offense is a cry baby idiot and I will tell that to their face
 
Westboro is protected. Fighting words doctrine applies to directed, private-ish speech. Generally using fighting lime words in a public place as an act of speech is probably protected.

"Fighting words" refers to the manner of speech, not the content. Insults and offense are protected areas of expression. "Fighting words" refers to the specific context and manner of said expression. There is a bit of a gray area involved there, something of a judgement call; but the key difference is in how words are used, not what they are.
 
"Fighting words" refers to the manner of speech, not the content. Insults and offense are protected areas of expression. "Fighting words" refers to the specific context and manner of said expression. There is a bit of a gray area involved there, something of a judgement call; but the key difference is in how words are used, not what they are.

Okay. I knew what people think of fighting words when does as public speech is not fighting words, but wrong on the why. Thank you.
 
Here is the counter argument. Any 9/11 family that took offense is a cry baby idiot and I will tell that to their face

Those would be fighting words probably. How about a Muslim family who took offense to a Draw Muhammad contest? Would you call them cry baby idiots to their faces too?
 
I answered above, but I'll note here the difference in scale as well. The GZM was supposed to be an 11-story building with a prayer room that accommodated up to 2,000 worshipers. It was to be built on ground where parts of the plane that hit the South Tower fell, and presumably some body parts as well (including those that have never been found). Geller's event was a small transitory affair with a few hundred attendees held in the middle of nowhere with very little publicity. On the grand scale of provocations, it would barely register with normal people, although obviously it does and did with the people who need to acclimatize to the modern world.

Finally, I'll note that the intensity of my disapproval or approval, respectively, is quite modest. I won't even go so far as to call the backers of the GZM hateful bigots or extremists, or their project a racist or hateful project, let alone take concerted action to stop it.

That's one heckuva prayer room. Most theaters I go to seat only slightly more than that and those are stacked vertically.
 
No it isn't. Why is it perfectly fine to build a place of worship for a 1400 year old child rapist?

They don't actually worship Mahomet, y'know.


And is a 1400 year old really a child? And I thought Obamacare was expansive in its definitions. Hey-o!
 
Last edited:
Those would be fighting words probably. How about a Muslim family who took offense to a Draw Muhammad contest? Would you call them cry baby idiots to their faces too?

I would if it provoked my ire, but nothing gets me fuming mad like 9/11 families and accompanying bs.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom