Can a CharlieHebdo-type attack happen in the US?

?
I see gay rights protesters at gay pride events hollering about Jesus, sin, and hell directly at people who gather around to listen and laugh at them.
Or take the Westboro Baptist nutjobs.
Unless I'm missing something?

Westboro is protected. Fighting words doctrine applies to directed, private-ish speech. Generally using fighting lime words in a public place as an act of speech is probably protected.
 
I think that they heard about it, hatched their little plan and went about it.

Yes, this is an important distinction to make. What occurred here was not some random passerby incensed to violence by inflammatory comments. This was two guys engaging in a botched terrorist attack, with very clear religious motivations. There is no need for distractions.
 
So why do you think she opposes the construction of new mosques?

Does she oppose the construction of all new mosques or only the one near Ground Zero? I opposed that too. I thought it was a deliberate provocation that was being facilitated by local government.
 
They weren't comparing the incidents. But please - go ahead and remind us all how star-spangled awesome Texas is.

Oh wait. Did you mean that committing blasphemy against Islam in Paris is somehow different from committing blasphemy against Islam in Texas? Is blasphemy somehow ok if the "right" people are doing it?
 
They're absolutely right. There is no comparison between the incident in Paris and the incident in Texas. In Texas, they shoot back.

You don't think that's a little disrespectful to the French cops? Say, the ones who died when they shot back?
 
Yes, this is an important distinction to make. What occurred here was not some random passerby incensed to violence by inflammatory comments. This was two guys engaging in a botched terrorist attack, with very clear religious motivations. There is no need for distractions.

One quibble I have. I don't think we know it was a "botched" terrorist attack rather than just a failed terrorist attack. We tend to dismiss "botched" terrorist attacks as less serious or less threatening, and perhaps that's a reasonable thing to do. But it's possible that this one failed only because of bad luck (or good luck, depending upon your perspective).
 
Oh wait. Did you mean that committing blasphemy against Islam in Paris is somehow different from committing blasphemy against Islam in Texas? Is blasphemy somehow ok if the "right" people are doing it?

I think that you're not trying to understand others' arguments now. It is obviously not an issue of who's doing it, but what motivates them to do it.

I think it's reasonably debatable whether there's a significant difference between Geller and Charlie Hebdo, but there won't be a debate if you insist on misreading what others say.
 
Does she oppose the construction of all new mosques or only the one near Ground Zero? I opposed that too. I thought it was a deliberate provocation that was being facilitated by local government.

A little off-topic, but as I understand it, there was no mosque being proposed near Ground Zero. There was a planned Islamic community center.
 
You don't think that's a little disrespectful to the French cops? Say, the ones who died when they shot back?

No, I don't, because I was trying to make a joke and win the award for pith (although I can count the number of times I've been nominated on one hand, not counting my thumb, and one of those times I nominated myself :mad:).

I have no doubt the French police and soldiers are very brave. I like to make jokes at their expense because it's something of a meme, but I think the French's reputation for being ineffective at war is wholly undeserved and unfair.
 
I think that you're not trying to understand others' arguments now. It is obviously not an issue of who's doing it, but what motivates them to do it.

No, I understand it perfectly well. I was just being obnoxious. I'm feeling particularly frisky this morning. Of course I completely disagree with the argument and think the Charlie Hebdo guys are being ridiculous.
 
No, I understand it perfectly well. I was just being obnoxious. I'm feeling particularly frisky this morning. Of course I completely disagree with the argument and think the Charlie Hebdo guys are being ridiculous.

Then why not argue that point rather than feigning incomprehension?
 
A little off-topic, but as I understand it, there was no mosque being proposed near Ground Zero. There was a planned Islamic community center.

It doesn't actually matter, but I think the Islamic center was to have a prayer room inside which would count as a mosque for religious purposes. The main point was the "intent" behind it. It seems to me that somebody acting in good faith would have backed down when such a large number of family members of 9/11 attack victims voiced their disapproval.
 
Oh wait. Did you mean that committing blasphemy against Islam in Paris is somehow different from committing blasphemy against Islam in Texas? Is blasphemy somehow ok if the "right" people are doing it?

What in the wide world of sports are you going on about?

The comparison was between Charlie Hebdo and Pamela Geller's groups. What they do and what they're mandate is.

Charle Hebdo uses satire to discuss topical issues. Pamela Geller and her group are hateful provocateurs. That's what they do. That's why they exist.

I suspect you already know this though and just happen to have a few tons of straw lying around that need a use.
 
Does she oppose the construction of all new mosques or only the one near Ground Zero? I opposed that too. I thought it was a deliberate provocation that was being facilitated by local government.

She was an active opponent of the mosque being built in Murfreesboro, TN, and has complained that "after 9/11, mosque construction in America has nearly doubled".
 
Then why not argue that point rather than feigning incomprehension?

Some ideas are so ridiculous that a little ridicule is called for. The idea that there is no comparison between Charlie Hebdo and Pamela Geller is one such idea.
 
From what I remember, plenty of people put CH in exactly the same category as Geller's haters, and made exactly the same accusations of incitement and provocation against them.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom