Can a CharlieHebdo-type attack happen in the US?

The winning cartoon is the one with Mahomet swinging a sword shouting "You can't draw me!" and the cartoonist replying "That's why I draw you."

He is Bosch Fawstin, an apostate.

Can someone find the CNN argument/interview where Geller said that they had many submissions, mostly historical perspectives and that the winner was by a former Muslim and was one of those more traditional views?

Interesting what she considers a historical/traditional view of Muhammad. Would one say that's more vampire-looking or wolfman-looking?


ETA:
Apologies. She doesn't say that. She mentions the historical perspective and then says that the winner was a former muslim but doesn't say anything about his drawing being a more traditional or historical view of "the prophet". MY BAD.Looking through the submissions (in the post I linked to above), I'm having trouble finding many of those more traditional/historical types that she's talking about.
 
Last edited:
Can someone find the CNN argument/interview where Geller said that they had many submissions, mostly historical perspectives and that the winner was by a former Muslim and was one of those more traditional views?

Interesting what she considers a historical/traditional view of Muhammad. Would one say that's more vampire-looking or wolfman-looking?


ETA:
Apologies. She doesn't say that. She mentions the historical perspective and then says that the winner was a former muslim but doesn't say anything about his drawing being a more traditional or historical view of "the prophet". MY BAD.Looking through the submissions (in the post I linked to above), I'm having trouble finding many of those more traditional/historical types that she's talking about.

I took the use of "traditional" to mean "representational" as in not abstract or post modern.

But looking at some of the others...I'm offended by the bad art. Not "kill some mother ****ers" offended but damn...
 
I'm going to be perfectly honest and admit that I'd likely feel differently about this if it wasn't for Pamela Geller being involved. I just hate her so much.

At least you are honest about it. Too many others are laboring mightily to avoid admitting that is the only reason they don't support free speech in this instance.
 
To show (hopefully) that a critical mass of people exist who won't be cowed into giving up their freedoms to appease extremists.



Actually, they proved that we have a long way to go do defend our freedoms. Even in Texas (Texas for God's sake!), you can't criticize Islam without spending $10,000 on security (and needing it). Hopefully, the next time, there will be no attack, and after a few dozen more held without incident, it will be possible to forgo the $10,000 expenditure on security.



Not pointless at all. And the attack was not pointless either. There is a battle going on, and it remains to be seen who will emerge victorious. Thank God there are plenty of people brave enough to fight for free speech. There are so many people here who aren't, unfortunately.

:rolleyes:
 
Not pointless at all. And the attack was not pointless either. There is a battle going on, and it remains to be seen who will emerge victorious. Thank God there are plenty of people brave enough to fight for free speech. There are so many people here who aren't, unfortunately.

So you'll be joining up? With little attention there's a similar amount of recruiting going on for mercenaries who want to go fight IS. I'm sure they could use another gun.

Or are you going to fight for freedom of speech on the internet behind a layer of anonymity.

In short, don't pull that "whatsamatta you skeered, wimp!" crap, okay? You generally argue from a position I do not support, but you don't cross into personalized nonsense.
 
I am willing to suffer the consequences of my actions. It is my fault. I accept this. You may blame me for my actions - they are willfully undertaken and sometimes designed to provoke.

However, if things are going to get violent, there will be a new set of consequences for me to consider. Perhaps, in that case, I would withdraw. Are things going to get violent?

Might makes right?

Appeasement of violence does not work. Why do you keep insisting they were not willing to take the consequences, seems they were willing to take the risk that you are quailing under.
 
Why is it OK for you to hate her but it's not OK for her to hate Muslims?

I hate her for things she actually does. She hates all Muslims for things she imagines they might do.

Geller is beneath contempt,and one of the worse aspects of the attack is that it creates sympathy for her.
But that is irrevlent to the free speech isues invovled.

How is this a free speech issue? Near as I can tell it was legal for her to piss people off. And it will be legal in the future too.
 
Because it filters out nonsense and failure. All speech is not equivalent.

I never said all speech was equivalent. But even nonsense speech is still speech, so this does nothing to rescue your absurd inversion of the truth.

Indeed, and I do not inhabit those places as a general rule.

That's your choice.

Please do not put the burden on me to justify crazy jihadists.

I'm putting the burden on you to justify your own crazy argument. And you can't.

However, understanding that crazy jihadists exist means I will consider them as part of the context of the world I live in, just as I would any other danger. I recognize they are not civil, and are in fact, monstrous. But I do not wish to become monstrous myself, nor to be uncivil merely to make a point about monsters.

In other words, you will cower before those monsters, and make up excuses for your cowardice.

Rather, I prefer to remain civil in the hope that it will attract others to a more pleasant way of living. We are better than the terrorists.

So is Geller.

We don't have to act in ways that encourage them. We don't have to give them opportunities to become martyrs for a foolish cause by being foolish ourselves.

You are naive to believe they need us to grant them such an opportunity.

The crocodile may not choose to eat you last, no matter how much you feed it.
 
So you'll be joining up? With little attention there's a similar amount of recruiting going on for mercenaries who want to go fight IS. I'm sure they could use another gun.

Or are you going to fight for freedom of speech on the internet behind a layer of anonymity.

In short, don't pull that "whatsamatta you skeered, wimp!" crap, okay? You generally argue from a position I do not support, but you don't cross into personalized nonsense.

By "here" I meant the US. Not this forum. Sorry for the confusion. I was afraid that it might be interpreted that way. As for the "chickenhawk" accusations, I'm sure you realize that such arguments are incredibly childish. I never claimed to be one of the "brave" people, so it doesn't even work as an allegation of hypocrisy.
 
I hate her for things she actually does. She hates all Muslims for things she imagines they might do.

I'm quite sure that the latter statement is false on two counts. She doesn't hate all Muslims. In fact, I think she's made it quite clear that she hates the ideology, not the people who nominally call themselves Muslim. Also, she doesn't have to imagine what they do. Many of them do it, or say they'll do it. As for the former statement, it's pretty ironic. I think you hate her for what you imagine she does, but she doesn't actually do.

How is this a free speech issue? Near as I can tell it was legal for her to piss people off. And it will be legal in the future too.

If people legitimately fear for their safety in expressing themselves through legal speech, then their right to speech has been curtailed. That is a problem, and either the government or society as a whole should do more to protect that right.

A gay marriage opponent might ask a similar question of course. You might try to think of an analogy yourself.
 
I'm going to be perfectly honest and admit that I'd likely feel differently about this if it wasn't for Pamela Geller being involved. I just hate her so much.

Hate seems to be one of your primary motivating factors. This is not healthy, Travis. It doesn't help you, it only makes you miserable.
 
At least you are honest about it. Too many others are laboring mightily to avoid admitting that is the only reason they don't support free speech in this instance.

Don't be coy. Who do you have in mind?
 
I go back and forth on this, and I think I've come around to Marplot's point of view: yes, you have the right to draw whatever you want, but why would you do something that will knowingly upset people?

Let's take freedom of speech. Yes, I have the right to stand on a street corner and say horribly racist and sexist things, but can I really be surprised when I eventually get punched in the face for it? If you take a random group of people, and start insulting them in the worst way you know how, a few are going to react with more than just angry stares. That's just how people are. There's always a few weirdos in every group. So why do it in the first place? ...


(Assuming you're American) I don't think you have that right. Your scenario would probably fall under the fighting wordsWP (as in "them's") exception to the First Amendment; basically, as i read it (not a lawyer), there to deny just that sort of up close and personal, in your face name-calling protection as free speech.

It's an interesting exception in the context of the Muhammad cartoons, the ways it might apply, and the ways it doesn't.
 
(Assuming you're American) I don't think you have that right. Your scenario would probably fall under the fighting wordsWP (as in "them's") exception to the First Amendment; basically, as i read it (not a lawyer), there to deny just that sort of up close and personal, in your face name-calling protection as free speech.

It's an interesting exception in the context of the Muhammad cartoons, the ways it might apply, and the ways it doesn't.

?
I see gay rights protesters at gay pride events hollering about Jesus, sin, and hell directly at people who gather around to listen and laugh at them.
Or take the Westboro Baptist nutjobs.
Unless I'm missing something?
 
Regardless of whether Fudbucker's hypothetical falls under the "fighting words" exception to 1st amendment protections, this event most clear did NOT constitute fighting words. The scenarios are not equivalent. Geller didn't set up shop in front of a mosque and start screaming at people going to Friday prayers. This was an event that people who might be offended could trivially avoid, and in fact would need to make an effort to see. The attackers had to go out of their way to go to the event (it wasn't even in the state they lived in), and I suspect they never actually even saw any of the speech at the event.
 
Regardless of whether Fudbucker's hypothetical falls under the "fighting words" exception to 1st amendment protections, this event most clear did NOT constitute fighting words. The scenarios are not equivalent. Geller didn't set up shop in front of a mosque and start screaming at people going to Friday prayers. This was an event that people who might be offended could trivially avoid, and in fact would need to make an effort to see. The attackers had to go out of their way to go to the event (it wasn't even in the state they lived in), and I suspect they never actually even saw any of the speech at the event.

I think that they heard about it, hatched their little plan and went about it.
I wonder if they cased the place long enough to find out if the event went on as scheduled.
If it had been replaced by something else, would they have been unaware, and shot up a completely unrelated event?
 
Charlie Hebdo Editor Rejects Pamela Geller Comparisons: ‘She Is Obsessed by Islam’

Sunday night's shooting at the art show in Garland, Texas, restarted many of the same debates about free speech and the dangers of cross-cultural provocations that took place in the wake of the Charlie Hebdo massacre in January. But in a discussion today, the French satirical magazine's editor-in-chief Gérard Biard and its film critic Jean-Baptiste Thoret distanced themselves from the cartoon exhibit and its organizer, Pamela Geller.

Speaking with Suzanne Nossel, the executive director of PEN American Center, the Charlie Hebdo pair stressed that their job was to start a global debate while those hosting the Garland show simply aimed to provoke.

"Comparing this Pamela Geller thing and Charlie Hebdo is nonsense," Thoret said. "It's an anti-Islamic movement, and she said it's an anti-Islamic movement, fighting against what she called the Islamization of the U.S. Maybe there is just one thing in common: You can't mess with Texas, you can't mess with Charlie Hebdo."

The Charlie Hebdo team, Biard said, simply aims to "comment on the news."

"The difference between us and these people is that these people are organizing contests, anti-Islamist contests," he continued. "It's an obsession ... We are not obsessed. We are just obsessed by the news, and by how the world is going on. The difference with Pamela Geller, she is obsessed by Islam. She waits every morning and thinks, What can I do today to defy these people?"
 
I'm quite sure that the latter statement is false on two counts. She doesn't hate all Muslims. In fact, I think she's made it quite clear that she hates the ideology, not the people who nominally call themselves Muslim. Also, she doesn't have to imagine what they do. Many of them do it, or say they'll do it. As for the former statement, it's pretty ironic. I think you hate her for what you imagine she does, but she doesn't actually do.



If people legitimately fear for their safety in expressing themselves through legal speech, then their right to speech has been curtailed. That is a problem, and either the government or society as a whole should do more to protect that right.

A gay marriage opponent might ask a similar question of course. You might try to think of an analogy yourself.

So why do you think she opposes the construction of new mosques?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom