Can a CharlieHebdo-type attack happen in the US?

Some ideas are so ridiculous that a little ridicule is called for. The idea that there is no comparison between Charlie Hebdo and Pamela Geller is one such idea.

Two different organizations with two different mandates. They got shot at. That's the only similarity.
 
Does she oppose the construction of all new mosques or only the one near Ground Zero? I opposed that too. I thought it was a deliberate provocation that was being facilitated by local government.

Please do tell me how you can possibly defend the notion that it was a deliberate provocation.
 
It doesn't actually matter, but I think the Islamic center was to have a prayer room inside which would count as a mosque for religious purposes.

The full architectural plans for the center have not been implemented, but a prayer space in the building in question opened in 2011.

It seems to me that somebody acting in good faith would have backed down when such a large number of family members of 9/11 attack victims voiced their disapproval.

What about all the family members of the 9/11 attack victims who voiced their approval?
 
She was an active opponent of the mosque being built in Murfreesboro, TN, and has complained that "after 9/11, mosque construction in America has nearly doubled".

I've only had time for a cursory review, but it seems like her objections to it (e.g. the disproportionate size relative to the local Muslim population, the anonymity of the funding) are legitimate.

Not sure if her claim that "after 9/11, mosque construction in America has nearly doubled" is a complaint or an observation or if it is even true. If true, it does deserve some attention given that the Muslim population of the US has not grown at nearly the same rate, and much of the money for that construction does seem to be coming from abroad. Personally, I am wary of construction of new houses of worship anyway, because I consider it a waste of resources and a tax dodge. I am particularly wary of new mosque construction since I consider Islam to be more than just a religion. In many ways, it is a political ideology stapled to a religion.
 
I hate her for things she actually does. She hates all Muslims for things she imagines they might do.


How is this a free speech issue? Near as I can tell it was legal for her to piss people off. And it will be legal in the future too.

Like try to kill her?
 
Oh wait. Did you mean that committing blasphemy against Islam in Paris is somehow different from committing blasphemy against Islam in Texas? Is blasphemy somehow ok if the "right" people are doing it?

Apparently free speech is only for the politically correct.
 
Please do tell me how you can possibly defend the notion that it was a deliberate provocation.

It was my opinion from the beginning because of the sensitivity of the so-called hallowed ground around the WTC site and the lack of any need for an Islamic center downtown, let alone right there. Also, there was no funding in place at all. It seemed like the aim was to create controversy and raise funds off of the publicity that followed. Finally, as I've already pointed out, failing to back off once 9/11 families expressed their feelings indicates bad faith.
 
I knowingly upset people all the time. I could hardly post my opinions in strongly worded form without drawing ire here. The question is whether we have some purpose in mind, and what other options may serve as well or better.

I accept that my contentiousness will reduce my social capital here as a consequence of an unpopular opinion. But I think expressing my views is a purpose worth the trouble. If I thought someone here was going to shoot at me for my opinions, I'd have to reevaluate my calculation. Apparently, the risk of attack was worth holding a contest to draw pictures of Mohammed for the people organizing the event. At least it was prospectively. We will have to wait and see if they hold the event again.

So the idea for militants and violent religious fundamentalists is to systematically increase the risk associated with the behavior they wish to prohibit until it reaches the point where the risk (for practically everyone) outweighs the benefits of expressing their views publicly.

And for those very few who continue to insist on "provoking"... well, they know the risks.
 
You and I agree on something. Let us celebrate!

It was and it wasn't. What ever was to be built had thousands off supporters. I'm sure their motivations for supporting such a project were diverse and surely included at least some that were provocative in nature. Of course many supporters saw this as an act of planting their flag on ground they attacked.


Also.... you could not have a more accurate handle for someone coming to support the do not offend side in this.
 
Last edited:
No votes count for far more than yes votes in this instance.

Why do the opinions of these families of 9/11 victims matter more than the opinions of the families of other 9/11 victims?

The "no"s would be suffering a hardship;

What hardship would the families of these 9/11 victims be suffering that the families of the other 9/11 victims would not be suffering?
 
Here we go again!

What hardship would the families of these 9/11 victims be suffering that the families of the other 9/11 victims would not be suffering?

There are probably some interesting analogies to draw between people praying towards Mecca over there and people drawing cartoons over there.
 
Last edited:
Why do the opinions of these families of 9/11 victims matter more than the opinions of the families of other 9/11 victims?

Well, I just told you. There is an asymmetry between lukewarm approval (or, perhaps, the unwillingness to be seen as intolerant) and vehement opposition. In any case, just in terms of raw numbers, the "nays" had it.

What hardship would the families of these 9/11 victims be suffering that the families of the other 9/11 victims would not be suffering?

Offense. A feeling of insult. You know, the same kind of trauma that so-called moderate Muslims might feel when Pamela Geller holds a "Draw Muhammad" contest.
 
Offense. A feeling of insult. You know, the same kind of trauma that so-called moderate Muslims might feel when Pamela Geller holds a "Draw Muhammad" contest.

The same kind of offense, but in one case you want to cater to the offended and in the other you want to cater to the offenders.
 
Last edited:
I don't think that the fact one is skin color and the other religion is all that essential (see below), but I appreciate the thoughtful response.
Did you completely miss the rest of the post? And the fact that one is about religion and the other about race is a very important difference; one is a choice that can be changed, the other is not.

I don't really view religion as being a simple choice in the sense you suggest here. A believer believes that his religion is true, that what it teaches is a correct view of the world, and that aside from truth, his own well-being in a very deep sense is at stake (salvation, in the terms of Christianity). It is not as if he can reason, "It seems that these beliefs do not fit in well in this society, so perhaps it is better if I change what I believe." To do so is to give up on what the believer views as fundamental truths about the nature of his existence and his relationship to his Creator, as well as to jeopardize his possibility of a rewarding afterlife.

This is nonsense. Very few people, if any, are perfectly devout. Everyone has doubts, even the most fanatical. Everyone evaluates their beliefs at some level. Some do so only superficially, and their beliefs tend to be superficial. It's true that many people double down when confronted with evidence that refutes or challenges their beliefs; but that is again a choice they make.

There's the other problem that many, one might even say most, religious people simply do not understand what they believe. They parrot a set of dogmas without really knowing the reason for them, the story behind them, how they fit together in the context of their religion, or whether they are actually a historical part of their religion.

Further, people very often pick and choose what parts of their chose religion to believe, and which to argue with. Many change bits and pieces throughout their lifetime to suit their evolving experiences and prejudices; while oftetn claiming to have always believed the same thing. This is especially true with syncretistic religions like the "New Age" beliefs.

So, yes, of course, at some point each religious person presumably makes a choice to believe or not (though I'm not sure how conscious that might be, so even that seems controversial), but I don't regard religion as something which can be easily changed.

You're both right and wrong here. If you observe religious people long enough, you'll see how their beliefs, and how they act on their beliefs, changes over time. Usually the changes are fairly subtle, but often can be dramatic. Keep in mind, as well, that there is a well-known phenomenon among the religious known sometimes referred to as "New Convert Syndrome", that is, those newly converted to the religion are commonly far more invested in it than those raised in the religion. New converts are almost always the most fanatical as well. This is not universally true, of course; but true more often than not.

If you look, the overwhelming majority of terrorists, especially those originating from First World countries and middle-class or better backgrounds, are recent converts, often from within prisons. Either converts who previously had no significant religious beliefs, or converts from a more moderate sect of their religion. They still have doubts and there is often confusion about what they truly believe, and they are dealt challenges from people around them about their newfound beliefs, so they do what is most human and double down, become more devout, intensify their adherence to the tenets of their chosen worldview, and try to shut out doubt with a "fake it 'til you make it" strategy.

Religion is very much a choice; and especially for the fanatical it is a choice they have made rather than acceding to a choice others (like their parents) others have made for them.

And I'm not too sure how the permanence and non-voluntary nature of black skin makes the offense all that different than the offense of the true believer.
Because it is something they have no control over at all. Further, in the US, use of racially-loaded terms is still very closely associated with events of racially-motivated violence and discrimination. The time of Jim Crow laws and Separate But Equal is still within living memory. When I was a teen back in the '80s, interracial relationships were still a very big deal.
for that reason alone, it is a very different thing. The use of racial slurs is very much an act of aggression the majority of the time, in the US cultural context.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom